Magical abduction okay?

Feb 23, 1:17 PM

#2

Piromysl

Offline

Jul 2015

12397

Is this your first Isekai or something?

Feb 23, 1:38 PM

#3

Animaticide

Offline

Aug 2021

485

This is the weirdest question I have seen all year here

Feb 23, 1:52 PM

#4

ejleon

Offline

Apr 2021

2826

middle_pickup said:
Just finished the first episode. Okay, so homegirl gets abducted from earth yet nobody says a thing about it? She's just...okay with that? Most jarring anime logic I've seen in a while.

They do explain the situation to both women, just not on camera, however, later there are references to it.

Note: I don’t lazily watch 3-5 episodes, biasedly compare to other anime, or unfairly judge by surface level similarities. With every anime I start, I watch the entire series, both Japanese Sub & English Dub, then judge each anime based on what they present, to give an honest and fair rating.

Feb 23, 1:52 PM

#5

Sled_Sled

Offline

Jun 2022

81

I'm So Confused. Isn't That *JUST* Isekai?

I'm level

on mal-badges. View my badges.

Feb 23, 1:55 PM

#6

middle_pickup

Offline

Aug 2022

127

SledFred said:
I'm So Confused. Isn't That *JUST* Isekai?

I mean, kind of but not really. Isekai happens when you die, and get reincarnated I think. This show literally abducted her from her house after she finished working for the day. Big difference imo.

Feb 23, 1:59 PM

#7

middle_pickup

Offline

Aug 2022

127

Piromysl said:
Is this your first Isekai or something?

No. I think this one, if it counts as isekai, is wholly different from the typical reincarnation into a new world after truck-kun killed me sort of thing. Dying is inevitable. We'll all die. Getting to live a second life is a plus, even if it's not in your world. Having your life hijacked before you finish it isn't the same thing.

Feb 23, 2:04 PM

#8

Piromysl

Offline

Jul 2015

12397

middle_pickup said:

Piromysl said:
Is this your first Isekai or something?

No. I think this one, if it counts as isekai, is wholly different from the typical reincarnation into a new world after truck-kun killed me sort of thing. Dying is inevitable. We'll all die. Getting to live a second life is a plus, even if it's not in your world. Having your life hijacked before you finish it isn't the same thing.

Then you should know, that MC being just summoned is quite common and nobody cares within the story.

Feb 23, 2:31 PM

#9

Moppit

Offline

Nov 2018

1306

middle_pickup said:
Just finished the first episode. Okay, so homegirl gets abducted from earth yet nobody says a thing about it? She's just...okay with that? Most jarring anime logic I've seen in a while.

It is still kidnapping. It isn't okay, but the world you're from can't do anything about it. You might as will cooperate or at least pretend to since you don't have any allies.

Feb 23, 2:56 PM

#10

ninaruyi

Offline

Jan 2018

5

I never thought about the abduction part but even if they die and get reincarnated, it always fascinates me that almost no one misses their past life, relationships and especially their freedom from their original world. Magic and harems are good and all but if you have no freedom (this applies mostly to women), what does it even mean.

I'm mostly talking about this anime because some of the scenes in the first season and in the second makes me think that going from a modern world where you had freedom, to live in a magical world where your marriage will be discussed by a group of men is a big no for me. I don't think the protagonist even cares or thinks about that, but it still makes me ponder.

Feb 23, 3:08 PM

#11

SenshadouOtaku

Offline

May 2023

465

middle_pickup said:

SledFred said:
I'm So Confused. Isn't That *JUST* Isekai?

I mean, kind of but not really. Isekai happens when you die, and get reincarnated I think. This show literally abducted her from her house after she finished working for the day. Big difference imo.

Reincarnation is when you die. Isekai is when you get transported into a different world. Nice try

Feb 23, 5:12 PM

#12

Moppit

Offline

Nov 2018

1306

SledFred said:
I'm So Confused. Isn't That *JUST* Isekai?

Isekai is just a nice way of saying abduction. Still it's against there will but being forced to another dimension or world instead.

MoppitFeb 23, 7:00 PM

Feb 23, 6:59 PM

#13

N1nj4L1nk

Offline

Jul 2022

91

Isekai literally means in another world. You could get there by dying, being summoned, being sucked into a (game/show/book), by getting into a magic wardrobe, putting on a magic ring then jumping into a puddle, or falling through a crack in spacetime. How you get there doesn't change the genre.

Feb 23, 7:07 PM

#14

CrazyButNot4U

Offline

Mar 2013

3762

This thread is stupid but hilarious. 🤣
This is definitely their first isekai series. In fact, the genre is already too old to get that reaction. 😏

It's not that I dislike this genre but... to add unnecessary fan services to/in/for heroines
and ultimately destroys her character and personality; their purity tarnished because of it,
is the only thing I hope to not happen to them. For that sole purity is my fan service.

Feb 23, 8:35 PM

#15

middle_pickup

Offline

Aug 2022

127

Piromysl said:

middle_pickup said:

No. I think this one, if it counts as isekai, is wholly different from the typical reincarnation into a new world after truck-kun killed me sort of thing. Dying is inevitable. We'll all die. Getting to live a second life is a plus, even if it's not in your world. Having your life hijacked before you finish it isn't the same thing.

