Report ma1kawa11's Profile

Hello! Thank you for your recommendation on Secret Santa.

I just finished it today, and I thought it was a good experience. It’s an anime that brings everything in the form of conversation—from the most random jokes possible to clever references to other works, and even breaking the fourth wall.

The characters have great chemistry, and their jokes keep things lively. Definitely a fun watch (´▽｀)

Hope you have an awesome New Year!

Glad to hear you liked those. I was pretty much positive you'd like AE, so I had to bring it up again. The AE movie is quite impressive when it comes to the aesthetics, atmosphere, etc. Maybe puzzling as to how to interpret it, though. I was just now trying to recall who the composer was for RX, but it seems the only other anime credits she has are for the Code Geass films (aside from singing the theme song for Fujiko Mine Lupin spinoff series). That and RX are so different, lol, so I wonder what her CG compositions are like.

Oh, an oversight on my part is that when I chose not to include GITS, I didn't have a slot for Kenji Kawai. So I'd switch that out with Patlabor 2. Unlike with Berserk, I've listened to that many times outside of the anime and quite recently. Pretty sure you'd also like that if you like the GITS OST.

The song really annoys me. That aside, the biggest issue with the Death Parade OP is that it clashes horribly with the show. There are a lot of songs I don't especially like that fit a show well, so it's much easier to tolerate the song and maybe even enjoy it on some level. Plus, cutting the song down to 1:30 can work wonders for some songs that are too long or repetitive or have weaker sections somewhere along the way. I agree that it's professional, but I'd rather listen to keyboard cat or The Shaggs. XD

Key is completely forgotten on MAL. Strangely, back when I used IMDB more, I used to hear about it all the time.

I read a novel now and then, but I also tend not to read much fiction because fiction is something I use as a break from articles and non-fiction books (so fiction breaks are usually anime or film instead of reading). I also like audiobooks for fiction a lot and usually fall asleep to one as well. Do you like genre fiction for novels much? There's an unlisted YouTube channel I could send you that has a lot of interesting genre fiction.

I've never been much into ballet or watching musical performances. Outside of film or animation, music is a purely aural experience for me. I've probably seen some version of The Rite of Spring on TV a long time ago when I left the art channel on that played a lot of classical, but I'll check streaming.

I've actually listened to the Celeste OST without having ever played the game and liked it okay. I like a lot of rapidly looping music, if that's the main issue as an OST. But, also, with something like Berserk, I'm probably going by my memory of watching the series rather than listening to the OST in this case. So maybe that shouldn't count so much. I've tried a bunch of OSTs that I loved during a film/series with tracks that were too long or with voice overs and various things like that, so it's hard to say.

Uh, I'm trying to recall any accordion music in anime, now that you mention it. Other than a street music scene or a joke involving Europe. Spit and Accordion. Wow. XD

I can see the MGX OST being really effective in the series based on what I've heard so far.

I find some of the tracks work fine outside of the shows for Lain and Boogie, and I used to listen to them when playing chess XD. Maybe that's kind of weird... Main thing though is that both rely a lot more on sound design than other anime. I like the OP for Lain a lot but not the ED. I guess I'm not crazy about either for BP, but the OP grew on me for the visuals and sometimes the song kind of fits the tone of that (sort of...) but not the show as much. The ED is pretty throwaway, and the visual element is just a replay of scenes. Honestly, many corners are cut with EDs, and I have a harder time remembering ones that I like. What is your opinion of Death Parade's OP...? not sure if you've seen that, but I hate that song so much. I find it so weird watching an episode after hearing that. XD

I heard the Franxx manga somehow fixed the ending, though obviously that couldn't be of interest for you if you only like the score. I'm just wondering what possessed them to end it as they did. That's AoT ending-tier bad, lol.

I just saw your comment now, and thank you!

I remember not liking Jigoku Shoujo. Honestly, I have a hard time getting into most episodic series. Some of the bigger exceptions are Mushishi and Kino's Journey. Did you get into it as a horror fan? I want to say the sound element of the Uzumaki adaptation this season is fairly good too.

Same, there are a lot of OSTs I like that don't correlate with liking the series, especially for OPs and EDs, which are made more complicated because it's harder to separate them from the visual component, or I prefer to think of them as audiovisual rather than purely audio as I will sometimes do with OSTs. For example, I'm not sure how much I like the song for the Generator Gawl OP, but I like the visuals a lot, and they go well with the song. Kazuto Nakazawa always does cool stuff with the OPs he's attached to.

I respect Darling in the Franxx partly for its dumpster fire qualities, tbh XD. Can't remember the soundtrack too well, other than catchy OP or something. I'll try it after I send my comment.

I'm familiar with and like most of the OSTs you listed, except I can't really say anything about Nichijou or Spit Maiden. They're both on my PTW list. GITS and Akira are usually on any list I'd make, but I'll skip them this time. Metropolis also has a really strong usage of music. btw, have you tried Hosono's older non-Ghibli work? I find a lot of his stuff from Birth, Venus Wars, Arion, and etc., to be pretty good electronic music that's never mentioned.

