Forum SettingsEpisode Information
Forums
New
What did you think of this episode?
DO NOT discuss the source material beyond this episode. If you want to discuss future events or theories, please use separate threads.
DO NOT ask where to watch/download this episode or give links to copyrighted, non-fair use material.
DO NOT troll/bait/harass/abuse other users for liking or disliking the series/characters.
DO read the Anime Discussion Rules and Site & Forum Guidelines.
Pages (2) [1] 2 »
Nov 25, 2022 10:35 AM
#1

Offline
Mar 2020
1466
I still wonder what Misha did to get the attention of both Lungmen and Reunion, but good that she has Rhodes Island to help her out. Some interesting themes this episode, they explored the difference between Reunion and Rhodes Island, despite them both consisting of Infected people. Reunion is just something that spreads lies and false hope so people can grasp it, while Rhodes Island is grounded in realism.

I do hope Misha and Rhodes Island can get to safety and Misha can get treatment, but I highly doubt they're out of trouble.
Nov 25, 2022 11:31 AM
#2

Offline
Jan 2020
2
Aaaaaand that's a wrap for Episode 5, now that Rhodes Island got some assistance from Penguin Logistics, they've finally got some more people to cover Misha's extraction. Though, they are still far from safe, and it seems like Misha is a high priority target for Reunion as well. I'm very glad about Apple Pie (Exusiai) and my girl Lupo Ice Queen (Texas) having their debut here, really made my day.

But yeah, definitely looking forward to the next episodes, keep it up, Yostar Pictures!



Loved this little scene when Exu took a bite of Texas' pocky stick, hehe
Nov 25, 2022 11:45 AM
#3

Offline
Nov 2010
413
This was probably the weakest episode so far, because the direction and animation took a slight dip. There was a lot of context in the early part they skipped, which made it feel rushed and without real connection.
On the good part, the Skullshatterer and Misha stuff was nice and the consequences of Oripathy in Misha going out of control was very important to show what we are really dealing with instead of just talking about it.
Nov 25, 2022 11:57 AM
#4

Offline
Dec 2018
4002
i still don't see where they are going with this, with only 3 episodes left.
Nov 25, 2022 1:37 PM
#5

Offline
Sep 2010
887
StateofOhayo said:
i still don't see where they are going with this, with only 3 episodes left.


After seeing the pace of first three episodes, it was easy to tell (for those familiar with AK storyline) where the anime is going to end.

It will be a good place to end but unless there are more seasons after this, this will become "Go play the game!" advertisement anime.

Though with just 8 episodes, the anime has been doing solid job telling the early game storyline.
Nov 25, 2022 2:16 PM
#6
Offline
Oct 2020
24
eso18 said:
StateofOhayo said:
i still don't see where they are going with this, with only 3 episodes left.


After seeing the pace of first three episodes, it was easy to tell (for those familiar with AK storyline) where the anime is going to end.

It will be a good place to end but unless there are more seasons after this, this will become "Go play the game!" advertisement anime.

Though with just 8 episodes, the anime has been doing solid job telling the early game storyline.

yeah and the season name is called prelude to dawn with season 1 in trailer pvs. So it is safe to say season 2 is probably in works.
Nov 25, 2022 2:29 PM
#7
Offline
May 2015
12
Mymbl3 said:

yeah and the season name is called prelude to dawn with season 1 in trailer pvs. So it is safe to say season 2 is probably in works.


They hired a voice actor for FrostNova. Allegedly a not cheap one, though I don't think who it is was actually confirmed. No reason to do that without a season 2 at least being heavily considered.
Nov 25, 2022 3:53 PM
#8

Offline
Aug 2009
76
As much as I'm fan of arknights, this anime is looking kinda terrible. It came down to me in this episode when I started jumping seconds due to impatience. It's sooo slow, like, everything really. The soundtrack seems like it's trying to make you take a nap. The characters or anything simply have no background nor context, I just know them cause I already play arknights, but technically speaking it's so lackluster.

It's a real shame to me. I will continue watching and hoping for it to get better, what can happen, but the series (already episode 5) is already a wasted potential. Like, I can't see someone who doesn't play the game wanting to play it after this, much on the contrary and that's so sad.
Nov 25, 2022 3:59 PM
#9
Offline
Jan 2021
10
worst episode, I don't know, why suddenly the red hair character feels close to Amiya, comes without a clear purpose.
Nov 25, 2022 4:08 PM

Offline
May 2021
436
Exceptionally bad episode even for this show's standards. Literally nothing happened and while nothing was happening it was poorly animated and poorly acted as well. They ought to start adding some interest other than weak plot "lines" that don't develop or am gonna drop this show soon
Nov 25, 2022 4:34 PM

Offline
Nov 2022
60
Liked it!

Pretty good episode. Finally got a bit more action and the dialogue felt more meaningful and grabbed my interest better than the last couple of eps, which were boring as heck.

The new aspect of this show that I'm starting to enjoy is all the politics. At first, it was just "good guys vs. bad guys", but there's clearly a lot more to it than that and I'm becoming more and more curious as to the enemies' motives, individually and as a whole.

