This account is my second account on MAL and just contains the anime that I watched (or rewatched) after "1 January 2021"
For my curious old friends: Yes, I deleted my first account. (Its lists was so complicated and useless.) Yes, I was not watching anime since 2017 and yes, I returned.
Enjoy your anime :D
My Milestones of Anime
1st anime I watched: Candy Candy (Yes I know, It is a shoujo :D)
1st anime I watched on TV: Captain Tsubasa (I could never complete it.)
1st anime I watched while knowing it is called "anime": Steins;Gate
NOTE: This list is just a reference for me. Naturally my main ranking criteria is "my enjoyment from show". So this list doesn't refer to something seriously.
NOTE 2: By the way, 5 is a good score for me. Actually I even like some of my 4's. So please don't be mad at me.
10 - Like MAL said, it must be a masterpiece to get 10. It must affect my life and make me looking my life different than before. It must have great character designs and gorgeous plot-lore-story. It will be much better if it gives me something that I had never saw and keeps curiosity and interest at the highest level from beginning to the end. The shows that get a 10 from me are highly recommended. Probably I will watch it over and over.
9 - It must be an amazing show and amaze me. It must affect my life and make my vision of life better. It should have a great story-plot and characters. It can have a few issues/flaws about story-plot or characters but nothing too serious. The shows that get a 9 from me are really enjoyable and I highly recommend them. Probably I will watch it again completely. (The main difference between 9 and 10 is my enjoyment and mood :D)
8 - It must be a really good show. It doesn't have to affect my life and make my vision of life better but if it does, that would be great. It might have some small-medium issues/flaws that irritates me a little bit but it is still really enjoyable. By the way, It should have at least three really well designed characters and great plot-story. The shows that get an 8 from me are enjoyable, not highly but I recommend them. Probably I will watch some of its clips again. It is a really low chance but maybe I will watch it again completely.
7 - It must be a good show, watched and liked it... Story doesn't have to be an original one but it should be good. Characters should be well designed and at least one of them should be really qualified. It might have some noticeable medium issues/flaws that irritates me but still an enjoyable show. If you are not a really selective viewer you will probably like this show. The shows that get a 7 from me are enjoyable, not highly but I recommend them. I will watch its clips again but I probably will not watch it again completely. (The main difference between 7 and 8 is my enjoyment and mood :D)
6 - It should be a fine show. Most of animes belongs to this category. Story is probably not an original one but it is fine. Characters don't have to be well designed but at least one of them should be qualified well. It might have some really noticeable medium-big issues/flaws that irritates me much but still an enjoyable show. The shows that get a 6 from me are enjoyable. I recommend them with a little hesitation . At the end of the day it will worth your time. Probably will not watch it again.
5 - It is an average show with lots of medium-big issues/flaws that irritates me reallly much. Story is cliche probably and characters are not well designed. Some of them would have depth but nothing really satisfying. The shows that get a 5 from me might be an enjoyable show but nothing more. I recommend them with a little hesitation or not recommend. At the end of the day it might worth or not worth your time. I will not watch it again.
4 - It is a bad show to me. It has a badly written story and character designs have no depth. It is even lower than the cliche classification.The shows that get a 4 from me might be an enjoyable show but not for me. I do not recommend them but can understand why people likes this show or why they are recommending it. I will not watch it again.
3 - It is a really bad show to me, has a really badly written story. There is no one that I can call "characters" in the show. I cannot understand how people like this show. Nothing much to say about this category. The shows that get a 3 from me are not an enjoyable show and not for me. I highly recommend not to watch it.
2 - It is a terrible show. No plot, no story, no character design. I cannot understand how people like this and I'm angry with them about this show. The shows that get a 2 from me are annoying and irritating. Nevermind the depth, There is nothing here. Please avoid...
1 - You know what I'm gonna say :D
NOTE : As you can see "Art quality" is not a big deal for me... I don't mind art quality when I'm ranking, except the situations when it irritates me really much. I am just dropping 1 point if I feel it irritates me or disturbs my focus on story of anime.
NOTE : I think, expectations before watching an anime musn't affect its score that much. Because every anime has got its own way to tell a story or make you laugh. You can not estimate its way before you watch it. For example you can not (should not) lower the score of an ecchi-comedy because of its weak plot or story. This would be unfair, because the purpose of this anime is not the plot. It just wanna make you laugh. Then, if you laugh, this anime should be a good anime. I know, it is a very shallow example but this is the easiest way to explain.
By the way, don't miss understand me. I don't want to say "just throw the expectations off". Because at the end of the day, this is just a trade. You have some expectations and want something, so anime gives you something. If you like that "something" you score it high or opposite of this. This is normal. But I wanna say "selection of our expectations" is our way of thinking, so the effects of expectations must be at minimal level when we are objectively ranking. I hope you can understand me.
Summary, I'm ranking every anime at their own class. I think, a good rom-com is better than an average sci-fi. At the end of the day, plot of rom-com might be worse then sci-fi's but I'm ranking them in their own class. I think this is the best way to rank objectively.
NOTE :I did not mention this on my ranking criteria but actually I really care about audio. It is an "after ranking process" so I did not include it on my criteria list. First, I give my score to an anime and after that I add or subtract points according to audio performance.
First of all, performances of "seiyū"s (voice actors) are really make the show level up or down. A bad voice acting can ruin all the emotion of the scene or opposite of this. Voice acting is much more important than animation quality, I think. So it is a big and important criteria for me. Mostly, voice acting evaluation is the last part of my general evaluation process.
Secondly, the OSTs. I consider it as a bonus. If a show has got a good OST, it is a bonus so I might add some points but if it hasn't, no problem. Just like I said, it is a bonus criteria. By the way, my quality criterion depends on how much I listen to it. For example, if I listen an OST at least once a day it is probably a good OST...
Ben de Evangelionun hakkında iyi şeyler duymuştum. Birde Anno Hideaki gibi bir yönetmen yönetiyorsa ne kadar güzel olur kim bilir.. Şuanki izlediklerim bittikten sonra Evangelion'a başlayıcam bakalım ..
Ben de psikolojik, romantizm, komedi, gerilim vs. bunları gerçekten severim. Özellikle animenin kendiside güzelse tadına doyum olmuyor xd
Yaşamdan kesitler türü ise eğer animenin kendisi güzel olursa tadı oluyor öteki türlü, kötüyse gerçekten sıkıcı olabiliyor :/
All Comments (9) Comments
Yaşamdan kesitler türü ise eğer animenin kendisi güzel olursa tadı oluyor öteki türlü, kötüyse gerçekten sıkıcı olabiliyor :/