Forum SettingsEpisode Information
Forums
New
Jul 12, 3:22 PM
#1

Offline
Dec 2023
201
Edit: I got my answer thanks to that very kind MAL user who had read the VN - so I have marked the post as ignored and won't see new replies, have fun chatting :)

I am wondering if anyone can help me understand something, possibly fans of the VN source.

As each new trailer has released for this anime I end up with equal parts hype and concern lol at one point it was my most anticipated of summer season.

Concern part - this show is marked as romance but judging by the trailer the MCs are an adult man and a female kid - and based on what the synopsis says she is a


So I guess my questions is.....what is going on here lol?

I don't want to start any wars here - people can watch whatever they want and I don't care, I just want to know if I personally want to avoid getting invested in this anime.


Thanks.
YordaTricoJul 12, 10:24 PM
Pages (2) [1] 2 »
Jul 12, 3:32 PM
#2
Offline
Jul 2022
307
Yorda_trico said:
I am wondering if anyone can help me understand something, possibly fans of the VN source.

As each new trailer has released for this anime I end up with equal parts hype and concern lol at one point it was my most anticipated of summer season.

Concern part - this show is marked as romance but judging by the trailer the MCs are an adult man and a female kid - and based on what the synopsis says she is a


So I guess my questions is.....what is going on here lol?

I don't want to start any wars here - people can watch whatever they want and I don't care, I just want to know if I personally want to avoid getting invested in this anime.


Thanks.

From the character pages he's 17 and she's actually the one much older ironically lol
Jul 12, 3:41 PM
#3

Offline
Dec 2023
201
Reply to WestOnAndrewAve
Yorda_trico said:
I am wondering if anyone can help me understand something, possibly fans of the VN source.

As each new trailer has released for this anime I end up with equal parts hype and concern lol at one point it was my most anticipated of summer season.

Concern part - this show is marked as romance but judging by the trailer the MCs are an adult man and a female kid - and based on what the synopsis says she is a


So I guess my questions is.....what is going on here lol?

I don't want to start any wars here - people can watch whatever they want and I don't care, I just want to know if I personally want to avoid getting invested in this anime.


Thanks.

From the character pages he's 17 and she's actually the one much older ironically lol
@WestOnAndrewAve

thanks for the reply.

Based on that I am wondering if it is one of those "loophole" romances then lol "old mind in the young form" so they get away with it, then again anime seems to get away with it even if they don't use loopholes haha.

Maybe I am going crazy or something but she REALLY looks like a kid, there is a scene in the new trailer in which another woman grabs her by the head and it honestly could be mistaken for mother and young child haha.

I love the water world setting and it also looks cute/ funny....but a bit conflicted on that one point :/
Jul 12, 3:47 PM
#4
Mad scientist

Offline
Aug 2020
222
dude, it's anime. Fiction. Who cares? Watch the first ep or give it 3 and make up your mind if you like it or not. First time?
Jul 12, 3:54 PM
#5

Offline
Dec 2023
201
Reply to ColCasey
dude, it's anime. Fiction. Who cares? Watch the first ep or give it 3 and make up your mind if you like it or not. First time?
@ColCasey

ah the obligatory anime defender "dude, it's anime" response without any attempt to answer the question that was asked.

"Who cares?"

ummmmm me clearly - which is why I asked the question haha


Edit: I see you gave Jobless Reincarnation a 9, now it all makes sense haha
YordaTricoJul 12, 4:05 PM
Jul 12, 4:07 PM
#6
Mad scientist

Offline
Aug 2020
222
Yorda_trico said:
@ColCasey

ah the obligatory anime defender "dude, it's anime" response without any attempt to answer the question that was asked.

"Who cares?"

ummmmm me clearly - which is why I asked the question haha


Edit: I see you gave Jobless Reincarnation a 9, now it all makes sense haha

you already got the answer, so why would I repeat it? Bottom line is, watch it or don't if you are scared to see a romance with a young looking girl. Guessing you are new to this medium if you have gripes with this kind of stuff so you have to find out for yourself
Jul 12, 4:11 PM
#7
Offline
Apr 2019
221
Yorda_trico said:
@ColCasey

ah the obligatory anime defender "dude, it's anime" response without any attempt to answer the question that was asked.

