What's the exact loophole in aqua's theory of his father?

Sep 27, 11:03 PM

Offline

Oct 2022

2

FULL SPOILER, Aqua is 16 and Himekawa’s father committed the murder/suicide 17 years ago (or something like that) so Himekawa’s father couldn’t be the father of Aqua and Ruby

Sep 27, 11:13 PM

#3

Otaku_guru

Offline

Jul 2023

182

Gera_O_Arellano said:
FULL SPOILER, Aqua is 16 and Himekawa’s father committed the murder/suicide 17 years ago (or something like that) so Himekawa’s father couldn’t be the father of Aqua and Ruby

I know that and I don't think It's a spoiler because anyone who has watched till episode 11 should be able to understand this much if they paid attention and even they kind of revealed their real father in ending of ep 11. but Main thing is what loophole is Akane thinking about because Aqua didn't tell her that his father committed suicide 17 years ago.

Sep 27, 11:27 PM

#4

Gera_O_Arellano

Offline

Oct 2022

2

Reply to Otaku_guru

Gera_O_Arellano said:
FULL SPOILER, Aqua is 16 and Himekawa’s father committed the murder/suicide 17 years ago (or something like that) so Himekawa’s father couldn’t be the father of Aqua and Ruby

I know that and I don't think It's a spoiler because anyone who has watched till episode 11 should be able to understand this much if they paid attention and even they kind of revealed their real father in ending of ep 11. but Main thing is what loophole is Akane thinking about because Aqua didn't tell her that his father committed suicide 17 years ago.

@Otaku_guru but it was quite the news, so a simple search could tell that it was 17 years ago. Also is likely Akane knew well as she knows Himekawa from the theater company.

Sep 27, 11:46 PM

#5

gorenjoyer

Offline

Dec 2023

1

the loophole is that Taiki's mom might have cheated on her husband with (Ruby and Aqua)'s Dad.

Sep 27, 11:48 PM

#6

Animorphimagi

Offline

Apr 2015

194

there's no proof that Taiki's parents were his parents. their suicide could've been faked by the true killer or the father could've killed themselves from the shame of raising a kid that wasn't his. I feel like I've heard of that happening in Japan before.

Sep 27, 11:51 PM

#7

sDluffy

Offline

Oct 2022

79

Otaku_guru said:
When Aqua mentioned his theory first time about his father being married and having affair with AI and other stuff, I also thought this theory was not correct and there was a big loophole but I do not know what exactly is the loophole. I have my theory about it but I want to hear from you who understood the loophole Akane was thinking about.

i think akane thought that the blood which aqua took can be manipulated in hospital or by someone who is there real father (shown in ep 11)
because i think aquas father is very rich so he can manipulate this and i think he qas always keeping eye on aqua
and what do you think the loophole might be?

Sep 27, 11:52 PM

#8

sDluffy

Offline

Oct 2022

79

Gera_O_Arellano said:
@Otaku_guru but it was quite the news, so a simple search could tell that it was 17 years ago. Also is likely Akane knew well as she knows Himekawa from the theater company.

no because himekawa told aqua that he is using his mother's surname and not his father's to keep his identity hidden so aside from director I don't think anyone knows himekawa's father did a suicide

Sep 28, 12:00 AM

#9

Otaku_guru

Offline

Jul 2023

182

sDluffy said:

Otaku_guru said:
When Aqua mentioned his theory first time about his father being married and having affair with AI and other stuff, I also thought this theory was not correct and there was a big loophole but I do not know what exactly is the loophole. I have my theory about it but I want to hear from you who understood the loophole Akane was thinking about.

i think akane thought that the blood which aqua took can be manipulated in hospital or by someone who is there real father (shown in ep 11)
because i think aquas father is very rich so he can manipulate this and i think he qas always keeping eye on aqua
and what do you think the loophole might be?

According to my understanding, The real father might have planned all of this like having a kid with another woman which is himekawa's mother or You can also say Himekawa's mother cheated on her husband with Aqua's and Ruby's real father and they had a child. Now I don't know if the real father is involved in the murder or not and if he is then this theory might be correct. He then killed Himekawa's mother and her husband to show it as a suicide and also killed the killer of AI to show it a suicide as well

Otaku_guruSep 28, 12:04 AM

Sep 28, 12:09 AM

#10

sDluffy

Offline

Oct 2022

79

yup 👍 i also think himekawa's father was not the cheater but his mother was a cheater who had child with aqua father

Sep 28, 1:04 AM

#11

HoangNguyen2107

Offline

Dec 2020

616

Sep 28, 1:16 AM

#12

NegativeRei

Offline

Sep 2024

103

The man who died together with Himekawa's mother is not his biological father. His mother cheated on him.

Sep 28, 3:50 AM

#13

Yeshaiah2015yesh

Offline

Dec 2022

938

Otaku_guru said:
When Aqua mentioned his theory first time about his father being married and having affair with AI and other stuff, I also thought this theory was not correct and there was a big loophole but I do not know what exactly is the loophole. I have my theory about it but I want to hear from you who understood the loophole Akane was thinking about.

