| I've been eagerly awaiting an approval. I don't know what goes on behind the scenes and am sure there is a reason but wasn't this animation created in Japan? Surely it can be approved otherwise why even have an entry in the database to begin with... I love MAL and when I'm watching a show I HAVE TO update it and if I can't it eats at me for lack of a better word. Can this please get approved soon?!?! |
 |
| Yeah seriously. It's already got pages on anilist and others. This is the only thing from this season I'm watching that I can't add to my list and it's crazy. AND this was announced months ago. If it's due to a lack of mods or something, I'd volunteer to assist. |
| For real. We're into episode 5 already. |
 |
| Mods are Gundam haters or something. This is one of the best things airing this season. It should be top priority. |
Keiggard said: Um what?!?! Just because something hasn't gotten approved right away you say this site has gone downhill? That's ludicrous. This site has gotten better and better since I joined back in early 2016, and now that DeNA has bought MAL it can only get better!This site has really gone down hill. It's a shame. |
|
| Off topic but it's funny to see some people not know that MAL isn't with DeNA anymore. Media Do owns it now. |
The_Sum_of_Zero said: Oh, apologies I couldn't remember if it was Media Do or DeNA who bought them recently... I remember reading the article a month or so ago.Off topic but it's funny to see some people not know that MAL isn't with DeNA anymore. Media Do owns it now. |
|
Nezuko_Cypress said: Keiggard said: Um what?!?! Just because something hasn't gotten approved right away you say this site has gone downhill? That's ludicrous. This site has gotten better and better since I joined back in early 2016, and now that DeNA has bought MAL it can only get better!This site has really gone down hill. It's a shame. I hope this is trolling Lucky me I also have an account on AniList and I can track my watching of THE ORIGIN there. |
|
anikevin said: Mods are Gundam haters or something. This is one of the best things airing this season. It should be top priority. Approving seasonal entries should be top priority always. |
|
killahoe said: Its honestly getting ridiculous. If the original 2015 movies can get approved why can't this? It's just a TV edit. It's the exact same thing as your typical recap episode.Seriously... there isnt even any info listed about characters or anything. Why is this anime being overlooked. |
|
Bekoniyataki said: Yeah someone said something like that already, it's ridiculous at this point. Someone also said the mods hate Gundam and I'm starting to believe it, another said they hope this is trolling. I mean it's the 40th Anniversary of the Gundam franchise surely this can get approved.Yea, already episode 5, worth to approve imo |
|
| As much as having the Gundam movies trilogy as its own trinity separated from the TV series is a good thing, I still don't se the point of having Unicorn and The Origin's TV recuts as their own things... |
Rei366 said: As much as having the Gundam movies trilogy as its own trinity separated from the TV series is a good thing, I still don't se the point of having Unicorn and The Origin's TV recuts as their own things... how are we going to discuss the TV series version? The episode count doesn't match. Also this was only avaiable in OVA format before, now it is a proper seasonal It is different from, say, https://myanimelist.net/anime/13601/Psycho-Pass where it had a REBROADCAST after the TV series ended It seems that MAL doesn't know what to do with these kind of entries, because Unicorn already has its own entry but THE ORIGIN and this https://myanimelist.net/anime/39695/Zoku_Owarimonogatari https://myanimelist.net/anime/36999/Zoku_Owarimonogatari Are pending approval (the tv version of zoku owari) If they aren't going to accept these two pending entries, they may as well delete the TV version of Unicorn (and other similar cases - I don't know any other than Zoku Owarimonogatari) |
deimoscodeMay 28, 2019 8:24 AM
|
Nezuko_Cypress said: Bekoniyataki said: Yeah someone said something like that already, it's ridiculous at this point. Someone also said the mods hate Gundam and I'm starting to believe it, another said they hope this is trolling. I mean it's the 40th Anniversary of the Gundam franchise surely this can get approved.Yea, already episode 5, worth to approve imo The mods hate Gundam? Well, guess I'm gonna look into an alternate list site. Is anilist decent? (Kidding. Sorta.) |
The_Sum_of_ZeroMay 28, 2019 7:53 PM
The_Sum_of_Zero said: No idea, I strictly use MAL. It's my preferred platform.Nezuko_Cypress said: Yeah someone said something like that already, it's ridiculous at this point. Someone also said the mods hate Gundam and I'm starting to believe it, another said they hope this is trolling. I mean it's the 40th Anniversary of the Gundam franchise surely this can get approved. The mods hate Gundam? Well, guess I'm gonna look into an alternate list site. Is anilist decent? |
|
| lol its simply because there is not enough database moderators, the admins says they will recruit more but that takes a lot of time on its own it will be approved in the future no doubt, heck if you compare the manga approval queue that takes much much longer and i heard the backlog of the manga approval is in 7000+ manga entries and that is fucking ridiculous and good luck to the new manga database moderators with that |