Gonna keep watching, see you all next ep!
Odd_ManNov 25, 2022 4:38 PM
Nov 25, 2022 5:57 PM
Offline
Sep 2017
4
Apple pie Best Girl
Nov 25, 2022 7:24 PM

Offline
Feb 2021
1011
There is 3 more episodes in this series. I wonder if this series will wrap up any good? But still a decent episode nonetheless.
Nov 25, 2022 8:09 PM
Offline
Jun 2022
4
Spoiler on why Skullshatterer is searching for Misha
.
Also yeah as an AK player I can say in game episode (chapter) 1 to 3 (with some stuff skipped in the anime, or changed like in the W cameo with Rhodes) feels really slow. The next three episode will have more action btw, as we reach the end of the Misha arc

That said, I prefer them to make an anime or movie of one of the more interesting story events, such as the eldritch horror abyssal hunters series or Kazimierz capitalism knights series. If I'm not wrong they confirmed a season 2 in the makings (?) which would continue the main story after the Misha arc to the frostnova arc (ah shit) but since the first season isn't that interesting plot wise as the plot of the second season, I'm guessing there would be lesser viewers from those who watched the first season and don't play the game.

Also the story events where Rhodes Island goes to the beach and everyone wears a swimsuit while beating the shit out of a fucked up monster or capitalist businessman (or both)...... surely Yostar pictures and Hypergryph wouldn't miss the chance to profit off from a beach episode
corporealmachineNov 25, 2022 8:17 PM
Nov 25, 2022 8:17 PM
Offline
Mar 2018
62
Finally get to see Apple Pie and Texas animated.
Nov 25, 2022 8:48 PM
Offline
Aug 2018
98
We finally get to see PenguLogs! This is the best episode yet.
Nov 25, 2022 9:15 PM
Offline
Apr 2016
40
Each episode just get better and better. A slow progress but a progress still. Love the best ship, Texas x Exusia. More please.

The scenery still eye catching as ever, some of the emotional impact not get cut this time and actually hit. A little awkward movement animation but dont mind, dont mind. Keep it up.
Nov 25, 2022 10:26 PM
Offline
Jan 2021
10
the base story is not wrong, what makes the quality decrease is the director, and the cost of the animation.

honestly these episodes have so much potential but they are very cost effective
Nov 25, 2022 10:35 PM
Offline
Nov 2022
21
Иноричи said:
Honestly messing up ep 3 was probably the nail in the coffin. Nothing about the narrative is interesting anymore.

Why is RI in Lungmen? What does RI even do? Why are they in conflict with Reunion? The most fundamental questions that structure the plot are simply just ignored while events progress seemingly aimlessly. And they barely just answer the Who are RI and Who are Reunion for the audience with an exposition dump mid-chase in episode 5 of 8...

Adding in some lore does not substitute for a plot nor does it give the audience enough info to even begin to reasonably assume the answers to any of these questions. And once the literal backbone of events is made up in the minds of the audience (or just ignored), there are an infinite number of questions during the arc which spring up...

Who is Misha? Why is she being chased? How is Amiya the leader of RI when she's clearly immature and quite honestly incompetent? Who is Exusia? Who is Texas? Who are Penguin Logistics? Why are they helping the LGD? Why is Chen acting like she has a stick up her ass when RI is their saving grace? What is their deal with the LGD? Who is Kalstit?

Tbf, these are details can (and usually are) supplemented later on. But the issue with this adaptation is it forsakes the plot and piles questions on top of questions while throwing in cameo's and elongated lore dumps. It also doesn't help the Doctor is a literal blank sheet with no goal or backstory and Amiya is an unrelatable saint, while the rest of the cast don't have enough screen time to become relevant to the audience at all.

As much as I like Arknights, I genuinely don't think it's possible to derive much enjoyment from the anime without having some level of game knowledge. The only excitement or discussion related to the anime that exists anymore is Apple Pie showed up, Texas did this from players of the game. At this point, they might as well just end things with a bang and treat the entire Prelude to Dawn as a prequel or season 0. Trying to lay down the plot mid-way through an arc with 3 eps left isn't even worthwhile.

-
Aside from Ayahi Takagaki voicing Frostnova, nothing really suggests an s2 is in production. In fact I genuinely doubt they'd start production until they properly gauge reception, blu-ray sales, and game statistics. Since reaching rank 3 in playstore top grossing following ep 2, nothing major has changed with the AK revenue ranking so... yeah, probably just rumors at best.

I note that your questions about RI were answered by episode 4 during the conclusion of the contract, they explained why the reunion attacks the lungmen
Episode 5 Amiya talks about the fact that they have different views with the reunion on the topic of protecting the infected
Nov 26, 2022 12:12 AM
🥊 CHAMPION 🥊

Offline
Apr 2016
23914
Confidence!
Well, seems the enemy knows Bear!!! kekeke
Nov 26, 2022 12:45 AM
Offline
Jul 2019
1305
I was very supportive of this show as I'm an Arknights veteran but seeing this episode I can't help but be disappointed. You can see after episode 3 that the quality took a nosedive. Animation is awkward as hell and lacks energy. Action sequences leave a lot to be desired. Why are they standing there and not doing anything? An entire episode of essentially walking around in circles doing nothing.
Nov 26, 2022 12:55 AM