OSTs:

-RahXephon (Incidentally, I recall there being some Wagner in the first episode. Borodin somewhere too)
-Angel's Egg (I recall suggesting this one to you, and based on the kind of composers you like outside of anime, I think you'll find it worth trying)
-Alien 9
-Night on the Galactic Railroad (this and the one below are essential for me because of Haruomi Hosono)
-Genji Monogatari
-Serial Experiments Lain (kind of hard to separate this and the one below from sound design, though)
-Boogiepop Phantom
-Hi no Tori: Houou-hen (absurdly underrated OST but fairly well known anime because of Tezuka)
-Berserk 1997 (wanted to add Susumu Hirasawa somewhere)
-Roujin Z (a film that involved Otomo of Akira, and the score is kind of similar to Akira, only maybe more restrained?)

I definitely liked some of the LotGH OPs and EDs, but there are so many of them so not sure which ones. I like Gunsmith Cats and Elfen Lied OPs a lot. I've heard most of the others but don't remember them well. I'd like to try the ED for A Kite because I also don't remember that, but the soundtrack seems a lot more effective than I remember. It's kind of easy to get lost in certain scenes when a score complements what's going on well. :P

OP/ED is insanely hard for me to pick, and I'd probably have to dig through a bunch of them. But I like these (Elfen Lied is also an easy choice for me, but I'll leave it out since you have it).

OP - both Record of Lodoss War OVA and TV
OP - Niea Under 7 (totally unique with those vocals!)
OP - Key the Metal Idol
OP - Dirty Pair Project Eden (holy shit the visuals)
ED - Now and Then, Here and There
OP - Witch Hunter Robin (feels like the most music videoish OP ever, lol)
OP and ED - RahXephon (think this has one of the strongest OP/ED combos out there)
ED - Aku no Hana
OP - Higurashi (feel like this does a great job of creating a kind of paranoid moe horror)
OP - Vlad Love (I think this is opening 1... great mood)

Edit: Yeah, I like the Franxx OST, and I'm kind of curious how it's used during the series, as it's way different than I remember.

Hey. Thanks, I've been good. How have you been? Although it makes sense in your case, it's sort of unusual on MAL to see a list of fav people that are all composers (except Watanabe). Do you have a list of favorite OSTs in anime (or in general)? I was rewatching the original Hellsing recently, and I forgot how interesting the OST and sound design were (plus, Youta Tsuruoka has to be the most notable sound designer in anime).

Hi, thanks :)
I also love Legend of the Galactic Heroes, Metropolis and Terror in Resonance from your list, but my free list can only hold 10 titles hehe
I'm curious, how did you find me in MAL?

if you didn't like berserk 1997 it didn't really adapt most of the manga material

infact that's not truly saying anything because the manga has more fucked shit in it

I really wanted him to die at the end

omg you also hate mirai nikki too based

You're welcome.

Just make sure it's the 1970s version of Wickerman unless you're looking for a comedy. X)

What kind of cult was it, if you don't mind answering?

Well, these kind of critiques of capitalism tend to be framed purely in terms of economics. I feel propaganda has always been more important than money when it comes to media, and what is profitable will sometimes be rejected because it's not in line with current and developing propaganda trends. The way parent companies and global markets work, they can often afford losses. A loss in one area can be recouped in another. And if even a small percentage of the Indian or Chinese market watch something, then that's a big profit.

I haven't read the original manga either, but, from what I've heard, the old 1980s OVA is much more faithful. Yuasa applied an aesthetic reminiscent of his other films/series and turned it into a silly high school thing with a lot of bad additions. If you don't mind the amount of violence and you think the trailer for the 1980s Devilman OVA looks good, then I'd suggest it.

https://myanimelist.net/anime/2354/Devilman__Tanjou-hen

From what I recall with class struggle, there's something about the upper class drafting or pushing the lower class into war, and I can definitely see that in the OVA, with the rich guy enlisting the help of the MC. Crybaby? I don't remember but I doubt it.

I don't like Crybaby either. It's a watering down of Yuasa's past glory, it's Netflix produced, a poor adaptation, and I don't think it does anything that well.

Nowadays "stereotypically villainous" almost always means not. Usually when I watch a murder mystery there's one person who is too obvious and can be ruled out immediately. Even if they make a twisty plot where you've come to not suspect them and then fake you out, it just doesn't seem to work to use the character for that.

I'm not a big fan of Midsommar, but I do like a lot of the imagery. It's interesting how much of the art that we see on the walls explains the process of the rituals and such. Do you like Wicker Man too? More so the older one than the Nicholas Cage one. X) I thought I remembered it having a good OST.

I guess it's not surprising. I feel like film craftsmanship has mostly dropped as a whole, so something that's a bit more difficult to do well like horror will fall even harder. And then you get a lot of the gross stuff to replace atmosphere or effective construction or anything like that.

The most memorable horror work for me that came out in the last few years was probably Petscop, but that's a fake "let's play" series rather than a movie.

I'm surprised you disliked Devilman Crybaby so much, but it honestly is a pretty bad adaptation. The first Devilman OVA is more like a horror film, and I think it's a much better adaptation. The only people disagreeing are probably people coping because daddy Yuasa failed them. X) Has a Kenji Kawai score too, I think.