Toaru Majutsu no Index III Episode 26 Discussion

Offline

Jun 2014

226

ssjokg said:

TKMike said:

Bolded line triggered me, even though I disliked the show, this bolded statement is not true at all and just you not paying attention to the actual episodes while claiming it's the "shows" fault.

Also your statement of 90% of the people on this forum agreeing it to not be higher than a 7 is not true at all. You can actually see the votes on this forum lmao, do the math and you will realise how ignorant you are.

Yes.The majority of the audience wasnt paying attention. That is clearly the problem.

Lmao, is that what you interpreted from my comment?? HAHAHAHAHHA, are you this butthurt to assume Im claiming everyone who hates the serie didn't pay attention incl. myself? HAHAHAHAHAHHH, Im dying :'D Can you actually read??

Apr 9, 2019 5:45 AM

#204

Read this if you want to start the Fate/ series but don't know from where.

Offline

Aug 2009

20056

Good to know.......

Apr 9, 2019 5:48 AM

#205

Offline

Jun 2014

226

ssjokg said:
Good to know.......

Good to know a LN reader can't read actual comments ^^

Apr 9, 2019 6:14 AM

#206

Offline

Oct 2018

289

Tsukumo_Yuuma said:

MahiaErebeaNegi said:

There's also a rumor that Nishikiori himself have no idea what should he do to Index III even when the show started airing lol, that alone just shown that how bad he as a director is.

The whole "We have learned our lesson from the failure of Index III" statement is a fucking joke as long as he is still directing Index lol.

i think they will most likely change him if there's a 4th season
this is from index reddit about the rumor idk if it's true :
"Actually true, the one posting it was the Chinese Toaru forum moderator, who was translating the recent anime interview.

Its actually Yoshino and Nishikori interview, the bottom line was Nishikori's micromanagement pissed off both of them and the seiyuus.

Kamachi insisted on working on certain rewrites to shorten the character wordings, and using various kind of filming technique to visualize the narration, Nishikori turned it down. Nishikori insisted on having Touma stand around not fighting, because he thinks Touma is just a perverted lucky bastard (actual words), Kamachi never offered him any help ever since.

Yoshino insisted they can't fit everything in, and certain unnecessary scenes can be removed or have Kamachi do some rewrite, Nishikori turned it down.

Seiyuus (Index's especially) had various ideas on how to put in more emotion into the characters, Nishikori turned it down.

It pissed off Kamachi so much that he said "its bad" and left production, and Yoshino was passive aggressive the entire interview, but Nishikori kept on insisting that He was following the book, even though the original author's suggestions were completely ignored and he COMPLETELY MISSED THE POINT ON EVERYTHING."

they say this is from an interview in newtype magazine , so i think we'll wait till js06 translate it to be sure

According to the thread this was first discovered, it really turns out the Chinese guy put a ton of his own interpretations(and bias) on various comments on interviews in the past, the ones js06 already did. I mean it makes sense now doesn’t it? Why would some guy on baidu be the only one with the latest newttpe magazine?

Apr 9, 2019 8:47 AM

#207

NoviSun

Offline

Aug 2018

1810

KiLLZONE15JYU said:
My friend I hate to tell you this but it sucks because the light novel was far better than this and it was rushed with bad animation. Don't support this because you get disappointments from JC Staff along with the director. Eveyone in Japan find this adaptation poor and the BD sales just bombed which is a disappointment.

And who says LN Readers aren't elitist, entitled, obnoxious curs? hahahahaha

Apr 9, 2019 8:55 AM

#208

Offline

Dec 2018

196

NoviSun said:

KiLLZONE15JYU said:
My friend I hate to tell you this but it sucks because the light novel was far better than this and it was rushed with bad animation. Don't support this because you get disappointments from JC Staff along with the director. Eveyone in Japan find this adaptation poor and the BD sales just bombed which is a disappointment.

And who says LN Readers aren't elitist, entitled, obnoxious curs? hahahahaha

Have you ever read it then saying things without any knowledge?
PS Don't disrespect others opinion even you got to abmit that this adaptation was bad.

Apr 9, 2019 1:23 PM

#209

TomHazard

Offline

Nov 2018

47

NoviSun said:

KiLLZONE15JYU said:
My friend I hate to tell you this but it sucks because the light novel was far better than this and it was rushed with bad animation. Don't support this because you get disappointments from JC Staff along with the director. Eveyone in Japan find this adaptation poor and the BD sales just bombed which is a disappointment.

