| Moved from Anime Discussion |
| Yeah so it should be listed as a sequel on here. |
hadakanohadaka said: It's not a direct sequel more of a spiritual successor to Amagami SS I feel like that's something you'd say about Amagami SS to Kimikiss Pure Rouge. When you bring a character back and introduce family ties to the original then we're already in sequel territory. |
| Should've put this under the Alternative Settings of Amagami SS since it's pretty clear it is set in the same setting and world. |
 |
tr1ckst3r said: Should've put this under the Alternative Settings of Amagami SS since it's pretty clear it is set in the same setting and world. I'd disagree with that. Alternative Setting seems to be for same characters in a different setting. For Seiren the characters are mostly different and the setting is still the same. |
AmethystItalian said: oh, I mean spin-off of Amagami SS.tr1ckst3r said: Should've put this under the Alternative Settings of Amagami SS since it's pretty clear it is set in the same setting and world. I'd disagree with that. Alternative Setting seems to be for same characters in a different setting. For Seiren the characters are mostly different and the setting is still the same. |
|
tr1ckst3r said: AmethystItalian said: oh, I mean spin-off of Amagami SS.I'd disagree with that. Alternative Setting seems to be for same characters in a different setting. For Seiren the characters are mostly different and the setting is still the same. Even spin off is weird as it's set in the future of the original series. |
AmethystItalian said: well that is spin offs, I don't think the timeline matter as long as it set in the same setting and world.tr1ckst3r said: oh, I mean spin-off of Amagami SS. Even spin off is weird as it's set in the future of the original series. |
|
PaverschlevMKII said: I think in 'MAL' terms this would be classified as "Other" since it takes place in the same universe and such and has some ties to Amagami SS. Just to look at Code Geass's main story and then the movies that relate to it but not directly are under "Other". I feel it should get the same treatment as the Macross series does on MAL. Set in the future? Check Same universe? Check Character relations to past entry? Check Can't see it being anything other than a sequel when using Macross as precedent. |
| It would confuse those who'll start watching Amagami SS and see this as a sequel. Amagami SS is based on the VN and this is original, the only thing that they have in common is the setting (+ the 2 relations above). It's better off staying as 'Other' than a sequel to separate them, imo. I mean it's not Alternate Setting/Version, not a side story and not really a sequel (even if it's years later in the same school, the focus is on different characters). |
Raccoon_Citizen said: It would confuse those who'll start watching Amagami SS and see this as a sequel. Amagami SS is based on the VN and this is original, the only thing that they have in common is the setting (+ the 2 relations above). It's better off staying as 'Other' than a sequel to separate them, imo. I mean it's not Alternate Setting/Version, not a side story and not really a sequel (even if it's years later in the same school, the focus is on different characters). Macross is in the exact same situation. Should we change all those to "Other" as well? People seem to manage fine with that show. It's set years later, in the same universe with a focus on new characters. If anything Amagami has an even stronger relation as they have a character that was actually in both. |
AmethystItalian said: I didn't watch Macross so I can't say much about it, only that it's an action/mecha/military/romance/sci-Fi/space (so they can have a relation between them related to a conflict/aftermath of something or whatever) while Amagami SS is mostly focusing on romance between those set of people. Especially since it has side stories and a sequel, separating them as 'Other' is prefered.Raccoon_Citizen said: It would confuse those who'll start watching Amagami SS and see this as a sequel. Amagami SS is based on the VN and this is original, the only thing that they have in common is the setting (+ the 2 relations above). It's better off staying as 'Other' than a sequel to separate them, imo. I mean it's not Alternate Setting/Version, not a side story and not really a sequel (even if it's years later in the same school, the focus is on different characters). Macross is in the exact same situation. Should we change all those to "Other" as well? People seem to manage fine with that show. It's set years later, in the same universe with a focus on new characters. If anything Amagami has an even stronger relation as they have a character that was actually in both. And honestly, I don't see that one character as a strong relation since he appeared only once/twice iirc while he was sleeping. Plus, we didn't watch Seiren yet. Anyways, it doesn't matter, I just want this to be as good as Amagami SS and I hope to see Ai as a cameo xD (since her brother is there) and a 2nd season too. |
More topics from this board
Poll: » Seiren Episode 12 Discussion ( 1 2 3 )Stark700 - Mar 23, 2017 |
143 |
by SenseiSempai-san
»»
Sep 15, 4:04 AM |
|
Poll: » Seiren Episode 11 Discussion ( 1 2 )Stark700 - Mar 16, 2017 |
57 |
by SenseiSempai-san
»»
Sep 15, 3:34 AM |
|
Poll: » Seiren Episode 10 Discussion ( 1 2 )Stark700 - Mar 9, 2017 |
64 |
by SenseiSempai-san
»»
Sep 15, 3:12 AM |
|
Poll: » Seiren Episode 9 Discussion ( 1 2 )Stark700 - Mar 2, 2017 |
99 |
by SenseiSempai-san
»»
Sep 15, 2:31 AM |
|
Poll: » Seiren Episode 8 Discussion ( 1 2 3 )Stark700 - Feb 23, 2017 |
131 |
by SenseiSempai-san
»»
Sep 15, 12:25 AM |