My Youth Romantic Comedy Is Wrong, As I Expected (light novel)
Who is your best girl?
| With Zoku well and truly kicked off, lets take a second to tell everyone our favourite girls. My favourite is obviously the only true option, Yui. Yui > All. That is all. Edit: Here is my list 1. Yui 2. Komachi 3. Isshiki 4. Yukino 5. Haruno 6. Saki 7. Saika 8. Shizuka 9. Hina 10. Miura |
happenApr 30, 2015 7:30 PM
[size=67]My profile | "A real man is someone who prepares himself for death before he eats breakfast every morning."  |
| Well I'm all for Yui, but in terms of popularity we all know that Yukino is more popular than Yui in terms of official rankings and MAL voters (Yukino have 1600+ favorites and Yui have 376 favorites) |
 |
 |
 |
| I always liked Yui out of the two girls in the Service Club. While it may the shine the light on Yui at the moment, I don't think the end result is going to turn out as I hope. But I also like Ebina. She's surprisingly perceptive and say something insightful once in a while for someone who speaks lot less often than Miura. |
| No way to recall What it was that you had said to me Like I care at all But it was so loud And you sure could yell You took a stand on every little thing And it was so loud |
Syndromic said: If the end result is Yukino, I will literally cry for days.I always liked Yui out of the two girls in the Service Club. While it may the shine the light on Yui at the moment, I don't think the end result is going to turn out as I hope. |
[size=67]My profile | "A real man is someone who prepares himself for death before he eats breakfast every morning." |
| Saika is best girl for sure, Shizuka is a close second though. |
| Voted for Yukino then if that makes you sad. |
 |
unkind said: Syndromic said: If the end result is Yukino, I will literally cry for days.I always liked Yui out of the two girls in the Service Club. While it may the shine the light on Yui at the moment, I don't think the end result is going to turn out as I hope. Problem is Yukino is pretty much the most popular character in Oregairu, so prepare yourself for the worst... |
|
DarklordVor said: Ruined by Japan's shit taste again. ;-;unkind said: If the end result is Yukino, I will literally cry for days. Problem is Yukino is pretty much the most popular character in Oregairu, so prepare yourself for the worst... |
[size=67]My profile | "A real man is someone who prepares himself for death before he eats breakfast every morning." |
| I'm surprised that there are two votes for Miura. I always thought she was written to be an unlikeable character. |
[size=67]My profile | "A real man is someone who prepares himself for death before he eats breakfast every morning." |
unkind said: I'm surprised that there are two votes for Miura. I always thought she was written to be an unlikeable character. Fairly speaking, Miura has some redeeming qualities. I.e despite being bitchy, she cares deeply for her clique members. |
 |
Feaor said: Saika is best girl for sure, Shizuka is a close second though. |
 |
| Yui: best girl, hands down. |
 If Evangelion were Rokka no Yuusha the seventh would be Shinji. |
| Itching to see how this thread will turn out after Isshiki and Yukino have their spotlights. It isn't even half way through, let all the girls shine |
TerapinApr 30, 2015 8:03 PM
| Yui is a good character, no doubt about that but she isn't that interesting of a character. She is the usual girl in your group who wants to preserve the great moments and relationships she share with others. I don't have anything against that but there's nothing more to her. The problem going on between Hachi and Yukino is that they thought they were similar but this thinking is shattered now( Yukino not revealing her knowing Hachi before their meeting in the club and Hachi sacrificing himself to help people keep their superficial relationship ). She thought they both hated superficiality and honestly they do but they have realised their way of thinking is different. Yukino has some very grave problems with her family and once people know them i think many of the haters will be able to get her character. She feels more realistic (once her background is revealed)as compared to Yui. Also her moments with Hachi have more depth and interesting as compared to his moments with Yui. Again maybe i am saying this because i have read all the light novels up to recent volume 10. Also Hachi is smart enough to know that Yui has fallen for him but it's also quiet obvious that he is not interested in her that way. Also Wataru Watari has sprinkled a a lot hints lately so we won't have to wait a lot to know the OTP(volume 11 coming on June 18). So i'll vote for Yukino. |