Offline
Jan 2009
101807
animation is bad for this episode but ye most anime have bad animation after few episodes in the beginning anyway
Nov 26, 2022 1:25 AM
Offline
Nov 2022
21
SomeGuyWithHair said:
I was very supportive of this show as I'm an Arknights veteran but seeing this episode I can't help but be disappointed. You can see after episode 3 that the quality took a nosedive. Animation is awkward as hell and lacks energy. Action sequences leave a lot to be desired. Why are they standing there and not doing anything? An entire episode of essentially walking around in circles doing nothing.
Here I disagree with you. The series reveals some issues more.
- Disagreement between the reunion and RI
-Amiya disclosure
- Demonstration of how the disease gives not only art, but also the serious condition of the patient
-Made a hint at Misha's Spoiler
About walking in a circle, quite strangely, everything was logically explained in the slums, the enemy is going along the paths where he is not to the allies.
With animation, I also did not notice anything like that, except for one blooper with a reflection in the hair.
Nov 26, 2022 4:47 AM

Offline
Feb 2014
1092
EH?! Not a single "APPLE PIE!" line from my girl Exusiai. Good to see Exusiai and Texas animated though...

A bit of a spoiler about Misha although it has been hinted on this episode.


Also if you want more spoilers.


Nov 26, 2022 6:49 AM

Offline
Feb 2021
4248
Not gonna lie, this episode was rough to watch. Animation is a downgrade, pacing feels very weird, and the whole thing just doesn't feel connected in a weird fashion. The weakest episode so far, but after good 4 previous episodes, I can still let this off the hook.

With things going, as an anime-only fan, I guess the last boss will be that full face masked person (I assume a woman from her voice and slender legs). I thought the final fight will be Rhodes vs Talulah, but that sounds rushed so all I'm asking is for the show to end on a good note.
"Nobody could laugh at someone who's trying their hardest" -Machio-

Nov 26, 2022 9:48 AM
Offline
Sep 2017
19
As someone who has no problem with restrictive animation I still enjoyed the episode. The atmosphere of the show is what keeps it interesting for me greatly helped by the backgrounds and ambient noise. Franka's monolouge at the end of the episode hit hard and it's moments like this that I vastly prefer the animes presentation.
Nov 26, 2022 1:40 PM
Offline
Mar 2022
43
DanBurr said:
As someone who has no problem with restrictive animation I still enjoyed the episode. The atmosphere of the show is what keeps it interesting for me greatly helped by the backgrounds and ambient noise. Franka's monolouge at the end of the episode hit hard and it's moments like this that I vastly prefer the animes presentation.

What anime is this?
I don’t get anything
I might as well drop it
It’s so boring
Nov 26, 2022 2:14 PM
Offline
Sep 2017
19
_Zuki said:
I might as well drop it


Probably for the best, no shame in dropping something you personally find boring. It is a slow burn political drama (with some action), if it doesn't click for you that is perfectly fine. These kinds of shows ask a lot from their viewers mainly in thinking about obscured narrative direction and character motivation, as a result can be boring and appear to be too vague.
Nov 26, 2022 2:25 PM
Offline
Mar 2022
43
DanBurr said:
_Zuki said:
I might as well drop it


Probably for the best, no shame in dropping something you personally find boring. It is a slow burn political drama (with some action), if it doesn't click for you that is perfectly fine. These kinds of shows ask a lot from their viewers mainly in thinking about obscured narrative direction and character motivation, as a result can be boring and appear to be too vague.

Yeah you right
Only God know how I got to episode 5
Nov 26, 2022 3:46 PM

Offline
Apr 2022
776
Someone played tic tac toe with spraypaint and didn't even finish the game. The cross wins damn it!

Nov 26, 2022 7:09 PM
Offline
Nov 2022
8
im very sad exu didn't say Apple pie ;-;
Nov 26, 2022 7:26 PM
Offline
Nov 2019
186
From narrative perspective they did very good. The first wise step was to start the show from the middle of a mission where one of their key members were suffering from amnesia. That made the information feeding to the viewers more natural via perspective storytelling. It helped in establishing key informations regarding power system, several hints of worldbuilding and economical highlights while showcasing sacrifices that potrayed the cruelty of their current situation. They did all that in first 3 episodes. The pacing is not rushed at all and yet they manage to explore necessary details. After that 2 episodes were a bit slow. Now only 3 episodes left. They aren't rushing things. By the looks of it this may be an information feeding project to make the viewers interested into the game instead of killing all the major characters right and left. First worldbuilding and power system, now ideologies. Doing pretty good as introductory season/project. Atleast I'm invested to know about it more unlike other mediocre gaming promotional projects from this year: Cyberpunk.
Nov 26, 2022 11:19 PM

Offline
Jul 2015
803
Honestly no complain.. This episode was just as how I remember them in the game with the Goofy Exusui taking them thru the roofs LMAO


OhWhenDidiAsk said:
im very sad exu didn't say Apple pie ;-;

Yea.. But we at least now know that Exusui DP is a freaking Apple Pie.

UkRsNov 26, 2022 11:25 PM
Nov 27, 2022 4:10 AM

Offline
May 2015
6037
Sweet home Texas!
"The future is always blank. Only your willpower can leave footsteps there."

