| which do you prefer, i thought the anime was kinda childish compared to the manga. also, how was the novel compared to the manga/anime? |
| i read the 1st volume of NHK but was very disappointed. The manga was rushed in a way and the issue of the hikkori wasn't significant until later on. That one volume probably covered 3 episodes of NHK but i'm willing to read the final volume jsut to see a more 'pleasureable' ending between satou and misaki . |
| The manga goes more into detail on Misaki. I love both. So I'm not too sure whats better. |
| I personally like the anime more. The problem with the manga was that the characters were far more insane. It focused on that far too much and in the end, felt like it was trying to force a reaction out of you. Things like, "this is really disturbing, so you should get chills here" It didn't feel honest. They kinda over-stepped themselves there. Some of the important scenes were handled very differently too. this spoils parts of both the anime and manga. Basically, it felt too surreal. For this type of thing to hit home, it needs to feel as if it could actually happen. |
Powered by hinatachan - TaigaForum |
| I agree with Palimpsest 100% Misaki is way crazy in the manga. Plus, a lot of what made NHK my favorite series was missing in the manga. i.e. the suicide scene. The manga still rocked overall though, but falls short when compared to the anime. |
| I go for anime, though i have manga in my laptop. maybe soon i'll check on the manga version thanks |
 |
| The anime was better IMO, but both of them are good ^-^ |
| Haven't seen th anime, but I've read the manga and the novel. So I'll say manga. |
| I think the anime was WORLDS better than the manga. Not to say I didn't enjoy the manga, but the anime was pretty much life changing for me and really sucked me into anime in general more than I already was. The anime was intense and life changing whereas the manga was just kind of a relaxed or lackadaisical read without a whole lot of meaning. As for the novel, I own it but have not gotten around to reading it yet. I'm guessing I'll like it more than the manga but less than the anime. I am in love with the music from the anime too. I generally put the soundtrack on when I was reading the manga. It really adds a lot to it. |
 |
| I really enjoy a lot more the manga... exactly for the same reasons that most of you prefer the anime :P. The characters ( specially misaki) were crazier in the manga, the threads of relationships between them is more complete (or complicated, depends on your point of view :P ) and enters more into the details. For me the anime was a rushed version of the manga that couldn't stay at the same level. The next spoiler is for the ones that have read the manga AND have seen the anime. If you haven't read/seen both, read it under your own discretion :P |
| "The past will often attack the present with the pain of your memories." "There is no wish that doesn't come true." "The brain is a microcosm creating its own stories. People then live out these stories." "Time does not exist. Only the illusion of memories exist." "Existence does not rely on matter. Everything is phantom." "The waking dream called the world is constantly changing. What's so sad about that?" "Pure perfection has no past. That is how you live perfectly." "How can you say you are a phantom?" Seiichi Kirima |
More topics from this board
Poll: » Misaki or Hitomi for Satou Tatsuhiro?justnlife23 - Sep 30, 2007 |
24 |
by RHAYLEYVIEWS
»»
Nov 2, 2014 7:23 AM |
|
» [CLOSED] MEMBERCARDSrawrandom - Dec 2, 2009 |
19 |
by Alby
»»
Jul 2, 2010 6:30 PM |
|
» Welcome to the NHK! Club Officers Wantedjustnlife23 - Sep 30, 2007 |
6 |
by tery999
»»
May 16, 2010 1:39 AM |
|
» Is the dubbed version any good?MukaBlue - Jan 22, 2009 |
2 |
by loghneckbeard
»»
May 2, 2010 10:47 AM |