kitkatxz said: Yukino best girl, no Contest once again. Will you Yuifags ever understand? >.< I respect your opinion on Yukino, but saying a fan as a fag, is beyond immature and childish way to implore your opinion. |
|
ShrewOne said: taz_99 said: Yui is a good character, no doubt about that but she isn't that interesting of a character. She is the usual girl in your group who wants to preserve the great moments and relationships she share with others. I don't have anything against that but there's nothing more to her. The problem going on between Hachi and Yukino is that they thought they were similar but this thinking is shattered now( Yukino not revealing her knowing Hachi before their meeting in the club and Hachi sacrificing himself to help people keep their superficial relationship ). She thought they both hated superficiality and honestly they do but they have realised their way of thinking is different. Yukino has some very grave problems with her family and once people know them i think many of the haters will be able to get her character. She feels more realistic (once her background is revealed)as compared to Yui. Also her moments with Hachi have more depth and interesting as compared to his moments with Yui. Again maybe i am saying this because i have read all the light novels up to recent volume 10. Also Hachi is smart enough to know that Yui has fallen for him but it's also quiet obvious that he is not interested in her that way. Also Wataru Watari has sprinkled a a lot hints lately so we won't have to wait a lot to know the OTP(volume 11 coming on June 18). So i'll vote for Yukino. I don't know, I've also read all the way up to volume 10 and the few chapters that's translated of 10.5, and I still like Yui most. If I could vote for another, I'd easily choose Iroha. Again in the end it comes down to individual opinion. |
| I honestly prefer if he goes with no one |
| Sword in hand, a warrior clutches stone to breast. In sword etched he his fading memories In stone, his tempered skill By sword attested, by stone revealed. Their tale can now be told |
| Fuck yeah, best girl is winning |
| Once again, MALers and their fucking SHIT TASTE! For fucks sake BOTH main character females are bad. Especially Yukino...what a giant pretentious BITCH! Yui is an insufferable airhead who wants to be a vacuous popular girl so she still forces herself to hang out with that blonde princess. I mean seriously, are we watching the same anime? |
| Yui I guess... but honestly I don't like anyone in this anime (not that I even like the show to begin with) |
  |
JustALEX said: Why are you even watching it then?Once again, MALers and their fucking SHIT TASTE! For fucks sake BOTH main character females are bad. Especially Yukino...what a giant pretentious BITCH! Yui is an insufferable airhead who wants to be a vacuous popular girl so she still forces herself to hang out with that blonde princess. I mean seriously, are we watching the same anime? |
[size=67]My profile | "A real man is someone who prepares himself for death before he eats breakfast every morning." |
Dragon_Slayer_X said: kitkatxz said: Yukino best girl, no Contest once again. Will you Yuifags ever understand? >.< Don't worry Vol 9, Bonus Track and 10 will destroy their illusions. What are you talking about? It is not over yet, but you're very sure Yukino will end up with 8man? What confidence... XD |
|
| Yukinon, Komachi, Iroha. Best Girls of this series. |
| Big Order (TV):great anime or greatest anime? |
Dragon_Slayer_X said: testamentKAISER said: What are you talking about? It is not over yet, but you're very sure Yukino will end up with 8man? What confidence... XD Did i say anything about the ending? I only said it will destroy their delusions..........it could be about the best girl or the end girl or both. Well as much as I hate to admit it, we all know that Yukino is the most popular girl character in the series. If the author wants to end Hachiman with someone, its gotta be Yukino, and that will leave Yui one sided.... Or they could go with the Oreimo ending with Komachi for the lolz! |
|
kitkatxz said: DarklordVor said: I respect your opinion on Yukino, but saying a fan as a fag, is beyond immature and childish way to implore your opinion. It's a joke on reddit we use for this waifu war :3. No harm intended Hehe sorry :3 I don't really use reddit... no harm indeed *peace* |
|
| Yui is my favourite :) |
 |