"Ruling over death means ruling over life. Death is the climax of life. To have the best death, you must honor life."
Nov 27, 2022 6:55 AM
Shingster

Offline
Jun 2015
4422
It does seem that the partnership with the defense force is in name only. Given the oppression its no surprise that Reunion would have plenty of supporters within the slums. But to counter that its nice to see operators from penguin logistics here to help them. So there are different types of oripathy as well then. If Misha had left it she would eventually have become infected as well. If anything the lore of Arknights does a great job at showing the rifts within society that divide the two factions. Some saviors of the infected Reunion aspires to be though when they use force on those infected that don't buy their BS. But at the same time this shows why Rhode island's operators are so loyal to the cause. Overall I liked this ep and felt that it featured a nice balance of action, lore and character intros with a nice emphasis on what divided the two sides and how they treat people. Franka had quite a lot of lines but Ai Kakuma shined in her portrayal of her.
Signature removed. Please follow the signature rules, as defined in the Site & Forum Guidelines.
Nov 27, 2022 7:29 AM
Offline
Nov 2022
7
Inorichi said:
Honestly messing up ep 3 was probably the nail in the coffin. Nothing about the narrative is interesting anymore.

Why is RI in Lungmen? What does RI even do? Why are they in conflict with Reunion? The most fundamental questions that structure the plot are simply just ignored while events progress seemingly aimlessly. And they barely just answer the Who are RI and Who are Reunion for the audience with an exposition dump mid-chase in episode 5 of 8...

Adding in some lore does not substitute for a plot nor does it give the audience enough info to even begin to reasonably assume the answers to any of these questions. And once the literal backbone of events is made up in the minds of the audience (or just ignored), there are an infinite number of questions during the arc which spring up...

Who is Misha? Why is she being chased? How is Amiya the leader of RI when she's clearly immature and quite honestly incompetent? Who is Exusia? Who is Texas? Who are Penguin Logistics? Why are they helping the LGD? Why is Chen acting like she has a stick up her ass when RI is their saving grace? What is their deal with the LGD? Who is Kalstit?

Tbf, these are details can (and usually are) supplemented later on. But the issue with this adaptation is it forsakes the plot and piles questions on top of questions while throwing in cameo's and elongated lore dumps. It also doesn't help the Doctor is a literal blank sheet with no goal or backstory and Amiya is an unrelatable saint, while the rest of the cast don't have enough screen time to become relevant to the audience at all.

As much as I like Arknights, I genuinely don't think it's possible to derive much enjoyment from the anime without having some level of game knowledge. The only excitement or discussion related to the anime that exists anymore is Apple Pie showed up, Texas did this from players of the game. At this point, they might as well just end things with a bang and treat the entire Prelude to Dawn as a prequel or season 0. Trying to lay down the plot mid-way through an arc with 3 eps left isn't even worthwhile.

-
Aside from Ayahi Takagaki voicing Frostnova, nothing really suggests an s2 is in production. In fact I genuinely doubt they'd start production until they properly gauge reception, blu-ray sales, and game statistics. Since reaching rank 3 in playstore top grossing following ep 2, nothing major has changed with the AK revenue ranking so... yeah, probably just rumors at best.


"Why is RI in Lungmen? What is their deal with the LGD" EP 3, based on their analysis, Reunion's next target is Lungmen. Dr kal'tsit is there to make a contract that allows RI to operate openly inside Lungmen's borders.
"What does RI even do?" EP 2, they're a pharma company but they do more than just play with test tubes. Second half of EP 3 you get even more info.
"Why are they in conflict with Reunion?" EP 1, Reunion kills innocents, I believe that conflicts with a group that tries not to kill people at all. "Who are the reunion?" EP 1, angry infected that can't take the discrimination any more.
"Who is Misha? Why is she being chased?" The main characters don't know and they're currently trying to find out.

"Who is Exu Who is Texas? Who are Penguin Logistics? Why are they helping the LGD? Who is Kal'tsit?" You don't need to know the motivations, relationships and past's of every single character on the first episode that they're introduced in.
"Why is Ch'en acting like she has a stick up her ass when RI is their saving grace?" EP 4, because Ch'en doesn't see RI as their saving grace, she believes the LGD can handle it without RI's help.
"Doctor has no goal or backstory" EP 1 and 2, Doctor was the leading expert on Oripathy and dedicated themselves to finding a cure. Doctor was in a cold sleep and survived the "sarcophagus". EP 3, Doctor's current goal is to "complete" themselves "bit by bit" and promises to help realize Amiya's ideals.

Anyways I've been watching anime only reactors on youtube and found some that have been greatly enjoying it and theorizing about the world and characters. I've seen multiple anime onlies say they didn't mind the stiff action in episode 5 cause they're just interested in the story, characters and the world.
Nov 27, 2022 7:58 AM
Offline
Jul 2022
5
wao wao wao wao big wao
Nov 27, 2022 12:26 PM
Offline
Nov 2022
7
Inorichi said:
Evalith said:

"Why is RI in Lungmen? What is their deal with the LGD" EP 3, based on their analysis, Reunion's next target is Lungmen. Dr kal'tsit is there to make a contract that allows RI to operate openly inside Lungmen's borders.
"What does RI even do?" EP 2, they're a pharma company but they do more than just play with test tubes. Second half of EP 3 you get even more info.
"Why are they in conflict with Reunion?" EP 1, Reunion kills innocents, I believe that conflicts with a group that tries not to kill people at all. "Who are the reunion?" EP 1, angry infected that can't take the discrimination any more.
"Who is Misha? Why is she being chased?" The main characters don't know and they're currently trying to find out.

