|
I just joined myanimelist. I have been watching since 2014 non-stop. I still have a while to go. If I do an anime review/rating, use the following criteria:
10 I couldn't stop thinking about it for a week.
9 It was great and touched my feelings
8 It was great
7 It was good
6 It was ehhhh, watchable
5 and below is just unwatchable
|
All Comments (3) Comments
This is not the story, this is the premise.
"Also playing with him is his love interest which is passionate to the game, so you can guess who convinced him to join."
There is no romance in this and fukami and koshiyama are never implied to be anything more than friends.
"The rest of the story can be guessed as any competitive club focused story."
Except that it doesn't play out as the ones I know of and whilst this isn't really my genre overall, I've seen other reviewers concur. There's no stakes upon which the entire cast's future depends, the MC isn't a great player and the whole main club is average at best all the way to the end with the exception of sasajima as an individual who is blatantly overpowered. There may well be other ones out there that do the same thing and that have the same story (that is more tightly focused around the MC finding his place, rather than becoming the best), but this is hardly "as any competitive club focused story". There are certainly differences to the ones I know.
"The art is well done, I only put a 7 since Toei Animation has a thing where they will drop the quality overtime. But for the first 4 episodes, it's consistent so no problems there."
I'm not 100% sure on what you were saying here but it sounds like you marked it down because of some theoretical drop in art quality based on the studio that doesn't really happen. I don't disagree with the 7 rating overall, this is just what I mean.
I could go on but I think I made the point.