DO NOT discuss the source material beyond this episode. If you want to discuss future events or theories, please use separate threads.
DO NOT ask where to watch/download this episode or give links to copyrighted, non-fair use material.
DO NOT troll/bait/harass/abuse other users for liking or disliking the series/characters.
DO read the Anime Discussion Rules and Site & Forum Guidelines.
DO NOT ask where to watch/download this episode or give links to copyrighted, non-fair use material.
DO NOT troll/bait/harass/abuse other users for liking or disliking the series/characters.
DO read the Anime Discussion Rules and Site & Forum Guidelines.
| Next episode with Alisa, FINALLY Also, wtf. You can stream this anime on MAL? |
CookingPriest said: royaldocks said: He is in charge of the stupid slow motions, atmosphere,poor sounds and fight choreography which are all lacking big . sure the source material is poor when it comes to story but everything that I mentioned he is in charge ! Which just shows that he is not INTO the product. This has none of his strength so he can't "get into it" which results in artificial TRIES(just like how UBW was completely hollow emotionally because Miura was more interested in upskirt shots) Its quite clear that Hirao does not care too much about this but still tries to make it look good. For the lack of better example of this situation it is like handing directing Dark Knight to Michael Bay, while having Christopher Nolan try to direct Twilight. Cue both going "Uhhh, why am I doing this again?" Takayuki Hirao is as out of tune with "gotta take down huge monsters omg omg let's fight" Gods Eater as Takahiro Miura is out of tune with "let's delve into what these characters think about and how they see the situation and why" kind of thing. Saying all of this I still want him to do Heavens Feel. Meh I don't. I hope HF crashes and burns. Its impossible to do in one movie anyway and it is impossible to get it right without at least getting Shirou's characterization in UBW right. AT BEST people will perceive it as "tr00 mature sequel" throwing derogatory remarks to the other to routes even more and missing the point about what the hell is going on. The faster people forget about ufo's FSN adaptations the better it is for the franchise. It hasn't been confirmed as 1 film. Also it doesn't matter what secondaries think. |
 Anime is good, fucking deal with it. |
| I hope Alisa makes this show a bit better. So far the characters leave me a bit cold to be honest. |
| "Perhaps there is a universal, absolute truth. Perhaps it justifies every question. But that's beyond the reach of these small hands." Mamoru Oshii There is a cult of ignorance (...) nurtured by the false notion that democracy means that “my ignorance is just as good as your knowledge.” Isaac Asimov |
| dat shit eater doe. decent episode. i think theo nly thing that came a bit off to me was the slowmo..idk seems like it can be handled better.with the previous UFO works i had an issue with a lot of the animations being to fast it wasn't very clean and you would miss a good amount of things because the anime didnt linger on them enough for anyone except maybe the reader base to even see them and the readers caught these things mainly because they read the scene and know what queues and actions to look for. here the animation comes off a bit too slow the action doesnt quite feel as excitingas it probably could have been. i think the ep gets a 4/5 |
| can't decide wether it looks refreshing or just awful. everything else is just.. boring. slow-paced action scenes can be cool, though. |
| "1/10, not enough underboob shots" - MAL. |
YehartJul 20, 2015 2:57 PM
"Hi!" |
DeeIsMe said: The soundtrack was, once again, the highlight of the episode, IMO. Appearance-wise, Alisa kind of reminds me of Marie from Persona. |
 |
black1blade said: It hasn't been confirmed as 1 film. Also it doesn't matter what secondaries think. It's just typical Fai being Typical Fai YEEART said: "1/10, not enough underboob shots" - MAL. Sounds about right lol |
 |
YEEART said: except everyone thats complaining said nothing about that "1/10, not enough underboob shots" - MAL. since not even slight fan service can save this show |
Vindstot said: Also, lets not forget the fabulous underboob. :9 Anyhow, looking forward to the next battle. Hope it'll turn out better than the first one. Damn that underboob xD That aside, she looks totally badass. Best girl Alisa :D But does this show even have any romance? No point in having best girl without any romance and shipping possibilities :( |