"Who cares?"

ummmmm me clearly - which is why I asked the question haha


Edit: I see you gave Jobless Reincarnation a 9, now it all makes sense haha

He answered you perfectly. Bringing up what other people rate things is only showing your immaturity
Jul 12, 4:11 PM
#8

Offline
Dec 2023
201
Reply to ColCasey
Yorda_trico said:
@ColCasey

ah the obligatory anime defender "dude, it's anime" response without any attempt to answer the question that was asked.

"Who cares?"

ummmmm me clearly - which is why I asked the question haha


Edit: I see you gave Jobless Reincarnation a 9, now it all makes sense haha

you already got the answer, so why would I repeat it? Bottom line is, watch it or don't if you are scared to see a romance with a young looking girl. Guessing you are new to this medium if you have gripes with this kind of stuff so you have to find out for yourself
@ColCasey you know what - you are right that I wasn't clear on what I was asking, so just to clear that up....what I was asking was more or less "is she supposed to be the form of a kid??"

And my hope is a VN reader might be able to clarify something concrete that could help me either be at peace or decide not to watch.

For example if they said "it is never explains but nothing really happens, it is more about emotional stuff" then I would relax...

Or maybe they would say something else and I would think "F THAT"...

but yes if I don't get any more clarification then I will probably have to just find out for myself
Jul 12, 4:11 PM
#9

Offline
Dec 2023
201
Reply to Todday
Yorda_trico said:
@ColCasey

ah the obligatory anime defender "dude, it's anime" response without any attempt to answer the question that was asked.

"Who cares?"

ummmmm me clearly - which is why I asked the question haha


Edit: I see you gave Jobless Reincarnation a 9, now it all makes sense haha

He answered you perfectly. Bringing up what other people rate things is only showing your immaturity
@Todday what answer did he give me? He just wanted to poke at me which you know full well, but I imagine that you agree with him so he = right and me = wrong.


Edit: Jobless Reincarnation a 10, your defending of him now makes sense haha
YordaTricoJul 12, 4:19 PM
Jul 12, 4:22 PM
Mad scientist

Offline
Aug 2020
222
Yorda_trico said:
@ColCasey you know what - you are right that I wasn't clear on what I was asking, so just to clear that up....what I was asking was more or less "is she supposed to be the form of a kid??"

And my hope is a VN reader might be able to clarify something concrete that could help me either be at peace or decide not to watch.

For example if they said "it is never explains but nothing really happens, it is more about emotional stuff" then I would relax...

Or maybe they would say something else and I would think "F THAT"...

but yes if I don't get any more clarification then I will probably have to just find out for myself

If you have this much trouble deciding if you want to watch it or not, why bother? These kind of shows clearly aren't for you. Also google exists.
Regarding mushoku tensei, try watching it first before judging other peoples rating of it. You might enjoy it but considering how pensive you are about atri maybe you should stick to SOL shows without romance whatsoever, better for your heart.
Jul 12, 4:23 PM

Offline
Feb 2020
1718
Reply to YordaTrico
@WestOnAndrewAve

thanks for the reply.

Based on that I am wondering if it is one of those "loophole" romances then lol "old mind in the young form" so they get away with it, then again anime seems to get away with it even if they don't use loopholes haha.

Maybe I am going crazy or something but she REALLY looks like a kid, there is a scene in the new trailer in which another woman grabs her by the head and it honestly could be mistaken for mother and young child haha.

I love the water world setting and it also looks cute/ funny....but a bit conflicted on that one point :/
@Yorda_trico for the real answer--from a VN reader--here it is:



there might be other VN readers who come across this that can give more accurate details, since it has been quite a while since i read it
Jul 12, 4:26 PM
Mad scientist

Offline
Aug 2020
222
Yorda_trico said:
@Todday what answer did he give me? He just wanted to poke at me which you know full well, but I imagine that you agree with him so he = right and me = wrong.


Edit: Jobless Reincarnation a 10, your defending of him now makes sense haha

Since you're going to keep judging peoples scores of a show you haven't watched, you didn't have gripes with Violet? She's 14, Gilbert's way older. Nothing? Oh right she looks a bit older so it's fine but not the other way around?
Jul 12, 4:31 PM

Offline
Dec 2023
201
Reply to ColCasey
Yorda_trico said:
@Todday what answer did he give me? He just wanted to poke at me which you know full well, but I imagine that you agree with him so he = right and me = wrong.


