 If you liked
Soul Eater
|
 ...then you might like
Durarara!!
|
Celty has a death scythe and so is the other characters of "soul eater". It also has that same feel because its also a bit Gothic and a little weird and scary. Once you watch Soul Eater you should also watch Durarara! because these two are both good and awesome anime!
Both have a bit of a darker atmosphere, good action & fight scenes, and engaging characters. Both possess elements of the supernatural (Soul Eater obviously more so than Durarara). Both have well-crafted plot structures.