Forum Settings
Forums
A Silent Voice
Available on Manga Store
New
Pages (2) « 1 [2]
Oct 28, 2021 1:38 AM

Offline
Aug 2019
188
Shiro_Yasha78 said:
FluffyExpress said:
Its almost like no one is seeing the MAIN THEME that is forgiveness within this movie. In the beginning, Shoya was just as much in the wrong as Ueno. No matter what he did to fix his mistakes, he didn’t deserve forgiveness, yet he was forgiven. I truly suggest anyone who hates Ueno watch this movie again with an actual heart inside them. Believe me, it will open up your world in a way where you can actually see how great this movie is. Hating Ueno simply makes you as an audience member self-centered. But it’s okay, I forgive you. I’m only here to help :).
Yup, totally agreed. If Shoya deserves forgiveness then Ueno does obviously, in the end she seem to understand what she did was wrong(at least that's what I think). The real bitch is Kawai(the self-centred blonde girl), I really despise her kind.

We still must forgive….
Oct 31, 2021 4:06 AM
Offline
Jan 2011
1115
FluffyExpress said:
Its almost like no one is seeing the MAIN THEME that is forgiveness within this movie. In the beginning, Shoya was just as much in the wrong as Ueno. No matter what he did to fix his mistakes, he didn’t deserve forgiveness, yet he was forgiven. I truly suggest anyone who hates Ueno watch this movie again with an actual heart inside them. Believe me, it will open up your world in a way where you can actually see how great this movie is. Hating Ueno simply makes you as an audience member self-centered. But it’s okay, I forgive you. I’m only here to help :).


He was about to make the ultimate sacrifice for her. So that is redemption worthy.
Nov 4, 2021 5:48 PM
Offline
Oct 2021
1
Hmm. I definitely dislike Ueno for a lot of the movie, however, with the final scene I would say that it is supposed to show the personality 'mending' and her undergoing personal growth to become a better person. I think if her character was fleshed out a bit more and there was more focus at the ending this point would be stronger but I believe we are supposed to hate her less at the very least towards the end.
Feb 8, 2022 2:45 PM
ダンダダン

Offline
Jun 2015
532
fu*k it i just finish rewarching this movie and man I hate her character so much that if I was a character in this movie I'd beat the living shit outta her who da f*ck acts this rude who pissed in ur tea and biscuits she needs someone to put her in her place

Feb 12, 2022 2:47 AM
Offline
Feb 2022
8
Kelly32723 said:
Lyrexx said:

It doesn’t really change her character either way, but you should really read the manga. They cut out several important things in the movie. The manga was way better. I like Naoka though. She’s a bitch, but she’s at least upfront about it I guess. And I mean, she fits more with Shoya than Shoko does in my opinion. He’s probably not good enough for Shoko, and their relationship’s pretty much built around guilt. It’s really fragile. She’s a bitch though, so I understand why she’s very hated

Ofc in my opinion I’d say Shouko and Ishida fit better but you have your own opinion so just hold on to it ig.
On to the main point. I personally would say that Ueno had no need to do anything to Shouko? Wether it be jealousy or what happened when Ishida saved Shouko she’s completely ignoring everything shes done to her in her childhood. Hitting her badmouthing her just hating her in general. Like when she was mad at her and threw her against the wall that pissed me off. In my mind: (YOU HURT HER YOU MADE HER HATE HERSELF BECAUSE SHE COULDNT HEAR YOU. YOU WERE ONE OF THE REASONS blah blah blah) and I’d say it’s true (I want to think it’s true anyway 💀)
In the end she’s a bit too jealous I think and she’s a bitch
Kawai can dig a hole and live in it without ac
Feb 12, 2022 12:14 PM
Offline
Jul 2021
997
MannyChii said:
Kelly32723 said:

It doesn’t really change her character either way, but you should really read the manga. They cut out several important things in the movie. The manga was way better. I like Naoka though. She’s a bitch, but she’s at least upfront about it I guess. And I mean, she fits more with Shoya than Shoko does in my opinion. He’s probably not good enough for Shoko, and their relationship’s pretty much built around guilt. It’s really fragile. She’s a bitch though, so I understand why she’s very hated

