Forum SettingsEpisode Information
Forums
New
Pages (2) « 1 [2]
Feb 11, 10:52 PM
🍅 Tomato 🍅

Offline
Feb 2020
102752
Yay! It's added. :3
Feb 12, 10:39 PM
Offline
Mar 2016
117
OK, now add the Rick and Morty anime and the shorts as well. :)
Feb 12, 11:00 PM

Offline
Sep 2020
5382
Reply to wjbraden
OK, now add the Rick and Morty anime and the shorts as well. :)
@wjbraden Rick and Morty is not an anime.
Feb 13, 9:38 AM
Offline
Mar 2016
117
Reply to ZXEAN
@wjbraden Rick and Morty is not an anime.
@ZXEAN There's an anime coming this year, directed by Takashi Sano (who also directed Tower of God, among others) from Telecom Animation Film https://www.animenewsnetwork.com/encyclopedia/anime.php?id=25711

There are also several other anime shorts from Sano and other Japanese animators that have come out in the last few years. I tried adding them to the database here and they were all unapproved and deleted (despite having all these Japanese credentials, and said shorts being in Japanese, sub-only). It's all quite clearly anime, the only thing is they were never released in Japan (yet anyway).

MAL is going to have to get with the times and realize that as anime gets more and more international, more stuff like anime premiering first in the US and other countries is only going to increase.
Feb 13, 9:43 AM

Offline
Sep 2020
5382
Reply to wjbraden
@ZXEAN There's an anime coming this year, directed by Takashi Sano (who also directed Tower of God, among others) from Telecom Animation Film https://www.animenewsnetwork.com/encyclopedia/anime.php?id=25711

There are also several other anime shorts from Sano and other Japanese animators that have come out in the last few years. I tried adding them to the database here and they were all unapproved and deleted (despite having all these Japanese credentials, and said shorts being in Japanese, sub-only). It's all quite clearly anime, the only thing is they were never released in Japan (yet anyway).

MAL is going to have to get with the times and realize that as anime gets more and more international, more stuff like anime premiering first in the US and other countries is only going to increase.
@wjbraden Didn't knew about that. Hopefully thay add those anime as well.
Feb 15, 10:24 PM
Offline
Nov 2019
14
Oh, it's finally added! Cool!

Feb 15, 10:26 PM
Offline
Nov 2019
14
Reply to wjbraden
@ZXEAN There's an anime coming this year, directed by Takashi Sano (who also directed Tower of God, among others) from Telecom Animation Film https://www.animenewsnetwork.com/encyclopedia/anime.php?id=25711

There are also several other anime shorts from Sano and other Japanese animators that have come out in the last few years. I tried adding them to the database here and they were all unapproved and deleted (despite having all these Japanese credentials, and said shorts being in Japanese, sub-only). It's all quite clearly anime, the only thing is they were never released in Japan (yet anyway).

MAL is going to have to get with the times and realize that as anime gets more and more international, more stuff like anime premiering first in the US and other countries is only going to increase.
@wjbraden
wjbraden said:

MAL is going to have to get with the times and realize that as anime gets more and more international, more stuff like anime premiering first in the US and other countries is only going to increase.


By MAL's logic, JoJo Part 6 is not an anime. /j
Feb 16, 12:49 PM

Offline
Oct 2019
912
Reply to HawKeye09
I was also wondering why it isn’t getting added to the database. However, finally it is!
In case of the debate whether it’s an anime or not, obviously it’s an anime.

1. Sunghoo Park is a Japanese anime director (even tho he is Korean) as he has done JJK 0, JJK S1, Monsters etc.

2. Ninja Kamui has Japanese voice casting as every anime should have

3. Almost all of the production members are Japanese except some of them being non Japanese/Asian. Mind you this also happened to Cyberpunk Edgerunners and there were also non Asian people involved but eventually it was a product of Studio Trigger and managed to win the anime of the year award. Here, Ninja Kamui is a product of E&H which is owned by Subghoo Park himself.

4. Even the theme song performing band (Coldrain) is Japanese, it’s just they make songs in English and nowadays many anime choose English songs as OPs EDs.

What should not be considered as anime are Arcane, Blue Eye Samurai, Vox Machina, Castlevania etc as those are not originally from Japan. Those are in general animated series, not “ANIME”.
@HawKeye09 The sole criterion for a MAL inclusion appears to be a relaxed or limited form of #3:

1. Thomas LeSean, the director and original creator of Cannon Busters is neither Japanese nor Chinese/Korean, so #1 is irrelevant.

2. Chinese shows animated by Chinese studios such as Mo Dao Zu Shi were included way before a Japanese dialogue version was released - or without one being released at all. Hence #2 is probably irrelevant.*

4. Multiple anime or their Korean / Chinese brethren have featured western songs by western bands, so #4 is also irrelevant.

MAL includes a subset of #3. Said subset means an animated work created -or co-created- by a Japanese, Korean or Chinese studio*. That's it. Due to studios doing extensive outsourcing globally, to both freelancers and other studios, I do not think the mix of the creative team matters.

Only the animation studio matters. The distribution company or the company that commissions the work is also irrelevant. As is the style of the work, which can be explicitly non anime(etc)-like (see Ousama Ranking for a recent example).

