DO NOT discuss the source material beyond this episode. If you want to discuss future events or theories, please use separate threads.
DO NOT ask where to watch/download this episode or give links to copyrighted, non-fair use material.
DO NOT troll/bait/harass/abuse other users for liking or disliking the series/characters.
DO read the Anime Discussion Rules and Site & Forum Guidelines.
DO NOT ask where to watch/download this episode or give links to copyrighted, non-fair use material.
DO NOT troll/bait/harass/abuse other users for liking or disliking the series/characters.
DO read the Anime Discussion Rules and Site & Forum Guidelines.
| The fighting scene was so well done love this after story! |
| Signature removed. Please follow the signature rules, as defined in the Site & Forum Guidelines. |
| it was an ok episode. i thought it was really cliche, and little too dramatized. its hard for me to feel sad for a character who makes me laugh all the time Also WTF with that guy who grabbed mei? what was he going to do with her? It took okazaki a while to respond to that; if i were in okazaki's place, id charge at that guy immediately cant wait for the next episode(♥ misae ♥) |
Kyon97Oct 25, 2008 10:34 PM
angel999 said: I quote:SORRY BUT I DISAGREE! Sure the feelings are there BUT VIOLENCE NEVER SOLVES NOTHING! There better solutions! There is NO NEED TO POUND ON EACH OTHER. Sure this is anime BUT SAYING IT IS OK TO BEAT UP PEOPLE (friends or not) just to get to the bottom of things IS WRONG! It is the same as using violence as means to express oneself in order TO END THE MISUNDERSTANDING! Sure Sunohara deserved it and all but THERE MUST HAVE BEEN ANOTHER WAY! Friendships among men are often based on shared activities, instead of emotional sharing, which is more typical of women's friendships. It's called male bonding. This is not true of all men, no different than it is of all women, but in general, men are unable to express themselves through words, and most often express themselves through actions or deeds. This was not a group of people pounding one guy within an inch of his life. This was two guys, who are friends, essentially wrestling out their anger at each other -- no different than two girls would scream their anger at one another."This anime is saying"? Since when did we start looking at anime for our life lessons? It's fiction; it's entertainment. It's supposed to be enjoyable, and that's exactly what this episode was in my book. Don't take every episode of every anime personally, and lighten up a bit. |
| That episode was so much fun to watch XD I really enjoyed it! I was so pissed of...this damned Soccer club. Sunohara coming to the rescue was so awesome! Totally love the characters, awesome story and remembered, how much I loed this show - and still love! Next Ep looks promising. CLANNAD! |
| Hurry up Eclipse, it's been like 4 days. |
 |
| love the friendship theme in this episode...and i actually enjoyed the brawl between tomoya and sunohara |
 |
| DAMN IT ECLIPSE!!!!!! WHY!!!!!!! AFTER 4 ****IN DAYS!!!! *Throws Super Mario Galaxy* |
| Go Watch Sumomo momo Its epic. It has not gotten much attention... Episode 1 http://www.veoh.com/videos/v83597095dreGdW#comments  |
angel999 said: Sorry brother, even in this real world there are things that can NOT be solved just by talking alone and there are things that can be solve just by throwing away your money. Every problem has its own solution and every solution are not the same and NOT every solution are always peaceful. As for Kineta said above, you are putting too much your personality into this discussion.SORRY BUT I DISAGREE! Sure the feelings are there BUT VIOLENCE NEVER SOLVES NOTHING! There better solutions! There is NO NEED TO POUND ON EACH OTHER. Sure this is anime BUT SAYING IT IS OK TO BEAT UP PEOPLE (friends or not) just to get to the bottom of things IS WRONG! It is the same as using violence as means to express oneself in order TO END THE MISUNDERSTANDING! Sure Sunohara deserved it and all but THERE MUST HAVE BEEN ANOTHER WAY! Well, it is sad that Eclipse is taking a week break due to the Halloween. |
 "A Legend is but a tale of a beautiful lie." |