Edit: Jobless Reincarnation a 10, your defending of him now makes sense haha

Since you're going to keep judging peoples scores of a show you haven't watched, you didn't have gripes with Violet? She's 14, Gilbert's way older. Nothing? Oh right she looks a bit older so it's fine but not the other way around?
@ColCasey

"why bother?"

ummmm because I want to watch it if it isn't creepy? BIG BRAIN TIME!!!!

Try googling for the age of that character and let me know your results....nothing turned up for me except reddit posts that would contain massive spoilers.

"try watching it first before judging other peoples rating of it."

I would never watch Jobless R, it sounds utterly horrific, like some kind of child predators fantasy


Also I am laughing as you clearly skimmed my MAL and didn't even take time to read the score I gave Violet Evergarden movie hahaha look again??



YordaTricoJul 12, 4:35 PM
Jul 12, 4:38 PM
Offline
Jan 2019
5
VN reader here, it's very sweet and light, nothing to worry about. It doesn't elude to pedo stuff and makes sense in the story with how it's handled.

It's a lovely romance and a lovely story so I hope you thoroughly enjoy it!
Jul 12, 4:41 PM

Offline
Dec 2023
201
Reply to Boazanian
@Yorda_trico for the real answer--from a VN reader--here it is:



there might be other VN readers who come across this that can give more accurate details, since it has been quite a while since i read it
@Boazanian thank you for the added context, I really appreciate it.

Also I had a look at your MAL and you seem like someone who would really like Planetarian: The Reverie of a Little Planet :)

maybe you have seen it, but I didn't find it
Jul 12, 4:43 PM

Offline
Dec 2023
201
Reply to The_Lamington
VN reader here, it's very sweet and light, nothing to worry about. It doesn't elude to pedo stuff and makes sense in the story with how it's handled.

It's a lovely romance and a lovely story so I hope you thoroughly enjoy it!
@The_Lamington

thanks for this reply I appreciate it

I guess maybe I added some confusion for others with how I phrased my original post but this kind of clarification was what I was looking for. And I am good with this kind of format.

I have been excited for this show since watching a trailer early this year so I really hope to enjoy it too!

Thanks again!
Jul 12, 4:44 PM
Offline
Jan 2019
5
Reply to YordaTrico
@ColCasey

"why bother?"

ummmm because I want to watch it if it isn't creepy? BIG BRAIN TIME!!!!

Try googling for the age of that character and let me know your results....nothing turned up for me except reddit posts that would contain massive spoilers.

"try watching it first before judging other peoples rating of it."

I would never watch Jobless R, it sounds utterly horrific, like some kind of child predators fantasy


Also I am laughing as you clearly skimmed my MAL and didn't even take time to read the score I gave Violet Evergarden movie hahaha look again??



No problem, I understand your worries perfectly. ATRI nothing like you'd fear, I hope you have a wonderful time with it.

It's nothing like mushoku at all, closest maybe to plastic memories?

Just like to say though with your comment about mushoku, it starts off gross and that is off-putting for many people so I understand you not wanting to read or watch it. But claiming the series as a whole is pedo bait is a pretty revolting generalisation, that completely erases all the character growth which the series is about
The_LamingtonJul 12, 4:50 PM
Jul 12, 4:47 PM

Offline
Feb 2020
1718
Reply to YordaTrico
@Boazanian thank you for the added context, I really appreciate it.

Also I had a look at your MAL and you seem like someone who would really like Planetarian: The Reverie of a Little Planet :)

maybe you have seen it, but I didn't find it
@Yorda_trico no problem! also, i never watched/read Planetarian before but i mightve heard about it once. ill keep it in mind tho, astronomy is something im quite interested in!
Jul 12, 4:49 PM

Offline
Dec 2023
201
Reply to The_Lamington
No problem, I understand your worries perfectly. ATRI nothing like you'd fear, I hope you have a wonderful time with it.

It's nothing like mushoku at all, closest maybe to plastic memories?

Just like to say though with your comment about mushoku, it starts off gross and that is off-putting for many people so I understand you not wanting to read or watch it. But claiming the series as a whole is pedo bait is a pretty revolting generalisation, that completely erases all the character growth which the series is about
@The_Lamington

I hear what you are saying, but such things are very subjective and we all have to make peace with our own morals all said and done.

There is no objective standard for how much questionable content will make a entire show become something horrid.

for one person it could become horrid and immoral only when 60% of the run time has this kind of content, but for me all it takes is one single scene and I know the kind of author I am dealing with.

