I rate anime on philosophical impact, you measure this by searching for any evidence for the level of the philosophical impact on the mind and by looking for the retention of how the impact will retain in the mind. If these factors are very good then I am willing to give the animeshow a rating of 10/10, otherwise it would be lower. In addition many animes are on watching, because I don't remember always if I have seen the anime entirely.
There are three kinds of models: Rating on Film criticism/Literary Analyse [Film Theory/Literary Criticism], Rating on Philosophical Idea [Philosophy of life] and the last one rating on enjoyment [Fulfillment]
Some people use 7 as standard > some people use 5 as standard > I rate with 7, because most anime has philosophical impact as long as there is a story (in contrast to hentai). I understand why people use 5 ratings, because people want to rate on a full scale of comparison between anime. Also people who are rating with film theory or literary criticism, could be people who read also other mediums like the VN, Manga and LN.
There is a reason why some anime have an average score of 8 or higher.
-What is reason to watch more of the anime (objective, dreams, goals)
-What is the reason to enjoy an episode (achievement, comedy, progress, change)
-What is the reason to enjoy an entire anime (idea, expression, art, characters)
-Technical details (Correct timing like: dialogues, sound, animation and climax; correct colouring scenes and suitable backgrounds for each frame)
The last thing to mention: There are two worlds;
The world of Comedy, echhi, harem "The fun good mindless messages" &
The world of Thriller, action, adventure, Romance; "The more realistic more mind pressured world but with emotional messages".
One of the properties of high rated anime are (8.5-10):
- Commentary from narrator in the anime
- Problem and emotion
- Quote of character development
- Pace (watch more to learn more)
Examples are: Food wars, Rainbow, from the Abyss, Violet Evergarden
Minpoints and not getting 8
- Not coherent in the theme of the anime (Dr. Stone).
- Bad pacing.
And Special thanks to the ratings and anime list of
[*]
Chloe-tsundere
[*]
Kineta (Database Admin)
[*]
Luna (Forum Mod) & (Database Admin)
[*]
Koleare ("Retired" Forum Mod)
[*]
Suzune-chan ("Retired" Forum Mod)
[*]
Tachii ("Retired" Forum Mod)
~Honored Normal Members~ and ~Of course staff and Retired Members~
[*]
Aero (10.5K Posts) - Active Member & Admin of
MAL Awards Club (Retired Moderator)
[*]
AlexSadist (67K Posts) - Active Member
[*]
AngelHana (3.5k > 3.8K Posts) - Card Maker
[*]
Alisa (10.3K Posts) - Active Member & Admin of
Japanese 101: Beginning Japanese
[*]
Asako (6.3K Posts) -
Subs vs. Dubs v2
[*]
Archaeon (2.4K Posts) - Reviewer
[*]
IntroverTurtle (17.8K > 28.6K Post) - Active Member
[*]
Hahaido (1K > 1.5K Post) -
Hahaido's tips to stylize your layout - Card Designer & CSS Designer
[*]
Kibidango (10.3K > 10.6K Posts) - Active Member, Cardcaptor Sakura Fan & Admin of
Japanese 101: Beginning Japanese
[*]
Legolasdf (10.7K > 25.2K Posts) - Active Member & Admin of
Slice of Life Club and
Namine's Café
[*]
Lupadim (7.7K > 10.4K Posts) - Active Member
[*]
Lyfa (18.7K > 30K Comments & 18.6K > 22.6K Posts)) - Active Member & Admin of
Namine's Café
[*]
Raidol (7.9K Posts) - Active Member & Admin of
Luna_'s Fan Club
[*]
SerasAshley (11.9K > 12.4K Comments) - Active Member & Admin of
Recommendation Club
[*]
Shishio-kun (1.9K > 2.9K Posts) -
Customize your list! &
All premade list and profile layouts -
CSS Expert & Admin of
Shishio's Custom Lists & Profiles
[*]
Tachii (10.5K > 10.9K Posts) - Active Member
[*]
Tsubasalover (18.8K > 21.3K Posts) - Active Member& Admin of
SPRING 2014 ANIME
[*]
Tsudecimo (8.6K > 20K Post) - Active Member
[*]