| Shizuka is objectively (xD) best girl, no other is either as likeable or as hot as she is. second place is tied for both yukino and yui i dont care about the rest at all, not enough of them so far for me to judge |
 |
unkind said: Why are you even watching it then? Cuz of Hachiman.....he's a very interesting character, and not a typical MC in these types of anime, I want to see what happens to him and how he develops. And to be fair, I do think Yui is a BAD character, but I can see why people like her...Yukino on the other hand is not only a bad character, she's not very likable. I think people like her only because she's the main female character and her looks....which to be fair, is also understandable, but admittedly it frustrates me. |
JustALEX said: unkind said: Why are you even watching it then? Cuz of Hachiman.....he's a very interesting character, and not a typical MC in these types of anime, I want to see what happens to him and how he develops. And to be fair, I do think Yui is a BAD character, but I can see why people like her...Yukino on the other hand is not only a bad character, she's not very likable. I think people like her only because she's the main female character and her looks....which to be fair, is also understandable, but admittedly it frustrates me. Why are they bad characters? Give us reasons. Don't just say "what is" and expect us to take your word at face value. |
| Totsuka <3 |
JustALEX said: unkind said: Why are you even watching it then? Cuz of Hachiman.....he's a very interesting character, and not a typical MC in these types of anime, I want to see what happens to him and how he develops. And to be fair, I do think Yui is a BAD character, but I can see why people like her...Yukino on the other hand is not only a bad character, she's not very likable. I think people like her only because she's the main female character and her looks....which to be fair, is also understandable, but admittedly it frustrates me. She's both good and likeable. |
|
JustALEX said: Once again, MALers and their fucking SHIT TASTE! For fucks sake BOTH main character females are bad. Especially Yukino...what a giant pretentious BITCH! Yui is an insufferable airhead who wants to be a vacuous popular girl so she still forces herself to hang out with that blonde princess. I mean seriously, are we watching the same anime? Gotta agree both of them are bad but Yui less for me. Yukino thinks way too highly of herself sometimes that she thinks its a given for fcks sake get over yourself. Yui still befriends the blond haired bitch (a lot of you probably knows why she's a bitch), the only good thing about Yui is how she approaches Hiki. Before people reacts too much this is all from my point of view so I dont need people forcing their opinions on me or saying I should change my view by pointing out things. |
  |
SansrivaaL said: JustALEX said: Once again, MALers and their fucking SHIT TASTE! For fucks sake BOTH main character females are bad. Especially Yukino...what a giant pretentious BITCH! Yui is an insufferable airhead who wants to be a vacuous popular girl so she still forces herself to hang out with that blonde princess. I mean seriously, are we watching the same anime? Gotta agree both of them are bad but Yui less for me. Yukino thinks way too highly of herself sometimes that she thinks its a given for fcks sake get over yourself. Yui still befriends the blond haired bitch (a lot of you probably knows why she's a bitch), the only good thing about Yui is how she approaches Hiki. Yeah I agree with this, but probably Yukino's stuck up act is because of her family issue going around with her mother and sister. Which made her annoying and getting distant from Hachiman. On the other hand Yui still befriend that blond girl because I think Yui is the "nice girl" Hachiman talked about, where she would be nice to everyone she knows, which led Hachiman to shrug off every affection from Yui as if those are just the "nice girl" act. |
|
JustALEX said: I don't understand your logic. unkind said: Why are you even watching it then? Cuz of Hachiman.....he's a very interesting character, and not a typical MC in these types of anime, I want to see what happens to him and how he develops. And to be fair, I do think Yui is a BAD character, but I can see why people like her...Yukino on the other hand is not only a bad character, she's not very likable. I think people like her only because she's the main female character and her looks....which to be fair, is also understandable, but admittedly it frustrates me. Personality-wise, Hachiman and Yukino are similar. They are both kind of pretentious. Not to mention that Hachiman has a horrible personality. I mean, even though he tells people the truth, he doesn't pay much heed to how it feels for them. Even if he is a genuinely caring person. I'm just saying, logically, if you hated Yukino and Yui, you would hate Hachiman too. They all have their human flaws. That's what makes them good characters. The entire show is based off how messed up they are and the troubles they face because of it. |
