The Executioner and Her Way of Life
RayReynolds said: GalacticMagna said: This right here. Look just because it was able to avoid the simple thing of being a "wish fufilment isekai" doesn't mean it's good. I didn't enjoy something like Power Rangers RPM for doing something different from the typical Power Rangers formula. I loved it for the likable characters, the well structured, thought provoking story and the character development that was top notch, (besides the point I know but you get the gist) Executioner on the other is doesn't have any of that. And let's face what would happen if the roles were reversed.... I'm certain you wouldn't be on defense mode now would you. I had my reasons to drop the show, from un-interesting (and sometimes irritating) characters, a world building while being decent not having much intrigue, and really boring story. But yeah. 9 episodes in and you folks are still on this narrative of what happened into episode 1. Certainly, I find more interesting and fun other isekai that were precisely a "wish fufilment isekai" like "death march" that this novel concept, but putrid sunk in the concept of insipidity. DUH its just the premise of the story its the story of Shokei Shoujo, meaning Executioner Girl so they Executed the isekai-ed Boy and Girl in the same episode, episode 1. simple as that |
RayReynolds said: Certainly, I find more interesting and fun other isekai that were precisely a "wish fufilment isekai" like "death march" that this novel concept, but putrid sunk in the concept of insipidity. DUH its just the premise of the story its the story of Shokei Shoujo, meaning Executioner Girl so they Executed the isekai-ed Boy and Girl in the same episode, episode 1. simple as that ok, but you should rather assume that the show is bad for all things I've said |
RayReynolds said: DUH its just the premise of the story its the story of Shokei Shoujo, meaning Executioner Girl so they Executed the isekai-ed Boy and Girl in the same episode, episode 1. simple as that ok, but you should rather assume that the show is bad for all things I've said You... you barely said things and, like, those criticisms (if you can call them like that) were very shallow. The show has better things than killing that boy anyway, it was at best something funny to me and not something that I would say make it better than other series. It's fine if you don't like it tho, I can definitely get behind the "I don't care if other people think it's good, if I think it is boring then I don't have to like it". RayReynolds said: and 2010 and its harem battles will continue to be better Battle harems were definitely a better trend than isekai, but I like this one. |
Strykeryno said: @Lab_Rat_0978 ''you claimed executioner pulled a ClickBait on the audience'' Except it freakin did. Both show focused on ''generic MC'' until they got killed of by the actual MC. Just because you see a different message in it doesn't mean it's not technically different. Your whole point is leaning on the fact it wasn't hidden in synopsis nor the trailer, where i did reply that some people go blind into some shows and if you would ask them who is the protagonist of the series based on them watching the 1st 10 minutes on the 1st episode 70% procent of them would tell you it's Mitsuki. In TN 99% would tell you it's Nanao. The guy before you understood my point well enough. ''and yet nobody mentions flare? she also kills innocents all the time you know? its also revealed in episode 8-9 she killed a married woman with husband and children'' TN spoilers ''also, in nana the generic hareem isekai male MC aint ded'' Manga chapter 47 spoiler btw. That's like the finale of the 2nd season if we're speaking of 1 cour seasons that is. ''youre doing too hard by comparing nana and executioner, thats like thinking all anime are "naruto" just like what my mom says all the time lol as its showcased in anime episode 7 even the LORE in executioner is especially built for adventure and the adventure theme gets even thicker in light novel vol 3 onwards (in anime, we're in vol 2 btw) fyi executioner being adventure anime is foreshadowed by akari's statement back in anime episode 2'' I'am 9 episode in with SSnVR and on going with TN manga (unlike you) so yes it's NOT the same genre or direction but both shows share plenty of similarities in story/characters and their roles. Hell if it wasn't for TN fandom i wouldn't even notice this series to begin with. Again look at the ''recommendations'' tab on https://myanimelist.net/anime/47162/Shokei_Shoujo_no_Virgin_Road what do you see there? Make no mistake i'am not saying that one show is better then the another since genre-wised they are different despite sharing quite amount of similarities. Strykeryno