Yanoflies (12.6K Posts) - Active Member
[*]
Zeenipai (11.2K Posts) - Active Member & Admin of
Namine's Café
----The Sentence of Anime----
Dealing with class: date a live
Dealing with death: Anohana, Angel Beats, Colorful, Death Parade
Dealing with emotion & memories: Ef a tale of memories/melodies, Plastic Memories
Dealing with identity: Kaiba, Sola, Uta Kata, Ghost in the Shell, Serial Experiment, Ergo Proxy
Dealing with choices & deceiving: Akame ga Kill, Hunter X Hunter, Rosen Maiden, ChäoS;HEAd, Steins;Gate, Spice and Wolf
Dealing with competition: Shokugeki no Souma, DBZ, One Piece, Fairy Tail, Bleach, Hunter x Hunter
Dealing with weirdness: Blend S, MM
Dealing with equality (no man is born equal): Boku no Hero Academia, Youkoso Jitsuryoku Shijou Shugi no Kyoushitsu e, Baka to test
Dealing with factions: Fate/Zero, Pandora Hearts
Dealing with good and evil: Death Note, Shiki, UQ Holders!
Dealing with living forward: Little Busters (Refrain&EX), 5 Centimeters per Second
Dealing with discrimination: Ajin, Elfen Lied
Dealing with society: Blue Literature, Paranoia Agent, Tokyo Ghoul, Shiki
All Comments (17) Comments
Main Site | Site Forum | Voting Page | Mal Club | Mal Thread
Sorry if I'm bordering you!
renascence
[spoiler]
We are proud to deliver to you our very first Newsletter. The Club has been brought back to life for about four months now and we plan to make many things in the future for all the members to enjoy. For now here are some of the things that may interest you.
Read Together
If you are interested in reading with someone else in the club, either by choosing from those who have their names and reading choices listed, or by joining the list, you can visit the above link.
Mini Event: Anime & Literature
We will hold an anime-watching event throughout May, and currently we are opening a poll for you to vote for the anime that will be included in the event. Visit the given link for more information and also to cast your vote. The poll will be open for approximately one week.
Other threads to join:
Introduce yourself (if you haven't)
Ask for reading recommendation
Brag about books you currently read
...or just completed
General discussion
News of literary world
Our Games
Guess the characters
Biblio This or That
Anagram: Harry Potter Edition
Useful links:
Forum rules & guideline
Table of content
The staffs
Staff Recruitment: Open
If you would like to receive more Newsletter in the future, you can subscribe here.
We look forward to seeing you at the club!!!
The last day of division finals is tomorrow, 14 of September. Kanade will be fighting against Misaka Mikoto.
League Finals start on 21 of September and last till 5 of October. These are the final rounds, so don't forget to give your vote for Kanade!
If You are interested in events like ISML or Japanease Saimoe, You should also be interested in European Saimoe event organized by the Senpuu Society. Give it a chance and vote for your favorite heroine in fierce battle of flames!
P.S. Due to the club having so many members, we aren't able to send out newsletters to all of our members. If you would like to receive newsletters from the Slice of Life Club, post here.
Our newsletters include notifications on when our competition rounds start, club event information, information on our monthly banner contest (new feature starting in September), news about updates and changes to the club, etc.
P.S.S We are in need of active card makers!
We do a few monthly editions and we really need some more card makers to help out with those. If you are interested in applying, click here.
please tell us at
http://myanimelist.net/forum/?topicid=1208907
[/IMG]
[IMG]
Well, maybe welcome to the forums of MAL since you've been a member for a while now 0.o
anyways,
Nice to meet you ^^