Forum Settings
Forums
New
Sep 12, 2022 10:17 AM
#1
Offline
Aug 2021
419
So in chapter 48 Mafuyu says that he’s afraid to attend the concert because he knows he has to choose between music and Uenoyama but I’m so confused. Why does he think he has to choose one or the other?? They’re literally in the band together lol can someone pls explain cause I’m definitely missing something here.
Sep 12, 2022 11:42 PM
#2

Offline
Jun 2021
2965
kakashis_sidehoe said:
So in chapter 48 Mafuyu says that he’s afraid to attend the concert because he knows he has to choose between music and Uenoyama but I’m so confused. Why does he think he has to choose one or the other?? They’re literally in the band together lol can someone pls explain cause I’m definitely missing something here.


That was the case with Ugetsu and Akihiko (Chapters 15-28: Vol. 3: Chap. 15-16.5, Vol. 4: Chap 17-21.5 and Vol. 5: 22-28.5 (https://www.reddit.com/r/GivenAnime/comments/ldy5af/movie_here_i_listed_the_content_of_the_manga_that/); also tackled in Given Movie). I think Mafuyu thought something similar would apply to him and Uenoyama; he thought he has to put music and Uenoyama on a scale ⚖️ just like Ugetsu did with music and Akihiko. But they are different from Ugetsu and Akihiko. And it looks like he's afraid things would change (well, things will definitely change once they debut and they're also graduating). Some people don't really welcome change because of all the uncertainty or find it hard to adjust to changes. Plus, he's also afraid of making the wrong choice. So he ruminates on a lot of things to be certain before taking any action; it also has something to do with what happened to him and Yuki when Yuki started the SYH band as Yuki spent more time with music and away from Mafuyu.

Yeah, you're right they're in the same band so it's a bit confusing. But like Ugetsu said, Mafuyu neglected factoring in what Uenoyama thinks. So before Mafuyu decides whether to debut or not with Given, Ugetsu suggests Mafuyu listen to what Uenoyama has to say first hence attending the concert (to listen to the music Uenoyama and SYH finished which is actually Yuki's song for Mafuyu; of course both Mafuyu and Ugetsu know nothing of this).

This is just a rough explanation.
IridescentJauneSep 12, 2022 11:46 PM
Sep 13, 2022 8:54 AM
#3
Offline
Aug 2021
419
IridescentJaune said:
kakashis_sidehoe said:
So in chapter 48 Mafuyu says that he’s afraid to attend the concert because he knows he has to choose between music and Uenoyama but I’m so confused. Why does he think he has to choose one or the other?? They’re literally in the band together lol can someone pls explain cause I’m definitely missing something here.


That was the case with Ugetsu and Akihiko (Chapters 15-28: Vol. 3: Chap. 15-16.5, Vol. 4: Chap 17-21.5 and Vol. 5: 22-28.5 (https://www.reddit.com/r/GivenAnime/comments/ldy5af/movie_here_i_listed_the_content_of_the_manga_that/); also tackled in Given Movie). I think Mafuyu thought something similar would apply to him and Uenoyama; he thought he has to put music and Uenoyama on a scale ⚖️ just like Ugetsu did with music and Akihiko. But they are different from Ugetsu and Akihiko. And it looks like he's afraid things would change (well, things will definitely change once they debut and they're also graduating). Some people don't really welcome change because of all the uncertainty or find it hard to adjust to changes. Plus, he's also afraid of making the wrong choice. So he ruminates on a lot of things to be certain before taking any action; it also has something to do with what happened to him and Yuki when Yuki started the SYH band as Yuki spent more time with music and away from Mafuyu.

Yeah, you're right they're in the same band so it's a bit confusing. But like Ugetsu said, Mafuyu neglected factoring in what Uenoyama thinks. So before Mafuyu decides whether to debut or not with Given, Ugetsu suggests Mafuyu listen to what Uenoyama has to say first hence attending the concert (to listen to the music Uenoyama and SYH finished which is actually Yuki's song for Mafuyu; of course both Mafuyu and Ugetsu know nothing of this).

This is just a rough explanation.

Thank u sm for clearing that up, that makes a lot of sense

More topics from this board

Poll: » Given Chapter 27 Discussion

Danae - Aug 19, 2019

5 by puckisha »»
Sep 19, 2024 4:14 PM

Poll: » Given Chapter 21 Discussion

Shu0chan - Feb 13, 2019

4 by puckisha »»
Sep 19, 2024 2:04 PM

Poll: » Given Chapter 20 Discussion

Danae - Aug 18, 2019

3 by puckisha »»
Sep 19, 2024 1:29 PM

Poll: » Given Chapter 18 Discussion

wawawawawawawawa - Apr 29, 2019

2 by puckisha »»
Sep 19, 2024 12:54 PM

Poll: » Given Chapter 11 Discussion

SkyFullOfStars - Jul 12, 2019

2 by puckisha »»
Sep 19, 2024 7:51 AM
It’s time to ditch the text file.
Keep track of your anime easily by creating your own list.
Sign Up Login