You and others might find my comments on that anime provocative, but let's remember who poked at who first, that guy came on here being a prick, and I bit back, but people want to ignore his provocation and focus on mine because I had a go at an anime they like - logic and fairness doesn't matter.

I even wrote this on my original post "I don't want to start any wars here - people can watch whatever they want and I don't care, I just want to know if I personally want to avoid getting invested in this anime." but still I got that kind of comment because they cannot help themselves.

Jul 12, 4:50 PM

Offline
Apr 2021
2663
Oh wow reverse anime romance … she is dating down 😅😂
Note: I don’t lazily watch 3-5 episodes, biasedly compare to other anime, or unfairly judge by surface level similarities. With every anime I start, I watch the entire series, both Japanese Sub & English Dub, then judge each anime based on what they present, to give an honest and fair rating.

Jul 12, 4:50 PM
Mad scientist

Offline
Aug 2020
222
Yorda_trico said:
@ColCasey

"why bother?"

ummmm because I want to watch it if it isn't creepy? BIG BRAIN TIME!!!!

Try googling for the age of that character and let me know your results....nothing turned up for me except reddit posts that would contain massive spoilers.

"try watching it first before judging other peoples rating of it."

I would never watch Jobless R, it sounds utterly horrific, like some kind of child predators fantasy


Also I am laughing as you clearly skimmed my MAL and didn't even take time to read the score I gave Violet Evergarden movie hahaha look again??




Imagine being this judgemental about what anime to watch. Stop self inserting my guy and try to watch for enjoyment instead. Although you sound like a pretty big snowflake so not sure if this medium is for you honestly. It's animated fiction, so don't be sad when you can't call the police on the MC. Relax and try not to be the most judgemental dude on the planet for a change
Jul 12, 4:54 PM

Offline
Dec 2023
201
Reply to ColCasey
Yorda_trico said:
@ColCasey

"why bother?"

ummmm because I want to watch it if it isn't creepy? BIG BRAIN TIME!!!!

Try googling for the age of that character and let me know your results....nothing turned up for me except reddit posts that would contain massive spoilers.

"try watching it first before judging other peoples rating of it."

I would never watch Jobless R, it sounds utterly horrific, like some kind of child predators fantasy


Also I am laughing as you clearly skimmed my MAL and didn't even take time to read the score I gave Violet Evergarden movie hahaha look again??




Imagine being this judgemental about what anime to watch. Stop self inserting my guy and try to watch for enjoyment instead. Although you sound like a pretty big snowflake so not sure if this medium is for you honestly. It's animated fiction, so don't be sad when you can't call the police on the MC. Relax and try not to be the most judgemental dude on the planet for a change
@ColCasey

so you self inserted yourself into this post to poke at my views then make no attempt at answering anything but because you didn't like that I bit back you go on the defensive and say this to me...

honestly that has kind of made my year, absolutely priceless haha I mean the level of hypocrisy is so insane that you could't even make that up in a fantasy story

no more even needs to be said, let's just capture this perfect moment forever haha
Jul 12, 4:54 PM
Mad scientist

Offline
Aug 2020
222
"People can watch whatever they want and I don't care" -proceeds to insult people for liking MT and calling it a child predator fantasy. Get off your high horse
Jul 12, 4:56 PM
Offline
Jan 2019
5
Reply to YordaTrico
@The_Lamington

I hear what you are saying, but such things are very subjective and we all have to make peace with our own morals all said and done.

There is no objective standard for how much questionable content will make a entire show become something horrid.

for one person it could become horrid and immoral only when 60% of the run time has this kind of content, but for me all it takes is one single scene and I know the kind of author I am dealing with.

You and others might find my comments on that anime provocative, but let's remember who poked at who first, that guy came on here being a prick, and I bit back, but people want to ignore his provocation and focus on mine because I had a go at an anime they like - logic and fairness doesn't matter.

I even wrote this on my original post "I don't want to start any wars here - people can watch whatever they want and I don't care, I just want to know if I personally want to avoid getting invested in this anime." but still I got that kind of comment because they cannot help themselves.

