|
Perfect Anime/Manga (no particular order):
- Legend of the Galactic Heroes (OVA/Novels)
- Steins;Gate
- Monster
- Baccano
- Odd Taxi
- Gurren Lagann
- Dorohedoro (Manga)
- A Silent Voice (Film)
Selection Criteria (IE: What is Perfection?):
- Ties up all most (>95%) of plot points and is generally free of contrivances
- Compelling characters (Clarification: they don't need to be relatable, though they must be to be well written)
- Plot is irrespective of culture; the throughline and delivery of the story is universal and not locked into specific normative cultural lenses
- Satisfying, earned conclusion; the ending must follow from the events in the story, and individual plot points must have clear causal linkages between them
|
All Comments (12) Comments
Kanye is life
I found your Recommandation to TTGL-Redline so amusing I took it into my signature
hope you´re okay with that :D
A much improved style of review upon the topic of DuRARARARARARARARARA and such. Still, I feel the plot explanation was a tad vague. What's DuRARARARARARA about anyway? What happens?
Another thing I noticed was that your intro and outro of your review seemed a bit rushed. The beginning just kind of dove right into explanation without easing the reader into it with a hook of some sort. Try making a comment about a certain part of the anime while using your own sense of wit or fashion to make it sound appealing. With the outro, you don't really do enough to explain the series as a whole, simply a run-off of your pro-con list for the whole thing. It doesn't leave the reader with a sense of closure, as I'm sure the anime itself didn't for you as well.
But now I know how you review. Very well done for a follow-up. I can see you at least attempting to improve your writing style and that makes me one happy camper. I'll be sure to read your future reviews as well. Well done!
For the first time, your review was well-structured. Minimal spelling and grammar errors are also noticeable seeing as some of the members of this site don't speak English instinctively, so it's always nice to see so few errors. Your language was a bit formal, but how can you not explain Inferno Cop without reverting back to your primal instincts of testosterone fueled manhood? It's just so stimulating!
But I'm getting myself riled up at 4 am with people sleeping in my house, so I need to calm down. My point is, I'd like to see you review more of things that you've actually completed instead of going by an assumption based on only two episodes. I'd like to see how you develop more in the future with your reviews as a critic. I'll be sure to scope out for your name whenever another one of your reviews come out in the future! Until then, happy reviewing!