said: @Lab_Rat_0978 ''you claimed executioner pulled a ClickBait on the audience'' Except it freakin did. Both show focused on ''generic MC'' until they got killed of by the actual MC. Just because you see a different message in it doesn't mean it's not technically different. Your whole point is leaning on the fact it wasn't hidden in synopsis nor the trailer, where i did reply that some people go blind into some shows and if you would ask them who is the protagonist of the series based on them watching the 1st 10 minutes on the 1st episode 70% procent of them would tell you it's Mitsuki. In TN 99% would tell you it's Nanao. The guy before you understood my point well enough. ''and yet nobody mentions flare? she also kills innocents all the time you know? its also revealed in episode 8-9 she killed a married woman with husband and children'' TN spoilers ''also, in nana the generic hareem isekai male MC aint ded'' Manga chapter 47 spoiler btw. That's like the finale of the 2nd season if we're speaking of 1 cour seasons that is. ''youre doing too hard by comparing nana and executioner, thats like thinking all anime are "naruto" just like what my mom says all the time lol as its showcased in anime episode 7 even the LORE in executioner is especially built for adventure and the adventure theme gets even thicker in light novel vol 3 onwards (in anime, we're in vol 2 btw) fyi executioner being adventure anime is foreshadowed by akari's statement back in anime episode 2'' I'am 9 episode in with SSnVR and on going with TN manga (unlike you) so yes it's NOT the same genre or direction but both shows share plenty of similarities in story/characters and their roles. Hell if it wasn't for TN fandom i wouldn't even notice this series to begin with. Again look at the ''recommendations'' tab on https://myanimelist.net/anime/47162/Shokei_Shoujo_no_Virgin_Road what do you see there? Make no mistake i'am not saying that one show is better then the another since genre-wised they are different despite sharing quite amount of similarities. Im starting to doubt whether you have watched executioner or not Nope, it freaking didnt first you should've at least read the title, and then there's this Girl popping up, showing kindness to a random isekai-ed Boy out of nowhere literally everything about this Girl screaming SUS, Idk about you but I think anyone with even a smol brain if they have read the title, The Executioner Girl, they would've instantly deduced that this Girl must be the infamous Executioner are you implying Baiting homo sapiens/humans would be as simple as Baiting regular fishes? lol Im fairly certain even the Haters who watched episode 1 also noticed that menou was more than likely, an Executioner, who planned to kill the isekai-ed boy sooner than later its just, as I stated before they only failed to predict that the isekai-ed boy would die For Real. thus it made em Angery almost everything you say fail to answer why is all the hatred on menou, its literally shown multiple times how flare, also an executioner killed boys girls men and women, she also shouted at kid menou and other orphans that they're villains btw thx to menou, all the orphans were released by flare back then so we're gonna just forget about kid menou's good deed huh? ok Ive never claimed executioner is better than nana nor accusing you for claiming nana is better than executioner either. why would mention things that we both dont even care about? lol I simply asked whether nana is adventure oriented anime or not, thats all to put it into perspective, just cuz there are multiple anime have the shounen troupes, it doesnt mean theyre all the same as we can clearly see for example, ONE PIECE is adventure anime, thats obviously quite different compared to idk Naruto. even if we bring FMA another adventure anime, ONE PIECE and FMA are still nothing alike, these two simply follow some shounen troupes, thus the similarities |
Lab_Rat_0978May 28, 2022 10:36 PM
| @Strykeryno Im fairly certain the troupe sacrifing innocents for the greater good or kill a few to save a lot isnt really a new thing, iirc FATE's mc Kiritsugu and EMIYA also believe in this idea? psycho pass is also the same, its all for the greater good. probably |
| @texasfangirl1999 the fact that something so unique is hated says a lot about how mainstream garbage has completely drowned out the rest of the animes and his proposals. The Anime for straight people has convinced many that the world revolves around them, flattering the young public and their idealistic thoughts, that the girls who treat them badly are actually in love with them for that reason good animes of this season like healer girl and birdie wing have such a bad acceptance here, they just hate animes where the average guy is not the center of attention. |
