most over rated anime of this year

NoSurrender1690 said:
oh hell no

Pat_To_Do-List said:

Kyoukai no Kanata I think is the most overrated anime show this year. No doubt.

Pat_To_Do-List said:

Kyoukai no Kanata I think is the most overrated anime show this year. No doubt.

DarknessOfEmo said:
There's more shows this season are overrated too.

NoSurrender1690 said:
its kyo ani show high ratings are expacted its better tha other kyo ani shows imo KnK from what ive seen is better than K on example

almozayaf said:
You mean under rated

GreatRumbler said:
Definitely an underrated series, more people need to watch it.

Lopkir said:
looking back at what i wrote, he might be Japanese.
his spelling mistakes would seem appropriate , but it doesn't give you the right to force your stupid opinions down other peoples throat, sorry if i came off as ignorant but i don't take anything back i meant every word, his location says chiba.
so either you are a old ass japanese dude, a young japanese hipster or the BIGGEST weaboo i have ever seen in my life.

worldeditor11 said:


Lol Lopkir, he is a known troll in MAL.

Lopkir said:
this guy is so butt hurt, not many people of this generation are going to watch Gundam, like from 1979, people would gravitate to a show of their generation, just because something is old doesn't make it fucking good. dont be a fucking hipster " Oh i liked the original from the 70's." blah blah blah ,if for some reason you are 50 years old and grew up watching these old shows, fine i see you are heavily biased in your opinion and i understand where you are coming from, if you arent then you are just being a massive tool. just fucking realise. NOT EVERYONE SHARES YOUR OPINION.
every point you stated was highly debatable.



Things you debate a shows quality on. that bother me.

9 merchandise sales

6 Impact on General Pop Culture in Japan and the West 7 Impact on Otaku Culture in Japan and the West

1 Impact on Impact on industry both the anime and Original Manga had

2 TV Ratings in Japan [ Gross for movies Unit sales for OVAs 3 Manga Ka of the Sourcework

NONE of THESE Determine Quality only Monetary value.
What the hell does this have to do with a shows quality..... NOTHING

Now. Here's my main gripe, aside from you going full WEABOO and calling a show bad, based on your Biased Opinion.

You call it over rated.
You call the music "abisamal" Ah Bee Sah Mal AHAHA wtf. Abysmal is the word you were looking for

You see i had never heard of this series until a while ago. guess how i found out about it, THROUGH the soundtrack , The Soundtrack that I and a lot( and i mean a lot of people ) think is great, you cannot just say the quality is bad based on your own tainted opinion the sound track was a well put together and varied piece. with a lot of electronic music and classical thrown in i have listened to the entire soundtrack and it is far from bad in fact as a fan of music in general its good , REALLY good.

you sir are extremely biased and have gotten under my skin. i don't even like the series but from an un biased point of view, its not bad. in fact enjoyable at times.
it is people like you that make me angry when people call ME a weaboo, even as a joke it irksy me.

have fun judging all of the anime with your fucked up judging system that by no means determines quality.

HERE is what i and most sane people would judge a series by.

Story,Characters, Animation, Sound/Voice Acting and Enjoyment.

Please notice the lack of anything monetary that would involve sales or impact or Ratings that you previously posted. These don't make a series good, these are merely observations.

Lopkir said:
much weaboo very biased wow

Master_of_MAL said:
you mean underrated

Durbikins said:
In a year with Shingeki no Kyojin, Kyoukai no Kanata, and Kill la Kill, this is the one you claim to be most overrated?

Durbikins said:
In a year with Shingeki no Kyojin, Kyoukai no Kanata, and Kill la Kill, this is the one you claim to be most overrated?

Durbikins said:
In a year with Shingeki no Kyojin, Kyoukai no Kanata, and Kill la Kill, this is the one you claim to be most overrated?

Zergneedsfood said:
This guy is really butthurt and also has the worst reasons for rating things. I think I got cancer reading them.

Talk about someone who doesn't know how to appreciate art. It is 100% fine to not like Gatchaman Crowds, because I can see why people have issues with it, but those criteria are just bullshit and have nothing to do with how good a show is.

Zergneedsfood said:


I think he's also bad at math. Like...elementary math.

Says KlaK is not as overrated.

KLK Ranked 316 with over 77k people watching and an average score of 8.16.

Gatchaman with only 17k people completed with an average score of 7.56.

Clearly the latter is overrated!

Help me, I have cancer.

Pat_To_Do-List said:

Which one? Log Horizon? Steins;Gate movie?

Meritas said:
The anime is terribly underrated, it should stand somewhere in the Top #250, but I never expected it to fall in 1200+. It's an anime that revives the hero genre in such a genius way, and Hajime is seriously one of the best MCs ever. The OST is just a killer. And the "childish" animation actually complements the unique style of the show.

GuiltyKing said:
Talk about butthurt opening post.

This show's awesome. End of story.

Titanz25 said:


Accurate comment

Dazedonthemoon said:
FGAU1912's 11 main things he rates anime on represents everything i hate about the industry.

why the fuck would you rate an anime based on merchandise sales? what a tool. impact on pop culture? tool. comparing it to a similar BIG name? tool. TV ratings, letting someone else tell you what you like? super tool!

and really, i dont openly insult people much but you are the reason anime is becoming terrible.

