Forum SettingsEpisode Information
Forums
New
Sep 28, 2022 3:51 PM
#1
Offline
Jan 2018
11
"I don't understand David's motivations, why would he dive into a life of crime and get chromed up when he's seen what it's done to everyone around him"

Yea bro it's simple as that just put down the augs bro walk away just stop being a cyberpunk

Do you think your average crackhead had never seen a crackhead before trying crack? Do you think all those unfortunate boys the world over who join gangs didn't grow up seeing parents and older brothers die in the street?

That's just life, for whatever reason, people keep on doing objectively dumbass things. Maybe it's because they don't know anything else, maybe it's because they have an ego, think they're going to be different. Sometimes they actually have the charisma to draw other people in to support them and follow the same dream (to their demise)

That's kindof what this entire show is about. This isn't a light novel adaptation about hyper rational 300 IQ high schoolers.
TheBellmanSep 28, 2022 4:12 PM
Sep 28, 2022 4:06 PM
#2

Offline
May 2022
932
TheBellman said:
"I don't understand David's motivations, why would he dive into a life of crime and get chromed up when he's seen what it's done to everyone around him"

Yea bro it's simple as that just put down the augs bro walk away just stop being an cyberpunk

Do you think your average crackhead had never seen a crackhead before trying crack? Do you think all those unfortunate boys the world over who join gangs didn't grow up seeing parents and older brothers die in the street?

That's just life, for whatever reason, people keep on doing objectively dumbass things. Maybe it's because they don't know anything else, maybe it's because they have an ego, think they're going to be different. Sometimes they actually have the charisma to draw other people in to support them and follow the same dream (to their demise)

That's kindof what this entire show is about. This isn't a light novel adaptation about hyper rational 300 IQ high schoolers.

Once he got caught up in everything it seemed pretty inevitable. Part of the tragedy was he eventually had Lucy by his side and a lot of money living in a beautiful apartment. Unfortunately he was passed the point of no return. All of that was never going to be enough.
Sep 28, 2022 4:11 PM
#3

Online
Jul 2015
12657
Reminds me of this thing:

Sep 28, 2022 4:54 PM
#4
Offline
Jun 2021
1292
ngl at one point he did have a choice to turn back but i guess he was too far in being a cyberpunk idk
Sep 28, 2022 11:26 PM
#5
Offline
Mar 2018
7
when you run on the edge, it's difficult to step down but it's far more easy to step over. And this is true for everything, especially in the cyberpunk genere. People who write such things never ever touched a cyberpunk novel... shame those are a good read.
Sep 29, 2022 12:05 AM
#6
Offline
Jul 2021
338
this post was made by rich kid that don't know why poor people need money again.
Sep 29, 2022 4:36 AM
#7

Offline
Jul 2021
181
whether or not cyberpunk makes sense to the viewer is pretty indicative of your experience within reality. that's part of why it's so good. if you don't get it, it might be because you've grown up among the 'corpos' who the show isn't trying to relate to in the first place.

anyways, you had a point right up until the 'objectively dumbass' part. because it isn't objectively dumbass to join a gang or whatever: to some people it's practically the only option, the only family they have, and how could your only choice be a dumbass one?

what's dumbass is judging from the outside as you manoeuvre your own existence of choices which have largely been already made for you.
-- art-house/psychological/stylish/philosophical anime enjoyer with yuri bias and the attention span of a smol-antlered creature --
Sep 29, 2022 4:40 AM
#8
Offline
Jan 2018
11
3looming said:


anyways, you had a point right up until the 'objectively dumbass' part. because it isn't objectively dumbass to join a gang or whatever: to some people it's practically the only option, the only family they have, and how could your only choice be a dumbass one?

what's dumbass is judging from the outside as you manoeuvre your own existence of choices which have largely been already made for you.

That makes it subjectively the only decision someone is capable of making, not any less self destructive objectively.