And who says LN Readers aren't elitist, entitled, obnoxious curs? hahahahaha

Shit bait.
Even though, you are genuinely free to say whatever you want after reading 24 books from the Old Testament.

Apr 9, 2019 2:36 PM

#210

Offline

Mar 2019

48

@TKMike I said the forum, not the polls. I'm assuming that even you can see that the VAST majority of the people discussing in this forum hated it, and are certainly not giving it a 7 or higher. Even if you read the reviews on the main page for this anime, most of them aren't very positive. If I had wanted to reference the polls, I would have referenced the polls.

Apr 9, 2019 2:48 PM

#211

Offline

Jun 2014

226

Elisile said:
@TKMike I said the forum, not the polls. I'm assuming that even you can see that the VAST majority of the people discussing in this forum hated it, and are certainly not giving it a 7 or higher. Even if you read the reviews on the main page for this anime, most of them aren't very positive. If I had wanted to reference the polls, I would have referenced the polls.

Srry, but the poll is in this forum, aka it's part of the forum..... Or am I wrong? Im not even defending this anime, but I know the general consensus are atleast more positive than negative on this forum. I am not the type who's purely focussing on the vocal minority, especially when a chunk of the complainers cant even make up their mind of what the Light Novel portrayed when I read their complaints when compairing to the source material

TKMikeApr 9, 2019 2:53 PM

Apr 9, 2019 2:58 PM

#212

Offline

Mar 2019

48

TKMike said:

Elisile said:
@TKMike I said the forum, not the polls. I'm assuming that even you can see that the VAST majority of the people discussing in this forum hated it, and are certainly not giving it a 7 or higher. Even if you read the reviews on the main page for this anime, most of them aren't very positive. If I had wanted to reference the polls, I would have referenced the polls.

Srry, but the poll is in this forum, aka it's part of the forum..... Or am I wrong? Im not even defending this anime, but I know the general consensus are atleast more positive than negative on this forum. I am not the type who's purely focussing on the vocal minority, especially when a chunk of the complainers cant even make up their mind of what the Light Novel portrayed when I read their complaints when compairing to the source material

Even if you go by the polls, 50% of people can't even bring themselves to say that it was 'good' or that they 'liked it'. In my estimation, saying that it was 'OK' is the real- world equivalent of saying "this is average at best". And you can confirm that, as the grading scale says that the 'OK' rating is only a 3/5, which is essentially average. And over 20% of people disliked or hated it.

Now, a valid counter- argument might be something along the lines of "Yes, but you're ignoring the other 50% of people who said that they liked it or loved it". Well, in virtually every other real- world application, we hardly consider it a 'success' if barely 50% of people can even admit that they like something. A YouTube video with equal amount likes and dislikes? Yikes. A critic's score of a movie of only 50%? No way.

Apr 9, 2019 3:22 PM

#213

Offline

Jun 2014

226

Elisile said:

TKMike said:

Srry, but the poll is in this forum, aka it's part of the forum..... Or am I wrong? Im not even defending this anime, but I know the general consensus are atleast more positive than negative on this forum. I am not the type who's purely focussing on the vocal minority, especially when a chunk of the complainers cant even make up their mind of what the Light Novel portrayed when I read their complaints when compairing to the source material

Even if you go by the polls, 50% of people can't even bring themselves to say that it was 'good' or that they 'liked it'. In my estimation, saying that it was 'OK' is the real- world equivalent of saying "this is average at best". And you can confirm that, as the grading scale says that the 'OK' rating is only a 3/5, which is essentially average. And over 20% of people disliked or hated it.

Now, a valid counter- argument might be something along the lines of "Yes, but you're ignoring the other 50% of people who said that they liked it or loved it". Well, in virtually every other real- world application, we hardly consider it a 'success' if barely 50% of people can even admit that they like something. A YouTube video with equal amount likes and dislikes? Yikes. A critic's score of a movie of only 50%? No way.

