 If you liked
Kumanishi Bijutsubu Rough Sketch-senpai
|
 ...then you might like
Kuchi ga Saketemo Kimi ni wa
|
The overall settings of the mangas are different (there's nothing supernatural and its set in a highschool), yet the feeling of the kinda straightforward male lead and tsundere female lead (who's known as a badass and stuff) interacting together and causing cute reactions from our heroin are very similar.
Though as I said, this isn't remotely close to the supernatural genre, only the interactions between the two leads are similar.