@Yorda_trico Yeah no, I entirely get why you had to snap back and say that considering other comments. And yeah, it's definitely subjective. I'm not a fan of hearing that language when you haven't seen it, but it's definitely not for everyone and clearly you're not going to enjoy it

But yeah hopefully you get ATRI is different. When you've seen it, please post a comment on how you find it!
Jul 12, 5:02 PM

Offline
Dec 2023
201
Reply to The_Lamington
@Yorda_trico Yeah no, I entirely get why you had to snap back and say that considering other comments. And yeah, it's definitely subjective. I'm not a fan of hearing that language when you haven't seen it, but it's definitely not for everyone and clearly you're not going to enjoy it

But yeah hopefully you get ATRI is different. When you've seen it, please post a comment on how you find it!
@The_Lamington

Tomorrow this will pop into my head and I will regret making such a bold and judgemental statement on Jobless R especially as it should have nothing to do with what the intention of this post was, I just get so fed up of people like that guy antagonising and my immature side wants to be a prick back.

But yes I certainly will post on my thoughts, ATRI became one of my forecasted 10/10 shows for this season when I first heard about it, and I hope that will become reality. I have a big soft spot for robot stories like Vivy, Plastic Memories and Planetarian: The Reverie of a Little Planet <3 hopefully ATRI can join them.

Thanks again!
Jul 12, 5:05 PM

Offline
Dec 2023
201
Reply to ColCasey
"People can watch whatever they want and I don't care" -proceeds to insult people for liking MT and calling it a child predator fantasy. Get off your high horse
@ColCasey

oh so you did read that? if you start with me that all goes out the window ;)

makes it even funnier that you still made your antagonistic comment now haha you just keep taking loses my friend, another picture perfect moment
Jul 12, 5:06 PM
Offline
Jan 2019
5
Yeah from those anime you're gonna have a lot of fun
Hope you have a good day!
Jul 12, 5:10 PM
Mad scientist

Offline
Aug 2020
222
Yorda_trico said:
@ColCasey

oh so you did read that? if you start with me that all goes out the window ;)

makes it even funnier that you still made your antagonistic comment now haha you just keep taking loses my friend, another picture perfect moment

Nah I read your comment about writing it. Could't bring myself to read a whole novel about being afraid to watch an anime with a young looking ROBOT-girl possibly being a love interest
Jul 12, 5:13 PM

Offline
Dec 2023
201
Reply to ColCasey
Yorda_trico said:
@ColCasey

oh so you did read that? if you start with me that all goes out the window ;)

makes it even funnier that you still made your antagonistic comment now haha you just keep taking loses my friend, another picture perfect moment

Nah I read your comment about writing it. Could't bring myself to read a whole novel about being afraid to watch an anime with a young looking ROBOT-girl possibly being a love interest
@ColCasey

but you could bring yourself to leave an unconstructive antagonising comment - understood :)

we are probably boring each other now and I don't want to say "let's leave it there" like I should have the last word, so you say whatever you like in response and I will leave it here.
Jul 12, 5:18 PM
Offline
Dec 2023
159
Yorda_trico said:
@ColCasey

ah the obligatory anime defender "dude, it's anime" response without any attempt to answer the question that was asked.

"Who cares?"

ummmmm me clearly - which is why I asked the question haha


Edit: I see you gave Jobless Reincarnation a 9, now it all makes sense haha

Going through someone’s profile to make a point? Dude that’s low. What are you, new here?
Jul 12, 5:21 PM

Offline
Dec 2023
201
Reply to TommyTheWeeb139
Yorda_trico said:
@ColCasey

ah the obligatory anime defender "dude, it's anime" response without any attempt to answer the question that was asked.

"Who cares?"

ummmmm me clearly - which is why I asked the question haha


Edit: I see you gave Jobless Reincarnation a 9, now it all makes sense haha

Going through someone’s profile to make a point? Dude that’s low. What are you, new here?
@TommyTheWeeb139

ah another person ignoring the fact that it was not me who delivered the initial provocation, and I even tried to discourage any kind of behaviour in my original post

but yes I am the villain here, for sure!

Have a great day my friend!
Jul 12, 5:45 PM

Offline
Dec 2023
201
Reply to Boazanian
@Yorda_trico no problem! also, i never watched/read Planetarian before but i mightve heard about it once. ill keep it in mind tho, astronomy is something im quite interested in!
@Boazanian

in that case there is a scene in you will just absolutely love.

I would be so excited for anyone to watch it but someone who likes astronomy - that is even more exciting.

It is a very touching story!
Jul 12, 5:50 PM
Offline
Jan 2019
5
Reply to YordaTrico
@Boazanian

in that case there is a scene in you will just absolutely love.

I would be so excited for anyone to watch it but someone who likes astronomy - that is even more exciting.