These things end with prison or an early grave, it's never a good decision on any extended timeline. Yet people keep doing it because, as you say, there is often no apparent choice in the matter. And that's tragic, and more society's fault than anything else.
Sep 29, 2022 8:06 AM
#9
Offline
Oct 2020
108
lmao well said but personally it just makes me sad to think about drug abuse the thing i actually don't like is how David's situation wasn't even that desperate his life could have been "normal" in the beginning or theoretically after he saw his leader die
totherpage95Sep 29, 2022 8:12 AM
Sep 29, 2022 9:01 AM
Offline
Jan 2021
2
totherpage95 said:
lmao well said but personally it just makes me sad to think about drug abuse the thing i actually don't like is how David's situation wasn't even that desperate his life could have been "normal" in the beginning or theoretically after he saw his leader die

His mom died and he was broke. Plus due to Lucy he was pulled into all this cyberpunk business, he liked it that's all.
It wasn't more like desparate. he just took a liking to it
Sep 29, 2022 10:47 AM
Offline
Nov 2021
7
in my opinion that's a pretty dumb thing to do... but i can see that he's traumatized by the death of people he loves so much so he just keeps trying and trying to protect the only and most important person he had left
Sep 29, 2022 8:40 PM
Offline
Jun 2015
2
CHT13 said:

Once he got caught up in everything it seemed pretty inevitable. Part of the tragedy was he eventually had Lucy by his side and a lot of money living in a beautiful apartment. Unfortunately he was passed the point of no return. All of that was never going to be enough.


*bear in mind I never played the game*

This is the part that slightly annoyed me. I had no issues with the plot until David became the gang leader; Maine's cyberpsychosis was inevitable. The time-skip wasn't really necessary and just made David and Lucy seem even more distant than they were. From here though, I feel like there was really no good reason for Lucy to not talk to David about what she saw in the deep-dive, and being secretive about dealing with it just made David even more lost at this point. David had nothing meaningful in the meantime except become stronger with more implants and build his reputation by taking contracts, literally killing people, which obviously will build up the strain on his conscience, therefore lead him closer to cyberpsychosis. This is what he thought Maine wanted him to do. IMO, his mother's dream was kind of a lost cause since he dropped out and starting doing illegal activities.

At this point I don't really know what drove David to continue using the harmful implants, at least to the extent at which he did. I was so surprised when I saw David double his normal size, next to Lucy. It felt so wrong knowing how much he mattered to Lucy and how dangerous these cyber augments were. He was experiencing the symptoms the Doctor warned about and shrugged them off...

Why? He was on track to fulfil Lucy's dream WITH him, even saying "only 250K" for a trip to the moon, so he definitely wasn't in a financially desperate situation at all. So then, what fuelled his drive to keep going on, unless he was already too deep in or enjoyed the mercenary life? I personally believe it was largely because of Lucy's absence and evasiveness after the deep-dive gig. Lucy being secretive and on multiple occasions telling David she needs "a little more time" instead of telling him the truth kept him walking on the self destructive path. He needed someone to snap him out of it especially after his uncle/father-figure slowly spiralled into madness and died in front of him. He needed someone to escape with. .. and I think Lucy, the most important person left in his hectic life, let him down here. She had good intentions but instead of opening her arms to him she kept the truth behind the deep-dive gig to herself, and this lack of connection and trust eventually led to her own rash mistake, falling for Faraday's trap due to her stress/emotional state after their argument.

It doesn't really make sense to me that they aren't really there for each other after Maine just died... yet it seemed like they slept with each other every night? That is a VERY close bond to have with someone... so why keep such an important secret from David here? Not working with him is justified and keeps him reassured if she just told him that she was protecting him by doing the ICE dive thing. Instead, they are both left with uncertainty about each other's well-being and I just don't think it should be like that considering how close they were portrayed to be, lovers and all.
Kaos-AoDSep 29, 2022 8:58 PM
Sep 29, 2022 8:54 PM

Offline
May 2022
932
Kaostanza-AoD said:
CHT13 said:

Once he got caught up in everything it seemed pretty inevitable. Part of the tragedy was he eventually had Lucy by his side and a lot of money living in a beautiful apartment. Unfortunately he was passed the point of no return. All of that was never going to be enough.


*bear in mind I never played the game*

This is the part that slightly annoyed me. I had no issues with the plot until David became the gang leader; Maine's cyberpsychosis was inevitable. The time-skip wasn't really necessary and just made David and Lucy seem even more distant than they were. From here though, I feel like there was really no good reason for Lucy to not talk to David about what she saw in the deep-dive, and being secretive about dealing with it just made David even more lost at this point. David had nothing meaningful in the meantime except become stronger with more implants and build his reputation by taking contracts, literally killing people, which obviously will build up the strain on his conscience, therefore lead him closer to cyberpsychosis.

At this point I don't really know what drove David to continue using the harmful implants, at least to the extent at which he did. I was so surprised when I saw David double his normal size, next to Lucy. It felt so wrong knowing how much he mattered to Lucy and how dangerous these cyber augments were. He was experiencing the symptoms the Doctor warned about and shrugged them off...