 "The greatest glory in living lies not in never falling, but in rising every time we fall." |
DekuxUraraka said: "Hidden gem" lmao. Get the fuck outa here fam. Thus is pure trash. The plot is boring, makes no sense, characters are dull. It has a 6.7 score for a reason, because it's actually trash. That the plot and the characters seem boring to you is totally subjective, could I tell you that seeing a guy fighting like goku or deku seems boring to me but that you find it entertaining is totally valid, that the plot make no sense is totally false if you haven't paid attention it's your problem |
| "The greatest glory in living lies not in never falling, but in rising every time we fall." |
| I’ll be honest I watch Isekai for the self-insert power fantasy, and watching the self-insert character die was like watching myself die so there’s that. Not that it’s a bad thing, I’m not gonna review bomb this because a side character died. But I still feel guilt for Mitsuki for some reason. However… the characters it gives you to fill in for the self-insert character aren’t all that interesting based on what I’ve seen from some more detailed reviews and what little I watched. Granted this still looks way more interesting than some shows this season, I’ll give it a try. |
 |
| i felt bad for like 2 minutes after his death but i kinda get over it. I dont understand why people got so attached with him. |
| I've learned to ignore the ratings on this website. I'm enjoying the show, but I feel like the LN is probably a lot better, but I do not have time to read it so for now I'll enjoy what the anime. This may be surprising to newer members, but if this show aired 10 years ago, I suspect the rating would be even lower. The anime community back then was even more spiteful imo. |
 |
RayReynolds said: too much credit they give a show just from killing that poor nobody in Ep1 when have the same old isekai tropes regurgitated here, but with “subverting your expectations”, corrupt churches and exchanging one power fantasy (male wish fulfillment) for another stuff (yuribait lol) they already thinks that their mediocre show is remarkable do you intentionally have the need to self insert in every show you watch? I'd rather have a cute girl as an mc rather than a bland generic male person I'm not saying that this show is "good" because it's is "subverting your expectations"; actually I think it is a pretty avarage fantasy show, yet enjoyable. It seems that you can't get over the fact that your random guy is dead. It's like being mad at fucking Annie from AoT because she killed a fuckton of random scouts in her arc. Who would be mad because some random guy died?!?! |
RayReynolds said: too much credit they give a show just from killing that poor nobody in Ep1 when have the same old isekai tropes regurgitated here, but with “subverting your expectations”, corrupt churches and exchanging one power fantasy (male wish fulfillment) for another stuff (yuribait lol) they already thinks that their mediocre show is remarkable do you intentionally have the need to self insert in every show you watch? I'd rather have a cute girl as an mc rather than a bland generic male person I'm not saying that this show is "good" because it's is "subverting your expectations"; actually I think it is a pretty avarage fantasy show, yet enjoyable. It seems that you can't get over the fact that your random guy is dead. It's like being mad at fucking Annie from AoT because she killed a fuckton of random scouts in her arc. Who would be mad because some random guy died?!?! I have never said that I want to have a self-insert, I said that this seems to me boring and generic, you do not know how to read. |
Sekirodiealotoft said: RayReynolds said: boring and generic like mitsuki. This show is anything but that.I have never said that I want to have a self-insert, I said that this seems to me boring and generic, you do not know how to read. 7 episodes are enough to declare this show is dead direction is boring, animation is bad, story is badly execute and even if i get better ur not gonna carry in watching something thats been crap for more than 7 episodes? |
| @RayReynolds it seems that you aren’t watching the same show as I am. The generic animes that you says about always focus 90% of the time on a single character, the typical poor boy-teenager black-hair who becomes OP without any effort despite always emphasizing how much he is trying when it is not true, contradictory and without a good characterization those characters are not more than a blank slate, while here the characters are defined by real personalities; Menou does not try to be an exponent of effort or overcoming there are several different and original topics that your limited understanding cannot process. |