Let me get this straight, you claim average == terrible? Or are you manipulating the definition simply to justify your own statement?? Last time I checked, it being okay means it isn't bad nor good, aka it's even justified to remove them from comparison since they are neutral, aka "irrelevant" anyways.
This is the actual stats at this moment:
Good == 50%
Okay == 27.46%
YOUR ACTUAL STATEMENT == 22.54%

Split them and we would have:
Good == 63,73
YOUR ACTUAL STATEMENT == 36,27

Apr 9, 2019 4:32 PM

#214

Offline

Mar 2019

48

@TKMike Why are you just assuming that, if the 'Ok' choice were to be removed, that everyone would just split 50/50 to either 'good' or 'bad'? I understand from a raw statistics point of view why you would do that, but we have no idea if that's actually how it would pan out. And from where I'm sitting, the discussions on this thread have been almost universally negative towards the season. The reviews on the main page are almost universally negative. The overall rating can barely scrounge up a 7/10, and that's even being generous and rounding up. Apparently, even the original author of the LN disliked the anime adaptation, and the anime's director has been coming under fire from various different fronts. So, given this overwhelming circumstancial evidence, I would lean towards more of those 'Ok' voters actually voting 'Disliked it', not 'Liked it'.

Because also, think of it like this. Those 27% 'Ok' voters couldn't even bring themselves to say that they liked it. There's a reason for that. If they liked it, it shouldn't have been that hard to say so. For example, you see how harsh I've been on the show? Even I voted that I 'Liked' this episode (aka 4/5). And this is coming from ME. So, yes, it should not have been that hard for those people to admit that they liked it. But since they couldn't even bring themselves to do that, I'm highly skeptical that many of them would lean in that direction if the 'Ok' option was removed.

My justification for thinking that they would lean more in the 'Disliked it' direction is that the odds are stacked in favor of them voting 'Liked it' at the present moment. They obviously like the series and the franchise if they were willing to watch this anime. They are dedicated enough to actually come to this online forum to discuss and to vote. Hell, many of them seem to be LN readers, which should give even MORE of a positive bias to the situation. Yet, despite all of that, not more than 50% of people could bring themselves to say that it was above average. That's really not good, because the assumption is that the amount of positive reviews and positive votes would be biased and inflated in the positive direction, for my aforementioned reasons. And even so, 50% of people either hated it, disliked it, or were giving it a 'pity vote' of 3 instead of 2 or 1. And we've seen many people in discussions and reviews saying that they've inflated their scores a bit just because they love the franchise, even though they really hated this season. So my claims aren't completely baseless.

Now, if we removed all of that positive bias, can you imagine how many more of those votes would become 1s or 2s? I really don't think it would split 50/50 good and bad. All of the evidence points that it would mostly go bad.

Apr 9, 2019 6:44 PM

#215

Offline

Oct 2018

289

Elisile said:
@TKMike Why are you just assuming that, if the 'Ok' choice were to be removed, that everyone would just split 50/50 to either 'good' or 'bad'? I understand from a raw statistics point of view why you would do that, but we have no idea if that's actually how it would pan out. And from where I'm sitting, the discussions on this thread have been almost universally negative towards the season. The reviews on the main page are almost universally negative. The overall rating can barely scrounge up a 7/10, and that's even being generous and rounding up. Apparently, even the original author of the LN disliked the anime adaptation, and the anime's director has been coming under fire from various different fronts. So, given this overwhelming circumstancial evidence, I would lean towards more of those 'Ok' voters actually voting 'Disliked it', not 'Liked it'.
.

Y’all can continue for discussion but appearently from what I understand there’s no real source on that so you probably shouldn’t use it as evidence (yet)

Apr 9, 2019 6:50 PM

#216

Offline

Mar 2019

48

Tiau said:

Elisile said:
@TKMike Why are you just assuming that, if the 'Ok' choice were to be removed, that everyone would just split 50/50 to either 'good' or 'bad'? I understand from a raw statistics point of view why you would do that, but we have no idea if that's actually how it would pan out. And from where I'm sitting, the discussions on this thread have been almost universally negative towards the season. The reviews on the main page are almost universally negative. The overall rating can barely scrounge up a 7/10, and that's even being generous and rounding up. Apparently, even the original author of the LN disliked the anime adaptation, and the anime's director has been coming under fire from various different fronts. So, given this overwhelming circumstancial evidence, I would lean towards more of those 'Ok' voters actually voting 'Disliked it', not 'Liked it'.
.

Y’all can continue for discussion but appearently from what I understand there’s no real source on that so you probably shouldn’t use it as evidence (yet)

Are you referring specifically to the allegations of the author not liking the adaptation, and the director coming under fire? Because the rest of what I said is clearly observable on this site.

