Fire Punch

Edit

What would you like to edit?

SynopsisBackgroundAlternative TitlesPictureChapters/VolumesPublishing DatesRelationsTypeExternal Links  

Its edgy, but it has a reason to be edgy.(this and the last line are the only important points here)

It is a story about a lot of things, as any good story should be; and never gets stagnated always keeping a good rithm. Needless to say, no moment is wasted as everything has a point either thematically narratively, to be funny or a combination or both.

Worderful management of scenes, delivering huge narrative and emotional (fire) punches.

Its not meant for everyone.

Im literally a fanboy of this manga, as you can see by the 10 i gave it, but I really have thought about the quality ... of it, and even re read it and i stand by my words, its not for everyone, but maybe it is for you.

But all I have said doesn't really matters, its just a byproduct of how honest the story is and how much the author cares about it.

Okay, I just finished this today (after taking a long break on it to finish up some things) and I’ve got to say this - do not pay attention to reviews and read this yourself.

At times, I really enjoyed this manga, and other times I couldn’t believe I was still reading it. Some may say that’s a testament to its ability to drag you in and keep you in, but like many of the negative reviews have said, I believe it was mainly because I wanted to see what crazy turn Fujimoto was going to send me down next.

Now, those turns are what makes ... Fire Punch unique, and are why I rate it a 6, but you have to decide that for yourself. Many people try to ascribe a lot of different themes to this manga, themes that I don’t necessarily agree with. On its face, it’s wholly nihilistic, depressing, and little room for redemption, but that can be what draws you to it.

The difficult part for me with respect to the nihilism, and gradual recision of Agni’s character was that, I really enjoy stories with strong protagonists, one’s that I can identify with, or at least, can identify with their motives and reasons for being. Here, while the story is fantastical and, one can argue, damn near impossible to relate to much of anything going on, for much of the later story I couldn’t fathom, or even remotely understand, what the characters were doing. Or perhaps worse, how they got to thinking what they did and acting how they did with respect to the story prior, and that’s Fujimoto’s fault for the lightening fast pacing.

All in all, read this for yourself and decide. You might hate it after 10 chapters, 30 chapters, 60 chapters, I don’t know. But I think it’s worth it enough to at least try.

I initially wanted to do a comprehensive review for Fire Punch. While I hated the experience, I thought maybe there's enough passion and creativity behind it to warrant picking things apart. However, the more time I spent on trying to do that, the less value those elements started to carry, and the more Fire Punch began to look like a plain mess.

It starts with a solid and straightforward premise. Post-apocalyptic frozen world, some people have special powers called blessings, there's allegedly a big bad behind it all, and people are going crazy under these extreme conditions. Then comes a group of people trying to rebuild ... civilization and burn down Agni's village, his sister, and himself for the crime of cannibalism, even if it was in the form of eating endlessly regenerating limbs that Agni provided. He is then doomed to burn and suffer for a long ass time as his endless regeneration counters eternal fire. Years later, Agni learns to control the pain enough to think and move and goes on to get his revenge.
I don't like retelling whole chunks of the plot like that, but I saw this as the solid beginning for the series. It reminds me quite a bit of Hokuto no Ken but edgier in that regard. You have an insane unjust world in a setting where humanity is dying out, but here comes an incredible hero who nobody can stop. It's nothing especially unique, sure, but a pretty good setup for a short action story.

For a while, that's precisely how the story progresses before diving entirely off the rails towards whatever the author thought would be cool or funny or, in many cases, shocking. Fire Punch's lack of any direction or purpose is obscene. It genuinely feels like the whole thing was written without a plan in mind or at least trying to build up from what already exists. Characters appear and then get killed off for no reason. Potential thematic elements are introduced only to be discarded. There's nothing coherent about it. I had some fans tell me and tell others that it's about human connection, hope, emotions, etc., and sure, if you try, you can apply that sort of theme onto the story, but what's the point if the story itself doesn't develop it in any way?
For example, there's a moment later on in the story where a character reveals that they have gender dysphoria, and immediately that was enough for someone to say this is a topic that the manga talks about when in reality, all the discussion or commentary about dysphoria starts and ends with "it sucks." Wow, ok, good talk. Next time have a character also say that war is bad and that rich people are assholes, so it's even more profound.
Another example is Agni's whole role in this. It starts with revenge, but shortly after, the author plays pong with his motivation, what does he want, what does he live for, what does he value, and what does he hate? All these things just get flipped around for the sake of convenience.
There's nothing to take away here, just a bunch of episodes that allow fans to try and ascribe deeper meaning or value to the writing.

So what is left? The art is nice most of the time. In particular, the way Agni is drawn covered in flames is great. There are a few genuinely funny or heartfelt moments, but they're overshadowed by utterly tasteless shock content. Dogs raping kids, goons talking about how they'd rape a little boy, some necrophilia, pointlessly cruel farming of the blessed, a bunch of deaths that only happen for shock factor. It's no better than any other edgy schlock in that regard. Is this worth a read? If you want a good story or a cool action series, no. If you've read Chainsaw Man and thought, "Wow, I wanna read whatever else this genius wrote," then you probably already know the answer and only read this to find out why some asshole would give another masterpiece an unjust 3/10.