| "Well, it is sad that Eclipse is taking a week break due to the Halloween." Can you find the source for that statement. I doesn't seem to be true as they are releasing all their planned episodes sort of on time, except Clannad AS (which is the main show this fall) They just released index and they released Clannad AS 1 widescreen, so did they forget to sub Clannad AS 4 or just forget to put it on torrent? |
OmniknightOct 26, 2008 1:43 PM
 |
| Eclipse you make me sad. Where's the episode? :( |
     |
| >>"Can you find the source for that statement." Well, I don't really have any source to that statement because it was something I read somewhere else. >>"They just released index and they released Clannad AS 1 widescreen, so did they forget to sub Clannad AS 4 or just forget to put it on torrent?" Do you really think they can made such a mistake? I am not in their group so I don't how they work with their sub but I can say that not every single one of their member work on every single one of their project. For example they have a certain person to TS Clannad and that person is absented then the episode won't be able to released. As for the other project, if everyone for that project is still available then the episode will be able to release. |
"A Legend is but a tale of a beautiful lie." |
| What you say is true Siva. Just wondering why there isn't a release. Eclipse doesn't seem to have a forum or message board. Static subs site doesn't say anything either. @ NoyaChan: Be happy that people are out there subbing anime for you. SS-Eclipse can take their time if they want. Just want a notification =D |
|
Kineta said: "This anime is saying"? Since when did we start looking at anime for our life lessons? It's fiction; it's entertainment. It's supposed to be enjoyable, and that's exactly what this episode was in my book. Don't take every episode of every anime personally, and lighten up a bit. I don't really think there's anything wrong with trying to look deeper in to anime, i mean, if we weren't supposed to do that, shows like Lain or Evangelion might not have been so popular. Anyways, I my opinion, anime, as well with any form of art, the goal is not just about entertainment (though that can be the case for many things), but about communication. Which by saying you disagree with certain aspects of a show, is a part of. So I think anyone has the right to take whatever they see and make a judgement upon it, as long as there is some way to back up the point. Of course, you did mention something about Angel999 being too personal and emotional, but I don't intend to touch upon that, since I wanted to just focus on critical nature of anime. So maybe you can enlighten me with your view? p.s. I agree with Angel999 statement on the violence; this land is made up of love and peace! |
 |
| Nicely rounded off the arc. The fight scene between Tomoya and Youhei made me all emotional and stuff ;.; They even manged to start weaving in Yukine arc. But they probably won't dedicate one arc to it... next up is Misae, this is gonna be great too XD |
| I liked the resolution to this arc. To me, it kind of ended suddenly, but it was a very realistic ending. I'm gonna have to agree with the person that said fighting is just a way for guys to release their emotions. I've known many guys who have done exactly what Youhei and Tomoya did. They fought and then a few days later, laughed it off. In most cases it strengthened their friendship. Those speaking of peaceful solutions are pretty naive. Not everything can be solved with love and hugs. Guys are just agressive in nature. I wouldn't necessary say they're promoting violence either. It's just how some friendships are. I mean, they met each other because of fights. Not really looking forward to the next arc. She's not very ineresting to me. Hopefully it'll go by fast. |
| Is there any other decent subs for this? Eclipse is taking way too damn long. |
|
| Amazing episode. Really liking how this is progressing now. |
 |
| O_O ECLIPSE AHHHHHHHH!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! *Throws Sonic and the Secret Rings* |
| Go Watch Sumomo momo Its epic. It has not gotten much attention... Episode 1 http://www.veoh.com/videos/v83597095dreGdW#comments |
| Just to let you guys know, Eclipse just released their subbed version of Clannad AS 04. |
|
| So effin' epic. Fight scene with soccer team was simply amazing. |