Apr 9, 2019 8:45 PM

#217

Offline

Oct 2018

289

Elisile said:

Tiau said:

Y’all can continue for discussion but appearently from what I understand there’s no real source on that so you probably shouldn’t use it as evidence (yet)

Are you referring specifically to the allegations of the author not liking the adaptation, and the director coming under fire? Because the rest of what I said is clearly observable on this site.

The claims about the director and author stuff yes

Apr 9, 2019 10:31 PM

#218

Mkonji69

Offline

Apr 2019

2

Was really really hyped for index3 after watching the awesome Kick assim railgun s. What a letdown

Apr 9, 2019 10:40 PM

#219

Tsukumo_Yuuma

Offline

Dec 2015

500

Tiau said:

Elisile said:

Are you referring specifically to the allegations of the author not liking the adaptation, and the director coming under fire? Because the rest of what I said is clearly observable on this site.

The claims about the director and author stuff yes

but anyway nishikiori twitter was bombed lol the fans attacked him so much that he deleted his " thank you for watching tweet " but the yeah the info about the author isn't confirmed yet i think it'll be fake.

Apr 10, 2019 12:01 AM

#220

Botato

Offline

Nov 2013

22771

TKMike said:

ssjokg said:

Yes.The majority of the audience wasnt paying attention. That is clearly the problem.

Lmao, is that what you interpreted from my comment?? HAHAHAHAHHA, are you this butthurt to assume Im claiming everyone who hates the serie didn't pay attention incl. myself? HAHAHAHAHAHHH, Im dying :'D Can you actually read??

No he didn't claim that people who hate the adaptation weren't paying attention. He is talking about people who were confused or lost during many of this anime's arcs. If you've been following every discussion you'd notice the abnormally high percentage of comments saying things along the lines of "I don't know what's going on anymore."

Apr 10, 2019 3:54 AM

#221

Offline

Jun 2014

226

Botato said:

TKMike said:

Lmao, is that what you interpreted from my comment?? HAHAHAHAHHA, are you this butthurt to assume Im claiming everyone who hates the serie didn't pay attention incl. myself? HAHAHAHAHAHHH, Im dying :'D Can you actually read??

No he didn't claim that people who hate the adaptation weren't paying attention. He is talking about people who were confused or lost during many of this anime's arcs. If you've been following every discussion you'd notice the abnormally high percentage of comments saying things along the lines of "I don't know what's going on anymore."

Not my point, aka irrelevant. I was specifically talking about the claim Elisile made. NOT what the forum posters made in general. So he was just wasting his time pointing out something which was irrelevant to my message.

Apr 10, 2019 3:55 AM

#222

Offline

Jun 2014

226

Elisile said:
@TKMike Why are you just assuming that, if the 'Ok' choice were to be removed, that everyone would just split 50/50 to either 'good' or 'bad'? I understand from a raw statistics point of view why you would do that, but we have no idea if that's actually how it would pan out. And from where I'm sitting, the discussions on this thread have been almost universally negative towards the season. The reviews on the main page are almost universally negative. The overall rating can barely scrounge up a 7/10, and that's even being generous and rounding up. Apparently, even the original author of the LN disliked the anime adaptation, and the anime's director has been coming under fire from various different fronts. So, given this overwhelming circumstancial evidence, I would lean towards more of those 'Ok' voters actually voting 'Disliked it', not 'Liked it'.

Because also, think of it like this. Those 27% 'Ok' voters couldn't even bring themselves to say that they liked it. There's a reason for that. If they liked it, it shouldn't have been that hard to say so. For example, you see how harsh I've been on the show? Even I voted that I 'Liked' this episode (aka 4/5). And this is coming from ME. So, yes, it should not have been that hard for those people to admit that they liked it. But since they couldn't even bring themselves to do that, I'm highly skeptical that many of them would lean in that direction if the 'Ok' option was removed.

