Statistics
Anime History Last Anime Updates
All Manga Stats Manga Stats
Days: 86.4
Mean Score:
7.59
- Total Entries237
- Reread0
- Chapters15,550
- Volumes1,647
All Comments (20) Comments
A Cultured individual and Punpun fan is always a worthy friend :D
First off, congratulations to Sasuga Kei, as the author of this manga for causing a meltdown in the fanbase.
Ever heard of Food Wars/Shokugeki no Souma? The manga's ending was very disappointing and caused a huge letdown. Let me tell you, food wars ending is not even comparable to this manga. if Food wars has the worst ending in 2019, then this manga has the worst ending in the decade.
Story (10/10) : The story is about a guy named Natsuo who fucked with a stranger, then fucked with his step sister, then fucking up his entire family, then a lot more fucking, till the author decided to fuck the manga and its characters.
The story kinda dulls up after Natsuo forgot how to write. It seems the author also forgot how to write too.
Art (8/10) : The art has gotten much better than the previous work, Good Game. Alas, nice artstyle does not equal to nice storytelling.
Character (10/10) : The author succeeded in making a character everyone hates the most, which is the author himself. The author even got threatened in real life, and decides to not use social media, since everyone hates him. Congratulations.
Enjoyment (10/10) : I got enjoyment from watching the fanbase burns itself to the ground.
Overall (1/10) : read the Ending segment.
Ending (10/10) : *HEAVY SPOILERS HERE* This part is the cause for fanbase breakdown. After Sasuga Kei forgot how to write, He made Natsuo forgot how to write too, then he decides to fuck up the series by turning one of the main character to a fucking vegetable. At this point Natsuo already has a girlfriend, a pregnant one, and is going to get married, yet a fucking vegetable proceed to do NTR and taken Natsuo over the heroine. No one wins. Not the heroines, not Natsuo, not the Author, not the Fanbase, not the Fanbase that threathens the author, no one. The vegetable wins.
TLDR : MC screws with the characters, the author decided to screw him, and then turned the char
Lol, This much salt will make a juice taste like a broth
First off, congratulations to Sasuga Kei, as the author of this manga for causing a meltdown in the fanbase.
Ever heard of Food Wars/Shokugeki no Souma? The manga's ending was very disappointing and caused a huge letdown. Let me tell you, food wars ending is not even comparable to this manga. if Food wars has the worst ending in 2019, then this manga has the worst ending in the decade.
Story (10/10) : The story is about a guy named Natsuo who fucked with a stranger, then fucked with his step sister, then fucking up his entire family, then a lot more fucking, till the author decided to fuck the manga and its characters.
The story kinda dulls up after Natsuo forgot how to write. It seems the author also forgot how to write too.
Art (8/10) : The art has gotten much better than the previous work, Good Game. Alas, nice artstyle does not equal to nice storytelling.
Character (10/10) : The author succeeded in making a character everyone hates the most, which is the author himself. The author even got threatened in real life, and decides to not use social media, since everyone hates him. Congratulations.
Enjoyment (10/10) : I got enjoyment from watching the fanbase burns itself to the ground.
Overall (1/10) : read the Ending segment.
Ending (10/10) : *HEAVY SPOILERS HERE* This part is the cause for fanbase breakdown. After Sasuga Kei forgot how to write, He made Natsuo forgot how to write too, then he decides to fuck up the series by turning one of the main character to a fucking vegetable. At this point Natsuo already has a girlfriend, a pregnant one, and is going to get married, yet a fucking vegetable proceed to do NTR and taken Natsuo over the heroine. No one wins. Not the heroines, not Natsuo, not the Author, not the Fanbase, not the Fanbase that threathens the author, no one. The vegetable wins.
TLDR : MC screws with the characters, the author decided to screw him, and then turned the char
While reading other manga, I came across Domestic Girlfriend again and decided to skim it until the last few chapters. And damn I wish I never did.
Fuck the author!