| Lenka's such a noob. RIP Eric. (T_T) You will NOT be missed. Alisa's in "trouble" and Lenka will prove himself. Let's go, underboobs! |
I’m always searching for something, for someone. This feeling has possessed me I think, from that day… That day when the stars came falling. |
| RIP Eric, now lets see what Allisa and Lenka can really do in the next episode |
| Wow the OSTs are really good. I am looking forward to their release. Another good episode, a new God Eater appeared, she is pretty attractive. |
Harem_King said: YEEART said: except everyone thats complaining said nothing about that "1/10, not enough underboob shots" - MAL. since not even slight fan service can save this show Save it from what? A ranting person like you who goes to all ufotable topics to bash on ufotable shows because they hate the studio? Yea, nothing can save it from you that is correct. |
|
| Yeah....I think I'm going to avoid episode discussions from now on. All of you are complaining after only 2 episodes and you shit talk every show this season. It's not worth trying to have a genuine discussion with anyone because their comment gets lost in the sea of retards. It's complete aids, honestly. |
 |
AnimeFanJoe123 said: Yeah....I think I'm going to avoid episode discussions from now on. All of you are complaining after only 2 episodes and you shit talk every show this season. It's not worth trying to have a genuine discussion with anyone because their comment gets lost in the sea of retards. It's complete aids, honestly. This is MAL in a nutshell: Grey-Zone said: I don't get the complains about the MC... when they are flawed it's bad because "lol, generic"? When they are perfect it's bad because "lol, Gary Stu"? Seems the only generally liked MCs recently are the apathetic, indifferent ones like Saitama from OPM. If they wear a dark coat, smoke and are over 30 years old for some reason they are "forgiven" as well, even though they are manchildren who complain just as much as the so-called "whiny" teenager characters. I don't get it. You either get used to it, ignore it, or just don't bother coming back. It's a sea of complainers who's only vocabulary words are "generic, predictable, cliche, bland, and/or boring" |
|
KamiCity said: AnimeFanJoe123 said: Yeah....I think I'm going to avoid episode discussions from now on. All of you are complaining after only 2 episodes and you shit talk every show this season. It's not worth trying to have a genuine discussion with anyone because their comment gets lost in the sea of retards. It's complete aids, honestly. This is MAL in a nutshell: Grey-Zone said: I don't get the complains about the MC... when they are flawed it's bad because "lol, generic"? When they are perfect it's bad because "lol, Gary Stu"? Seems the only generally liked MCs recently are the apathetic, indifferent ones like Saitama from OPM. If they wear a dark coat, smoke and are over 30 years old for some reason they are "forgiven" as well, even though they are manchildren who complain just as much as the so-called "whiny" teenager characters. I don't get it. You either get used to it, ignore it, or just don't bother coming back. It's a sea of complainers who's only vocabulary words are "generic, predictable, cliche, bland, and/or boring" So true. It's disappointing because there aren't many sites like this with a wide variety of forums to discuss anime. I want to talk with others about the episodes, but I can't because of these shit talkers with no lives. Guess I'll have to rely on YT comments. |
|
AnimeFanJoe123 said: KamiCity said: This is MAL in a nutshell: You either get used to it, ignore it, or just don't bother coming back. It's a sea of complainers who's only vocabulary words are "generic, predictable, cliche, bland, and/or boring" So true. It's disappointing because there aren't many sites like this with a wide variety of forums to discuss anime. I want to talk with others about the episodes, but I can't because of these shit talkers with no lives. Guess I'll have to rely on YT comments. Thats actually worse lmao. |
 |
AnimeFanJoe123 said: KamiCity said: This is MAL in a nutshell: You either get used to it, ignore it, or just don't bother coming back. It's a sea of complainers who's only vocabulary words are "generic, predictable, cliche, bland, and/or boring" So true. It's disappointing because there aren't many sites like this with a wide variety of forums to discuss anime. I want to talk with others about the episodes, but I can't because of these shit talkers with no lives. Guess I'll have to rely on YT comments. There are some clubs within here that you can join that aren't full of complainers and can hold pretty good discussions if everyone is active. It takes some time, while the series gets going but someone is bound to make one for this show. You can also just join one of the general ones after you get used to some of the people here and you know who's in them. |