My justification for thinking that they would lean more in the 'Disliked it' direction is that the odds are stacked in favor of them voting 'Liked it' at the present moment. They obviously like the series and the franchise if they were willing to watch this anime. They are dedicated enough to actually come to this online forum to discuss and to vote. Hell, many of them seem to be LN readers, which should give even MORE of a positive bias to the situation. Yet, despite all of that, not more than 50% of people could bring themselves to say that it was above average. That's really not good, because the assumption is that the amount of positive reviews and positive votes would be biased and inflated in the positive direction, for my aforementioned reasons. And even so, 50% of people either hated it, disliked it, or were giving it a 'pity vote' of 3 instead of 2 or 1. And we've seen many people in discussions and reviews saying that they've inflated their scores a bit just because they love the franchise, even though they really hated this season. So my claims aren't completely baseless.

Now, if we removed all of that positive bias, can you imagine how many more of those votes would become 1s or 2s? I really don't think it would split 50/50 good and bad. All of the evidence points that it would mostly go bad.

You're literally grasping straw here. Irrelevant to my argument and just your way to justify your incorrectness.

Apr 10, 2019 9:53 AM

#223

Offline

Mar 2019

48

@TKMike All I can do is look at the evidence available to me on this forum, and it is overwhelmingly negative. If you believe that me using evidence to justify my rationale is 'irrelevant', then I think we're done here.

Apr 10, 2019 7:12 PM

#224

MiaAyende

Offline

Nov 2018

235

This season was a hot mess...I preferred Railgun over Index in the first place, but at least the other two seasons of Index made sense. Also, should it even be called Index at this point? She's in it for what? 20 minutes?

Apr 11, 2019 2:52 AM

#225

Stoorainclaire

Offline

Oct 2018

648

yeah this whole season 3 is very bad, poor adaption, too much fighting, rushing, less misaka, but yeah atleast not too much about index...overall i would say that this season was really bad...the only thing that save this is the last arc...

but hate to admit that I need season 4 right now!

Apr 11, 2019 4:21 AM

#226

Offline

Dec 2018

196

Stoorainclaire said:
yeah this whole season 3 is very bad, poor adaption, too much fighting, rushing, less misaka, but yeah atleast not too much about index...overall i would say that this season was really bad...the only thing that save this is the last arc...

but hate to admit that I need season 4 right now!

I don't want a sequel to this series. Its better off leaving then returning for new season.

Apr 11, 2019 4:30 AM

#227

Stoorainclaire

Offline

Oct 2018

648

KiLLZONE15JYU said:

Stoorainclaire said:
yeah this whole season 3 is very bad, poor adaption, too much fighting, rushing, less misaka, but yeah atleast not too much about index...overall i would say that this season was really bad...the only thing that save this is the last arc...

but hate to admit that I need season 4 right now!

I don't want a sequel to this series. Its better off leaving then returning for new season.

why not? yeah I know it's bad but what am I supposed to do with this unsatisfactory feeling? they keep hanging it there and no new season would be disaster. try reading the novel? sorry I cannot get the full experience with just reading with only word around...I rather read the manga if there is one.

Apr 11, 2019 5:06 AM

#228

Offline

Dec 2018

196

Stoorainclaire said:

KiLLZONE15JYU said:

I don't want a sequel to this series. Its better off leaving then returning for new season.

why not? yeah I know it's bad but what am I supposed to do with this unsatisfactory feeling? they keep hanging it there and no new season would be disaster. try reading the novel? sorry I cannot get the full experience with just reading with only word around...I rather read the manga if there is one.

A Reboot with a different studio is better than with a rushed story to a sequel.

Apr 11, 2019 5:10 AM

#229

Read this if you want to start the Fate/ series but don't know from where.

Offline

Aug 2009

20056

Stoorainclaire said:
sorry I cannot get the full experience with just reading with only word around.

A single volume of the series gives you more expereince than the entire 3rd season so.....

Apr 11, 2019 5:17 AM

#230

Offline

Dec 2018

196

ssjokg said:

Stoorainclaire said:
sorry I cannot get the full experience with just reading with only word around.

A single volume of the series gives you more expereince than the entire 3rd season so.....

He`s not interested in light novels but manga reader so he is just asking if there would be a good adaptation to this series.

Apr 11, 2019 6:46 AM

#231

Vikzor30

Offline

Apr 2012

50

I rewatched season 1 and 2 thinking I'll understand this season better, looking back I really dont understand this anime's storyline most of the time I think the only time I enjoyed the story is when Touma lost his memory and the time he saved the misaka sisters. Is the LN thousand times better? Im really wondering how this is so popular in japan.

Signature removed. Please check your inbox

Apr 11, 2019 10:09 AM

#232

Read this if you want to start the Fate/ series but don't know from where.