"Who is Exu Who is Texas? Who are Penguin Logistics? Why are they helping the LGD? Who is Kal'tsit?" You don't need to know the motivations, relationships and past's of every single character on the first episode that they're introduced in.
"Why is Ch'en acting like she has a stick up her ass when RI is their saving grace?" EP 4, because Ch'en doesn't see RI as their saving grace, she believes the LGD can handle it without RI's help.
"Doctor has no goal or backstory" EP 1 and 2, Doctor was the leading expert on Oripathy and dedicated themselves to finding a cure. Doctor was in a cold sleep and survived the "sarcophagus". EP 3, Doctor's current goal is to "complete" themselves "bit by bit" and promises to help realize Amiya's ideals.

Anyways I've been watching anime only reactors on youtube and found some that have been greatly enjoying it and theorizing about the world and characters. I've seen multiple anime onlies say they didn't mind the stiff action in episode 5 cause they're just interested in the story, characters and the world.


Reunion kills innocents -> So pharma company must hire PMC's and chase them across the continent to face this terrorist organization? This would make significantly more sense if RI rebranded themselves as the Avengers lol.

You're ignoring the point of my post which is that the plot is completely absent to the viewer. In fact you're only furthering the point that Lore does not substitute for a Plot. Telling the audience RI is a pharma company, does not mean anything to an anime only viewer. It confuses them more if anything since why is a pharma company hunting a terrorist org? Why does a pharma company need permission to move openly in Lungmen? And don't tell me it's cause Reunion is coming to Lungemen cause the question still remains, why is a pharma company hunting reunion? Where is the police force? The IPO? Is the LGD incompetent?

I've already addressed the side char quip you made in the post you're replying to, "Tbf, these are details can (and usually are) supplemented later on".

I'm not claiming the anime is absolutely terrible and completely unenjoyable, rather pointing out issues that many people have. Just scrolling through replies on this thread and previous threads should say enough.


Less so "chase them. hunting them." and more so making sure Lungmen doesn't fall into Reunion hands. Also it wasn't just Mephisto telling the audience that RI is a pharma company, it was telling the audience that RI is more than just a pharma company.
Mephisto: "You're a pharma company, but you do more than just play with test tubes."

This lets the audience know that RI is not in fact just a pharma company that plays with test tubes and the audience is aware cause RI is currently not doing pharma company stuff. The audience should know that this isn't "just a pharma company" "chasing" terrorists. RI is asking for permission to openly OPERATE in Lungmen, not just asking for a tour around the city. There are problems with the beginning of Arknights, but all of these ain't it.

And honestly you could say the LGD is incompetent based on the scene in EP 4 where they have trouble dealing with a single infected guy, or the fact that as said in EP 5, Reunion was using the slums to build their influence inside Lungmen and somehow Texas knew this and not the LGD (or the LGD does know but doesn't/can't do anything about it?).
Nov 27, 2022 4:00 PM

Offline
Jan 2022
1293
Man why does bunny girl even bother saving anyone? It's not like anyone ever appreciates what she does save for the "Dakutah" and Misha here.

Oh look its that wolf and angle girl that are in all that f*cked up hentai.
-insert NGE meme here-
Nov 28, 2022 12:08 AM
Offline
Oct 2019
7470
Still trying to keep Misha saved.

Wow they have Pocky (Qoocky) in this universe 🤣
Nov 28, 2022 5:06 AM

Offline
Jul 2013
1642
Man my impatience thread keeps aging really well. Everyone wants everything to be answered right away. It really is sad where the state of people has gone. We all need answers right away and nonstop action. Can't ever have a slow paced atmospheric show with mystery surrounding the world and characters. No we all need one note easy to read characters that fit archetypes.

Example. Who is Misha? Why is she being chased? I don't know just watch the show and find out. Does that need to be explained right away?

Almost every complaint I have seen comes from the show leaving stuff out and expecting the viewer to maybe have a brain and realize that the real world is complicated. Arknights doesn't just put everything on a silver platter. You have to either figure it out yourself or wait. It isn't that hard.
Nov 28, 2022 8:14 AM
Offline
Nov 2015
1
The episode has Texas in it. 10/10
Nov 29, 2022 11:09 AM
Offline
Jul 2019
860
Oh shit they got capture....................
Nov 29, 2022 3:33 PM

Offline
Feb 2018
967
Still not really sure where its going with this Misha character.
Dec 1, 2022 12:58 AM

Offline
Jul 2013
1642
Inorichi said:
Calal-Chan said:
Man my impatience thread keeps aging really well. Everyone wants everything to be answered right away. It really is sad where the state of people has gone. We all need answers right away and nonstop action. Can't ever have a slow paced atmospheric show with mystery surrounding the world and characters. No we all need one note easy to read characters that fit archetypes.

Example. Who is Misha? Why is she being chased? I don't know just watch the show and find out. Does that need to be explained right away?

