Forum Settings
Forums
New
Aug 28, 2019 12:18 PM
#1
Offline
Feb 2019
4
Did Gilgamesh really died? I didn't get that Sakura and Gilgamesh scene.

Mod edit: Added spoiler tag to the title.
DeadlyRavenAug 28, 2019 10:50 PM
Aug 28, 2019 12:29 PM
#2

Offline
Feb 2017
2712
Yep. Gilgamesh really died. He got consumed by the shadow
Aug 28, 2019 2:22 PM
#3

Offline
Apr 2015
4824
He ded. He mega ded
Aug 28, 2019 2:24 PM
#4

Offline
Dec 2009
219
Since she consumed all of the other Servants she's like overpowered as fuck, so yeah, he got REKT xD
Aug 28, 2019 10:44 PM
#5
Offline
Oct 2014
2837
he lost the duel against sakura and was sent to the shadow realm
Aug 29, 2019 8:06 PM
#6
Offline
Feb 2016
2
What happened to Gilgamesh?
Nom.
Sep 1, 2019 11:59 AM
#7

Offline
Nov 2014
9843
He became a delish.

Sep 23, 2019 9:26 PM
#8
Offline
Sep 2019
1
Just when I thought my boi Gil's gonna do some badass shit he got rekt in a second
L4NC3LoTSep 28, 2019 3:16 AM
Oct 17, 2019 7:40 AM
#9
Offline
Jan 2019
138
L4NC3LoT said:
Just when I thought my boi Gil's gonna do some badass shit he got rekt in a second

Im pretty sure its actually just bcuz of his ego that he lost that battle(if u can call that a battle)
Oct 17, 2019 8:19 AM

Offline
Mar 2019
188
Quinx_x said:
L4NC3LoT said:
Just when I thought my boi Gil's gonna do some badass shit he got rekt in a second

Im pretty sure its actually just bcuz of his ego that he lost that battle(if u can call that a battle)


I'd say arrogance more then ego but the main reason is servants have a real bad time against the shadow due to it's nature.
Jun 19, 2020 9:59 PM
Offline
Nov 2015
353
I hate this scene, wasnt he supposed to be a op character... His death was so anticlimatic
Jun 19, 2020 10:01 PM

Offline
Jan 2009
103136
lol ye he is kill like the mongrel (mix race of human and god) that he is too
Jun 19, 2020 10:12 PM

Offline
Jul 2013
4690
freizel said:
I hate this scene, wasnt he supposed to be a op character... His death was so anticlimatic


That's not how it works girl. There is no shounen powerscaling here. No matter how overpowered you are, if someone has the means to kill you then you will be killed.

The shadow is a natural enemy of all servants. Even Gilgamesh is afraid of it. Why do you think Archer himself, the one who literally ran the story of UBW, dropped all his objectives in favor of combating the shadow.
Jun 20, 2020 12:19 AM
Offline
Nov 2015
353
Dull_Lull said:
freizel said:
I hate this scene, wasnt he supposed to be a op character... His death was so anticlimatic


That's not how it works girl. There is no shounen powerscaling here. No matter how overpowered you are, if someone has the means to kill you then you will be killed.

The shadow is a natural enemy of all servants. Even Gilgamesh is afraid of it. Why do you think Archer himself, the one who literally ran the story of UBW, dropped all his objectives in favor of combating the shadow.


I dont understand why you assume i was looking for a shonen overpower Battle? ... I just wanted a little longer Battle for epicness, boy !

I DIDNT WANT Gilgamesh to win the clearly overpower Bad Bad shadow *roll eyes* ... I dais was anticlimatic, was too fast, was extremely easy ! So if a powerfull servant like him doesnt stand a freaking minute Battle then Who Will ? Also archer Battle was longer.

Dont put words on my statement, i wanted a longer Battle not him to Win
Jun 20, 2020 12:28 AM

Offline
Mar 2019
188
freizel said:
Dull_Lull said:


That's not how it works girl. There is no shounen powerscaling here. No matter how overpowered you are, if someone has the means to kill you then you will be killed.

The shadow is a natural enemy of all servants. Even Gilgamesh is afraid of it. Why do you think Archer himself, the one who literally ran the story of UBW, dropped all his objectives in favor of combating the shadow.


I dont understand why you assume i was looking for a shonen overpower Battle? ... I just wanted a little longer Battle for epicness, boy !

I DIDNT WANT Gilgamesh to win the clearly overpower Bad Bad shadow *roll eyes* ... I dais was anticlimatic, was too fast, was extremely easy ! So if a powerfull servant like him doesnt stand a freaking minute Battle then Who Will ? Also archer Battle was longer.

Dont put words on my statement, i wanted a longer Battle not him to Win

That's the contradiction though. If a longer battle ensues then Gil wins. The best way to kill him is to surprise him when he's being his usual arrogant ass self.

Those are also 2 completely different fights comparing them makes no sense.
Jun 20, 2020 12:32 AM

Offline
Jul 2013
4690
freizel said:
Dull_Lull said:


That's not how it works girl. There is no shounen powerscaling here. No matter how overpowered you are, if someone has the means to kill you then you will be killed.

