GRG3 said:CheliosX said:I thought Solo Leveling was peak before since it was the first ever manhwa I read (Dec 2023). I then came across the real peaks like ORV, Baskerville Bloodhound, GED, TBATE, Pick Me Up etc. That was when I realized SL was just meh in everything except fights.
As a power fantasy show, Solo Leveling is S tier. That's why battle shōnentards keep glazing it as if it's peak fiction. The fights are the only peak parts.
As for every other thing like world building, character depth and so on, it falls flat fr.
I only gave it (anime) a 9 for the fights and animation.
Story - 5.
Fights/animation - 9.
Shut your pretentious ass up. On about shonentards. You cannot be fr. You clearly have no idea how worldbuilding works.
Simply because SL has generic concepts integrated into its world like gates and dungeons and a game system doesnt mean that its worldbuilding is just bad and flat.
For example gates. SL literally variates between them in arcs. Red gates(Baraka), Double dungeons(Tusk arc and the Architect), Dungeon breaks(Jin-Ah and in the final war with the monarchs). Again, not a lot of other series beforehand or afterwards put this much thought into variation as to not bore the reader.
If you have read the series, which I am assuming you are cuz you quite literally said to. Then you why Sung Jin Woo is the only one who can constantly level up and why the system was given to him and why other hunters are capped at their strength. And you why Gates popped up outta nowhere and how mana came to exist on Earth.
Furthermore, there is so much thought put into hunting business. There is such a long process that comes with clearing a gate with a big guild so that they maximise profit. Dangers of joining smaller guilds. How exactly hunters make money. How exactly overpowered superhumans are kept in check with stuff like the Hunters Association being established in most global superpowers. I could go on and on You bring up something like TBATE which also had arcs of adventurers(basically hunters) and gates and you wouldnt find even a third of this much detail(manhwa only). There is so much love and thought put into making stuff like Hunters realistic and people like you just eat up whatever the next overly intellectual dumbass says and make that your opinion. You wont find anyone call TBATE generic even tho it starts of with a cliche world and plot(just like SL).
I havent even mentioned the amount of lore and worldmaking SL acc has. Makes it feel real with a world that had history. With Monarchs, Rulers, Outer Gods. Need i say more?
Of course there are flaws with SL worldbuilding. Re-awakening could have been explored more. How tf did Ashborn and the Architect manage to make Earths past into a gate. How exactly did the Rulers bring the denizens of chaos into Earth and trap them. You can critique SL' s world. But you cant just say its flat and bad because that means you cant read wtf.
I dont even know why I typed all this bro just shut up if you're not educated enough to acc critique the piece of media being discussed.
And for you saying the story is mid. You clearly enjoyed it in the past. How can you call a story that entertained you bad? However, unlike worldbuilding, perception of a story is subjective so yeah. Not even gonna argue that one. Character depth valid take ig.
And ORV is way better and acc peak fiction. But its not like ORV dont got problems too.
I didn't even bother to read all of this cause you seem to be worked up for some reason.
Now why are you so worked up? Yes, it's mainly battle shōnentards that praise SL as peak fiction and you know it. Tf is you on? Plus it's well known for being a peak power fantasy show, that much is clear. It has its own world building and character depth but they're not that well done to whatever. The fights overshadow it imo.
That's why I brought in ORV. It clears SL in the world building and character development and depth dept.
I don't even hate SL. I love it. But it's not peak fiction in general. Just peak power fantasy.
The story is okay but nothing special or fantastic. Simplistic as hell but good.
If you didn't get that much from the comment you replied to, then keep shut.