 If you liked
Date A Live
|
 ...then you might like
Witch Craft Works
|
I'm actually surprised I am the first to recommend this.
Both of these shows start off with a typical guy who is nothing special, and then all of a sudden he's the real deal with a hot girl on his side.
Some other small similarities are
-Both have magic in them
-Both have sisters who were secretly involved
-Both have a lot of destruction