The lope is

surch and watch youtube video or shorts called "Your Are Not The father " If you already watched them, you probably understand what iam saying

Sep 28, 6:02 AM

#14

SenshadouOtaku

Offline

May 2023

462

Pretty sure someone else made this thread when the episode came out

Sep 28, 11:57 AM

#15

Paharo05

Offline

Dec 2020

242

Otaku_guru said:
When Aqua mentioned his theory first time about his father being married and having affair with AI and other stuff, I also thought this theory was not correct and there was a big loophole but I do not know what exactly is the loophole. I have my theory about it but I want to hear from you who understood the loophole Akane was thinking about.

the other answers are wrong. What actually happened is that Himekawa's "father" died way before Ai was killed, so he couldn't be the one to plan her death. When he died, Aqua had already been born, but Ai was still alive

As Akane has already theorized Ai is Aqua's mother, and his father killed her, she could find this loophole. Aqua could have also find it, but he's so focused on living his life that he doesn't want to believe there could be an error

Sep 28, 12:39 PM

#16

Honeypon

Online

Jul 2022

45

gorenjoyer said:
the loophole is that Taiki's mom might have cheated on her husband with (Ruby and Aqua)'s Dad.

This is what I thought too. I had a feeling an affair with Aqua’s dad was the reason Himekawa’s dad committed the murder suicide

Oct 1, 2:28 PM

#17

CalorieEnchilada

Offline

Jan 2016

80

Reply to Paharo05

Otaku_guru said:
When Aqua mentioned his theory first time about his father being married and having affair with AI and other stuff, I also thought this theory was not correct and there was a big loophole but I do not know what exactly is the loophole. I have my theory about it but I want to hear from you who understood the loophole Akane was thinking about.

the other answers are wrong. What actually happened is that Himekawa's "father" died way before Ai was killed, so he couldn't be the one to plan her death. When he died, Aqua had already been born, but Ai was still alive

As Akane has already theorized Ai is Aqua's mother, and his father killed her, she could find this loophole. Aqua could have also find it, but he's so focused on living his life that he doesn't want to believe there could be an error

Paharo05 said:
As Akane has already theorized Ai is Aqua's mother

I forgot, has she mentioned this to Aqua yet or was this just entirely her realization.
I ask because besides he's told her a lot of details at this point that would make more sense to admit if she mentioned that she realized this.

Oct 6, 11:55 AM

#18

adbeaver

Offline

Mar 2015

736

After reading all the replies, I'm convinced the simple loophole is that Aqua didn't consider the possibility that Himekawa's mother was the one who cheated, not his father. Personally, I think the theories regarding the date of the suicide is far-fetched, because it would be too much of a silly mistake on Aqua's part for it to be a "loophole".

CalorieEnchilada said:
I forgot, has she mentioned this to Aqua yet or was this just entirely her realization.
I ask because besides he's told her a lot of details at this point that would make more sense to admit if she mentioned that she realized this.

If I recall correctly, she realized this on her own after being fed information from the director Aqua is close with. Don't think she mentioned this to Aqua yet, but maybe Aqua might have an idea that she knows.

Poll: » "Oshi no Ko" 2nd Season Episode 11 Discussion ( 1 2 3 4 5 ... Last Page ) Ricky16 - Sep 18	250	by Shikkakku »» Today, 2:46 AM
Poll: » "Oshi no Ko" 2nd Season Episode 8 Discussion ( 1 2 3 4 5 ) nirererin - Aug 21	246	by unmemorablehero »» Nov 22, 10:23 PM
Poll: » "Oshi no Ko" 2nd Season Episode 13 Discussion ( 1 2 3 4 5 ... Last Page ) Ricky16 - Oct 6	314	by smoodflamez »» Nov 21, 12:02 PM
Poll: » "Oshi no Ko" 2nd Season Episode 2 Discussion ( 1 2 3 4 ) Softhenic03 - Jul 10	194	by TheAquilaSamurai »» Nov 21, 12:28 AM
Poll: » "Oshi no Ko" 2nd Season Episode 12 Discussion ( 1 2 3 4 5 ) IzanaSolos - Sep 25	221	by Threepybot »» Nov 19, 11:39 AM

What's the exact loophole in aqua's theory of his father?

More topics from this board

Poll: » "Oshi no Ko" 2nd Season Episode 11 Discussion ( 1 2 3 4 5 ... Last Page )

Poll: » "Oshi no Ko" 2nd Season Episode 8 Discussion ( 1 2 3 4 5 )

Poll: » "Oshi no Ko" 2nd Season Episode 13 Discussion ( 1 2 3 4 5 ... Last Page )

Poll: » "Oshi no Ko" 2nd Season Episode 2 Discussion ( 1 2 3 4 )

Poll: » "Oshi no Ko" 2nd Season Episode 12 Discussion ( 1 2 3 4 5 )

Preview MangaManga Store

MoreTop Anime

MoreTop Airing Anime

MoreMost Popular Characters