Editor changed

Jan 23, 6:32 AM

Offline

Dec 2023

190

Does editors even matter when it comes to oda?
He has already said that he doesn't like someone else's idea and the editor will be in a inferior position to him.

Jan 23, 6:37 AM

#3

Elti979

Offline

Apr 2022

450

Ruthless_Lord said:
Does editors even matter when it comes to oda?
He has already said that he doesn't like someone else's idea and the editor will be in a inferior position to him.

editors matter just look up what they did to change one piece

Jan 23, 7:10 AM

#4

Nobef

Offline

Oct 2023

77

lets see what they can cookup

Jan 23, 7:19 AM

#5

Animeborn1

Offline

Aug 2018

27

Ruthless_Lord said:
Does editors even matter when it comes to oda?
He has already said that he doesn't like someone else's idea and the editor will be in a inferior position to him.

editors have recently done a good job at keeping oda unchecked stuff like the warlords and the supernovas were created on a whim by oda and have drastically increased the length of one piece

Jan 23, 7:26 AM

#6

IAmVento

Offline

Nov 2015

179

Ruthless_Lord said:
Does editors even matter when it comes to oda?
He has already said that he doesn't like someone else's idea and the editor will be in a inferior position to him.

The editor is way above the author. If the editor rejects an idea the author has to redo it

Jan 23, 11:16 AM

#7

Ruthless_Lord

Offline

Dec 2023

190

IAmVento said:

Ruthless_Lord said:
Does editors even matter when it comes to oda?
He has already said that he doesn't like someone else's idea and the editor will be in a inferior position to him.

The editor is way above the author. If the editor rejects an idea the author has to redo it

In normal cases yes.
But do you really believe that one Piece which is going for 28 years, if author disagrees with editor. Then editor can make changes?

Eiichiro oda is way more influential than some editor who changes every few years, I know how normally things work, but one Piece is different.

Ruthless_LordJan 23, 11:23 AM

Jan 23, 11:18 AM

#8

Ruthless_Lord

Offline

Dec 2023

190

Elti979 said:

Ruthless_Lord said:
Does editors even matter when it comes to oda?
He has already said that he doesn't like someone else's idea and the editor will be in a inferior position to him.

editors matter just look up what they did to change one piece

I don't know where to look up. If it has happened in earlier years then it's certainly possible but I doubt it happens now with oda.

I have also read in SBS, he specifically said he doesn't like anyone else's idea even editor's.

He is writing One Piece for more than 28 years, editors change every few years.

Ruthless_LordJan 23, 11:25 AM

Jan 23, 11:19 AM

#9

Ruthless_Lord

Offline

Dec 2023

190

Animeborn1 said:

Ruthless_Lord said:
Does editors even matter when it comes to oda?
He has already said that he doesn't like someone else's idea and the editor will be in a inferior position to him.

editors have recently done a good job at keeping oda unchecked stuff like the warlords and the supernovas were created on a whim by oda and have drastically increased the length of one piece

I don't understand what you are trying to say. Sorry.

Jan 23, 12:31 PM

#10

Animeborn1

Offline

Aug 2018

27

Ruthless_Lord said:

Animeborn1 said:

editors have recently done a good job at keeping oda unchecked stuff like the warlords and the supernovas were created on a whim by oda and have drastically increased the length of one piece

I don't understand what you are trying to say. Sorry.

the warlords and the supernovas were created because oda wanted to and weren't originally planned and it drastically increased the length of one piece

Jan 23, 6:59 PM

#11

Ruthless_Lord

Offline

Dec 2023

190

Animeborn1 said:

Ruthless_Lord said:

I don't understand what you are trying to say. Sorry.

the warlords and the supernovas were created because oda wanted to and weren't originally planned and it drastically increased the length of one piece

Yes I did read something about this in SBS, I don't remember exactly though.

Jan 24, 1:59 AM

#12

Madada3913

Offline

Sep 2022

34

Ruthless_Lord said:

IAmVento said:

The editor is way above the author. If the editor rejects an idea the author has to redo it

In normal cases yes.
But do you really believe that one Piece which is going for 28 years, if author disagrees with editor. Then editor can make changes?

Eiichiro oda is way more influential than some editor who changes every few years, I know how normally things work, but one Piece is different.

but editors can change something for example backstory of senor pink was in manga because editor wanted it there but oda himself didnt want it there

Jan 24, 2:00 AM

#13

Irshiki

Offline

Apr 2022

299

Ruthless_Lord said:
Does editors even matter when it comes to oda?
He has already said that he doesn't like someone else's idea and the editor will be in a inferior position to him.

Editors stopped to matter with Oda a long time ago, not because their role are inferior to him, but because he himself became an author so famous, so important to Shueisha itself that he can really do whatever he wants without even listening to what the editors says.