Almost every complaint I have seen comes from the show leaving stuff out and expecting the viewer to maybe have a brain and realize that the real world is complicated. Arknights doesn't just put everything on a silver platter. You have to either figure it out yourself or wait. It isn't that hard.



lol it's not about impatience or gratification, it's about interest. The Arknights anime presents itself with the mysterious doctor and RI's attempt at extracting dr from Chernobog.

This is the bare exposition to the plot and what piques the audience's interest. Then the anime goes fuckall let's go to lungmen without explaining anything about RI, anything about the main character and their goals. They present questions to the audience. Who is the doctor? Who are RI? Why are they going to Lungmen? Then go on to the next arc which develops new questions like "Who is Misha" without ever elaborating. It's an issue of proper narrative structure, not anything to do with the "state of people"

Nothing about the plot is known after 5 of 8 episodes, thats the problem.



Some of those things are even explained. Who are RI for example. RI is a group of people set on trying to help infected people. The show literally info dumps this. Who is Misha as I said above doesn't need to be answered the episode she is introduced and you are going to learn more about her in literally the next episodes.

Who is the doctor is, is a big mystery throughout the entire thing so answering that right away wouldn't make sense either.

Nothing about the plot is revealed? I just don't think you were paying that much attention. We get to learn about multiple factions who are in war due to different ideals. We learn about tons of different world building on what being infected is like. We learn that Amiyas goal is to help infected. So your statement "Then the anime goes fuckall let's go to lungmen without explaining anything about RI, anything about the main character and their goals." Is just flat out wrong. I will repeat again just to be clear. It is obvious 5 episodes in that there goal is to help infected people. They are then going to lungmen for that purpose as well and are trying to work with the LGD against reunion. They find Misha who is infected so this is who they are after. Obviously I can't say how they connect but the next episodes as I continue to repeat will.

Either way Evalith has already answered a ton of info that you can gather from the anime quite easily that you have just disregarded. So yeah I very much think it is impatience and the reason I picked the Misha comment out is that it is clear you need everything answered right away when the whole point is they don't even know who she is. By the end of the arc you will know who she is. And why she connects to the story. You will also learn even more more about RI and the LGD as they communicate through the arc. Which as Evalith already stated was partially answered in episode 3 if you just put context together. You get more of that context as the arc continues. I honestly can't understand peoples confusion and impatience. It isn't that hard. If you don't enjoy it that is fine but coming up with incredibly nitpicky things that are already either answered or are a huge mystery element of the story seems really petty to me.
Dec 1, 2022 12:10 PM

Offline
Jul 2013
1642
Inorichi said:
Calal-Chan said:


Some of those things are even explained. Who are RI for example. RI is a group of people set on trying to help infected people. The show literally info dumps this. Who is Misha as I said above doesn't need to be answered the episode she is introduced and you are going to learn more about her in literally the next episodes.

Who is the doctor is, is a big mystery throughout the entire thing so answering that right away wouldn't make sense either.

Nothing about the plot is revealed? I just don't think you were paying that much attention. We get to learn about multiple factions who are in war due to different ideals. We learn about tons of different world building on what being infected is like. We learn that Amiyas goal is to help infected. So your statement "Then the anime goes fuckall let's go to lungmen without explaining anything about RI, anything about the main character and their goals." Is just flat out wrong. I will repeat again just to be clear. It is obvious 5 episodes in that there goal is to help infected people. They are then going to lungmen for that purpose as well and are trying to work with the LGD against reunion. They find Misha who is infected so this is who they are after. Obviously I can't say how they connect but the next episodes as I continue to repeat will.

Either way Evalith has already answered a ton of info that you can gather from the anime quite easily that you have just disregarded. So yeah I very much think it is impatience and the reason I picked the Misha comment out is that it is clear you need everything answered right away when the whole point is they don't even know who she is. By the end of the arc you will know who she is. And why she connects to the story. You will also learn even more more about RI and the LGD as they communicate through the arc. Which as Evalith already stated was partially answered in episode 3 if you just put context together. You get more of that context as the arc continues. I honestly can't understand peoples confusion and impatience. It isn't that hard. If you don't enjoy it that is fine but coming up with incredibly nitpicky things that are already either answered or are a huge mystery element of the story seems really petty to me.


Lack of Explanation != Mystery

Saying the Doctor has amnesia is an element of mystery. Their past is unknown. However, that is not an explanation or reason for the CURRENT doctor to have extremely weak and confusing motives and fly about to Lungmen on an international terrorist hunt without clarifying his/her own motives, goals, or desires.

The only thing being disregarded is the point being made. I iterated numerous times that arc related questions like "Who is Misha" does not matter to anyone and will obviously be clarified later.

"RI is a group of people set on trying to help infected people.". Helping != World Police Force. Helping people and hunting terrorists are very different. The jump in logic from what they say, to what they do makes little sense. The only thing that's explicitly stated is RI is a Pharma company, which contradicts what happens on screen with RI being more capable than actual armed defenders of the most populous cities.

Learning more about Lungmen after they get there is absolutely fine, perfect. But not explaining "Why are we going to Lungmen?" Then ignoring the entire overarching plot and moving onto a side objective regarding Misha for 1-2 eps is just poor narrative structure.
Having W appear in episode 3, cutting out all the information about Scout's squad, removing her dialogue about what she got from her interaction with Doctor and Amiya, and using still frames so nothing shows on W's face isn't about impatience or gratification. It's poor series comp.

