People are sleeping on best girl Itsuki

Helshiki said:
Ok guys no toxicity, only pure discussion.

I am going to refer to Miku as "best girl" and Nino as "queen".
While initially best girl hated the mc she started liking him out of the blue. Best girl is shy and reserved and she got the highest number of fans. Best girl literally has no personality and is a totally bland character. Being shy isn't actually a personality since anybody can be shy depending on the situation. Dandere characters can be found in almost every other anime. Aside from her looks nothing really stands out. From what I have seen weebs tend to like any cute girl who romantically loves the mc.

Our queen (nino) is a tsundere. Tsundere, Another common troupe that can be found in any anime. She has the best character development? No, she just went from hating the mc to liking him in 3 seconds. That's not a character development, it's just a cliche tsundere move. The fact that y'all think tsundere characters are best girls is itself a highly subjective opinion. She drugs the mc twice and also tore the pages for which our mc worked till late night. And she didn't even apologize to him. People hate Ichika for what she did to best girl (because miku is cute) but people don't hate on our Queen because nobody cares about our mc.

But you know what? I hate Itsuki even more. She is always stalking our mc and also stayed at his house (thus coming in between best girl's relationship with mc) She even slapped our queen just because she thought the mc did a little hard work for her sisters. She prioritizes her career over our handsome mc, like seriously? She's diligent, honest (doesnt like deceiving people), hardworking, maintains a health relationship with her step father and her glutton side is actually the most wholesome thing ever. She's also the most stubborn which makes sense since she's the youngest but is also a very understanding girl and doesn't create "drama" like best girl or our queen. But that's all. Ikr? She's so PLAIN in comparison to Miku and Nino. Can't believe people actually think she's the best girl.

Conclusion: ̶M̶i̶k̶u ̶a̶n̶d ̶N̶i̶n̶o Itsuki best girl!

Just_jesse said:
S tier: Miku/yotsuba
A tier: itsuki
F tier: ichika
FF tier: nino

Just_jesse said:
S tier: Miku/yotsuba
A tier: itsuki
F tier: ichika
FF tier: nino

Helshiki said:
Ok guys no toxicity, only pure discussion.

I am going to refer to Miku as "best girl" and Nino as "queen".
While initially best girl hated the mc she started liking him out of the blue. Best girl is shy and reserved and she got the highest number of fans. Best girl literally has no personality and is a totally bland character. Being shy isn't actually a personality since anybody can be shy depending on the situation. Dandere characters can be found in almost every other anime. Aside from her looks nothing really stands out. From what I have seen weebs tend to like any cute girl who romantically loves the mc.

Our queen (nino) is a tsundere. Tsundere, Another common troupe that can be found in any anime. She has the best character development? No, she just went from hating the mc to liking him in 3 seconds. That's not a character development, it's just a cliche tsundere move. The fact that y'all think tsundere characters are best girls is itself a highly subjective opinion. She drugs the mc twice and also tore the pages for which our mc worked till late night. And she didn't even apologize to him. People hate Ichika for what she did to best girl (because miku is cute) but people don't hate on our Queen because nobody cares about our mc.

But you know what? I hate Itsuki even more. She is always stalking our mc and also stayed at his house (thus coming in between best girl's relationship with mc) She even slapped our queen just because she thought the mc did a little hard work for her sisters. She prioritizes her career over our handsome mc, like seriously? She's diligent, honest (doesnt like deceiving people), hardworking, maintains a health relationship with her step father and her glutton side is actually the most wholesome thing ever. She's also the most stubborn which makes sense since she's the youngest but is also a very understanding girl and doesn't create "drama" like best girl or our queen. But that's all. Ikr? She's so PLAIN in comparison to Miku and Nino. Can't believe people actually think she's the best girl.

Conclusion: ̶M̶i̶k̶u ̶a̶n̶d ̶N̶i̶n̶o Itsuki best girl!

Helshiki said:
Ok guys no toxicity, only pure discussion.