Jan 24, 7:50 AM

#14

Animeborn1

Offline

Aug 2018

27

Ruthless_Lord said:

Animeborn1 said:

the warlords and the supernovas were created because oda wanted to and weren't originally planned and it drastically increased the length of one piece

Yes I did read something about this in SBS, I don't remember exactly though.

yea and now the editors aren't necessarily saying oda can't do something but it's more like keeping him in check and not adding a plot line that will drastically increase the length

Jan 24, 8:16 AM

#15

Ruthless_Lord

Offline

Dec 2023

190

Animeborn1 said:

Ruthless_Lord said:

Yes I did read something about this in SBS, I don't remember exactly though.

yea and now the editors aren't necessarily saying oda can't do something but it's more like keeping him in check and not adding a plot line that will drastically increase the length

Yep, that's very necessary. I already can't see it ending even in next 5 years, who knows what will happen if he started adding even more plot lines.

Jan 24, 9:17 AM

#16

Animeborn1

Offline

Aug 2018

27

Ruthless_Lord said:

Animeborn1 said:

yea and now the editors aren't necessarily saying oda can't do something but it's more like keeping him in check and not adding a plot line that will drastically increase the length

Yep, that's very necessary. I already can't see it ending even in next 5 years, who knows what will happen if he started adding even more plot lines.

I mean the ending is definitely in sight this is the final saga with at Most 2 more arcs left but if I had to guess 10 years tops

Jan 24, 9:56 AM

#17

Ruthless_Lord

Offline

Dec 2023

190

Animeborn1 said:

Ruthless_Lord said:

Yep, that's very necessary. I already can't see it ending even in next 5 years, who knows what will happen if he started adding even more plot lines.

I mean the ending is definitely in sight this is the final saga with at Most 2 more arcs left but if I had to guess 10 years tops

Laughtale Island Arc, war Arc and post war Arc, atleast 3 arcs.

Blackbeard's backstory, Shanks and dragon too. More mythology about sun god as well as ancient kingdom and joyboy. What's one Piece, what is Luffy's dream? Imu's identity.

There is just too many stories left to tell. I probably may have missed many to mention too.

Jan 24, 12:49 PM

#18

Fluffygreygrass

Community Mod

~~꧁❃꧂~~

Offline

Nov 2022

655

Reply to Elti979

Ruthless_Lord said:
Does editors even matter when it comes to oda?
He has already said that he doesn't like someone else's idea and the editor will be in a inferior position to him.

editors matter just look up what they did to change one piece

@Elti979 Other than the warlords and supernovas, what else was changed?

Jan 24, 4:20 PM

#19

Animeborn1

Offline

Aug 2018

27

animegamer245 said:

Animeborn1 said:
the warlords and the supernovas were created because oda wanted to and weren't originally planned and it drastically increased the length of one piece

I thought the Supernova's were created because Oda's editor thought the Sabody arc felt a bit empty & suggested adding more characters to make it more interesting.

well no it was oda but yea that's why but but that was him letting his imagination go wild which the editors now try to keep him from doing that kinda thing obviously tho he gets final say

Jan 26, 7:17 AM

#20

IAmVento

Offline

Nov 2015

179

Ruthless_Lord said:

IAmVento said:

The editor is way above the author. If the editor rejects an idea the author has to redo it

In normal cases yes.
But do you really believe that one Piece which is going for 28 years, if author disagrees with editor. Then editor can make changes?

Eiichiro oda is way more influential than some editor who changes every few years, I know how normally things work, but one Piece is different.

I agree Oda has control of his series. I was responding to the last thing he said which was that the editor is an inferior position to the author.

» 2 things someguy - Yesterday	20	by JoeChip »» 16 minutes ago
Poll: » One Piece Chapter 1139 Discussion FMmatron - 5 hours ago	7	by Orangeblobfish »» 2 hours ago
Poll: » One Piece Chapter 502 Discussion VK11 - Jun 5, 2008	45	by M0ominfan »» Yesterday, 7:56 PM
Poll: » One Piece Chapter 501 Discussion Darkreaper70 - May 29, 2008	35	by M0ominfan »» Yesterday, 7:33 PM
Poll: » One Piece Chapter 1138 Discussion ( 1 2 ) FMmatron - Jan 28	66	by rey_s9 »» Yesterday, 9:44 AM

Editor changed

More topics from this board

» 2 things

Poll: » One Piece Chapter 1139 Discussion

Poll: » One Piece Chapter 502 Discussion

Poll: » One Piece Chapter 501 Discussion

Poll: » One Piece Chapter 1138 Discussion ( 1 2 )

MoreTop Anime

MoreTop Airing Anime

MoreMost Popular Characters