Then you should know, that MC being just summoned is quite common and nobody cares within the story.

Exactly. Anime logic. It's silly.

Feb 23, 8:41 PM

#16

middle_pickup

Offline

Aug 2022

127

CrazyButNot4U said:
This thread is stupid but hilarious. 🤣
This is definitely their first isekai series. In fact, the genre is already too old to get that reaction. 😏

I have avoided/dropped most of the isekai series out there since storytelling hinged on trope mechanics doesn't interest me. Though I have watched, and enjoyed the one everyone else agreed is good-Konosuba. Trying to think of others, but they're kind of forgettable to me I guess.

Feb 24, 7:47 AM

#17

ejleon

Offline

Apr 2021

2826

middle_pickup said:

Piromysl said:

Then you should know, that MC being just summoned is quite common and nobody cares within the story.

Exactly. Anime logic. It's silly.

But they did talk to both of them about the summoning … it has a flashback later.

I just rewatched the show, so it’s not that didn’t explain anything to them.

Note: I don’t lazily watch 3-5 episodes, biasedly compare to other anime, or unfairly judge by surface level similarities. With every anime I start, I watch the entire series, both Japanese Sub & English Dub, then judge each anime based on what they present, to give an honest and fair rating.

Feb 24, 11:04 AM

#18

Sayge45

Offline

Aug 2023

40

I mean I'm pretty sure she didn't die though It would fine if she's dead but not really if she's alive

Feb 24, 11:06 AM

#19

Sayge45

Offline

Aug 2023

40

it's more like transmigration than an iseaki I could be wrong it been like 2 years since I finished the 1st season

Feb 24, 12:15 PM

#20

Gl0rp

Offline

Feb 2022

299

N1nj4L1nk said:
Isekai literally means in another world. You could get there by dying, being summoned, being sucked into a (game/show/book), by getting into a magic wardrobe, putting on a magic ring then jumping into a puddle, or falling through a crack in spacetime. How you get there doesn't change the genre.

Out of curiosity is there an anime where someone puts on a magic ring, jumps into a puddle and because of that goes to another world? If not it should definitely be made.

Feb 24, 1:14 PM

#21

N1nj4L1nk

Offline

Jul 2022

91

Gl0rp said:

N1nj4L1nk said:
Isekai literally means in another world. You could get there by dying, being summoned, being sucked into a (game/show/book), by getting into a magic wardrobe, putting on a magic ring then jumping into a puddle, or falling through a crack in spacetime. How you get there doesn't change the genre.

Out of curiosity is there an anime where someone puts on a magic ring, jumps into a puddle and because of that goes to another world? If not it should definitely be made.

No but there is a Western book, "The Magicians Nephew". It is Chronologically the first Narnia book but I would suggest reading it second to last.

Feb 24, 1:29 PM

#22

Gl0rp

Offline

Feb 2022

299

N1nj4L1nk said:

Gl0rp said:

Out of curiosity is there an anime where someone puts on a magic ring, jumps into a puddle and because of that goes to another world? If not it should definitely be made.

No but there is a Western book, "The Magicians Nephew". It is Chronologically the first Narnia book but I would suggest reading it second to last.

Give it the anime treatment and I'm game. It can get pretty weird in a hilarious way when they make an anime out of a western story. :)

Feb 25, 4:13 AM

#23

N1nj4L1nk

Offline

Jul 2022

91

Gl0rp said:

N1nj4L1nk said:

No but there is a Western book, "The Magicians Nephew". It is Chronologically the first Narnia book but I would suggest reading it second to last.

Give it the anime treatment and I'm game. It can get pretty weird in a hilarious way when they make an anime out of a western story. :)

I agree, all of Narnia should be turned into an anime. With the right studio they would work really well.

Feb 25, 11:22 AM

#24

Ragon_Qc

Offline

Nov 2021

220

Doesn't matter if it's right or wrong. They can't do anything about it so they go with. You can't demand to see the manager.

» worth watching? Kitsune_089 - Oct 8	9	by naceale2019 »» Oct 16, 4:52 PM
» Do girls actually like this? IhnalakoKaina - Aug 22	9	by Vaturna »» Aug 22, 12:51 PM
Poll: » Seijo no Maryoku wa Bannou Desu Episode 2 Discussion ( 1 2 ) Stark700 - Apr 13, 2021	93	by SashaJoye »» Jul 3, 7:04 PM
Poll: » Seijo no Maryoku wa Bannou Desu Episode 12 Discussion ( 1 2 3 ) Stark700 - Jun 22, 2021	111	by HiljainenSipuli »» Jun 30, 12:44 PM
Poll: » Seijo no Maryoku wa Bannou Desu Episode 11 Discussion Stark700 - Jun 15, 2021	46	by HiljainenSipuli »» Jun 29, 8:55 PM

Magical abduction okay?

More topics from this board

» worth watching?

» Do girls actually like this?

Poll: » Seijo no Maryoku wa Bannou Desu Episode 2 Discussion ( 1 2 )

Poll: » Seijo no Maryoku wa Bannou Desu Episode 12 Discussion ( 1 2 3 )

Poll: » Seijo no Maryoku wa Bannou Desu Episode 11 Discussion

MoreTop Anime

MoreTop Airing Anime

MoreMost Popular Characters