Why? He was on track to fulfil Lucy's dream WITH him, even saying "only 250K" for a trip to the moon, so he definitely wasn't in a financially desperate situation at all. So then, what fuelled his drive to keep going on, unless he was already too deep in or enjoyed the mercenary life? I personally believe it was largely because of Lucy's absence and evasiveness after the deep-dive gig. Lucy being secretive and on multiple occasions telling David she needs "a little more time" instead of telling him the truth kept him walking on the self destructive path. He needed someone to snap him out of it especially after his uncle/father-figure slowly spiralled into madness and died in front of him. He needed someone to escape with. .. and I think Lucy, the most important person left in his hectic life, let him down here. She had good intentions but instead of opening her arms to him she kept the truth behind the deep-dive gig to herself, and this lack of connection and trust eventually led to her own rash mistake, falling for Faraday's trap due to her stress/emotional state.
was it mentioned or was I misinterpreting Lucy’s absence from the gang because I thought once she found out what their true intentions were she was secretly diving to keep Arasaka from finding David.
Sep 29, 2022 9:03 PM
Offline
Jun 2015
2
CHT13 said:
was it mentioned or was I misinterpreting Lucy’s absence from the gang because I thought once she found out what their true intentions were she was secretly diving to keep Arasaka from finding David.


In their argument just before Lucy gets captured, he said something like "After Maine's death, didn't expect you to leave us too." It is heavily implied she's not involved with the gang's activities anymore, thought she is not absent from his life cause well, you do see her laying in their bed a few times and getting up cause David is watching TV.

She was indeed diving in secret (idk where the bath tub was tbh) to protect the data she corrupted that was once about David, but I just don't see a reason she would hide this from him, especially when a lot of the gang's burden are now on his shoulders...
Sep 29, 2022 9:25 PM

Offline
May 2022
932
Kaos-AoD said:
CHT13 said:
was it mentioned or was I misinterpreting Lucy’s absence from the gang because I thought once she found out what their true intentions were she was secretly diving to keep Arasaka from finding David.


In their argument just before Lucy gets captured, he said something like "After Maine's death, didn't expect you to leave us too." It is heavily implied she's not involved with the gang's activities anymore, thought she is not absent from his life cause well, you do see her laying in their bed a few times and getting up cause David is watching TV.

She was indeed diving in secret (idk where the bath tub was tbh) to protect the data she corrupted that was once about David, but I just don't see a reason she would hide this from him, especially when a lot of the gang's burden are now on his shoulders...

Yeah she should’ve at least tried talking to him about it. This show really needed 2 to 3 more episodes. I hope if they do another season it’s a whole new story from a corpo or a nomads perspective. Definitely give Lucy at least a cameo and 12-13 episodes.
Oct 3, 2022 7:30 AM

Offline
Jul 2021
181
Piromysl said:
Reminds me of this thing:
absolute banger btw +1
-- art-house/psychological/stylish/philosophical anime enjoyer with yuri bias and the attention span of a smol-antlered creature --
Feb 5, 2023 9:58 PM
Offline
Dec 2017
27747
Piromysl said:
Reminds me of this thing:
lol yep thats basically it lol

More topics from this board

Poll: » Cyberpunk: Edgerunners Episode 10 Discussion ( 1 2 3 4 5 ... Last Page )

MegamiRem - Sep 13, 2022

1069 by Zimbabwaipoulet »»
Mar 17, 2:22 PM

Poll: » Cyberpunk: Edgerunners Episode 3 Discussion ( 1 2 3 4 )

erniii - Sep 12, 2022

165 by still_no_bitches »»
Mar 11, 12:36 PM

Poll: » Cyberpunk: Edgerunners Episode 2 Discussion ( 1 2 3 4 )

Air-117 - Sep 12, 2022

175 by still_no_bitches »»
Mar 11, 12:35 PM

Poll: » Cyberpunk: Edgerunners Episode 9 Discussion ( 1 2 3 )

Pre_Yum - Sep 13, 2022

103 by Luxiant »»
Feb 28, 6:49 PM

Poll: » Cyberpunk: Edgerunners Episode 8 Discussion ( 1 2 3 )

Pre_Yum - Sep 13, 2022

102 by Luxiant »»
Feb 28, 5:03 PM
It’s time to ditch the text file.
Keep track of your anime easily by creating your own list.
Sign Up Login