The parents actually do say that they are okay with Hina and Natsuo being together, for example when Natsuo gets stabbed to protect Hina, Rui overhears her parents saying "Maybe we shouldn't have forced them apart" when talking about Hina and Natsuo.
Another instance of this is when Tsukiko (Rui and Hina's mom) tells Hina that she'd approve if Hina got back with Natsuo.
4/ Still some phrasing problems in that quote, but I get the idea.
Hina did nothing to influence Natsuo marrying her, and Hina instead tried to convince Rui to marry Natsuo when she woke up.
You contradicted yourself in this reply.
>"Your lovely boyfriend chooses to break up with you"
>"Yes, Rui called off their marriage, Rui told Natsuo to live with her."
Was Natsuo supposed to force Rui to marry him? Even though he still had feelings for Hina and Rui told him to stay with Hina?
The shock from the crash and what ensued makes sense, Natsuo is shocked that this happens so he's not in a great state of mind, but he talks it over with Rui and they decide to cancel the marriage. We don't get to see what they say, but they are shown discussing it all night, until the sun rises.
NTR can only happen if let's say Natsuo was seduced by Hina intentionally while he was with Rui, but that's not what happened.
Rui intentionally called off the marriage herself, and after talking it out with Rui, Natsuo decided to marry Hina. Hina played no part in this.
1/ "The story is about a guy named Natsuo who fucked with a stranger, then fucked with his step sister, then fucking up his entire family, then a lot more fucking"
This is a way too simple and comedic way to present the story.
Sure, Rui was a stranger, but not for very long. Saying that she's a stranger here implies that she's never seen again, which is false.
Your way of presenting the story makes it seem like these events happen in quick succession, when there's genuine character developement between each event that you mentionned. Between his time with Rui after the Karaoke and his time with Hina, some 50+ chapters have passed where Natsuo and Hina confirmed their feelings for each other. He didn't just hop from Rui to Hina in an instant.
Natsuo didn't fuck up his family. His dad and stepmom were okay with him and Hina dating, and eventually came to accept him dating Rui.
2/ "The art has gotten much better than the previous work, Good Game"
This along with what I said earlier is another thing that makes me question whether you actually read the series or whether you wrote this review as a joke.
It's Good Ending, not Good Game.
How could you even get it wrong? You wrote that, submitted it without ever checking what the name of her previous series was? That's some serious interest you have there.
3/ "The author succeeded in making a character everyone hates the most, which is the author himself. The author even got threatened in real life, and decides to not use social media, since everyone hates him. Congratulations."
I'm not gonna mention how you didn't mention a single one of the characters from the series and instead decided to bash the author who, by the way, is a female, and not a male. (Again, your interest for this series is clearly very high)
The author isn't in the series, and she didn't "decide not to use SM", she never said that. She said that she didn't care about the hate coming from salty western fans and that the reception in Japan was positive.
The one thing she did say about SM is that she had to brace herself for hate every time she posted a tweet.
4/ "yet a fucking vegetable proceed to do NTR and taken Natsuo over the heroine."
The line that convinced me that you didn't read the series and instead just read some shitty rant on twitter or reddit and decided to write this for jokes.
When Hina got hit by Okunugi, she fell into a coma. Explain to me then, how she could NTR Rui and seduce Natsuo.
The decision to call off Rui and Natsuo's marriage came from Rui. Rui gave Natsuo the marriage form and told him to stay by Hina's side. Hina even asked Rui if she wanted to take her place on the marriage day. If anyone seduced Natsuo, it's Rui just after Hina was transfered.
Overall, it's clear to me that this is a shitpost review, that you didn't read the series and just wanted a quick laugh by shitposting. I don't understand how the mods have left this up for so long. The fact that people agree with you doesn't make what you say valid. I could say that Rui is a shit character because of X, Y and Z reasons, if those reasons aren't true and proovable with facts, my statement is invalid.
Validation from others doesn't make you correct, it only makes you think that you are.