OppaiLover-_- said:Sorry but your expectations must have been very low then, if you look at the manga art style of both Manga series it's great, and then you look at the anime and they just butchered it. Same thing with hinomaru sumo but atleast that was mostly 2D instead of bad CGI.
You keep calling the CGI shitty but haven't actually explained why or how yet at all... What part of its animation specifically, was so low quality and off-putting to you? And are you sure it isn't just you not liking CGI as an animation style?
But no, just because I didn't go into this ((CGI)) show expecting the art style to match the manga's (which is actually famous for its quality... And would be just about impossible to do true justice to even with 2D animation...) doesn't mean I had "very low" expectations... I went in with the expectations I always do. The same set of "very low" expectations that got me to a much lower mean score than you for our shared anime.
Are you sure you didn't go into this with unfair expectations? Because possibly this style of animation just isn't your thing?
I guess I should ask - are there any CGI anime you do like? What do you think of Houseki no Kuni's CGI? And since I can't see this show on your lists, just how far did you get into it? I doubt you'd give it a second chance, but I personally found it improved greatly after the first episode or two, and the proper fighting started.
And just to be clear here - I wasn't saying you were wrong for thinking it's ugly or disappointing, your opinion with that is just as valid as mine. No style works for everyone. It's just that I strongly disagree with the CGI and its animation quality being "shitty". It's always well-shot and well-choreographed, its models are detailed and well-stylized, it's expressive while nearly always maintaining reasonable model believability, it blends well with the 2D art and the numerous (IMO very great) effects the staff utilize, and like I said--it also always conveys momentum and impact very well in the fights. Truly shitty CGI is the 2016 Berserk adaptation, or that Overlord CGI, not this. Don't get me wrong, it's far from the best, but "shitty"? "Shitty" enough to completely ruin it...?
It should only do that if you have a very strong natural aversion towards the type of animation. |