Gakuen Alice, Jibaku Shounen Hanako-kun Recommendations
At a first glance, comparing JSHK to Gakuen Alice might seem like a stretch, but these two mangas share a surprising amount of core values and aesthetics.
Gakuen Alice is more Slice-of-Life and JSHK goes straight into the adventure, but both take a similar approach in how the stories are developed into something darker and more meaningful, while still carrying the lightheartedness from their early days - most notably due to the fact that the main cast are elementary/middle schoolers, respectively.
The main pairing mirror each other in dynamic, a teasing and mysterious guy vs naive yet optimistic girl who wants to learn more about them. Mikan
from GA and Nene from JSHK go through similar developments and have similar life lessons to learn, so their internal storylines are alike, but the guys are very different on the inside, as their identities are deeply rooted in the external storyline. Gakuen Alice is an older shoujo, so Natsume is more of a mean bully (at first!), whereas Hanako-kun is just mischievous. Both have love triangles, but it has more presence in GA.
Gakuen Alice has a magic system that is used & explored by the characters throughout the story. Their quirks are fun to watch and gives insight into who they are as a person. It's a tool to make the story more vibrant as the characters uncover the mysteries in the school.
JSHK is based around spirits and gods, but the worldbuilding is MUCH more detailed, and the story is about uncovering those secrets hidden in the world that goes well beyond the school grounds.
Both are done well, just used on different levels (micro vs macro) as writing tools.
All in all, Gakuen Alice is more old-school adventure fantasy, and Jibaku Shounen Hanako-kun is more modern, but both are masterpieces that you must read if you like the other.
read more