Ofc in my opinion I’d say Shouko and Ishida fit better but you have your own opinion so just hold on to it ig.
On to the main point. I personally would say that Ueno had no need to do anything to Shouko? Wether it be jealousy or what happened when Ishida saved Shouko she’s completely ignoring everything shes done to her in her childhood. Hitting her badmouthing her just hating her in general. Like when she was mad at her and threw her against the wall that pissed me off. In my mind: (YOU HURT HER YOU MADE HER HATE HERSELF BECAUSE SHE COULDNT HEAR YOU. YOU WERE ONE OF THE REASONS blah blah blah) and I’d say it’s true (I want to think it’s true anyway 💀)
In the end she’s a bit too jealous I think and she’s a bitch
Kawai can dig a hole and live in it without ac

Oh yeah Kawaii just unredeemably a bitch. At least she didn’t end up with Satoshi though. Wait actually, I could see Shouya together with either of them. He has better chemistry with Naoka still imo, but a relationship with Shouko would probably also work out. Everyone around them would support it too, so unless they just end up not being meant to be together or smth, it should work out. One bad thing though is that Shouko is too nice to just be upfront about issues she has with him. He might have to really watch what he says around her too, which can be really draining. Because she is emotionally weak and could get depressed again if he says the wrong thing. Yeah I’d prefer Naoka with Shouya nvm, the relationship between Shouya and Shouko would be unintentionally a little toxic imo due to not that much communication about important issues
Feb 12, 2022 12:17 PM
Offline
Feb 2022
8
Kelly32723 said:
MannyChii said:

Ofc in my opinion I’d say Shouko and Ishida fit better but you have your own opinion so just hold on to it ig.
On to the main point. I personally would say that Ueno had no need to do anything to Shouko? Wether it be jealousy or what happened when Ishida saved Shouko she’s completely ignoring everything shes done to her in her childhood. Hitting her badmouthing her just hating her in general. Like when she was mad at her and threw her against the wall that pissed me off. In my mind: (YOU HURT HER YOU MADE HER HATE HERSELF BECAUSE SHE COULDNT HEAR YOU. YOU WERE ONE OF THE REASONS blah blah blah) and I’d say it’s true (I want to think it’s true anyway 💀)
In the end she’s a bit too jealous I think and she’s a bitch
Kawai can dig a hole and live in it without ac

Oh yeah Kawaii just unredeemably a bitch. At least she didn’t end up with Satoshi though. Wait actually, I could see Shouya together with either of them. He has better chemistry with Naoka still imo, but a relationship with Shouko would probably also work out. Everyone around them would support it too, so unless they just end up not being meant to be together or smth, it should work out. One bad thing though is that Shouko is too nice to just be upfront about issues she has with him. He might have to really watch what he says around her too, which can be really draining. Because she is emotionally weak and could get depressed again if he says the wrong thing. Yeah I’d prefer Naoka with Shouya nvm, the relationship between Shouya and Shouko would be unintentionally a little toxic imo due to not that much communication about important issues
Kelly32723 said:
MannyChii said:

Ofc in my opinion I’d say Shouko and Ishida fit better but you have your own opinion so just hold on to it ig.
On to the main point. I personally would say that Ueno had no need to do anything to Shouko? Wether it be jealousy or what happened when Ishida saved Shouko she’s completely ignoring everything shes done to her in her childhood. Hitting her badmouthing her just hating her in general. Like when she was mad at her and threw her against the wall that pissed me off. In my mind: (YOU HURT HER YOU MADE HER HATE HERSELF BECAUSE SHE COULDNT HEAR YOU. YOU WERE ONE OF THE REASONS blah blah blah) and I’d say it’s true (I want to think it’s true anyway 💀)
In the end she’s a bit too jealous I think and she’s a bitch
Kawai can dig a hole and live in it without ac

Oh yeah Kawaii just unredeemably a bitch. At least she didn’t end up with Satoshi though. Wait actually, I could see Shouya together with either of them. He has better chemistry with Naoka still imo, but a relationship with Shouko would probably also work out. Everyone around them would support it too, so unless they just end up not being meant to be together or smth, it should work out. One bad thing though is that Shouko is too nice to just be upfront about issues she has with him. He might have to really watch what he says around her too, which can be really draining. Because she is emotionally weak and could get depressed again if he says the wrong thing. Yeah I’d prefer Naoka with Shouya nvm, the relationship between Shouya and Shouko would be unintentionally a little toxic imo due to not that much communication about important issues
MannyChii said:
Kelly32723 said:

It doesn’t really change her character either way, but you should really read the manga. They cut out several important things in the movie. The manga was way better. I like Naoka though. She’s a bitch, but she’s at least upfront about it I guess. And I mean, she fits more with Shoya than Shoko does in my opinion. He’s probably not good enough for Shoko, and their relationship’s pretty much built around guilt. It’s really fragile. She’s a bitch though, so I understand why she’s very hated