G0ldStarkJun 8, 2022 7:33 PM
| I was curious as well and look at the stats: More 1s then 2s or 3s. This show is definitely getting score bombed. Did some dumb anituber start this shit again because his self insert was killed? The fact alone we have to talk about Mitsuki even by ep11 really shows there is some truth to it. |
| "This emotion is mine alone. It is for Madoka alone." - Homura or how I would descripe Mahou Shoujo Madoka Magica. |
Sekirodiealotoft said: i honestly dont understand people. everyone complains about cardboard MCs and then when you get rid of them they complain too? Its not even a vocal salty minority situation like all those plebs who hate Re Zero or Mushoku Tensei for their quirky MCs, atleast those shows have a high rating.Comander-07 said: it wasn't an antituber that hated it. It's just that people on this site can't accept that not every isekai needs a harem mc. Idk it's just weird that anyone got attached to him and is somehow surprised he isn't the main character.I was curious as well and look at the stats: More 1s then 2s or 3s. This show is definitely getting score bombed. Did some dumb anituber start this shit again because his self insert was killed? The fact alone we have to talk about Mitsuki even by ep11 really shows there is some truth to it. Are people here really so immature? Are they really parroting this much? I have been on MAL for a long time now so its hard to surprise me, but I genuinely thought the userbase at large was less shitty. Thats why I was hoping its just some dumb anituber drama again. Its clearly getting brigaded with those 1s breaking the bell curve, otherwise it would be some 7ish show which is good enough for yuri(bait), I mean even Flip Flappers didnt manage a higher score. Ah well its clearly the yuri curse, I guess if Akari was a dude it would be 7.5 |
| "This emotion is mine alone. It is for Madoka alone." - Homura or how I would descripe Mahou Shoujo Madoka Magica. |
Comander-07 said: it wasn't an antituber that hated it. It's just that people on this site can't accept that not every isekai needs a harem mc. Idk it's just weird that anyone got attached to him and is somehow surprised he isn't the main character.I was curious as well and look at the stats: More 1s then 2s or 3s. This show is definitely getting score bombed. Did some dumb anituber start this shit again because his self insert was killed? The fact alone we have to talk about Mitsuki even by ep11 really shows there is some truth to it. it's weird considering that there are already isekai with female protagonist like kuma bear, slime taoshite and land of deadale. I already wondered why people are so salty for this series when there are already many animes with only female characters |
 |
Idoreview said: His power was Null(ification of things), and his final magic subtitle was regarding the uncreation and recreation of all things. Why this is portrayed as lesser to the Princess of Persia, who's to say? I personally think it's just one example of inconsistent writing in a show that plainly refuses to answer any questions it poses. naaahh, not really the other isekai-ed girl who also gets killed quite easily in episode 1, her pure concept is ivory/white but its not the same ivory as hero ivory who killed and sealed the 4 human major errors a thousand years ago just for your information in japanese language, even a single kanji's character can be read in many different ways and it can also have many different meanings |
Lab_Rat_0978Jun 14, 2022 6:12 PM
Fede_5000 said: it wasn't an antituber that hated it. It's just that people on this site can't accept that not every isekai needs a harem mc. Idk it's just weird that anyone got attached to him and is somehow surprised he isn't the main character. it's weird considering that there are already isekai with female protagonist like kuma bear, slime taoshite and land of deadale. I already wondered why people are so salty for this series when there are already many animes with only female characters cuz kuma, slime hunter and leadale didnt spill generic hareem isekai mc's blood, they're clean |