*With, I think, Japanese or Korean or Chinese dialogues also being mandatory; but if anyone knows of an approved submission made by a Japanese/Korean/Chinese studio with only western dialogues please let me know.
Feb 16, 1:11 PM

Offline
Oct 2019
912
Reply to wjbraden
@ZXEAN There's an anime coming this year, directed by Takashi Sano (who also directed Tower of God, among others) from Telecom Animation Film https://www.animenewsnetwork.com/encyclopedia/anime.php?id=25711

There are also several other anime shorts from Sano and other Japanese animators that have come out in the last few years. I tried adding them to the database here and they were all unapproved and deleted (despite having all these Japanese credentials, and said shorts being in Japanese, sub-only). It's all quite clearly anime, the only thing is they were never released in Japan (yet anyway).

MAL is going to have to get with the times and realize that as anime gets more and more international, more stuff like anime premiering first in the US and other countries is only going to increase.
@wjbraden I was not aware a release in Japan was a criterion. So until/unless an anime is released in Japan it cannot be added here even if it's wholesale Japanese?
Feb 16, 1:53 PM
Offline
Mar 2016
117
Reply to Sharpedon
@wjbraden I was not aware a release in Japan was a criterion. So until/unless an anime is released in Japan it cannot be added here even if it's wholesale Japanese?
@Sharpedon It's not, but it sure seems like they want it to be.
Feb 16, 1:55 PM
Offline
Apr 2020
101
so this CARTOON is anime but Scott Pilgrim takes off is not

MAL you are fu...
Feb 17, 5:15 AM

Offline
Feb 2009
103
smokinhaze said:
Fr but I feel like ninja kamui is definitely gonna be approved it’s fucking peak bro . But the real issue is that mal don’t include American animation like for example The Legend of Vox Machina , blood of Zeus and arcane .I can go one there so much with this animation style that mal ignores or sum .

Old Post but it's not even American animation if it was it definitely shouldn't be here but it's not
Feb 17, 7:31 PM

Offline
Sep 2020
5382
@smokinhaze It's being made by "E&H Production" which is a Japanese studio.
Feb 17, 7:35 PM

Offline
Feb 2009
103
smokinhaze said:
@-Crimson- no ur wrong ninja kamui is an American animation wym?? It’s from adult swim . And yes it should definitely be on here regardless it’s gonna be peak .

It's not lol, literally the guy who worked in mappa started his own studio and this is the series it made, it's not american whatsoever. You are the wrong one here.
Feb 17, 7:41 PM

Offline
Jan 2024
42
Reply to -Crimson-
smokinhaze said:
@-Crimson- no ur wrong ninja kamui is an American animation wym?? It’s from adult swim . And yes it should definitely be on here regardless it’s gonna be peak .

It's not lol, literally the guy who worked in mappa started his own studio and this is the series it made, it's not american whatsoever. You are the wrong one here.
@-Crimson- yea i worded it wrong it’s obviously animated by a Japanese studio .but how is it not American tho ? Adult swim is licensing this anime in America. Ur getting too mad I’m high 24/7 don’t take me seriously :p
Feb 17, 7:42 PM

Offline
Feb 2009
103
smokinhaze said:
@-Crimson- yea i worded it wrong it’s obviously animated by a Japanese studio .but how is it not American tho ? Adult swim is licensing this anime in America. Ur getting too mad I’m high 24/7 don’t take me seriously :p

I honestly do find it odd myself I couldn't tell ya I just know about the studio and that it's made by them.
Feb 17, 7:54 PM

Offline
Feb 2009
103
smokinhaze said:
@-Crimson- yea I’m dumb it’s a Japanese anime it’s just this anime popped up hella on adult swim it threw me off. we haven’t had a anime on adult swim ina while too .

Lol that's okay dude, I can see how that could throw you off and be confusing.
Feb 18, 6:06 AM

Offline
Apr 2011
90
Why do you care what other people think if you have a great time watching it? Also, calling everything "peak fiction" must be a way to express your ignorance for your generation. Everything must be peak or mid for you guys, all you care about is hype.
Pages (2) « 1 [2]

More topics from this board

Poll: » Ninja Kamui Episode 1 Discussion ( 1 2 3 4 5 )

IzanaSolos - Feb 10

225 by dhell26 »»
Dec 16, 10:40 PM

Poll: » Ninja Kamui Episode 13 Discussion ( 1 2 3 )

IzanaSolos - May 4

145 by zibeline »»
Dec 2, 12:17 AM

» Why is Ninja Kamui allowed to be on MAL? ( 1 2 )

Zenbers - Mar 17

63 by mikebz45 »»
Oct 23, 10:21 AM

Poll: » Ninja Kamui Episode 4 Discussion

FireRifle64 - Mar 2

46 by Cersil »»
Oct 21, 1:19 PM

Poll: » Ninja Kamui Episode 3 Discussion ( 1 2 )

IzanaSolos - Feb 24

58 by Cersil »»
Oct 21, 1:14 PM
It’s time to ditch the text file.
Keep track of your anime easily by creating your own list.
Sign Up Login