HOW I RATE ANIME AND MANGA
10: It's a Masterpiece. It's the pinnacle of it's genre and I'd recommend almost everyone try it unless you hate the genre.
9: It's Exceptional and I absolutely loved it. If it's a genre that you generally like, even if only a little, this is an absolute MUST try.
8: It's Great and I really enjoyed my time watching/reading it. If you like the genre, then I would definitely recommend giving it a shot.
7: It's Very Good and does many things well. However, I'd only recommend it to someone else if they're a big fan of the featured genre(s).
6: It's Pretty Good and it was certainly enjoyable, but it's not something that I would recommend to anyone else, even if they like the genre.
5: Just Mediocre. It's definitely not bad, but it either doesn't have any unique qualities, or it's being held back by something like weak writing.
4: It's Subpar and doesn't do anything particularly well. It's certainly not awful, but generally falls flat even compared to the mediocre stuff.
3: It's Far Below Average and completely fails in one or two crucial areas, with the most common failure being the writing of the story.
2: It's Truly Awful and should be avoided. It just fails in multiple major areas which completely drag it down beyond redemption.
1: It's Irredeemable Garbage and it probably shouldn't exist. It's so terrible that you may want to try it just to laugh at it.
NOTE: I do NOT score in a vacuum. I rate almost all anime and manga when compared against other works within the genre or with similar themes. Obviously, there will always be elements of bias within scores.
Comments
Comments have been disabled for this profile.