Previously known as kFYatek.
Rating scale:
My scores are calculated using some rather elaborate Excel sheet that takes six factors into account: memorability, story, consistency, emotional impact, technical quality, and subjective ranking. I had too much trouble calibrating my rating scale in a fair way while rating with more direct methods.
That's why the score boundaries are somewhat blurry and even I don't know exactly how they work :D But in general, it goes more or less like this:
10. Pretty much flawless. Saying anything bad about such show would be extreme nitpicking.
9. I realize some flaws, but the overall enjoyment is still extremely high - still an instant classic that leaves a deep impression.
8. Not the God-tier any more, but it's still a really good watch, well above the average.
7. Enjoyable, but nothing that particularly stands out in the sea of shows. Usually the type of shows you hype about while watching them, but forget about after a month or two.
6. Still enjoyable if you're not expecting a masterpiece, but the kind of show you feel well right from the start that something is off about.
5. Mediocrity level. Watchable, but not worth remembering.
4. Not only not worth remembering - those shows are almost impossible to remember.
3. Just above the watchability threshold. Shows that I've seen, but maybe I wish I haven't.
1, 2. Unwatchable. I'll probably never give those grades, as I generally don't rate shows I haven't finished, and finishing an unwatchable show is pretty much impossible.
Unrated. INSUFFICIENT DATA FOR MEANINGFUL ANSWER, to quote a certain piece of literature. Shows that I don't feel qualified to rate.
|
All Comments (25) Comments
highfive!
Me:
If you are interested you can find the link on my channel.
~Natalia
i even remember that, thank you XD
but he is the most dreadful ball of fur ever... pokémons run with fear when they hear his name.
Kyuubey Trollord does't blink...
...NEVER. XD
ah yes, nice review in Madoka.
Gertrud: 710 Gertrud - minor planet orbiting the sun
Anthony: 272 Antonia - asteroid
Adelbert: 719 Albert - Amor asteroid
Suleika: 563 Suleika - minor planet orbiting the sun
Ulla: 375 Ursula - large main-belt asteroid
Charlotte: Charles - a lunar crater (?)
Pyotr:2720 Pyotr Pervyj - main belt asteroid
Elly: 2650 Elinor - an asteroid
Daniyyel: Daniell - a lunar crater
Albertine: 1290 Albertine - asteroid
Anja: 265 Anna - asteroid
Elsa Maria:182 Elsa and 170 Maria, both asteroids
Sebastians: 1482 - Sebastiana - asteroid
Gisela: 352 Gisela - asteroid
Dora: 668 Dora - main belt asteroid
Uhrmann:
Bartels: 17823 Bartels - a main belt asteroid
Oktavia: 598 Octavia - an asteroid
Holger: 9266 Holger - main-belt asteroid
256 Walpurga - asteroid !!
http://wiki.puella-magi.net/Talk:Gertrud
Some things might be far-fetched, so can you go through it and add things that make sense?
The connection with Josephine seems likely imo.