How about rating something on the Art direction, character design, dialogue, uniqueness, storyline... or maybe, just maybe... how it made you feel.

Zergneedsfood said:
Since you don't seem to even know how to type, I find it strange how even you can take yourself seriously. It's interesting how you consider yourself a critic but have little to zero traces of intelligence that would give you a sliver of credibility.

Your only beef with the show seems to be a random outburst that says nothing (this is a running motif, that's a word critics might use by the way so you should learn what it means in a storytelling sense) and then a random irrelevant comment about how many episodes each had, and how you can't possibly imagine how a show with 150 episodes can be rated worse than one with only 12...which sounds like the most infantile statement I've ever heard. No, actually I'm pretty sure a kid who hasn't even learned to count to 150 can tell that you're full of shit.

Pretty sure the lack of basic grammar and spelling is also giving me new forms of mental illnesses.

Zergneedsfood said:
lol

Implying you have any reasonable evidence to prove this.

Zergneedsfood said:


Congratulations bro.

Durbikins said:
In a year with Shingeki no Kyojin, Kyoukai no Kanata, and Kill la Kill, this is the one you claim to be most overrated?

Dazedonthemoon said:
You won't get anywhere with this guy. He lets numbers and merch sales determine whether or not he likes something. Devoid of any emotional thought.

His comments are equivalent to Nazi Germany being okay with taking away all the Jews, because that was popular opinion and you listen to what the government/anime industry tells you.

sonictoryuiai said:
Not sure about this being overrated but Crowds was not what a few/lot of us expected it to be. Feels like it was meant to be something else but to get people watching they slapped gatchaman on the title and made one of the characters a almost nude loli.

Dazedonthemoon said:


It was a Gatchaman made for todays world in my opinion. Yes that girl didnt wear much but the animators were awesome enough to not use it in a fanservice way. There was no panning to her boobs or ass throughout the series if memory serves me. That was a breath of fresh air, it was basically like she was in a bikini. No gratuitous shots.

Dazedonthemoon said:


It was a Gatchaman made for todays world in my opinion. Yes that girl didnt wear much but the animators were awesome enough to not use it in a fanservice way. There was no panning to her boobs or ass throughout the series if memory serves me. That was a breath of fresh air, it was basically like she was in a bikini. No gratuitous shots.

FGAU1912 said:
It was a Gatchaman made for todays world in my opinion. Yes that girl didnt wear much but the animators were awesome enough to not use it in a fanservice way. There was no panning to her boobs or ass throughout the series if memory serves me. That was a breath of fresh air, it was basically like she was in a bikini. No gratuitous shots.

Dazedonthemoon said:

you call me baised

Dazedonthemoon said:
I tried hard to read what you wrote but I barely understood any of that. Ill try to comment on the parts I think I understood.

When I said "todays world", I mostly meant where we are technologically as a modern world and the selfishness of people not wanting to do good without incentive. I wasnt referring to the anime industry or anything like that, and obviously since I'm American, i can only vouch for "todays world" from an American viewpoint.

Also super sentai shows seem very tacky and way too old school for most westerners because it seems just too childish, at least with the group of 5 transforming to do good a la Power Rangers. The new Gatchaman does this well because it had the throwbacks to the old era on super sentai but making it modern and will probably do better overseas if it ever gets picked up over here.

And of course Gundam makes more money than moe. Gundam is universal so that all age groups and enjoy and kids buy the crap out of it. Its like over here with Disney and Pixar movies that sell like crazy because everyone LOVES them and parents take kids to see it in theaters no matter what. Rated R movies intended for adults might end up being more groundbreaking when it comes to substance but they will never make Disney money. This however does not make them inferior because they made less money.

You calling me bias is just showing the difference between our cultures, just like to me it seems you are being bias because of your intense love of the older culture surrounded by Gatchaman and super sentai. I get it, it sucks when something you loved changes drastically from the older source material but it happens all the time. A good example over here would be the new Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles movie that is about to come out... they are completely changing it and it is pissing alot of people off. But they want to sell to the modern era, not the old one. Sometimes you just got to let go and accept the change with an open mind because our opinions wont change the direction these things go.

FGAU1912 said:


1 im almost 30 and still watch sentai and if u go to the sentai muisc concest it is manly older teens there not perants taking there younger kids to the show

2 imyour age if not a bit older im 29 in july] were og the same genreration id would think

3 if Moe is to last like alot of people on MAL want it to it needs to start make clser to gundam or Toku money or its fad that will die or be confiend to smaller studios

4 there was a Kamen rider Move relsed inUS call kamen rider the 1st and a shot for shot reamke of tv show caled Ryuki[ Dragon Night] that won tv awards in the us

5 working at animage as i do i have the same deabtes with my coworkers as this but they say well anime need more internaion sucess to sutain then i direcet them to the top 50 anime here and then they im kinda right that ithe internatonal market is in the long run going to marginalize anime futher than it is becuase of the fact the big Network tv aired tv anime [ Japan are not Pupular here on Mal] and the one that are can and never will be mainstream cuase of the time of night there shown a here


its not nostlgia over all its a oncern that all fans and some makers shpuld feel are some are feeling Hell bothn Tomino and Miyazaki have come out an attcked the amount of Otaku in the industry and how that is on fact harmfull to the greater well being of the industry
----------------------------
hence why i rate as i do that was the first thing you acctck me for