[size=67]My profile | "A real man is someone who prepares himself for death before he eats breakfast every morning." |
unkind said: JustALEX said: I don't understand your logic. Cuz of Hachiman.....he's a very interesting character, and not a typical MC in these types of anime, I want to see what happens to him and how he develops. And to be fair, I do think Yui is a BAD character, but I can see why people like her...Yukino on the other hand is not only a bad character, she's not very likable. I think people like her only because she's the main female character and her looks....which to be fair, is also understandable, but admittedly it frustrates me. Personality-wise, Hachiman and Yukino are similar. They are both kind of pretentious. Not to mention that Hachiman has a horrible personality. I mean, even though he tells people the truth, he doesn't pay much heed to how it feels for them. Even if he is a genuinely caring person. I'm just saying, logically, if you hated Yukino and Yui, you would hate Hachiman too. They all have their human flaws. That's what makes them good characters. The entire show is based off how messed up they are and the troubles they face because of it. Also, being an airhead doesn't necessarily make her a bad character or a bad person. Sure, it'd be great if we were all geniuses but a person's self-worth is not defined solely by their intelligence. So, "Yui is stupid" is shitty criticism. It's quite evident to every single one of us that she is, but that doesn't make it bad writing. Alex, you're going to have to try harder. |
NudeBear said: unkind said: I don't understand your logic. Personality-wise, Hachiman and Yukino are similar. They are both kind of pretentious. Not to mention that Hachiman has a horrible personality. I mean, even though he tells people the truth, he doesn't pay much heed to how it feels for them. Even if he is a genuinely caring person. I'm just saying, logically, if you hated Yukino and Yui, you would hate Hachiman too. They all have their human flaws. That's what makes them good characters. The entire show is based off how messed up they are and the troubles they face because of it. Also, being an airhead doesn't necessarily make her a bad character or a bad person. Sure, it'd be great if we were all geniuses but a person's self-worth is not defined solely by their intelligence. So, "Yui is stupid" is shitty criticism. It's quite evident to every single one of us that she is, but that doesn't make it bad writing. Alex, you're going to have to try harder. Actually, yui keeps the balance in the club, she maintains equilibrium |
| Actually glad that nepal is facing disaster |
| Hoping for Yukino, but I am wondering if they will ever get together. |
 |
Static-Of-65 said: BOth of the main two ones are rather boring. Yukino has close to no character development at all, and Yui is flat out annoying and unbearable. That being said, If I have to chose between annoying and boring, I'd rather chose second. there is always.....sensei |
| Actually glad that nepal is facing disaster |
More topics from this board
Poll: » Yahari Ore no Seishun Love Comedy wa Machigatteiru. Zoku Episode 8 Discussion ( 1 2 3 4 5 ... Last Page )Stark700 - May 21, 2015 |
673 |
by MylanP
»»
Yesterday, 8:55 PM |
|
Poll: » Yahari Ore no Seishun Love Comedy wa Machigatteiru. Zoku Episode 13 Discussion ( 1 2 3 4 5 ... Last Page )Stark700 - Jun 25, 2015 |
1006 |
by MidnightStar5
»»
Dec 27, 2024 6:53 AM |
|
Poll: » Yahari Ore no Seishun Love Comedy wa Machigatteiru. Zoku Episode 10 Discussion ( 1 2 3 4 5 ... Last Page )Stark700 - Jun 4, 2015 |
545 |
by JavanyXD
»»
Dec 25, 2024 10:27 PM |
|
Poll: » Yahari Ore no Seishun Love Comedy wa Machigatteiru. Zoku Episode 1 Discussion ( 1 2 3 4 5 ... Last Page )Stark700 - Apr 2, 2015 |
527 |
by powermaiden02
»»
Dec 1, 2024 2:38 PM |
|
Poll: » Yahari Ore no Seishun Love Comedy wa Machigatteiru. Zoku Episode 11 Discussion ( 1 2 3 4 5 ... Last Page )Stark700 - Jun 11, 2015 |
481 |
by hanyuhi16
»»
Nov 30, 2024 12:56 PM |