How I rate my mangas/animes (it is subjective of course ^^) :
10 : this is the absolute must read/watch. During future 10 or 20 years, I will want to read/watch again for sure, and for several times. This piece is full of very good ideas and can give people emotions. This can be also an anime/manga which has remarkable scenes.
9 : Almost same as for 10 but I think that in 10 years I will stop to read/watch it. However, I really think that these mangas/animes can be masterpieces for someone else. These are my first recommendations.
8 : Mangas/animes which has some good scenes and some chapters/episodes are VERY good. I will surely read/watch again in next years, but probably only interesting parts
7 :
- Mangas : This is a very good manga and I will probably read it several times. However it doesn't meet "serious" expactations. It can be because of too much fan service, too many bad jokes,... They are very good, but some pages are stopping me to read. An example can be Fairy tail for me. I like the story and characters, but there are too many scenes that are designed to meet "boys" expectations.
- Animes : I spent a good moment watching it. This is not THE blockbuster of course but it is good, particularly to those who are interested in similar animes. They are fun, no more, no less.
6 : This is good to read/watch at least one time. I usualy like similar animes/mangas, but this one is disappointing for me. There is not enough epic scenes or emotions on it. However characters and story are very good.
5 : Almost same but characters or/and story has lack of consistency
4 : It could be good, but story, characters design or something else has made me to stop or delay this one.
3 : Something that can be read, just to know
2 : Something that can be read but something is really awful
1 : No. Just no. never again. It did not yet happened to me
All Comments (1) Comments
10 : this is the absolute must read/watch. During future 10 or 20 years, I will want to read/watch again for sure, and for several times. This piece is full of very good ideas and can give people emotions. This can be also an anime/manga which has remarkable scenes.
9 : Almost same as for 10 but I think that in 10 years I will stop to read/watch it. However, I really think that these mangas/animes can be masterpieces for someone else. These are my first recommendations.
8 : Mangas/animes which has some good scenes and some chapters/episodes are VERY good. I will surely read/watch again in next years, but probably only interesting parts
7 :
- Mangas : This is a very good manga and I will probably read it several times. However it doesn't meet "serious" expactations. It can be because of too much fan service, too many bad jokes,... They are very good, but some pages are stopping me to read. An example can be Fairy tail for me. I like the story and characters, but there are too many scenes that are designed to meet "boys" expectations.
- Animes : I spent a good moment watching it. This is not THE blockbuster of course but it is good, particularly to those who are interested in similar animes. They are fun, no more, no less.
6 : This is good to read/watch at least one time. I usualy like similar animes/mangas, but this one is disappointing for me. There is not enough epic scenes or emotions on it. However characters and story are very good.
5 : Almost same but characters or/and story has lack of consistency
4 : It could be good, but story, characters design or something else has made me to stop or delay this one.
3 : Something that can be read, just to know
2 : Something that can be read but something is really awful
1 : No. Just no. never again. It did not yet happened to me