Scoring for me isn't as defined as for most.
Anything in 10-8 range are all great shows. Difference isn't that big between really liked and really really liked it.
in 7-6 are like not waste of time but not show I would recommend.
5 and bellow are just waste of time. Naturally more atrocious shows have score as low as 1 but
from viewer stand point anything 5 and bellow are to be ignored.
If you wanna discuss a show or know my opinion about something from my list it's better to PM me.
P.S stop sending me random friend requests
|
All Comments (8) Comments
Seeing the mouthbreather below, I decided to post a comment in support. I've had people try to convince me that a story is dark if there's gory stuff happening in the background, or evil deeds such as slavery and sexual abuse (ex. the shit-fest called "Overlord". However, what people fail to understand is that any such element can be added to a story and serve no purpose - it's the effect it has on those you care about that makes it dark and grueling. So by making a story revolving around characters lacking in every aspect of the wordand saying it's dark, is the equivalent of expecting sympathy because someone, somewhere, completely unrelated to you is probably being tormented.
In the good words of Stalin, "The death of a man is a tragedy, the death of a thousand is statistics".
Then try to keep the scores the same lol. It looks incredibly lazy on your part and maks the review scream elitism like you are trying to sound smart. Like you are going to be more critical in a review rather than your own opinion. When obviously a review is still subjective.
Sure Hinamatsuri had plenty of other characters but I even give a clear example you seemed to ignore with Anzu. Not to mention none of the kids in the show act like kids anyway. You have the kid on the island who acts like she is 20 and the other kid who gets a job at a bar and is better working than most adults which is very unrealistic lol. You even ignored how I felt that was unfair about Hina because her backstory makes it make sense and she actually does grow very slightly. Just extremely slowly.
But you haven't seen her backstory and are also disregarding my few points I made about her to change your argument. You are criticizing an aspect when you don't understand her character because she does show fear when she is in clear danger. Which is even showed from episode one. The problem is she is very ignorant of the world. I mean the literal first thing she says in the entire show is dad to some random golem out in a forest. If that doesn't seem a bit off to you psychologically I don't know what to say. Kids are also way more resilient than you think and tend to recover from things faster than a teenager or adult, but it is in no way impossible for her to be mostly cherry which she even isn't. Your entire first criticism relied on her being shallow and undeveloped but now it is she seems inhuman? Her entire character is to contrast to how most humans were in the past, granted again you haven't fudging got that far lol.
So now your problem with the Golem has changed? Do you know how many people think he doesn't feel anything in the show ever? How many people were bored because he seems disinterested in most of the time? A whole bunch of people. The golem does slowly gain feelings. The reason the knee thing he felt was so traumatizing was it was the first time he felt bad for another creature. His goal at first starts as just wanting to find her parents. He doesn't really "care" for her the same in episode 3 then he does in episode 11 for instance lol. You are completely understanding his character wrong. But dude if he never got "attached" somewhat at the start again he would have just left her. The show goes into more detail on that later, but you dropped the show and are criticizing him for being what contradictory? Because that is literally the entire point of his entire character battle. It is like you ignored the core themes of the show xD
"World it self felt like reskin because it didn't do anything interesting with it."
This entire paragraph answers nothing that I have said. You again say it is a reskin but give no actual examples of Isekai shows that it is re-skinning fantasy-wise. But you actually give an example of it doing something different. So first the Golem is having feelings so he is contradicting himself but now he feels no feelings at all. Like holy fudge, the show develops him slowly over time. Compare him how he treated her in episode 1 from way later and it is beyond different. In episode 1 he literally doesn't even look after her or hold her hand or show any amount of real care. The guy's literal only motivation is to find her parents. He literally ignores her lets her get lost and in a comedic way says again. Showing this has been a common occurrence. He then only holds her hand so she doesn't go anywhere not because he "loves" her yet.
As I said everything is subjective, but I feel you need to put more thoughts into your criticism rather than saying oh this is shallow or bad, but actually go in-depth why, because I gave plenty examples of how the show was developing their relationship and you just move the argument rather than trying to rebuke what I said or understand what I said.
Long post ahead so I put it into spoiler tags to make it less cluttered on your profile. I hilariously enough don't expect you to read all of this but I hope you do. I also hope I don't come off as rude or arrogant but I recently finished this show and found it as a new favorite of mine and I feel your review isn't really as accurate as it seems. Granted everything is subjective and I respect your opinion on it no matter what. :D