The main thing you need to know about me while checking out my MAL is that I grade pretty strictly. I see a lot of people who will write a review for a series they call "a disaster" then rate the show a 7. For me, an average anime gets a 5, and if I give a show an 8, it means that series is exceedingly good. A 9 is something that goes above and beyond to provide something truly groundbreaking or exquisite. And I've only ever given three 10s to shows which I believe managed to be creative beyond my own imagination, and to leave me in real awe at the ability of the writers.
I currently have a short list of "Prospective 10's" which may be upgraded to a 10 on rewatch:
Monster
Heike Monogatari
Shiguang Dailiren
|
All Comments (11) Comments
I got curious and look at your list and saw you gave a 10 to an anime I never heard about : Watashi ga Motenai.
Is that this good ? Being more in SF and Fantasy, I usually find slice of life superfluous and boring, but what about this one ? Especially since you wrote that you are very strict in your notation ^_^
Although I'm yet okay with continuing the anime, strongly agreed with the point of fanservice, especially during the 3rd episode, that was something that deteriorated Asuka to my eyes. I find the story to be quite solid though, the action is yet decent (it does rely on shock factor though) and I like how they portray PTSD and military + magic. Something I don't like is the artstyle: apart from too sexualized, not fond of the design of Disas and find the general art to be mediocre.
By the way, love to see you appreciate Madoka, many drama, historicals and some of my faves!
what a surprise, the source for Satsuriku no Tenshi is a game that goes by the same name...
Sorry, I just feel like I had to point that out, nevermind me