| Why is this on MAL? This isn't anime |
| Opening is sung by BTS apparently, does this show have any following?? |
MAL also allow Donghuas (Chinese Animation) & Aenis (Korean Animation) in its database. https://myanimelist.net/forum/?topicid=515957 |
 "Genius lives only one storey above madness." – Arthur Schopenhauer. "Stupidity is a talent for misconception." – Edgar Allan Poe. "I'm tired... and hungry." – Alexioos95. |
| MAL's database includes animated media from East Asian countries in general, not just Japan. It's been like this for a while now. |
Alexioos95 said: MAL also allow Donghuas (Chinese Animation) & Aenis (Korean Animation) in its database. https://myanimelist.net/forum/?topicid=515957 >On MyAnimeList, a work is considered to be an "anime" if it meets all of the following: >It's created by professional staff in Japan for the Japanese market. YoshiKiller01 said: MAL's database includes animated media from East Asian countries in general, not just Japan. It's been like this for a while now. Nope, Korean and Chinese animation are on MAL when they release in the Japanese market, usually as subcontractors or when part of the production (either animation studio(s) or publisher) are japanese. This one doesn't look like any of these |
belial said: >On MyAnimeList, a work is considered to be an "anime" if it meets all of the following: >It's created by professional staff in Japan for the Japanese market. And just below , it's written : I.1 Country of Origin Animated works must be created: in Japan for the Japanese market (anime) in Korea for the Korean market (aeni) in China, Hong Kong, and Taiwan for their respective markets (donghua) as a joint production between Japan/Korea/China/Taiwan and another country, for both markets |
"Genius lives only one storey above madness." – Arthur Schopenhauer. "Stupidity is a talent for misconception." – Edgar Allan Poe. "I'm tired... and hungry." – Alexioos95. |
| So we can be reminded that k-pop idols are being beaten every day. But its ok, cuz we only care about them dancing in a funny way anyways. |
 |
Alexioos95 said: And just below , it's written : I.1 Country of Origin Animated works must be created: in Japan for the Japanese market (anime) in Korea for the Korean market (aeni) in China, Hong Kong, and Taiwan for their respective markets (donghua) as a joint production between Japan/Korea/China/Taiwan and another country, for both markets You quoted something irrelevant. The animation doesn't come to the japanese market and it's not anime by the very definition on that same page (already quoted) It was already bad enough that mods let MAL be spammed by Youtube videos and music |
belial said: Alexioos95 said: And just below , it's written : I.1 Country of Origin Animated works must be created: in Japan for the Japanese market (anime) in Korea for the Korean market (aeni) in China, Hong Kong, and Taiwan for their respective markets (donghua) as a joint production between Japan/Korea/China/Taiwan and another country, for both markets You quoted something irrelevant. The animation doesn't come to the japanese market and it's not anime by the very definition on that same page (already quoted) It was already bad enough that mods let MAL be spammed by Youtube videos and music There are plenty of Korean and Chinese productions in the database that weren't for the Japanese market. You're just gonna have to deal with it. Also, this one is currently airing. What makes you certain that it won't be broadcasted in Japan at some point, if it hasn't already. |
 |
Pyro said: There are plenty of Korean and Chinese productions in the database that weren't for the Japanese market. You're just gonna have to deal with it. Also, this one is currently airing. What makes you certain that it won't be broadcasted in Japan at some point, if it hasn't already. >It's created by professional staff in Japan for the Japanese market. being "broadcasted" in Japan isn't a criteria for non-anime to be on MAL The rules were linked, if you think you have an argument, at least read the thing first |
belial said: Pyro said: There are plenty of Korean and Chinese productions in the database that weren't for the Japanese market. You're just gonna have to deal with it. Also, this one is currently airing. What makes you certain that it won't be broadcasted in Japan at some point, if it hasn't already. >It's created by professional staff in Japan for the Japanese market. being "broadcasted" in Japan isn't a criteria for non-anime to be on MAL The rules were linked, if you think you have an argument, at least read the thing first My point is why do you keep bringing up that a non-Japanese production isn't for the Japanese market. There are existing entries that invalidate that. That being the case, one can infer "being created by professional staff in Japan for the Japanese market" isn't mandatory when it fits the criteria below, which is the Korean section in this case. |
|
Pyro said: No you can't. Go read the rulesone can infer |
belial said: No you can't. Go read the rules Is that all you have to say? You don't wanna elaborate or refute this at all? Pyro said: There are existing entries that invalidate that. Just gonna cut my reply so you can conveniently ignore what you want. Is it because you're unaware of what I'm referring to since you don't actually know much about the database and the various kinds of works in it. Don't bother replying to me if you don't have anything substantial to say. |
|
| Well this anime is fantastic and deserves at least a 10/10. But within those same rules that you told pyro to go read, it specifically states a subsection to which they ask you to go read for works they consider to be allowed on this site which aren't originated from the country of japan. I can copy and paste those subsections if you would like. This means they don't have to meet the condition which states "It's created by professional staff in Japan for the Japanese market." As long as it meets the conditions of the subsection. |
hammonlordofhamJun 2, 2023 11:55 AM
 |
Pyro said: I backed up the point of why its allowed on the website above. But did you do your PFP and footer? I really like the artwork.belial said: No you can't. Go read the rules Is that all you have to say? You don't wanna elaborate or refute this at all? Pyro said: There are existing entries that invalidate that. Just gonna cut my reply so you can conveniently ignore what you want. Is it because you're unaware of what I'm referring to since you don't actually know much about the database and the various kinds of works in it. Don't bother replying to me if you don't have anything substantial to say. |
|
belial said: Chinese and Korean animations are allowed in the database even if they aren't actually anime, provided they are made for the domestic market (so The Simpsons which is animated in South Korea isn't allowed on MAL whereas King's Avatar is allowed). It's been like that for ages. Kineta says the reason is because manhua and manhwa are so popular with manga fans that they realistically have to be in the database and adding donghua and aeni to MAL was just to keep the literature and animation parts of the database consistent with each other.Alexioos95 said: And just below , it's written : I.1 Country of Origin Animated works must be created: in Japan for the Japanese market (anime) in Korea for the Korean market (aeni) in China, Hong Kong, and Taiwan for their respective markets (donghua) as a joint production between Japan/Korea/China/Taiwan and another country, for both markets You quoted something irrelevant. The animation doesn't come to the japanese market and it's not anime by the very definition on that same page (already quoted) It was already bad enough that mods let MAL be spammed by Youtube videos and music |
  |