It is a very touching story!
@Yorda_trico it's based on the VN right?
Jul 12, 6:16 PM

Offline
Dec 2023
201
Reply to The_Lamington
@Yorda_trico it's based on the VN right?
@The_Lamington

yep :)

I actually hadn't played the VN and I only found out about that after.

But I plan to play it as I really loved the story so much. You know when you wonder "what will be my next special show" and then when it comes along you just feel it!

There is an OVA version and a movie version, I prefer the OVA and I think people should start with it as it is the first released, but like me if someone likes it I am sure they would want to try both versions.
Jul 12, 6:38 PM
Offline
Dec 2023
159
Yorda_trico said:
@TommyTheWeeb139

ah another person ignoring the fact that it was not me who delivered the initial provocation, and I even tried to discourage any kind of behaviour in my original post

but yes I am the villain here, for sure!

Have a great day my friend!

I didn’t say you were a villain im just saying, the person was not being rude or anything thery were just saying to give it a chance, im just here to say that going through someone’s profile to make a point is just..weird? I mean congrats, you win?
Jul 12, 6:53 PM

Offline
Dec 2023
201
Reply to TommyTheWeeb139
Yorda_trico said:
@TommyTheWeeb139

ah another person ignoring the fact that it was not me who delivered the initial provocation, and I even tried to discourage any kind of behaviour in my original post

but yes I am the villain here, for sure!

Have a great day my friend!

I didn’t say you were a villain im just saying, the person was not being rude or anything thery were just saying to give it a chance, im just here to say that going through someone’s profile to make a point is just..weird? I mean congrats, you win?
@TommyTheWeeb139

you win?


to loosely quote your own wise words - I didn't say anything about winning I'm just saying.

So when he said "Who cares?" in regards to my question that I cared to ask, and also a very snippy "First time?" at the end, he wasn't being provocative? How did he help me clarify anything?

I mean it all becomes a moot point if you look up and see that someone who played the VN was actually able to answer my question constructively without being antagonistic and provocative - which is why I made the post in the first place (IMAGINE THAT????)

Imagine if he hadn't made his snippy pointless unhelpful comment - this thread would only contain constructive people helping me understand the dynamics of the story in this anime.

But you clearly have a bias and see him as an innocent little kitten and me as a baddie, so let's agree to disagree and feel free to continue this conversation yourself if you have nothing better to do, at this point my question has been answered by a helpful person - so I am good.
Jul 12, 8:07 PM
Offline
Dec 2023
159
Yorda_trico said:
@TommyTheWeeb139

you win?


to loosely quote your own wise words - I didn't say anything about winning I'm just saying.

So when he said "Who cares?" in regards to my question that I cared to ask, and also a very snippy "First time?" at the end, he wasn't being provocative? How did he help me clarify anything?

I mean it all becomes a moot point if you look up and see that someone who played the VN was actually able to answer my question constructively without being antagonistic and provocative - which is why I made the post in the first place (IMAGINE THAT????)

Imagine if he hadn't made his snippy pointless unhelpful comment - this thread would only contain constructive people helping me understand the dynamics of the story in this anime.

But you clearly have a bias and see him as an innocent little kitten and me as a baddie, so let's agree to disagree and feel free to continue this conversation yourself if you have nothing better to do, at this point my question has been answered by a helpful person - so I am good.

It’s not that crazy, lol. You typed up an entire essay over this boring argument but what? No im just saying, I agree with him. It’s anime, just watch the first episode
Jul 12, 9:33 PM
Offline
Jun 2021
311
TommyTheWeeb139 said:
Yorda_trico said:
@ColCasey

ah the obligatory anime defender "dude, it's anime" response without any attempt to answer the question that was asked.

"Who cares?"

ummmmm me clearly - which is why I asked the question haha


Edit: I see you gave Jobless Reincarnation a 9, now it all makes sense haha

Going through someone’s profile to make a point? Dude that’s low. What are you, new here?

tourists these days
Jul 12, 9:33 PM
Offline
Jun 2021
311
Yorda_trico said:
@ColCasey

ah the obligatory anime defender "dude, it's anime" response without any attempt to answer the question that was asked.