Ofc in my opinion I’d say Shouko and Ishida fit better but you have your own opinion so just hold on to it ig.
On to the main point. I personally would say that Ueno had no need to do anything to Shouko? Wether it be jealousy or what happened when Ishida saved Shouko she’s completely ignoring everything shes done to her in her childhood. Hitting her badmouthing her just hating her in general. Like when she was mad at her and threw her against the wall that pissed me off. In my mind: (YOU HURT HER YOU MADE HER HATE HERSELF BECAUSE SHE COULDNT HEAR YOU. YOU WERE ONE OF THE REASONS blah blah blah) and I’d say it’s true (I want to think it’s true anyway 💀)
In the end she’s a bit too jealous I think and she’s a bitch
Kawai can dig a hole and live in it without ac
hdm
Kelly32723 said:
MannyChii said:

Ofc in my opinion I’d say Shouko and Ishida fit better but you have your own opinion so just hold on to it ig.
On to the main point. I personally would say that Ueno had no need to do anything to Shouko? Wether it be jealousy or what happened when Ishida saved Shouko she’s completely ignoring everything shes done to her in her childhood. Hitting her badmouthing her just hating her in general. Like when she was mad at her and threw her against the wall that pissed me off. In my mind: (YOU HURT HER YOU MADE HER HATE HERSELF BECAUSE SHE COULDNT HEAR YOU. YOU WERE ONE OF THE REASONS blah blah blah) and I’d say it’s true (I want to think it’s true anyway 💀)
In the end she’s a bit too jealous I think and she’s a bitch
Kawai can dig a hole and live in it without ac

Oh yeah Kawaii just unredeemably a bitch. At least she didn’t end up with Satoshi though. Wait actually, I could see Shouya together with either of them. He has better chemistry with Naoka still imo, but a relationship with Shouko would probably also work out. Everyone around them would support it too, so unless they just end up not being meant to be together or smth, it should work out. One bad thing though is that Shouko is too nice to just be upfront about issues she has with him. He might have to really watch what he says around her too, which can be really draining. Because she is emotionally weak and could get depressed again if he says the wrong thing. Yeah I’d prefer Naoka with Shouya nvm, the relationship between Shouya and Shouko would be unintentionally a little toxic imo due to not that much communication about important issues
you do realize they both know Sign language?
Feb 12, 2022 12:24 PM
Offline
Jul 2021
997
MannyChii said:
Kelly32723 said:

Oh yeah Kawaii just unredeemably a bitch. At least she didn’t end up with Satoshi though. Wait actually, I could see Shouya together with either of them. He has better chemistry with Naoka still imo, but a relationship with Shouko would probably also work out. Everyone around them would support it too, so unless they just end up not being meant to be together or smth, it should work out. One bad thing though is that Shouko is too nice to just be upfront about issues she has with him. He might have to really watch what he says around her too, which can be really draining. Because she is emotionally weak and could get depressed again if he says the wrong thing. Yeah I’d prefer Naoka with Shouya nvm, the relationship between Shouya and Shouko would be unintentionally a little toxic imo due to not that much communication about important issues
Kelly32723 said:

Oh yeah Kawaii just unredeemably a bitch. At least she didn’t end up with Satoshi though. Wait actually, I could see Shouya together with either of them. He has better chemistry with Naoka still imo, but a relationship with Shouko would probably also work out. Everyone around them would support it too, so unless they just end up not being meant to be together or smth, it should work out. One bad thing though is that Shouko is too nice to just be upfront about issues she has with him. He might have to really watch what he says around her too, which can be really draining. Because she is emotionally weak and could get depressed again if he says the wrong thing. Yeah I’d prefer Naoka with Shouya nvm, the relationship between Shouya and Shouko would be unintentionally a little toxic imo due to not that much communication about important issues
MannyChii said:

Ofc in my opinion I’d say Shouko and Ishida fit better but you have your own opinion so just hold on to it ig.
On to the main point. I personally would say that Ueno had no need to do anything to Shouko? Wether it be jealousy or what happened when Ishida saved Shouko she’s completely ignoring everything shes done to her in her childhood. Hitting her badmouthing her just hating her in general. Like when she was mad at her and threw her against the wall that pissed me off. In my mind: (YOU HURT HER YOU MADE HER HATE HERSELF BECAUSE SHE COULDNT HEAR YOU. YOU WERE ONE OF THE REASONS blah blah blah) and I’d say it’s true (I want to think it’s true anyway 💀)
In the end she’s a bit too jealous I think and she’s a bitch
Kawai can dig a hole and live in it without ac
hdm
Kelly32723 said:

Oh yeah Kawaii just unredeemably a bitch. At least she didn’t end up with Satoshi though. Wait actually, I could see Shouya together with either of them. He has better chemistry with Naoka still imo, but a relationship with Shouko would probably also work out. Everyone around them would support it too, so unless they just end up not being meant to be together or smth, it should work out. One bad thing though is that Shouko is too nice to just be upfront about issues she has with him. He might have to really watch what he says around her too, which can be really draining. Because she is emotionally weak and could get depressed again if he says the wrong thing. Yeah I’d prefer Naoka with Shouya nvm, the relationship between Shouya and Shouko would be unintentionally a little toxic imo due to not that much communication about important issues
you do realize they both know Sign language?

No I’m not talking about that. I was talking about how Shouko probably wouldn’t confront him about issues she has with him. And he might have to walk on eggshells so that he doesn’t say the wrong things. Idk if they’ll really be happy in a relationship because it’d be kinda draining for both of them imo
Feb 12, 2022 12:29 PM
Offline
Feb 2022
8
Kelly32723 said:
MannyChii said:
hdm
you do realize they both know Sign language?

No I’m not talking about that. I was talking about how Shouko probably wouldn’t confront him about issues she has with him. And he might have to walk on eggshells so that he doesn’t say the wrong things. Idk if they’ll really be happy in a relationship because it’d be kinda draining for both of them imo
well I feel like many relationships can be like that? Yes it can be bad but I don’t think she has any issues with him plus I’d say the first thing she’d do is confront him but in the nicest way possible and vice versa
(Also idk if it’s just me but I really don’t bother wanting to continue this convo 💀)
Feb 13, 2022 1:02 AM
Offline
Jul 2021
997
MannyChii said:
Kelly32723 said:

No I’m not talking about that. I was talking about how Shouko probably wouldn’t confront him about issues she has with him. And he might have to walk on eggshells so that he doesn’t say the wrong things. Idk if they’ll really be happy in a relationship because it’d be kinda draining for both of them imo
well I feel like many relationships can be like that? Yes it can be bad but I don’t think she has any issues with him plus I’d say the first thing she’d do is confront him but in the nicest way possible and vice versa
(Also idk if it’s just me but I really don’t bother wanting to continue this convo 💀)

oh yeah me neither tbh lmao
Feb 20, 2022 4:45 PM
Offline
Dec 2021
125
Ueno sucks! She is the worst character in this movie.
May 26, 2022 12:27 AM

Offline
Jun 2015
540
For most of the movie, I didn't like her, but once at the end I realized that she just has a weird way of forgiving someone who wasn't even guilty. She seems a little off the mark and over-protects her childhood friend.


Sorry my english is bad
May 26, 2022 12:47 AM

Offline
Jun 2015
540
I'm not defending her for the stupid things she did, I'm talking about the end
May 26, 2022 12:54 AM

Offline
Jun 2020
1501
I think she at least realize what she did was wrong. Unlike that blonde girl named Kawai.
May 26, 2022 1:01 AM

Offline
Jun 2015
540
chocomayu said:
I think she at least realize what she did was wrong. Unlike that blonde girl named Kawai.


We can see that if the movie would have continued. We would have seen a much better person (Ueno)
Pages (2) « 1 [2]

More topics from this board

» Did you cry? ( 1 2 3 4 5 ... Last Page )

Stacias - Aug 1, 2022

268 by Xdes »»
Mar 13, 3:09 AM

Poll: » Koe no Katachi Episode 1 Discussion ( 1 2 3 4 5 ... Last Page )

nihon_no_tsuki - Sep 21, 2016

742 by blauwiiss »»
Feb 27, 7:43 AM

» Extended cut of the movie? edit: (probably not real)

KaptainKoolaid - Dec 16, 2024

22 by Yeshaiah2015yesh »»
Dec 20, 2024 3:32 AM

Poll: » How many of us like ueno more than shoko

Hickykissy - Aug 21, 2024

43 by Allenzoko »»
Nov 2, 2024 7:53 PM

» Kyoto animation tease new anime release for 2025

Hickykissy - Sep 18, 2024

15 by dwoid »»
Sep 19, 2024 3:12 PM
It’s time to ditch the text file.
Keep track of your anime easily by creating your own list.
Sign Up Login