Season 2 announced!

Deku251 said:
I pray to god that they retcon the last 3 episodes of S1, because I really hate it when an anime is doing it's own thing instead of following the manga. Besides that, it would be a waste to not adapt the manga to it's full extend, it's only getting started from where the anime went anime only. Hope the best.

Opticflash said:


Dude, a studio should not retcon something simply because YOU personally didn't like it. There is nothing wrong with the last 3 episodes; the conclusion to episode 13 is almost exactly the same as if the last few episodes didn't happen.

Deku251 said:
You will understand it if you read the manga. I don't have to tell you what happens when an anime decides to go anime-only, and if you don't, just look at Promised Neverland. And I'm not the only one, a lot of people who read the manga thought that the last 3 episodes were rushed AF. No wonder, they skipped like 20 chapter of the manga and added plot twists that didn't even happen in the manga. Even if they wanted to follow the manga from here on, they simply can't, they would need to skip entire arcs, and nobody wants that, just believe me here.
All I'm saying is that it would be a shame if they decide to do there own thing, as I said before, they would need to skip entire arcs in order to make a little sense, so it would just be wasted potential.

Deku251 said:
You will understand it if you read the manga. I don't have to tell you what happens when an anime decides to go anime-only, and if you don't, just look at Promised Neverland. And I'm not the only one, a lot of people who read the manga thought that the last 3 episodes were rushed AF. No wonder, they skipped like 20 chapter of the manga and added plot twists that didn't even happen in the manga. Even if they wanted to follow the manga from here on, they simply can't, they would need to skip entire arcs, and nobody wants that, just believe me here.
All I'm saying is that it would be a shame if they decide to do there own thing, as I said before, they would need to skip entire arcs in order to make a little sense, so it would just be wasted potential.

chriskor022 said:
i read the manga and your opinion make sense for starters its not like TPN2 are u serious. And they adapt faithfully and end on chapter 50. The only nitpick is the reveal of Shirley being alive. So i dont know what manga you read. Because its does not bad like you saying

Deku251 said:
Did you read the previous chapters too? In like chapter 20 or something they skipped Robe-sama, an important character for the upcoming arc. In my opinion skipping a major character is far from nitpicking.
Then they healed Lou and Ricky with the power of plot instead of the OG manga route, they added a new part with Edward where he pisses of the star bearers and the great grandfather, which is something that goes against his goal, so he should never do it, they let him do it anyway, they made it clear for Edward and his gang that Kate is against the great grandfather, they go all out of there way in manga to get solid prove for that.
Maybe it is not as bad as Promised Neverland, but if it continues this way, it surely will,

Did you read the previous chapters too? In like chapter 20 or something they skipped Robe-sama, an important character for the upcoming arc. In my opinion skipping a major character is far from nitpicking.

Then they healed Lou and Ricky with the power of plot instead of the OG manga route

Edward where he pisses of the star bearers and the great grandfather, which is something that goes against his goal, so he should never do it, they let him do it anyway, they made it clear for Edward and his gang that Kate is against the great grandfather, they go all out of there way in manga to get solid prove for that.

but if it continues this way, it surely will, and if they wanted to make a faithful adaptation, why did they change so much things? Clover Works made it clear that they want to make an anime based on Shadows House, but with there own story and twists, they wouldn't have changed it otherwise

chriskor022 said:
are u blind they gonna adapt robe sama where is the evidence that they skipped it. And you dont know the reason they cut, but in sequel they gonna adapt it. Its nitpicking and not just that irs borderline stupid

the eyes being healed are not confirmed in the manga its in line that its instant recollection of there memories.

its the same as the manga because Edward is suspicious about Kate and because in manga you can see that he was not making anymore just adding in the lore to establish how Edward making his move in the future. And the status quo by grandfather is good decision because of how useful Edward in Shadows house. And they dont adapt the all out because its after the robe sama arc, so your assumption is not true

its not gonna change because its author decision and producers to change the final episodes but if ever got a sequel they gonna back on track. Thats why last year and now the author is hiatus by months to help the scripts. Thankfully the author is transparent in twitter you visit her twitter account to confirmed some things

Deku251 said:
Okay, I've read the manga chapters again and re-watched the last 3 episodes and what you are saying doesn't make any sense. Where is the proof that they skipped Robe-sama? Just watch the damn Anime with booth your eyes, there is your proof. And why do you believe that they are going to adapt Robe-sama, if they already skipped her? Either you have a time machine, or you have inhaled a lot of copium.
And yes, the eyes being healed is a sign that they also heales soot-sickness, it was basically explained, so I don't know what else to say here.
It is bad that they included the part where Edward makes his move against Kate in the last 3 episodes, because the conclusion from this is that the great grandfather is on bad terms with Edward. It is not possible to be faithful to the manga when you put 2 characters against each other when they were on good terms in the manga. It will led to problems, without question. I don't want to spoil the manga here more then I'm already doing, but it gets more clear when you take the most recent events with Edward into perspective.
Sadly, I can't read japanese, so I'm working with what google translate spits out. What I understand from these translations is that she isn't working close with the staff, she just said that the same staff is working on S2. I can't find any reason why you would assume that she is on hiatus just because of S2. But again, this could easily be a mistranslation on my part. But if its true what you are saying, and it really was her idea to change the last 3 episodes, then it would only support my standpoint, because it would increase the sales, like the second season of Promised Neverland made the manga sales skyrocket because people wanted to know what really happened. If you can recall it, this mess of a second season was also the mangakas idea.
This is going to be my last answer here, because it is just a waste of time. I'm not going to convince you, and neither will you me. If you are unable to see the sad reality here, then I'm sorry, I can't help you.