"Who cares?"

ummmmm me clearly - which is why I asked the question haha


Edit: I see you gave Jobless Reincarnation a 9, now it all makes sense haha

makes sense mushoku is great
Jul 12, 10:03 PM
Offline
Dec 2023
159
No1_LoliLover said:
TommyTheWeeb139 said:

Going through someone’s profile to make a point? Dude that’s low. What are you, new here?

tourists these days

lol their causing the inflation
Jul 12, 10:09 PM
Offline
Aug 2021
61
Mushoku being brought up here was completely unnecessary and just made this painful to read through and anybody who still believe that show is a pedo fantasy needs to grow up and relealize that perspective is just dumb and by the time anything romance involved actually does happens most of the characters are your average anime age and that perspective also downplays the severity of actual pedos and the reason MC ends up like that is ALMOST understandable. Opinion on Violet Evergarden Movie is also just real dumb considering that shows setting and Violets character.

As for your question which you should've just stuck to in the first place (and never mentioned Mushoku) the person who said the spoilers is completely correct and Atri is a lot like Plastic Memories and Planetarian. Also seeing as you like Planetarian I'd recommend anything made by the same Studio - Key, that has a good adaptation or is original (Clannad, Angel Beats!, Kanon (2006) etc.) just not Rewrite or Little Busters! (most VNs are better but these are substantially better). You'd probably also love the Key VN Stella of the End (written by the same guy as Planetarian who I believe also wrote most of Rewrites VN) which does the robot thing but with a Father Daughter relationship instead of romantic. Most VNs go on pretty big sales quite regularly on Steam.

Also do watch Planetarian: Storyteller of the Stars (the movie) as it adds quite a few extra things (that weren't even in the VN) throughout the recaps of the OVA that I think wraps up the story really nicely. And Plastic Memories has a VN (originally for PS Vita but a PC English fan patch exists) that has a happy ending in it (definitely need a guide to get there though).
Jul 12, 10:14 PM

Offline
Dec 2023
201
Reply to No1_LoliLover
Yorda_trico said:
@ColCasey

ah the obligatory anime defender "dude, it's anime" response without any attempt to answer the question that was asked.

"Who cares?"

ummmmm me clearly - which is why I asked the question haha


Edit: I see you gave Jobless Reincarnation a 9, now it all makes sense haha

makes sense mushoku is great
@No1_LoliLover

I honestly cannot thank you enough for rocking into this post with that username and disagreeing with me while agreeing with @TommyTheWeeb139 hahaha

it really reminds me of why I asked this question in the first place, and the kind of anime fans I truly don't want to associate with

No need for me to even reply on this post anymore, the combination of that username + your antagonistic reply has created a better defence for my question than I ever could with 10,000 words :)

thank you so much!
Jul 12, 10:17 PM

Offline
Dec 2023
201
Reply to KanekoKTIA
Mushoku being brought up here was completely unnecessary and just made this painful to read through and anybody who still believe that show is a pedo fantasy needs to grow up and relealize that perspective is just dumb and by the time anything romance involved actually does happens most of the characters are your average anime age and that perspective also downplays the severity of actual pedos and the reason MC ends up like that is ALMOST understandable. Opinion on Violet Evergarden Movie is also just real dumb considering that shows setting and Violets character.

As for your question which you should've just stuck to in the first place (and never mentioned Mushoku) the person who said the spoilers is completely correct and Atri is a lot like Plastic Memories and Planetarian. Also seeing as you like Planetarian I'd recommend anything made by the same Studio - Key, that has a good adaptation or is original (Clannad, Angel Beats!, Kanon (2006) etc.) just not Rewrite or Little Busters! (most VNs are better but these are substantially better). You'd probably also love the Key VN Stella of the End (written by the same guy as Planetarian who I believe also wrote most of Rewrites VN) which does the robot thing but with a Father Daughter relationship instead of romantic. Most VNs go on pretty big sales quite regularly on Steam.

Also do watch Planetarian: Storyteller of the Stars (the movie) as it adds quite a few extra things (that weren't even in the VN) throughout the recaps of the OVA that I think wraps up the story really nicely. And Plastic Memories has a VN (originally for PS Vita but a PC English fan patch exists) that has a happy ending in it (definitely need a guide to get there though).
@KanekoKTIA bla bla bla I am ignoring the fact that the other guy was antagonistic first because I like the anime that was insulted bla bla bla my opinions on Violet Evergarden are gospel bla bla bla


Edit: post now ignored as I got my answer hours ago, enjoy being toxic to all those who just wanted to pick a fight :)
YordaTricoJul 12, 10:29 PM
Jul 12, 11:14 PM

Offline
Aug 2013
5418
I’d recommend going to the therapist if you have problems with separating fiction from reality.
Unless you’re trolling. If you’re trolling, you should know that it isn’t funny for anyone.
Dub = fake crap. Always.
Jul 12, 11:30 PM
Offline
Dec 2023
159
Yorda_trico said:
@No1_LoliLover

I honestly cannot thank you enough for rocking into this post with that username and disagreeing with me while agreeing with @TommyTheWeeb139 hahaha

it really reminds me of why I asked this question in the first place, and the kind of anime fans I truly don't want to associate with

No need for me to even reply on this post anymore, the combination of that username + your antagonistic reply has created a better defence for my question than I ever could with 10,000 words :)

thank you so much!