Nothing is 'already' answered. It's poorly implied with lore, which I've stated does not substitute for a plot.


Contrary to what I'm saying, I'm actually more or less enjoying Arknights, but just because I like something does not immediately make it 10/10, perfect masterpiece. There are points that the show does well like the art direction given the staff's experience, and parts the show aren't so great such as episode structure and series composition given the "staff's/Hypergryphs?" lack of experience.

I'm not going to cover my eyes, pretend it's the best thing ever, and go about re-affirming biased beliefs, this isn't twitter. It's an episode discussion thread, I'm going to bring up the points worthwhile discussing. If you want to disagree, go right ahead. But do it with facts from the anime, not the "people's state of minds".


I don't think the Arknights anime is perfect either but I do find most of your complaints here to be stretching and multiple points were answered or are going to be answered. The show tells us that RI isn't just a pharma company by their actions and what they are doing. Not to mention a character says it out loud lol. We don't need the show to info dump us exactly what they are because god knows the show info dumps enough stuff already. Some of your complaints seem to come from the anime apparently not being a good adaptation in some aspects like with W, but if we are being honest the game handles this starting stuff way worse than the adaptation. I am glad you are enjoying it but don't act like your beliefs aren't biased either. Everybody's brain connects and notices different things due to our own bias but you stating "I'm not going to cover my eyes, pretend it's the best thing ever, and go about re-affirming biased beliefs, this isn't twitter." is like putting your opinion on a pedestal like it is better than everyone else's.

I just personally find your complaints to be nitpicky considering many are literally answered within the show. Like you pointing out my RI helps infected people saying that them helping people doesn't equal World Police Force. But through the show we can see that just them going out and helping people involves fighting Reunion. Even if they would rather not fight them. So them having to fight and gather people who can makes sense. It is easy to infer this all through context.

I guess all in all if you want to agree to disagree I can do that obviously. Though as I said I have complaints about Arknights in general too so I don't think you even realize how much we probably do agree on. I just have gotten tired of people being confused when honestly everything is really quite simple in this show.
Calal-ChanDec 1, 2022 12:14 PM
Dec 1, 2022 2:00 PM

Offline
Jul 2013
1642
Inorichi said:
Calal-Chan said:


I don't think the Arknights anime is perfect either but I do find most of your complaints here to be stretching and multiple points were answered or are going to be answered. The show tells us that RI isn't just a pharma company by their actions and what they are doing. Not to mention a character says it out loud lol. We don't need the show to info dump us exactly what they are because god knows the show info dumps enough stuff already. Some of your complaints seem to come from the anime apparently not being a good adaptation in some aspects like with W, but if we are being honest the game handles this starting stuff way worse than the adaptation. I am glad you are enjoying it but don't act like your beliefs aren't biased either. Everybody's brain connects and notices different things due to our own bias but you stating "I'm not going to cover my eyes, pretend it's the best thing ever, and go about re-affirming biased beliefs, this isn't twitter." is like putting your opinion on a pedestal like it is better than everyone else's.

I just personally find your complaints to be nitpicky considering many are literally answered within the show. Like you pointing out my RI helps infected people saying that them helping people doesn't equal World Police Force. But through the show we can see that just them going out and helping people involves fighting Reunion. Even if they would rather not fight them. So them having to fight and gather people who can makes sense. It is easy to infer this all through context.

I guess all in all if you want to agree to disagree I can do that obviously. Though as I said I have complaints about Arknights in general too so I don't think you even realize how much we probably do agree on. I just have gotten tired of people being confused when honestly everything is really quite simple in this show.



I agree that nobody is completely objective and I wasn't trying to put my opinions on a pedestal or anything with that quote, just saying that I'm not looking for confirmation bias and am stating my own opinion with my reasoning. Obviously, I have my own bias view on the anime and others may disagree, but they'll also be able to see my point of view hence the discussions thread.

I don't deny that anyone can make the assumption that RI's attempt to help the infected leads them to conflict with Reunion, but the issue is that unless the infected only exist where Reunion go, why is RI going to Lungmen? Why not go to Ursus or Victoria and help the infected there? Why does a pharma company intentionally choose the path which leads to conflict with terrorists?

If their goal isn't to fight Reunion, there's no reason to specifically go to Lungmen. If their goal IS to fight Reunion, it would be much more logical for RI to ambush Reunion themselves when Reunion is unprepared, then to attempt to defend a massive city from Reunion who could attack at any time at any place. Yes the audience can make assumptions through the lore given in the show, but these will ultimately be assumptions and are not always correct.

A large selling point of Arknights is it's expansive world building, but if you try to view the events of the anime with this broader world view, it makes the audience question why RI is doing what they're doing. Without knowledge of the game, anime only viewers are forced to make assumption after assumption, and the show isn't explicitly leading the viewer on or supplementing them with any new information to help rather completely ignoring these questions while moving onto a subplot with Misha.

For the most part, I see where you're coming from, that people can make assumptions about the plot. But what I think is that there simply isn't enough information given to the audience to make good assumptions. Which is the complaint I see most of in discussions, that people that haven't played the game do not understand where the show is going and why.