Idoreview said: Lab_Rat_0978 said: naaahh, not really the other isekai-ed girl who also gets killed quite easily in episode 1, her pure concept is ivory/white but its not the same ivory as hero ivory who killed and sealed the 4 human major errors a thousand years ago just for your information in japanese language, even a single kanji's character can be read in many different ways and it can also have many different meanings Great, we disagree but haven't established why. I say "This writing is bad because it's inconsistent" and you retort "No, have this barrage of unrelated things." I honestly don't even remember that encounter happening vividly, it wouldn't strike me as important, but I'll take your word for it being easy and whatnot to kill that character. I don't see how it's relevant to what I said though. Was her power also literally uncreation? If not, my ability to see the relevance is further limited by that. To the rest: Cool? This is being dubbed. It essentially has official english verbiage now, and that is the way I experienced it. the fact that ivory a thousand years ago and ivory 10 years ago are not the same is a Precedent, just cuz they both are literally "ivory" they're not necessarily the same things/pure concepts do you have no idea what a Precedent is? why would you think everything I said is unrelated? its also shown that menou didnt even need to use her scripture to kill "the null" isekai-ed boy, knifed to the head was more than enough to kill him for good in her scripture there are many anti-pure concept spells that are specialized in Purifying pure concepts, had the boy survived she would've used it just fine why didnt menou use it one her first move then? as we can see also in Episode 1 when archbishop orwell killed the ivory girl 10 years ago, its slow and flashy archbishop orwell had to use flare to distract the ivory girl whilst she's casting her anti-pure concept spell |
Lab_Rat_0978Jun 14, 2022 7:50 PM
Lab_Rat_0978 said: Idoreview said: His power was Null(ification of things), and his final magic subtitle was regarding the uncreation and recreation of all things. Why this is portrayed as lesser to the Princess of Persia, who's to say? I personally think it's just one example of inconsistent writing in a show that plainly refuses to answer any questions it poses. naaahh, not really the other isekai-ed girl who also gets killed quite easily in episode 1, her pure concept is ivory/white but its not the same ivory as hero ivory who killed and sealed the 4 human major errors a thousand years ago just for your information in japanese language, even a single kanji's character can be read in many different ways and it can also have many different meanings Just a little correction |
Ionliosite2 said: Lab_Rat_0978 said: naaahh, not really the other isekai-ed girl who also gets killed quite easily in episode 1, her pure concept is ivory/white but its not the same ivory as hero ivory who killed and sealed the 4 human major errors a thousand years ago just for your information in japanese language, even a single kanji's character can be read in many different ways and it can also have many different meanings Just a little correction the anime sub says its ivory, so lets blame the sub lol or myb the one I watched had a shitty sub |
Lab_Rat_0978 said: the anime sub says its ivory, so lets blame the sub lol or myb the one I watched had a shitty sub Nah, the subs aren't shitty, that's because it says Ivory, the thing is that it isn't it and they kinda made it clear. |
Sekirodiealotoft said: Girl kills one kid to prevent him from killing countless more. Everyone: this anime is edgy try hard garbage. I hate this murderous b----! Skeleton invades, enslaves, and slaughters people for literally no reason. Everyone: Overlord is the best anime ever! Momonga is the coolest! I think it's been proven that people support a murderous, bastard protagonist only if he's a boy with which they can self-insert. |
Thread cleaned, please refrain from starting off-topic discussions and keep things civil. |
| That kid was dangerous. The first thing he thought when acquired his power was "now, no one will get in my way..." . Yeah, i would knife him in the head too, this idiot would probably create a giant black hole in the planet. |
Malufeenho said: That kid was dangerous. The first thing he thought when acquired his power was "now, no one will get in my way..." . Yeah, i would knife him in the head too, this idiot would probably create a giant black hole in the planet. if isekai fans can be glad he came back... as crafting material kukukuku it can be said that he will always live as human parts inside Manon 🤣 |
 |
More topics from this board
» This Anime deserves a 2nd season!!MarekPPP - Aug 31 |
10 |
by zIlverKitsune
»»
Oct 6, 5:51 AM |
|
Poll: » Shokei Shoujo no Virgin Road Episode 1 Discussion ( 1 2 3 4 5 ... Last Page )Stark700 - Apr 1, 2022 |
330 |
by LycorAxis
»»
Sep 23, 9:34 AM |
|
Poll: » Shokei Shoujo no Virgin Road Episode 12 Discussion ( 1 2 3 )Stark700 - Jun 17, 2022 |
132 |
by MarekPPP
»»
Aug 31, 1:40 PM |
|
» This Anime doesn't deserve to get a new season!!Rezelix112 - Jul 20 |
15 |
by MarekPPP
»»
Aug 31, 11:22 AM |
|
Poll: » Shokei Shoujo no Virgin Road Episode 6 Discussion ( 1 2 3 )Stark700 - May 6, 2022 |
136 |
by AW_Flister
»»
Aug 9, 6:15 PM |