Hey look. You’re taking this way too seriously. Just move on. It’s drawings, it’s anime. Just watch it. Stop arguing with everyone, it’s 2:30 and your still hung up on something someone said. Just forget about it
Jul 13, 12:18 AM
Offline
Aug 2021
61
Reply to YordaTrico
@KanekoKTIA bla bla bla I am ignoring the fact that the other guy was antagonistic first because I like the anime that was insulted bla bla bla my opinions on Violet Evergarden are gospel bla bla bla


Edit: post now ignored as I got my answer hours ago, enjoy being toxic to all those who just wanted to pick a fight :)
@Yorda_trico Sorry for giving actual recommendation then asshole.

I'm also not defending the other guy, just saying my perspective on the Mushoku thing and the point of Violets Movie that went over your head.

I don't want to pick a fight otherwise I wouldn't have given you recommendations.

You're the one being antagonistic here
Jul 13, 12:39 AM
Offline
Jun 2021
311
TommyTheWeeb139 said:
No1_LoliLover said:

tourists these days

lol their causing the inflation

the numbers go up but at what cost..
Jul 13, 3:31 AM

Offline
Aug 2018
160
Reply to ColCasey
Yorda_trico said:
@ColCasey

ah the obligatory anime defender "dude, it's anime" response without any attempt to answer the question that was asked.

"Who cares?"

ummmmm me clearly - which is why I asked the question haha


Edit: I see you gave Jobless Reincarnation a 9, now it all makes sense haha

you already got the answer, so why would I repeat it? Bottom line is, watch it or don't if you are scared to see a romance with a young looking girl. Guessing you are new to this medium if you have gripes with this kind of stuff so you have to find out for yourself
@ColCasey You're the kind of anime fan who makes people ashamed to admit they like anime
Jul 13, 4:03 AM
Offline
Jun 2021
311
KanekoKTIA said:
@Yorda_trico Sorry for giving actual recommendation then asshole.

I'm also not defending the other guy, just saying my perspective on the Mushoku thing and the point of Violets Movie that went over your head.

I don't want to pick a fight otherwise I wouldn't have given you recommendations.

You're the one being antagonistic here

these type of people only hear what they want to hear like an inefficient school teacher
Jul 13, 4:04 AM
Offline
Jun 2021
311
Yorda_trico said:
@No1_LoliLover

I honestly cannot thank you enough for rocking into this post with that username and disagreeing with me while agreeing with @TommyTheWeeb139 hahaha

it really reminds me of why I asked this question in the first place, and the kind of anime fans I truly don't want to associate with

No need for me to even reply on this post anymore, the combination of that username + your antagonistic reply has created a better defence for my question than I ever could with 10,000 words :)

thank you so much!

*defense

this ain't the uk
Pages (2) [1] 2 »

More topics from this board

Poll: » Atri: My Dear Moments Episode 13 Discussion ( 1 2 3 )

KANLen09 - Oct 5

112 by Archean-Return »»
Nov 22, 9:40 PM

Poll: » Atri: My Dear Moments Episode 12 Discussion ( 1 2 )

KANLen09 - Sep 28

57 by Archean-Return »»
Nov 22, 8:38 PM

Poll: » Atri: My Dear Moments Episode 11 Discussion

IzanaSolos - Sep 21

44 by Archean-Return »»
Nov 22, 7:22 PM

Poll: » Atri: My Dear Moments Episode 10 Discussion ( 1 2 )

IzanaSolos - Sep 14

84 by Archean-Return »»
Nov 22, 5:24 PM

Poll: » Atri: My Dear Moments Episode 9 Discussion ( 1 2 )

KANLen09 - Sep 7

58 by Archean-Return »»
Nov 22, 4:16 PM
It’s time to ditch the text file.
Keep track of your anime easily by creating your own list.
Sign Up Login