changelog said: deg said: lol its simply because there is not enough database moderators, the admins says they will recruit more but that takes a lot of time on its own it will be approved in the future no doubt, heck if you compare the manga approval queue that takes much much longer and i heard the backlog of the manga approval is in 7000+ manga entries and that is fucking ridiculous and good luck to the new manga database moderators with that just my opinion but i do not think it will be approved at all. gundam: the origin is just a re-release of this https://myanimelist.net/anime/10937/Mobile_Suit_Gundam__The_Origin in tv format. Gundam Unicorn have a TV format too and that was approved if im right |
changelog said: the tv format of gundamn unicorn has almost on hour of new content/edited content whereas whereas currently gundamn the origin (tv) has been the exact same content as the original. unless they add/edit content to a significant degree, i doubt it will be added to the db. Unicorn RE:0096 had ZERO new content outside of the opening/endings. A few scenes maybe had a very few details added but otherwise it was identical to the OVAs. |
changelog said: The_Sum_of_Zero said: Unicorn RE:0096 had ZERO new content outside of the opening/endings. A few scenes maybe had a very few details added but otherwise it was identical to the OVAs. imo the new op and eds are enough to justify it having a separate entry. I'm not arguing against you, I think it deserves its own entry as well. I just keep seeing people saying RE:0096 has a bunch of new content when it doesn't. I also think the HD Remasters of SEED and DESTINY should get their own entries since their episode count and some openings/endings are different from the originals. |
OGLainFag said: So we have shity music videos like shelter but not this? amazing why the random shitting on shelter? LULWUT |
| Yes, please, approve this already. Thumbs up |
| "Manga readers are annoying, all they do is complain or spoil the anime we discuss in an anime forum. They should really do their whining at manga forums." Stolen from Janethan23. Add in visual novel readers too |
| We're up to episode 9 and this is still in limbo? What a joke. |
| The problem isn't to be approved or not, but not to release the episodes count for users. The function of this site is to allow users to organize their lists. If the entry is not approved, then delete it. But until then, allow the all functions. |
| There is nothing more annoying than watching a show and you go to update it but literally can't because it hasn't been approved yet. It baffles me why Anime like this don't get approved. It came from Japan did it not? Just because it's a TV edit doesn't mean it's any different from the film version and that got approved. If the movie version can get approved why can't this? They're the same thing just formatted differently. |
|
| 10 episodes and it still hasn't been approved... |
 |
| Another week it's been on Toonami and still not approved. I'm going to keep fucking posting until this shit gets approved. |
| It seems like none of the moderators are patrolling these threads enough to take notice, so we may have to reach out to them ourselves. I think if everyone here that cares about having this entry approved sends a message to each of the moderators in charge of the database we'll have a much better chance of having something done about it. Here is the list of all the anime database moderators. I think the main points we should try to mention when contacting them are:
Any thoughts on what to mention in these messages? It would probably be rude to blow up their inboxes with a bunch of messages all at once, but I think if everyone sent these messages at different times throughout the coming week it would show that a lot of people really care about it. |
 |
MrLegitimacy said: Will do... thank you for the suggestion.It seems like none of the moderators are patrolling these threads enough to take notice, so we may have to reach out to them ourselves. I think if everyone here that cares about having this entry approved sends a message to each of the moderators in charge of the database we'll have a much better chance of having something done about it. Here is the list of all the anime database moderators. I think the main points we should try to mention when contacting them are:
Any thoughts on what to mention in these messages? It would probably be rude to blow up their inboxes with a bunch of messages all at once, but I think if everyone sent these messages at different times throughout the coming week it would show that a lot of people really care about it. |
|
| Still not approved huh... this is beyond ridiculous! If Anilist can approve this why can't MAL? If they are to be MAL's competitors then don't you think something legit like this should be approved so people don't decide to go to Anilist and update Gundam Origin (TV EDIT) there?! I don't know anymore man, this is unbelievable! |
|
| 2 episodes left and nothing yet, shame... |
 |
| This is getting to be beyond fucking stupid. |
| Already watched Episode 12 |
Steam: https://steamcommunity.com/id/DouBleHDx /// Steam2: https://steamcommunity.com/id/DouBleHDx10  I'm level  on mal-badges. View my badges. |
| I just want to close this tab... |
  Kuinra "Kawaii Koinu" Daikuwa Shisa, Sheriff of Alberi Ventosi, Last of the Grays |
More topics from this board
Poll: » Mobile Suit Gundam: The Origin - Advent of the Red Comet Episode 13 DiscussionRod_Russ - Aug 14, 2019 |
12 |
by Ten
»»
Apr 29, 5:08 PM |
|
Poll: » Mobile Suit Gundam: The Origin - Advent of the Red Comet Episode 11 DiscussionVysarine - Sep 15, 2019 |
4 |
by Ten
»»
Apr 29, 3:48 PM |
|
Poll: » Mobile Suit Gundam: The Origin - Advent of the Red Comet Episode 9 DiscussionVysarine - Sep 1, 2019 |
4 |
by Ten
»»
Apr 29, 2:55 PM |
|
Poll: » Mobile Suit Gundam: The Origin - Advent of the Red Comet Episode 8 DiscussionVysarine - Aug 25, 2019 |
3 |
by Ten
»»
Apr 29, 1:44 PM |
|
Poll: » Mobile Suit Gundam: The Origin - Advent of the Red Comet Episode 6 DiscussionBerry-Vodka - Jul 16, 2021 |
4 |
by Ten
»»
Apr 29, 12:25 PM |