I am going to refer to Miku as "best girl" and Nino as "queen".
While initially best girl hated the mc she started liking him out of the blue. Best girl is shy and reserved and she got the highest number of fans. Best girl literally has no personality and is a totally bland character. Being shy isn't actually a personality since anybody can be shy depending on the situation. Dandere characters can be found in almost every other anime. Aside from her looks nothing really stands out. From what I have seen weebs tend to like any cute girl who romantically loves the mc.

Our queen (nino) is a tsundere. Tsundere, Another common troupe that can be found in any anime. She has the best character development? No, she just went from hating the mc to liking him in 3 seconds. That's not a character development, it's just a cliche tsundere move. The fact that y'all think tsundere characters are best girls is itself a highly subjective opinion. She drugs the mc twice and also tore the pages for which our mc worked till late night. And she didn't even apologize to him. People hate Ichika for what she did to best girl (because miku is cute) but people don't hate on our Queen because nobody cares about our mc.

But you know what? I hate Itsuki even more. She is always stalking our mc and also stayed at his house (thus coming in between best girl's relationship with mc) She even slapped our queen just because she thought the mc did a little hard work for her sisters. She prioritizes her career over our handsome mc, like seriously? She's diligent, honest (doesnt like deceiving people), hardworking, maintains a health relationship with her step father and her glutton side is actually the most wholesome thing ever. She's also the most stubborn which makes sense since she's the youngest but is also a very understanding girl and doesn't create "drama" like best girl or our queen. But that's all. Ikr? She's so PLAIN in comparison to Miku and Nino. Can't believe people actually think she's the best girl.

Conclusion: ̶M̶i̶k̶u ̶a̶n̶d ̶N̶i̶n̶o Itsuki best girl!

ArizNaeem200 said:
Definitely in my opinion itsuki is the best girl among the quintuplets

Sydsons said:
What is there to sleep on itsuki with? Like she has no other character traits than liking food.

Helshiki said:

Why are you asking this question? Did you not read my entire post? I have defined Itsuki's character in the 'shortest' way possible and it's fine if you disagree with me as long as you have valid arguments. It seems like you're just another Nino fan who thinks having a crush is a character trait.

Sydsons said:

"no toxicity, only pure discussion"
I gave my opinion, no need to be toxic about it.
My argument was there, I just see of her as bland with the bare minimum of character traits that don't really apply to anything in the anime and manga.

Helshiki said:


She's literally the reason why the mc decided not to quit his job. She's the

first one who came to know about his financial condition and actually had

a real character development that lead to her acknowledging him by the

end of s1. If you're thinking i was being toxic then you're probably wrong. I did say that your disagreement is fine as long as your reasoning his valid and I didn't directly label you as a butthurt nino fan.

Your argument was supposed to prove my points wrong but it doesn't. Also can you tell me what are Mik and Nino's character traits?

Sydsons said:

Oh I don't like miku. She's a stereotypical shy girl. For nino, she's generally a tsundere but I feel like she's a lot more real with herself and others rather than hiding behind a reputation. I appreciate that because I understood her position in society quite well, being someone in a similar position to her. I felt like there was a sense of reality when she wasn't drugging MC. I feel like my biases towards nino are more of a respect of the character than an actual crush on a fictional character (animephobic 😳😳)

With itsuki, she had many "important" experiences but I think that most of it didn't need to happen to make the story go by. In my opinion, she was there to support the audience on understanding the other characters without actually seeming like it was mouthfed to us through narration (I guess like a tour guide of the story? Quite difficult to explain). Examples being:
-showing the audience how MC lives in awful living conditions and how the quints will meet his family.
-giving away the bombshell of who "rena" actually is.
-how MC actually met the quints
-that their mother died years back
-that the quints absolutely suck at academics etc.

I do agree that she helped MC get back on track and that she did have a development arc near the start of the series, but otherwise I feel like everything she does is far too vague and typically will hint towards something new or a key theme will be reinforced. Most of her actions are either made for a skit or for a heartfelt scene which will end out being forgotten at the end anyway. Hence, why I don't think the writer knew what her character was past her development arc and why I don't really like her. Only solid points about her is that she cares about MC, her family and food.