| It was nice of KyoAni to put in a modified shot of a CG from the actual game in the end |
Mario1-7 said: O_O ECLIPSE AHHHHHHHH!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! *Throws Sonic and the Secret Rings* Yeah!!! My patience almost ran out. T_T Anyway, another freaking awesome ep, glad this small arc ended. |
 |
| Man that episode was great. The best episode so far. The end was hilarious. Poor Sunohara. >:3 |
| That was something else, as expected from Clannad. Loved this episode. |
 staff.applications ▼ guidelines.faq ▼ report.abuse ▼ thx.skittles ▼ thx.kina ▼ [H+] ³ ▼ |
| Great episode as usual, and a very nice end for this story arc, even if it felt a bit over the top in terms of drama from time to time. Guess that next time we'll have another secondary arc, the Misae one, before starting the true plot at mid-season probably (can't wait to watch the KyoAni version of the After Story, really... already preparing the tissues :)). |
 In every age, in every place, the deeds of men remain the same. |
| really powerful drama, but with plenty of comic relief. brilliant stuff |
 |
| I love it I love it I love it....I felt so many different emotions during this episode, OMG I love Clannad!!!!!! 6/5 |
| Was so good, this series is everything that great entertainment should be. |
   #NBHNC |
| I don't agree with opening post. I thought this episode was incredible. The best episode of the entire fall 2008 anime season so far. Character Development, story telling, plot. What the hell. The only problem is that widescreen is only for episode 1 so far. Don't matter I'm rewatching as widescreen comes out. Best show of the season. btw one of the best fight scenes ever. Not action-wise but emotional-wise. I don't think I've ever harbored so much resentment and have had it relieved as satisfactorily. I don't think I've been on this kind of emotional trip as early as the 4th episode in a series, either. |
| I agree with ^, this episode was amazing in so many ways. Oh my goodness at some points I was smiling, laughing, gasping, crying, well more on the verge of tears...to be honest, they were happy tears! This was a great, ending to the episode. I think I wanted to see maybe, a slightly better conclusion to Mei and Sunohara though, but it wasn't bad at all, maybe I wanted more of some screen time action with them :o wah, but oh well. I enjoyed every second it. Those soccer players were driving me insane! As soon as they grabbed Mei, I literally growle, lol. I think Tomoya and Sunohara's friendship scenes, were just great overall. I love Tomoyaaaa x10<3333 oh my goodness, and and and I want moar Nagisa! But that's okay, looks like were getting into Misaes story? Interesting! |
KitteniaOct 27, 2008 6:04 PM
 |
| SAGARA MISAE ARC! SAGARA MISAE ARC! SAGARA MISAE ARC! SAGARA MISAE ARC! SAGARA MISAE ARC! SAGARA MISAE ARC! MY FAVORITE ARC! I didn't think they were going to put it in! YES! |
 |
Kittenia said: Those soccer players were driving me insane! As soon as they grabbed Mei, I literally growle, lol. I think Tomoya and Sunohara's friendship scenes, were just great overall. I love Tomoyaaaa x10<3333 oh my goodness, and and and I want moar Nagisa! But that's okay, looks like were getting into Misaes story? Interesting! OMG those soccer players. When they insulted Nagisa I almost bit my tongue. If jerks like those in that situation made fun of my girlfriend I would literally have lost it. And they were bullying Mei I was like grr...... koolabsol said: As a guy I loved the friend fight because that's how it's supposed to be done and even though I was kinda irritated the girls were crying and stopped them if they had continued it might have gotten out of control. Wicked awesome ep in my opinion. Yes! |
| T.T @ Mei. NOOOOOOOO. GOOOOOO YOUHEI & TOMOYA! |
     #Feitoism @ irc.rizon.net - the official IRC channel for Fate Testarossa.  |
| Second fight was cool, their eyes really look different when they go into dark mode and give off a yandere-ish feel without the psychotic-ness (Nagisa, Tomoyo/a, Sunohara, Kotomi). I always wait for Yukine to disappear off the screen to the side then pop back in your face with a knife lol. Sunohara finding out about Sanae was great. |
 |
