| i generally avoid trashy harem ecchi shows does this show have any redeeming qualities aka is it worth watching i saw saw the new season is airing |
 |
DragyG said: Wasn't ecchi (aside from the traditional onsen/beach episode) and was my favourite fantasy anime in 2021. 2021? over re zero, mushoku tensei, slime, tsukimichi and finest assassin? you jokin? |
|
| nah , don't bother . |
DragyG said: Kitsune_089 said: 2021? over re zero, mushoku tensei, slime, tsukimichi and finest assassin? you jokin? I dropped tsukimichi Slime had a little bit too much of fighting Finest assassin weirded me out with the girls ready to take his dick everytime I felt asleep with some episodes of Re:Zero Mushoku Tensei has a huge flaw in it's balance to me. Sometimes it feels like nothing relevant actually happens between the turning points. I am not i have never heard such heresy in my life instantly invalidated your opinion |
|
| No. This is probably the most generic and straight up AI generated isekai trash you can find. If you have seen any other power fantasy isekai trash, then you'll basically have seen everything this show has to offer and this show does not even attempt to be unique or original. |
 |
| Don't bother, it's as mid as they come, the anime equivalent of bland oatmeal |
| Stuff in the streets, Stuff with drip in the sheets |
| It’s a regular isekai anime, not too much ecchi moments. Well, at least not in S1. |
 |
Piromysl said: No. This is probably the most generic and straight up AI generated isekai trash you can find. If you have seen any other power fantasy isekai trash, then you'll basically have seen everything this show has to offer and this show does not even attempt to be unique or original. Smartphone and Death March are isekai that are more AI generated though~ To OP: Whenever I see ‘worth reading/watching?’, my answer is decide for yourself, what do you like/dislike? I heard from many people that the anime is going the WN route instead of LN route. I am a LN reader, not a WN reader. I can only speak for the LN~ There are several isekai titles that have more worldbuilding and character development than Mushoku Tensei but Seirei Gensouki is not one of them. Seirei Gensouki is a redemption isekai that goes on a different path than Mushoku Tensei. I will use Mushoku Tensei as comparison due to both being redemption isekai. In terms of worldbuilding, most of Seirei Gensouki worldbuilding is on the lore, deeper than Mushoku Tensei but very messy and it comes very late in the story at volume 20 when the protagonist Rio is about to lose a fight to the same busy onee-san the second time. The protagonist is the weakest part of the isekai. As mentioned earlier, this is a redemption that goes on a different path. Rudeus wants to become a better person due to him being an useless bum in his previous life. Rio is a criminal until he suddenly receives memories from Haruto (Japanese self), which results in conflicting thoughts because criminals are condemned in Japan. And he tries to become a better person and stray away from his criminal life. I mentioned that the protagonist is the weak point of Seirei Gensouki because Rio is reckless at times. When Rio loses a fight with a busty onee-san due to her having godlike hero powers, his reaction is to fight her again with his own gang and everyone gets overpowered by her. >_> On the other hand, Rudeus will choose the diplomatic approach, using words and force should be a last resort as seen with how he dealt with his grandmother. In terms of side characters, Seirei Gensouki is better than Mushoku Tensei because many people has character development, it focuses on perspective of many characters instead of only the protagonist. Kinda hilarious that many LN readers treat a side character as the protagonist when reading Seirei Gensouki, just like COTE. XD I have read up to volume 24, the story is messy at this point, side characters are still more interesting than the protagonist. XD |
NewestPersonHere said: Piromysl said: No. This is probably the most generic and straight up AI generated isekai trash you can find. If you have seen any other power fantasy isekai trash, then you'll basically have seen everything this show has to offer and this show does not even attempt to be unique or original. Smartphone and Death March are isekai that are more AI generated though~ To smartphone's defense it actually has this whole titular smartphone gimmick. It gets boring by the end of first episode, but still. Spirit Chronicles on the other hand does has absolutely nothing that would imply that there was any human input or creative thinking involved. It is so outrageous in regard of unoriginality, that it has a LITERAL Kirito as a protagonist ripped straight from SAO down to voice actor and design and even character depth. I'm honestly surprised that SAO creator did not filed a copyright claim. |
PiromyslOct 9, 2024 4:36 PM
|
| First season sucked but I liked the first episode in season 2. Hopeful it continues to pick up from here. You're definitely in the wrong place if you dont like harems tho. |
Piromysl said: To smartphone's defense it actually has this whole titular smartphone gimmick. It gets boring by the end of first episode, but still. Spirit Chronicles on the other hand does has absolutely nothing that would imply that there was any human input or creative thinking involved. It is so outrageous in regard of unoriginality, that it has a LITERAL Kirito as a protagonist ripped straight from SAO down to voice actor and design and even character depth. I'm honestly surprised that SAO creator did not filed a copyright claim. The smartphone thing is also done in Masters Of Ragnarok. Fun fact: Smartphone, Masters Of Ragnarok, Seirei Gensouki are all published by the same light novel publisher in both Japanese (HJ Bunko) and English (J-Novel Club). XD LN readers are often debating whether Death March, Smartphone, Cheat Skill In Another World Reborn As A Space Mercenary or Arifureta is the worst isekai written. At the current rate, they are leaning towards Space Mercenary, Death March and Cheat Skill. XD I think you are try reading Seirei Gensouki treating a side character as the protagonist, it is more enjoyable that way. Most LN readers I know treat Miharu or Celia as the protagonist because they find silver-haired Kirito boring. Personally, I treated Liselotte as the protagonist until Volume 20 then switched to Celia at volume 21. Well, a lot of LN readers celebrated when silver-haired Kirito loses a fight to the busty onee-san in Volume 18. XD Well, a lot of isekai nowadays are more enjoyable when I treat a side character as the protagonist. Such as Norn Greyrat in Mushoku Tensei~ |
| Pretty good anime so far. One thing that surprised me about this anime, as an isekai, is how the MC always goes straight to the point. There's no unnecessary beating around the bush. I don't really know why MCs in any isekai never tells they are from another world, but in this anime it is not the case. The MC actually speak up and the plot isn't refrained to move forward because of that. |
More topics from this board
Poll: » Seirei Gensouki Episode 11 Discussion ( 1 2 )Stark700 - Sep 13, 2021 |
63 |
by Quiddity131
»»
Mar 11, 7:17 PM |
|
Poll: » Seirei Gensouki Episode 4 Discussion ( 1 2 )Stark700 - Jul 26, 2021 |
93 |
by elkensteyin
»»
Mar 6, 8:34 PM |
|
Poll: » Seirei Gensouki Episode 12 Discussion ( 1 2 3 4 )Stark700 - Sep 20, 2021 |
163 |
by Neko_Rance
»»
Feb 17, 5:37 AM |
|
Poll: » Seirei Gensouki Episode 10 Discussion ( 1 2 )Stark700 - Sep 6, 2021 |
73 |
by Neko_Rance
»»
Feb 17, 4:55 AM |
|
Poll: » Seirei Gensouki Episode 3 Discussion ( 1 2 3 )Stark700 - Jul 19, 2021 |
118 |
by Neko_Rance
»»
Feb 16, 2:55 PM |