All that is fair. Arknights has always had a fairly week start even in game, but I do think it is a bit weak due to the fact how big Arknights world truly gets. Thanks for being civil. I don't really have much else to add.
Dec 2, 2022 9:20 PM

Offline
Aug 2014
991
Hmm who is that person in red
Check My AnimeList (or click my signature)
My Main Genres: Adventure, Action, Fantasy
My Sub Genres: Slice of Life, Comedy, H&E

Check My Profile, my ranking
What I Watch This Season
Best Character & WAIFU This Season
Best OP/ED Song This Season
Dec 7, 2022 5:18 PM
Offline
Nov 2022
2
absolutely awesome
Dec 9, 2022 12:46 AM
Offline
Nov 2022
21
Inorichi said:
Calal-Chan said:


I don't think the Arknights anime is perfect either but I do find most of your complaints here to be stretching and multiple points were answered or are going to be answered. The show tells us that RI isn't just a pharma company by their actions and what they are doing. Not to mention a character says it out loud lol. We don't need the show to info dump us exactly what they are because god knows the show info dumps enough stuff already. Some of your complaints seem to come from the anime apparently not being a good adaptation in some aspects like with W, but if we are being honest the game handles this starting stuff way worse than the adaptation. I am glad you are enjoying it but don't act like your beliefs aren't biased either. Everybody's brain connects and notices different things due to our own bias but you stating "I'm not going to cover my eyes, pretend it's the best thing ever, and go about re-affirming biased beliefs, this isn't twitter." is like putting your opinion on a pedestal like it is better than everyone else's.

I just personally find your complaints to be nitpicky considering many are literally answered within the show. Like you pointing out my RI helps infected people saying that them helping people doesn't equal World Police Force. But through the show we can see that just them going out and helping people involves fighting Reunion. Even if they would rather not fight them. So them having to fight and gather people who can makes sense. It is easy to infer this all through context.

I guess all in all if you want to agree to disagree I can do that obviously. Though as I said I have complaints about Arknights in general too so I don't think you even realize how much we probably do agree on. I just have gotten tired of people being confused when honestly everything is really quite simple in this show.



I agree that nobody is completely objective and I wasn't trying to put my opinions on a pedestal or anything with that quote, just saying that I'm not looking for confirmation bias and am stating my own opinion with my reasoning. Obviously, I have my own bias view on the anime and others may disagree, but they'll also be able to see my point of view hence the discussions thread.

I don't deny that anyone can make the assumption that RI's attempt to help the infected leads them to conflict with Reunion, but the issue is that unless the infected only exist where Reunion go, why is RI going to Lungmen? Why not go to Ursus or Victoria and help the infected there? Why does a pharma company intentionally choose the path which leads to conflict with terrorists?

If their goal isn't to fight Reunion, there's no reason to specifically go to Lungmen. If their goal IS to fight Reunion, it would be much more logical for RI to ambush Reunion themselves when Reunion is unprepared, then to attempt to defend a massive city from Reunion who could attack at any time at any place. Yes the audience can make assumptions through the lore given in the show, but these will ultimately be assumptions and are not always correct.

A large selling point of Arknights is it's expansive world building, but if you try to view the events of the anime with this broader world view, it makes the audience question why RI is doing what they're doing. Without knowledge of the game, anime only viewers are forced to make assumption after assumption, and the show isn't explicitly leading the viewer on or supplementing them with any new information to help rather completely ignoring these questions while moving onto a subplot with Misha.

For the most part, I see where you're coming from, that people can make assumptions about the plot. But what I think is that there simply isn't enough information given to the audience to make good assumptions. Which is the complaint I see most of in discussions, that people that haven't played the game do not understand where the show is going and why.



Isn't it interesting when the viewer is not mistaken for an idiot, and everything is not chewed on him?

Well, yes, let's go completely into the depths, here we see organizations of the infected organizing genocide, what do you think in a world where prejudice against the infected is already great, will other countries begin to put much more pressure on the infected? And will other countries be ready to conduct a dialogue with those infected from the Republic of Ingushetia?

What ambush are you talking about? We have a desert here, you will not have enough people to surround it on the road to Longmen. The city itself is gigantic. Therefore, excuse me, but your brilliant strategic ideas are nonsense, impracticable from the point of view of human resources.
Pages (2) [1] 2 »

More topics from this board

» Non Arknights players?

_Aokii - Oct 29, 2022

23 by Nimo127 »»
May 27, 7:38 AM

Poll: » Arknights: Reimei Zensou Episode 8 Discussion ( 1 2 )

deg - Dec 16, 2022

93 by ChitOKun »»
May 15, 8:15 AM

» Is it canon that the doctor is a caucasian?

Papa_Scorch - Apr 23, 2023

6 by ChitOKun »»
May 15, 8:13 AM

Poll: » Arknights: Reimei Zensou Episode 1 Discussion ( 1 2 3 4 5 )

Boazanian - Oct 28, 2022

231 by bushman66 »»
Feb 27, 7:49 PM

Poll: » Arknights: Reimei Zensou Episode 4 Discussion ( 1 2 )

Mcsuper - Nov 18, 2022

57 by soupeatinger »»
Jan 14, 5:29 AM
It’s time to ditch the text file.
Keep track of your anime easily by creating your own list.
Sign Up Login