Offline

Aug 2009

20056

Vikzor30 said:
I rewatched season 1 and 2 thinking I'll understand this season better, looking back I really dont understand this anime's storyline most of the time I think the only time I enjoyed the story is when Touma lost his memory and the time he saved the misaka sisters. Is the LN thousand times better? Im really wondering how this is so popular in japan.

Every arc builds on teh next. If the evenst do not connect then the characters will. There was never a direct connection in all of them like you see in series like Bleach or Naruto.

The problem is that the the series, and that mean sall 3 seasons, failed at making the events and/or characters connect to one another.

How many remember that Yomikawa who is teaching at Touma's school is also Accelerator's guardian AND an Anti-skill?
How many remember that the magic side HAd conenctions with Aleister but didnt realize that it was THAT magician they killed so many years ago?
How many remember what even is Kazakiri an dhow speing the Sisters over the world is a plan?
Did poople realize that the Dragon in season 1 coming out of Touma;s hand WASNT created by the alchemist Izzard?
Or that the doctor DIDNT restore his hand but it regenerated?

Is the LN a thousand times better?

I cant tell you that as ai am biased.But it defintely makes a lot more fucking sense.

ssjokgApr 11, 2019 12:14 PM

Apr 11, 2019 1:04 PM

#233

Stoorainclaire

Offline

Oct 2018

648

ssjokg said:

Stoorainclaire said:
sorry I cannot get the full experience with just reading with only word around.

A single volume of the series gives you more expereince than the entire 3rd season so.....

that the thing is, I like index or railgun series from anime and that mean it's my first impression. most light novel reader said that it bad adaption but to me anime watcher only it's normal. of course I know this season is really bad, I can see that.

Apr 11, 2019 1:06 PM

#234

Read this if you want to start the Fate/ series but don't know from where.

Offline

Aug 2009

20056

Stoorainclaire said:

ssjokg said:

A single volume of the series gives you more expereince than the entire 3rd season so.....

that the thing is, I like index or railgun series from anime and that mean it's my first impression. most light novel reader said that it bad adaption but to me anime watcher only it's normal. of course I know this season is really bad, I can see that.

Igot into the series by wtching s1 and s2 of Index so yes, they were "normal" for me too.Till I read the novels.

Apr 11, 2019 4:06 PM

#235

Botato

Offline

Nov 2013

22771

Ok finally sat down and watched the last 2 episodes of this travesty. Obviously not impressed, but it wasn't as terrible as I expected save for the final 2 seconds, which managed to be worse than I thought. Tfw the last frame was just a smug Birdway tho, that's cool at least.

5/10, not a waste of time but one would be better off watching something else.

Apr 13, 2019 6:14 AM

#236

HibiChika

Offline

Jan 2013

2321

not gonna lie, i watched index s3 twice the speed coz accelerating this clusterfuck was the only way to get it over and done with and save some valuable time. somewhere along the line i just couldn't care less about the plot nor any of the characters motivation. i used to like jc staff. not anymore. 1/10

Apr 14, 2019 9:30 AM

#237

YizelTro

Offline

Feb 2015

3751

some people posted their opinion harsly or softly and some people got offended so easly which is why the chaos never stop

Apr 14, 2019 12:49 PM

#238

Offline

Dec 2018

196

YizelTro said:
some people posted their opinion harsly or softly and some people got offended so easly which is why the chaos never stop

Its MAL, this happens a lot. This series did felt rushed and boring but still I`m excited to see what happens next with the series. I don't think this series will ever get famous but if it gets a reboot with another studio then the series wouldn't look outdated.

Apr 15, 2019 10:09 AM

#239

Read this if you want to start the Fate/ series but don't know from where.

Offline

Aug 2009

20056

KiLLZONE15JYU said:
if it gets a reboot with another studio

Not gonna happen.

Unless the series REALLY bombs...like Umineko levels of sales.

Apr 15, 2019 10:12 AM

#240

Offline

Dec 2018

196

ssjokg said:

KiLLZONE15JYU said:
if it gets a reboot with another studio

Not gonna happen.

Unless the series REALLY bombs...like Umineko levels of sales.

Yeah I know but I think the series would bomb either way.

Apr 15, 2019 6:34 PM

#241

Offline

Oct 2018

289

KiLLZONE15JYU said:

ssjokg said:

Not gonna happen.