The shadow is a natural enemy of all servants. Even Gilgamesh is afraid of it. Why do you think Archer himself, the one who literally ran the story of UBW, dropped all his objectives in favor of combating the shadow.


I dont understand why you assume i was looking for a shonen overpower Battle? ... I just wanted a little longer Battle for epicness, boy !

I DIDNT WANT Gilgamesh to win the clearly overpower Bad Bad shadow *roll eyes* ... I dais was anticlimatic, was too fast, was extremely easy ! So if a powerfull servant like him doesnt stand a freaking minute Battle then Who Will ? Also archer Battle was longer.

Dont put words on my statement, i wanted a longer Battle not him to Win


Uhm... that's literally what you're asking for lol. A full on 1 episode shounen battle. Sadly that's not how things work here.

Yeah... nah luv. Longer battle and for what? That "fight" wasn't even supposed to climactic. Point of that little scuffle was Gilgamesh wanting to end things quickly before Sakura awakens into the shadow and he did except he's the one that got ended quickly by his natural enemy.

That's why you sit there and wait for the 3rd movie to come out instead of making contrived scenarios in your head.

Archer's battle was against True Assassin not the shadow and even when the shadow actually appeared in the forest, he still got done real quick by it despite being not a proper heroic spirit lol.

And like I said, there's literally no point in prolonging that battle.
Jun 20, 2020 12:34 AM
Offline
Nov 2015
353
Dieshouri said:
freizel said:


I dont understand why you assume i was looking for a shonen overpower Battle? ... I just wanted a little longer Battle for epicness, boy !

I DIDNT WANT Gilgamesh to win the clearly overpower Bad Bad shadow *roll eyes* ... I dais was anticlimatic, was too fast, was extremely easy ! So if a powerfull servant like him doesnt stand a freaking minute Battle then Who Will ? Also archer Battle was longer.

Dont put words on my statement, i wanted a longer Battle not him to Win

That's the contradiction though. If a longer battle ensues then Gil wins. The best way to kill him is to surprise him when he's being his usual arrogant ass self.

Those are also 2 completely different fights comparing them makes no sense.



Hahahhahah what with you and your assumption ? So you guys know better than me what i wanted and why i found It Rush and anticlimatic? Cuz i want Gilgamesh to win ? Lol so i dont want a 3rd movie? I wanted everything to end there xD
Jun 20, 2020 12:35 AM

Offline
Mar 2019
188
freizel said:
Dieshouri said:

That's the contradiction though. If a longer battle ensues then Gil wins. The best way to kill him is to surprise him when he's being his usual arrogant ass self.

Those are also 2 completely different fights comparing them makes no sense.



Hahahhahah what with you and your assumption ? So you guys know better than me what i wanted and why i found It Rush and anticlimatic? Cuz i want Gilgamesh to win ? Lol so i dont want a 3rd movie? I wanted everything to end there xD

Uhhhh I pointed out why that makes no sense and would hurt the story more then help it. If you just wanna break everything for your fav to win then have fun.
Jun 20, 2020 12:38 AM
Offline
Nov 2015
353
Dull_Lull said:
freizel said:


I dont understand why you assume i was looking for a shonen overpower Battle? ... I just wanted a little longer Battle for epicness, boy !

I DIDNT WANT Gilgamesh to win the clearly overpower Bad Bad shadow *roll eyes* ... I dais was anticlimatic, was too fast, was extremely easy ! So if a powerfull servant like him doesnt stand a freaking minute Battle then Who Will ? Also archer Battle was longer.

Dont put words on my statement, i wanted a longer Battle not him to Win


Uhm... that's literally what you're asking for lol. A full on 1 episode shounen battle. Sadly that's not how things work here.

Yeah... nah luv. Longer battle and for what? That "fight" wasn't even supposed to climactic. Point of that little scuffle was Gilgamesh wanting to end things quickly and he did except he's the one that got ended quickly by his natural enemy.

That's why you sit there and wait for the 3rd movie to come out instead of making contrived scenarios in your head.

Archer's battle was against True Assassin not the shadow and even when the shadow actually appeared in the forest, he still got done real quick by it lol.

And there's no point in a longer battle.


Once again you know everything, WoW you even know what i wanted and assume what i want to say too, good bro !

You just want to have the reason over my oppinion of wanting a Battle Royal be longer since for you was perfect the way It was ... Not a second longer, no more battles , Well then marvelous, im Happy you love It the way It was, i did not

Found It anticlimatic, deal with It
Jul 30, 2020 2:25 PM

Offline
Apr 2018
2104
freizel said:

I dont understand why you assume i was looking for a shonen overpower Battle? ... I just wanted a little longer Battle for epicness, boy !

I DIDNT WANT Gilgamesh to win the clearly overpower Bad Bad shadow *roll eyes* ... I dais was anticlimatic, was too fast, was extremely easy ! So if a powerfull servant like him doesnt stand a freaking minute Battle then Who Will ? Also archer Battle was longer.

