| Okaaay... I was just wondering... did anyone else NOT like that movie?? Cause I watched it and stuff... and I hated how they suddenly turned it into a mecha... and how it jumped from one piece to another so much, and in the end they just LEFT Ed and Al in the other side of the gate?? And then there was a random war... I just thought that the movie didnt really flow right.... THAT is not the right way to end an awesome series like FMA!!! T~T |
     Sig WILL change soon~ |
| How old are you? Do you have no concept of World War I? Granted its an alternate universe post WWI, but its still sticks to the basics of postwar. -_- how is it mecha? Just because Al doesnt have his 'magic' anymore? He's stuck in the real world remember? As an aftermath movie i thought it was pretty good. |
  "What happens when we die?" I know that the ones who love us will miss us. |
Ranivus said: How old are you? Do you have no concept of World War I? Granted its an alternate universe post WWI, but its still sticks to the basics of postwar. -_- how is it mecha? Just because Al doesnt have his 'magic' anymore? He's stuck in the real world remember? As an aftermath movie i thought it was pretty good. Uhh... sorry if I'm wrong but wasn't it like the beginning of World War II? With the whole rise of Hitler thing.... The mecha thing was that part near the end.... when they were fighting with the people in Ed and Al's world.... the things with the black goop on them... they never really explained what that black stuff was either. And really I'd have no complaints if it was an aftermath movie... but the movie is like the 52nd episode of FMA... so it should have been more of a continuation of what happened in the 51st episode... but I think they strayed off of that a lot... and the ending seemed a bit rushed too =/ |
Sig WILL change soon~ |
| I agree. This movie totally sucks. It was so boring that I couldn't watch it at once, coz if I had to watch it without breaks, after 20-30 minutes I would fall asleep. It's good that the anime adaptation stopped on this. Coz FMA would totally go down. But there is still that bunch of kids who will say that this was so awesome etc. and they didn't even read manga. For me, this movie and the tv series was a big dissapointment. Well, it was better than Naruto movies, but still not a memorable. |
 |
| The movie itself wasn't bad, really, but it was kinda sucky for FMA standards. Everything was rushed, incomplete, ending was a bit disappointing, the CGI was a flaw in FMAs otherwise flawless animation. And the villain was a blowhard. The historical references and the Thule society conspiracy stuff was pretty cool, though. |
| I nearly cried after the ending, I was really stupid. I think it was because Ed and Al never got to see if Roy and Riza get married...but that's just a selfish thing to cry for. I hated how Ed and Al was left on the other side of the gate. |
Signature removed. Please follow the signature rules, as defined in the General Forum Guidelines! |
ArucardPL said: I agree. This movie totally sucks. It was so boring that I couldn't watch it at once, coz if I had to watch it without breaks, after 20-30 minutes I would fall asleep. It's good that the anime adaptation stopped on this. Coz FMA would totally go down. But there is still that bunch of kids who will say that this was so awesome etc. and they didn't even read manga. For me, this movie and the tv series was a big dissapointment. Well, it was better than Naruto movies, but still not a memorable. I'm currently reading the manga and in my 50th chapters or so, and I didn't think the anime and movie were THAT bad. They were pretty good considering they went entirely off track. I'd much rather have the two brothers together, than split up. The movie could've used some work, but I'd still recommend it for anyone who's watched the anime. |
 |
| I was so freaking excited when I decided to watch the movie but unfornunately this happen o.O >.> -_-"" And what's up with Noah ''so-called'' kissing Ed?? Like WTF is that about??!! That's frustrating... no offense for those thinks the different the way as I do |
| It was okay.. They could have done a bit more with the animation and the characters, as well as the plot. The ending was good.. It just doesn't seem right that the two are seprated.. but I would have to say that they could have done alot more with it seeing as it is the end to the FMA series. It is a continuation of the series a couple of months or a years after Ed comes to the other side. So really it wasn't much of a continuation but it is. |
    |
| Ah, I feel like I'm the only one who really, really enjoyed the movie. :< I thought it fit FMA's mood rather well, considering it was never a truly 'happy' series to begin with. It was a bittersweet ending, but Edward and Alphonse were reunited and, no matter how hard it was to accept, their leave was accepted nonetheless by everyone they left behind. After all, it was a necessity and, as Edward himself said, they could no longer put their own desires above the well-being of everyone else. Additionally, the animation was absolutely gorgeous. |
xingflyApr 5, 2010 10:47 PM
    |
| I loved it. It was way better than the Brotherhood ending... Shamballa had a bittersweet ending to it, which is great in my book. I just hope that someone will continue the story later on one day. |
| . |
| Well, Elricest supporters must've been happy by the way it ended though. |
| Awful, Awful, Awful, Awful! What a terrible way to end the original anime. They didn't explain anything and Ed pretty much just goes back, says hello to everyone, and then leaves them all alone! What about poor Winry!!? Wasn't Mustang waiting for Ed to return too? Why the hell would he just let him go? I don't even see why they needed to close the gate...I mean its not like they would keep sending soldiers in after the last batch were decimated. It also felt waay to rushed. I mean they gave hoienheim, gluttony, envy, and wrath like maybe 10 mins of screen time. And they all ended up being transmuted. The writers could have done so much with those characters! Most importantly, what was all that black gloopy crap? Why did it cover that creepy blonde woman end give her like a weird freaky suit with scary red vision. Why the hell was gluttony like that? There was no good explanation for his grotesque form. The whole thing is just...oh my god...it was just horrible. I love fma so much but this just ruined it. Still, I can keep pretending that brotherhood is what really happened and the first anime was just a spin-off. |
 |
| OMG, they should've brought Winry with them ! what a crap |
 |
StabbyPWNS said: Ranivus said: How old are you? Do you have no concept of World War I? Granted its an alternate universe post WWI... Uhh... sorry if I'm wrong but wasn't it like the beginning of World War II? / *Face palm* That's why he said post WWI. World war 2 does come in in like 5 years or so after that I believe |
| There's no magical spell to save someone's life. |
More topics from this board
Poll: » Fullmetal Alchemist: The Conqueror of Shambala Episode 1 Discussion ( 1 2 3 )Kotori - Jul 6, 2008 |
138 |
by NaughtyNoddy
»»
Sep 18, 12:27 AM |
|
» I just realised something really dark about this movie. (Spoilers)Yoshistar123 - Jan 11, 2021 |
11 |
by APolygons2
»»
Mar 21, 7:26 AM |
|
» Fullmetal Alchemist Movie to Premiere on Toonami December 2013YourAnimeGuy - Nov 15, 2013 |
5 |
by Mystogan14579
»»
May 19, 2021 6:25 PM |
|
» Alchemy is possible in the other side of the gate, aka Earth.SwiftKilla - Feb 11, 2014 |
0 |
by SwiftKilla
»»
Feb 11, 2014 3:37 AM |
|
» Fullmetal Alchemist Movie to Premiere on Toonami December 2013YourAnimeGuy - Nov 15, 2013 |
0 |
by YourAnimeGuy
»»
Nov 15, 2013 8:20 PM |