Joined Aug. 10, 2022. This account has been tracking anime and manga since then.
1 - Horrible
× I found it extremely bad with no redeeming qualities.
× I would actively discourage anyone from watching/reading it.
2 - Very Bad
× Barely tolerable with maybe one or two small redeeming aspects.
× I wouldn’t recommend it to anyone.
3 - Bad
× There are a few elements I found okay, but the overall experience was negative.
× I might mention it to others as a cautionary tale but wouldn’t recommend it.
4 - Below Average
× There are some moments or aspects I liked, but the negatives outweigh the positives.
× I wouldn’t recommend it, but I wouldn’t discourage others who are genuinely curious.
5 - Average
× A middle-of-the-road series—neither good nor bad. It wasn’t a bad experience, but it wasn’t especially enjoyable either.
× I wouldn’t recommend it, but I also wouldn’t steer anyone away.
6 - Slightly Above Average
× I liked it more than not, but it didn’t leave a strong impression.
× Not necessarily something I’d recommend, but I wouldn’t oppose someone watching/reading it.
7 - Good
× I liked it and even found aspects of it enjoyable.
× I’d recommend it to people with an interest in its specific type of story, themes, or presentation.
8 - Very Good
× I liked it a lot and found it well-executed, compelling, or impactful in its own way.
× I’d recommend it to most anime/manga fans who are open to something with those strengths.
9 - Excellent
× I loved it and found it highly memorable with very few flaws.
× I’d enthusiastically recommend it to nearly everyone, regardless of their specific interests.
10 - Masterpiece
× A near-perfect experience that resonated deeply with me on an emotional or personal level.
× While creativity and technical qualities matter, my enjoyment and emotional/personal connection are central. Even less polished series can earn this rating if they deeply resonated with me.
× I’d recommend it to everyone and consider it essential viewing/reading.
1. Personal Enjoyment: My ratings are primarily based on how much I enjoyed the series, with emotional impact and personal connection playing a significant role.
2. Flexibility with Technical Aspects: While technical brilliance (e.g., animation, storytelling, direction, music, etc.) can contribute to a higher rating, a deeply personal or emotional resonance can elevate even less polished works to a higher rating.
3. Context-Specific Appreciation: Not every story has the same goals. I consider how well a series fulfills its unique type of story, themes, or presentation, which influences both my enjoyment and the recommendations I make.
4. Balance of Likes and Dislikes: A middle rating (5) reflects a truly average series—neither good nor bad—while higher or lower ratings depend on how much I liked or disliked it overall.
5. Recommendation Factor: My ratings also reflect how strongly I’d recommend the series to others, ranging from "not at all" (1-4) to "essential for everyone" (10).
2024 Winter:
- Dungeon Meshi
2024 Spring:
- Spice and Wolf
- Kaiju No. 8
- Konosuba 3
- Girls Band Cry
✅︎ 2.5 Dimensional Seduction
2024 Summer:
✅︎ "Oshi no Ko" 2nd Season
- Make Heroine ga Oosugiru!
✅︎ Alya
- Elusive Samurai
✅︎ Tsue to Tsurugi no Wistoria
2024 Fall:
- Re:Zero S3
✅︎ Dandadan
- Ao no Hako
- Chi. Chikyuu no Undou ni Tsuite
All Comments (0) Comments