Dont put words on my statement, i wanted a longer Battle not him to Win


My dude, Gil already got plenty of love and time in the spotlight throughout the main series up until this point. He was practically the last Servant standing in Zero, he was the secondary antagonist in the 1st route in which he got a final showdown with Saber, in UBW he became the Big Bad by taking control of the Grail AND he got an awesome death at the end. What more could you want?

HF as a route is an entirely different beast altogether and the studio already had to rush the pacing in order to fit the whole story into these movies. What's the point of prolonging a battle in which Gil had no chance in hell of winning to begin with?
Aug 1, 2020 1:23 PM

Offline
Mar 2020
90
freizel said:
Dull_Lull said:


Uhm... that's literally what you're asking for lol. A full on 1 episode shounen battle. Sadly that's not how things work here.

Yeah... nah luv. Longer battle and for what? That "fight" wasn't even supposed to climactic. Point of that little scuffle was Gilgamesh wanting to end things quickly and he did except he's the one that got ended quickly by his natural enemy.

That's why you sit there and wait for the 3rd movie to come out instead of making contrived scenarios in your head.

Archer's battle was against True Assassin not the shadow and even when the shadow actually appeared in the forest, he still got done real quick by it lol.

And there's no point in a longer battle.


Once again you know everything, WoW you even know what i wanted and assume what i want to say too, good bro !

You just want to have the reason over my oppinion of wanting a Battle Royal be longer since for you was perfect the way It was ... Not a second longer, no more battles , Well then marvelous, im Happy you love It the way It was, i did not

Found It anticlimatic, deal with It


I think that's the reason you seem frustrated over Gilgamesh's death: your interpretation of the Heaven's Feel route.

It's not supposed to be an epic battle royale themed anime that puts the fights at the forefront. That might've been more of the case for the Fate or UBW route, but the HF route focuses on darker and mature themes, and how Shirou's ideology clashes with reality and how he deals with it. If you're into Fate just for the fights, go rewatch UBW or get into another action show that put their fights in the center.

Hell, even in VN route for heaven's feel, where they had all the time in the world to elaborate on anything they want, the confrontation between Gil and the shadow lasted like 5 minutes, and most of it was just excessive description. It was purposeful that the fighting elements did not last long.

So yeah, if you're looking for battles and epicness, heaven's feel might not be for you, since its major appeal is the darkness and how heavy it is mentally, despite being from the Fate franchise whose appeal might be more centered on the battles.
Aug 12, 2020 10:18 PM
Offline
Nov 2015
353
plz_nofindme said:
freizel said:


Once again you know everything, WoW you even know what i wanted and assume what i want to say too, good bro !

You just want to have the reason over my oppinion of wanting a Battle Royal be longer since for you was perfect the way It was ... Not a second longer, no more battles , Well then marvelous, im Happy you love It the way It was, i did not

Found It anticlimatic, deal with It


I think that's the reason you seem frustrated over Gilgamesh's death: your interpretation of the Heaven's Feel route.

It's not supposed to be an epic battle royale themed anime that puts the fights at the forefront. That might've been more of the case for the Fate or UBW route, but the HF route focuses on darker and mature themes, and how Shirou's ideology clashes with reality and how he deals with it. If you're into Fate just for the fights, go rewatch UBW or get into another action show that put their fights in the center.

Hell, even in VN route for heaven's feel, where they had all the time in the world to elaborate on anything they want, the confrontation between Gil and the shadow lasted like 5 minutes, and most of it was just excessive description. It was purposeful that the fighting elements did not last long.

So yeah, if you're looking for battles and epicness, heaven's feel might not be for you, since its major appeal is the darkness and how heavy it is mentally, despite being from the Fate franchise whose appeal might be more centered on the battles.



Thanks for all the info but i Will still end It, just one more movie isnt ? So i Will end It, no point of watching 2/3 movies to drop It SINCE i dont hate It, just that fight
11 hours ago

Offline
Aug 2017
2407
Shadow ate him.

I prefer shadow wrecking everyone in this route. We saw enough battles in Saber and Rin routes.

More topics from this board

Poll: » Why do so less people like Sakura in comparison to Saber and Tohsaka? Which do you like? ( 1 2 )

Shizokami2 - Apr 8, 2020

51 by Zarutaku »»
10 hours ago

Poll: » Fate/stay night Movie: Heaven's Feel - II. Lost Butterfly Episode 1 Discussion ( 1 2 3 4 5 ... Last Page )

Kisaragi - Jan 15, 2019

493 by CarbonMD »»
11 hours ago

» So what's the point of Shinji existing at all?

whatever5464 - Dec 27, 2024

42 by CarbonMD »»
11 hours ago

» Anyone find Sakura Matou annoying or It just me? [Spoilers] ( 1 2 3 4 )

DemonDarknight - May 21, 2019

190 by CarbonMD »»
11 hours ago

» Now that Aimer is officially the Fate anime singer...

Dull_Lull - Dec 17, 2019

6 by blondedzero »»
Jan 11, 4:10 AM
It’s time to ditch the text file.
Keep track of your anime easily by creating your own list.
Sign Up Login