|
laidellent said: AnimeFanJoe123 said: So true. It's disappointing because there aren't many sites like this with a wide variety of forums to discuss anime. I want to talk with others about the episodes, but I can't because of these shit talkers with no lives. Guess I'll have to rely on YT comments. Thats actually worse lmao. Depends on where you go. Channels like ForneverWorld or ChibiReviews don't have very many retards spreading unnecessary negativity. Otherwise YT comments are a complete cesspool. |
|
| If you are all so willing to discuss why not just start a discussion instead of always complaining about other users posting generic crap? |
 |
AnimeFanJoe123 said: Depends on where you go. Channels like ForneverWorld or ChibiReviews don't have very many retards spreading unnecessary negativity. Otherwise YT comments are a complete cesspool. I like sawyer or luffy the dragon slayer the best, anrikus videos can also hold good discussion, his amount of followers are smaller though. |
|
HeroKenzan said: If you are all so willing to discuss why not just start a discussion instead of always complaining about other users posting generic crap? I shouldn't have to weed out the competent people every time I visit the forums. |
|
| It's just boring... ResidentSleeper |
 |
| This is utterly unremarkable, as expected, but the directing is still fairly good. It is a shame that Hirao was assigned God Eater instead of F/SN, though. This kind of thing really isn't his forte. Anyway, 2/5. Here's to hoping Ufotable make some wild directorial choices so this becomes more entertaining. |
Smudy said: I forgot who Eric was lol HOW CAN YOU FORGET ERIC?! HE IS THE GREATEST CHARACTER ON THERE |
 |
| Too good and too short. I honestly don't understand why F/SN is rated so high on this site when it's so shit, while this show is damn good and rated so low. |
HandsomeMan said: Maybe because you don't get to decide things for other people; or maybe because people have different opinions than you.Too good and too short. I honestly don't understand why F/SN is rated so high on this site when it's so shit, while this show is damn good and rated so low. It's also barely episode 2. I don't remember how well GE did in the US, but i'm sure it wasn't as big as it was in Japan |
|
Caliburn220 said: This is utterly unremarkable, as expected, but the directing is still fairly good. It is a shame that Hirao was assigned God Eater instead of F/SN, though. This kind of thing really isn't his forte. Anyway, 2/5. Here's to hoping Ufotable make some wild directorial choices so this becomes more entertaining. Just a friendly warning. It is a monster hunter game adaptation. The focus of such a game is power fantasy of seeing hot people destroy big gigantic monsters, with the remaining time usually spent fangirling over Alisa's design(still can't decide whether it is the stockings or weird boots or the upskirt that makes her one of hotest video game characters). That's it. I frankly can't see a way to actually make God Eater story or characters good without majorly changing everything in the story which they won't do. Just enjoy the fireworks and the artstyle and don't think too much about plot or characters. AnimeFanJoe123 said: Depends on where you go. Channels like ForneverWorld or ChibiReviews don't have very many retards spreading unnecessary negativity. Otherwise YT comments are a complete cesspool. AAHAHAHHAH Sorry. No. That guy is half the problem with at least three or four fanbases and consistently spreads most ridiculous "theories" confusing people, while most of the videos are the definition of non content(I am sorry but "fhasdshaifwa oMG" for 15 minutes is NOT a review) |
AhenshihaelJul 21, 2015 6:27 AM
 |
KamiCity said: fhasdshaifwa OMG is a lot better than biased and baseless nitpicking. He is wrong on various levels though.. |
| |
laidellent said: I know that, but I rather listen to someone theorize badly, than hear someone whine, especially when they do it in every video and multiple times in the same forumKamiCity said: fhasdshaifwa OMG is a lot better than biased and baseless nitpicking. He is wrong on various levels though.. Especially when someone makes arrogant posts as if they are somehow superior to everyone else and only their opinions matter. Straight up bullying. |
