Report Ashed_13's Profile

Thank you! Is anilist better than mal? From what I know it's more 'customizable' (score being the main thing) but it has fewer entries on the site (obscure anime specials / manga one-shots, dunno). I have an account just for backup on there

Happy birthday!

Thanks for replying! The first episode surprised me as I didn't realy know what was going on until close to the end. I'm not one to analyze the ost while watching but, while it may not be remarkable it at least doesn't feel out of place like in another anime we've talked about ;). I do like the OP a lot and the ED is good too.

Hey, I was watching the Tokyo Revengers anime, it's pretty good actually, and I knew that you've been reading the manga for a while now. I saw that you rated the anime lower than the manga, and I was wondering if there are any 'big' differences between them, or it's a good adaptation but hasn't gotten to the good part yet.
Sorry if this was weird, but I was just curious since I heard good things about it before the anime started.

I'm glad it was a pleasant wish to you. There's a lot going on but i'm safe and good, thanks.
I hope everything goes well for you in this new year n_n

Happy Birthday, have a great day!

Happy birthday! On the same day as mine :O

Oh, did you actually watch it tho ?
I wouldn't have the patience to sit through that...
I watched 1 and a half episodes of it then, to confirm my disgust I actually read the manga all the way through.
I still remember the pain of me completing it and then saying to myself," What ? Why ???? Whatever."

Still, shame the review's counter got reset.

Did you delete your review man or is it a glitch ?
I see the review but it shows " 0 people found this helpful "
Whaaaat.

Your review of Rent a Girlfriend is the best.

You know,there really wasnt any point in writing that review.Its not a 1 that I can confidently say and I think you should reconsider.

To be honest, I didn't pick up the anime until after it had been aired for a while and I don't pay attention to a lot of modern anime because I can't let go of 80s and 90s anime! However, after seeing word of this anime doing the rounds (some good, some bad!), I decided to give it a go. I did see before watching though that a lot of people hated the MC, so I went into it with that in mind. I'd have to agree with their sentiments there.
Honestly, I can half agree with some of your points, I just thought the 1 ratings were a little excessive and responded in the heat of the moment. A little triggered, if you will.

So all in all, I can agree that the anime certainly has weak points, but for me it didn't get in the way of my experience and I think I enjoyed it a little more than you did!

I could send you that response, but honestly it's a little ill-natured. The main reason I deleted it is because I thought it was a little too harsh. It mainly criticised the logic in some of your own criticisms. If you'd still like to see it, I could send it through a message.

Anyway, I appreciate your courteous and civillised response. I respect that. It would be nice if it always went like this! Thanks a lot ^^

I don't know what you and many others were expecting from an anime like Kanojo Okarishimasu. You pick apart, over-analyze and criticise every small detail, as if reviewing a Shakespearean theatre piece or work of art. I take it you don't watch much anime like this because many of your criticisms about it were things that are abundant and commonly seen in other anime of the same genre, and are generally accepted as being "just the way it is". Don't get me wrong, the anime is not exactly the next masterpiece, but I felt your review was irrational and gave more the impression of a rant from an enraged fan rather than a genuine criticism using sound logic and rational thought.

For the record, this not a case of some "butthurt fanboy defending his favourite anime". because it is by all accounts not my favourite anime, not even close. However, in my 7 years on MAL, this is only the 2nd time I've felt compelled enough to respond to another users' review. Any review on any anime that I consider unreasonable or irrational, even one that I do not like myself, would get the same treatment.

I actually composed a response that is more than double the length of this one but eventually decided to shorten it. I have however saved it to my notes in case this turns into a discussion.

Thanks for reading it! It was inspired a little by your review !
I just saw so many plot holes that I just couldn't not write a review about it.
Its pretty sad to see that so many people just give the show a pass just cause it has pretty girls in it. Its ridiculous.
Personally I was pretty hyped for it from the time they released its trailer and just as I watched its first episode, I was like WTF did I just watch ?

It was the biggest letdown for me till date since I started watching anime.😣😶

I even read the manga to make sure that my opinion was correct or not and boy-oh-boy, I've never been more correct.😌

Your review of Kanojo, Okarishimasu is pure gold. I agree with everything you said, especially about the MC, the man is the worst MC to ever exist in the history of anime according to me.