angel999 said: THIS SUCKS! VIOLENCE SOLVES NOTHING! BEEN THERE AND GOT MY ASS KICKED MANY TIMES...........CAUSE I PREFER BREAKING YOUR TV INSTEAD OF YOUR LIFE...MEANING TO KILL YOU! When I fight I kill and do not leave alone ever one who gets me angry. So if your little sister was being physically picked on by a bunch of guys older than her, you'll just tell them how they're such big meanies and that's it? Lol at you claiming you'll kill people if you fight but yet you believe violence does nothing. angel999 said: Sorry but I have to say this like I promised *PUNCHES Okazaki with uppercut* OKAZAKI BAKA! YOU MADE NAGISAWA CRY! I never hold back my promises! STUPID OKAZAKI! Nagisa will remember that.......good thing Okazaki did reconcile with Sunohara somehow it made Nagisawa happy! ^_^ That is a relief! There should have been another way somehow. You say violence doesn't solve anything but yet you choose violence anyway, even if it is an obviously fake gesture towards an anime character? Way to be hypocritical. I thought this arc ended well, albeit a tad bit abruptly. I'd rather Tomoya and Sunohara have beaten each other up instead of the girls intervening. I'm totally looking forward Misae's arc. |
 |
| PERFECT EPISODE I almost cried several times. |
逃げちゃ駄目だ。 |
| mei should of called out rape... enough said for now. i'm tiered |
| 1:18 et vivus et fui mortuus et ecce sum vivens in saecula saeculorum et habeo claves mortis et inferni |
| Finally! *Picks up all Nintendo Items* That episode was perfect no Flaws Tomoya Vs Sunohara was so intense. they fought after they got there asses kicked. I loved it so much I hope Eclipse gets the Next episode out there on time this week. Oh and those soccer guys are assholes Damn it. they made Mei cry Damn it She is not my sister and I would have just should up to kick there asses. Oh and who is Misae Sagara? |
| Go Watch Sumomo momo Its epic. It has not gotten much attention... Episode 1 http://www.veoh.com/videos/v83597095dreGdW#comments |
| that was the manliest moment we'll ever get from clannad, really. i didnt care for sunohara particularly because he seemed like such a one track character, but now i like him decently enough. and then there was the scene at the end with sanae and akio, and i laughed my ass off. great episode |
 |
Mario1-7 said: Oh and who is Misae Sagara? She's the person in charge of the dorms that Sunohara lives in. |
|
| I was very impressed with this episode. while i wasn't too big on the whole soccer thing, it did lead up to an amazing scene between Tomoya and Sunohara. I hear even 2ch praised it well for sticking to the VN. And yay for a Misae side story. We don't get enough of her <3 |
 |
| The best part was when Sunohara kicked the captain, he straight fucked him up. I liked the fight between Tomoya and Sunohara, it was very emotional, I just can't help the fact that fight was very depended on lies. Well, Sunohara and Okazaki got their ass beat and that's one of the better ways to learn a self lesson. |
| Intense episode. I was seriously wanting to punch those ass hole soccer team guys through my computer screen but fortunately sunohara beat me to it and saved me some money. sad that mei is gone again. going good so far, i really wish they would focus some more on the purple haired trio though. |
 |
| Wow, great episode. |
|
| ...I'm not overly impressed with the way the episode played out. The entire premise of the arc is basically the cast making things worse, and how much of a glaring idiot Sunohara really is. Guess they will continue to show the side-arcs of After Story, meh hopefully Misae's arc is better than this one. Just didn't feel the tension building up in this arc, had an overall mood of 'meh' as I watched the episode. |
More topics from this board
» How sad is this?Ghost_Davo - Oct 15 |
48 |
by Watashi43
»»
Dec 25, 4:35 PM |
|
Poll: » Clannad ~After Story~ Episode 17 Discussion ( 1 2 3 4 5 ... Last Page )Nightmare7 - Feb 5, 2009 |
357 |
by Lylamasque
»»
Nov 18, 1:56 PM |
|
Poll: » Clannad ~After Story~ Episode 24 Discussion ( 1 2 3 4 5 ... Last Page )OurSocialStatus - Mar 26, 2009 |
330 |
by Arima-san
»»
Nov 9, 9:46 PM |
|
Poll: » Clannad ~After Story~ Episode 22 Discussion ( 1 2 3 4 5 ... Last Page )patient_senses - Mar 12, 2009 |
1176 |
by Odang_Rizaru
»»
Oct 28, 2:44 AM |
|
Poll: » Happy/Sad ⁉️neel_senpai - Jun 28 |
27 |
by Lucifrost
»»
Oct 17, 7:43 AM |