KamiCityJul 21, 2015 6:46 AM
|
Ictius said: MAL sure is an interesting place. There were only 2 episodes and people are already moaning about story and character development. TWO F*CKING EPISODES. What did u expect from the mal community with his shit posting self proclaimed experts and elitists :P i like the anime.. its decent so so far.. maybe a 7 atm. it needs some charakter depths here and there but we are at EP2.... |
| Decent episode imo. Best part was the OST, which is actually pretty good. The way it is used though makes me think that the episode is going to end, over and over again. The animation is okay, although it feels like it's a bit slow at times. Interesting enough though, will keep watching. |
| Lenka just saved Eric's life and he returned the favor with the cost of his own life! Pretty sad to see him go so quickly. Now let's see what this Alisa girl can do in the next episode. |
| Seeing the MC just makes me want to play the game again. |
| A city's greatness is determined by the speed of its internet connection. |
| I can't understand. 3/10 The pacing is really dumb |
 |
| If only the writing was as good as the animation here. sigh... |
| I was sooooo boooored... also the animation was awkward at times. Hmmm, I'll give it a few more episodes, but so far it's really meh. |
.....    |
CookingPriest said: Caliburn220 said: This is utterly unremarkable, as expected, but the directing is still fairly good. It is a shame that Hirao was assigned God Eater instead of F/SN, though. This kind of thing really isn't his forte. Anyway, 2/5. Here's to hoping Ufotable make some wild directorial choices so this becomes more entertaining. Just a friendly warning. It is a monster hunter game adaptation. The focus of such a game is power fantasy of seeing hot people destroy big gigantic monsters, with the remaining time usually spent fangirling over Alisa's design(still can't decide whether it is the stockings or weird boots or the upskirt that makes her one of hotest video game characters). That's it. I frankly can't see a way to actually make God Eater story or characters good without majorly changing everything in the story which they won't do. Just enjoy the fireworks and the artstyle and don't think too much about plot or characters. AnimeFanJoe123 said: Depends on where you go. Channels like ForneverWorld or ChibiReviews don't have very many retards spreading unnecessary negativity. Otherwise YT comments are a complete cesspool. AAHAHAHHAH Sorry. No. That guy is half the problem with at least three or four fanbases and consistently spreads most ridiculous "theories" confusing people, while most of the videos are the definition of non content(I am sorry but "fhasdshaifwa oMG" for 15 minutes is NOT a review) Not as bad as Double4Anime. |
|
xcess090 said: I agree, i thought the first episode was better and this one was almost just recapping the last, but i still enjoyed it :)Not bad of an episode, I liked the first one better but it's still the second episode and a new character was just introduced so I'm keeping my hopes up. The OST was definitely great and I really like the art in this anime. |
 |
kyle8998 said: The new girl looks badass My thoughts exactly. Let's see her kick monster butt. |
| There are shots in this episode that look absolutely stunning, but the battle in the beginning was so.....slow, bland, and didn't have any sort of impact. The scene where the beast was swinging it's tail and the beast AND the guy were just standing there for 10 seconds was just awkward. It's like watching a turn based battle. Maybe it;s because the animators are not really accustomed to combining CGI monsters with 2D characters? Also I think the vocal music during the funeral was kind of....misplaced. |
| Liked the psp game for this, expected this anime to be at least decent. It wasn't.......dropped! |
More topics from this board
Poll: » God Eater Episode 13 Discussion ( 1 2 3 4 5 ... Last Page )Stark700 - Mar 26, 2016 |
264 |
by Calmdowntaku
»»
Jan 8, 5:52 AM |
|
» What's next ? [ spoilers inside]Naoumi16 - Nov 30, 2024 |
5 |
by Lilyitch691
»»
Nov 30, 2024 5:02 AM |
|
» Is this like the worst anime OST ever?Kayle_x_Morgana - Apr 4, 2022 |
9 |
by Drakel_3577
»»
Nov 3, 2024 12:41 PM |
|
Poll: » God Eater Episode 10 Discussion ( 1 2 3 4 5 ... Last Page )Stark700 - Mar 5, 2016 |
256 |
by LenkaXIVII
»»
Oct 26, 2024 1:53 PM |
|
Poll: » God Eater Episode 1 Discussion ( 1 2 3 4 5 ... Last Page )Stark700 - Jul 12, 2015 |
636 |
by Karva1
»»
Apr 14, 2024 5:53 PM |