Hi Julius~ I want to share with you this: I am tired of dumb people on this MAL site who love garbage shows and want to create a new small community to have great discussion. Today I made a hypothesis that rational people should at least hate Elfen Lied and some people who hate Elfen Lied should at least be more rational than average. So I look into their mess of reviews and found you and some other fellows~
One of my endeavors to find like-minded buddies was to join the infamous club "Critics and Connoisseurs" (CnC) whose 130 members claim themselves to have "confined taste" but I had really shitty experiences there. Many of them seem to be dumb in other ways... Therefore I want to create a new SERIOUS club to bash all the shows that should be bashed, systematically and scientifically (in contrast to CnC who look for 'good' shows to put into their relation columns - we look for bad-and-popular ones - of course we don't need to address countless of shitty ones that most people hate already). We can't let people embrace shitty shows any more because of their excessive production value (art and/or sound). The path we fight is for a future with better shows! The club page is under development but you can take a look at http://myanimelist.net/clubs.php?cid=22555
Let me know what you think :)
I've just read your review of "Elfen Lied" which I found rather good. Most of the points you put forth I wholeheartedly agree with. Personally, I thought even less of the show. I rated it 1/10 because I thought its negative aspects were far greater than its positive ones.
I think, however, that you might want to remove the last sentence of your review as it may seem insulting to many people and lead them to wrongly rate your work.
I look forward to reading more of your reviews in the future!
All Comments (5) Comments
One of my endeavors to find like-minded buddies was to join the infamous club "Critics and Connoisseurs" (CnC) whose 130 members claim themselves to have "confined taste" but I had really shitty experiences there. Many of them seem to be dumb in other ways... Therefore I want to create a new SERIOUS club to bash all the shows that should be bashed, systematically and scientifically (in contrast to CnC who look for 'good' shows to put into their relation columns - we look for bad-and-popular ones - of course we don't need to address countless of shitty ones that most people hate already). We can't let people embrace shitty shows any more because of their excessive production value (art and/or sound). The path we fight is for a future with better shows! The club page is under development but you can take a look at
http://myanimelist.net/clubs.php?cid=22555
Let me know what you think :)
I can't really see what sort of black metal you like, but I can see that you like good music anyway.
I think, however, that you might want to remove the last sentence of your review as it may seem insulting to many people and lead them to wrongly rate your work.
I look forward to reading more of your reviews in the future!