Report PESER's Profile

good taste

:D

You had the facts right but you misinterpreted them, I am sorry you had to spend time to check my list and leave a comment, since your misinterpretation nullified your replies...

"Whenever you find yourself on the side of the majority, it is time to pause and reflect" - Mark Twain

I have a low meanscore, most people with low meanscores rate Shingeki no Kyojin:S2 at 1/10, in order to not come off as agreeing with the majority, I rated it at 10/10 (I did that 10 months ago, in anticipation).
I haven't even watched it, giving it a 10 was a joke, which should have been obvious since I never seriously rate something as 10/10, but I still see where and why you misunderstood me.
- Take a look at Season 1 of Shingeki no Kyojin, I rated it 6/10.

About Monster, I said it is not good as people make it out to be, because it is no better than 8/10 and people praise it as a masterpiece and rate it at 9-10/10.

Finally about my reviews:
The overall of a review does not have to be an average between the 4-5 categories provided by MAL, only beginners follow that logic.
When rating a review, I also consider how it worked as a whole, the characters+story+animation+sound, not just rating each of them and then forming an average.
Also, sometimes my personal ratings may differ from the ones in my reviews because the review is objective while sometimes I like to be a bit subjective about my personal rating.

I am a polite guy who almost never looses his cool, so getting any strong reactions from is highly improbable.

Hello,
Fortunately, you are the first person ever to say I am "one of the most awful reviewers on MAL".

Feel free to share your thoughts on how I can improve my reviews.

>Just know that this grading is overly low to even watch any anime and if you don't like it then not sure why you are watching anyway.
__________________________________________________________________


Not sure what you mean by this? Do you mean that my grading system doesn't meet *your* standards? Well yeah, it's my system, not yours. It's not supposed to be universal. It's supposed to reflect my opinion.

The whole "Don't like it don't watch it", is kind of a useless point, no? There are critics for a reason. There are tastes for a reason. There are scores for a reason. If this point wasn't flawed then the grading system would only reflect a 5,6,7,8,9,10 scores, and not anything below. Since if they don't like it, why would they watch it, right?

Critical viewers watch things to try understand why they don't like something and explain that why to other people who may agree or disagree. If you aren't willing to debate then sending a message feels useless, no? I do want to thank you for corrected my factual error about it being an LN though!

___________________________________________________________________
> Also please check the source before you start writing
_________________________________________________________________
While I have admitted my factual incorrectness here, I hope *you* understand that regardless of where it came from, it doesn't change the fact that my arguments are substantial. Like, if you disagree with my arguments feel free to explain why. If you don't want to, then don't expect your points to be taken seriously.
___________________________________________________________________
>Also as an adaptation Konosuba did a really good job doing so.
___________________________________________________________________
I'm not judging it as an adaptation, i'm judging it as a piece of entertainment. If the source material is garbage, would you want the adaptation to be garbage too, just so it can "an accurate adaptation?" Hell no. I think anyone who loves entertainment would want everything to be great, regardless of its source material.

Yeah I miss typed. However, I think I defined exactly what I expect from comedy and I described why the comedy in Konosuba isn't interesting to me, specifically. I also talked about objectivity in comedy as well, I suggest you reread. What irrelevant things was I comparing it to, I'm curious?

About progress, I mentioned comedies doing both progression and lack there of. I judged Konosuba on the non-progressing comedies and it didn't do that well, for me. If you aren't going to clarify anything you are saying then I won't bother spending time debating this subject. All the best.

You are right about it being an LA. Will fix that immediately!

I wouldn't say my understanding of the show is low, if so, how so?

vomic- seiyuu fanclub!

would you like to join us ?
http://myanimelist.net/clubs.php?cid=21716