Unless the series REALLY bombs...like Umineko levels of sales.

Yeah I know but I think the series would bomb either way.

There's multiple problems with your statements here really,
1. Index is already famous, literally season 1 is the whole reason why it became big, and even now its the whole reason why it even has so many spinoffs and games.

2. So far, Index 3 still is like one of the better selling shows of its respective seasons, so yeah

Apr 15, 2019 10:06 PM

#242

Read this if you want to start the Fate/ series but don't know from where.

Offline

Aug 2009

20056

Selling a bit more than shows that didnt do well at all doesnt make it a success worthy of celebration.

Apr 16, 2019 3:33 AM

#243

Botato

Offline

Nov 2013

22771

While I agree that the sales aren't impressive so far, just a reminder that everything else also dropped in sales, likely due to digital distribution becoming more and more popular each year. Also because there's even more things coming out each season, people are being split further.

Apr 16, 2019 5:49 AM

#244

Tsukumo_Yuuma

Offline

Dec 2015

500

well, index 3 sales aren't very high but at least it can't be considered a flop.
hopefully railgun 3 will sell better than this and save to aru project ( i don't think accel anime will have high sales :"( )

Apr 16, 2019 6:33 AM

#245

Read this if you want to start the Fate/ series but don't know from where.

Offline

Aug 2009

20056

Tsukumo_Yuuma said:
well, index 3 sales aren't very high but at least it can't be considered a flop.
hopefully railgun 3 will sell better than this and save to aru project ( i don't think accel anime will have high sales :"( )

If they treat Railgun like Index then I dont see that working.

Apr 16, 2019 8:48 AM

#246

Offline

Oct 2018

289

Botato said:
While I agree that the sales aren't impressive so far, just a reminder that everything else also dropped in sales, likely due to digital distribution becoming more and more popular each year. Also because there's even more things coming out each season, people are being split further.

Indeed, what was considered a flop before is now a success. It just so happens that Index 3 fits exactly in that success range. Thus it's actually selling well

Apr 16, 2019 8:49 AM

#247

Read this if you want to start the Fate/ series but don't know from where.

Offline

Aug 2009

20056

I guess with shit budget like that even selling at all would be considered a success.

Apr 17, 2019 10:37 AM

#248

Offline

Dec 2018

196

Tiau said:

KiLLZONE15JYU said:

Yeah I know but I think the series would bomb either way.

There's multiple problems with your statements here really,
1. Index is already famous, literally season 1 is the whole reason why it became big, and even now its the whole reason why it even has so many spinoffs and games.

2. So far, Index 3 still is like one of the better selling shows of its respective seasons, so yeah

The series looks outdated and most of the blame was to the director but it's not all his fault which directs to the production committee as well. The composer is bad at naming New scores (no offense) which makes the score lackluster. The camera techniques were awful which shows bad animation if you want to know why the animation were transitioning awkwardly. Index 3 was selling ok but there is a big difference with the sales rate and it dropped massive which is a problem. I'm sorry Tiau but many fans were disappointed and felt this series was not intriguing at all. This series is going to bomb if JC Staff does this series because they cannot create good action scene which is sakuga or even make more than 50 episodes. A story needs to be interesting if it's paced properly if rushed than most of the answers are not solved. Fans can make their decision if they want a sequel and that doesn't mean it will keep getting a sucess of if is negative because that makes the series look bad which means less audience. If this studio don't fix their problem for this series than the series is best to get a reboot. The series doesn't look appealing to me anymore but it stays faithful to the source material then I'm sold back into this series because this was the only LN that was better than isekai shows like Re:Zero which is one of the best shows I watched in a long time and I understand the flaws but it's still great. The light novel for this series is amazing and I want to see a better adaptation then seeing Railgun fans making fun of this adaptation. Tiau you know that the director doesn't care for this adaptation but for it's fanservice which I think is a disgrace and most that fault is his. I don't think the production commitee are going to give this series a sequel because they mentioned a reboot before and they know how popular this LN series is which means that the series was mediocre to worst adaptation.
PS The writer's and the creator didn't get on well the director because he had a different perspective which means that the creator hate the meeting and left the production which puts it that he find the adaptation bad.

Vernon-and-MythApr 17, 2019 10:45 AM

Apr 17, 2019 8:36 PM

#249