Review Bombing Has Started

Oct 20, 6:42 PM

Offline

Jan 2021

84

Does a random rating really bothers you so much?
Just leave it bro, so what if its not in the number 1 spot. Stop seeking validation like this. You liked that episode right? Thats all that matters!
And didn’t you rate aot 1?😂😂
Like no way anyone can possibly think its 1/10 if not review bombing themselves😂😂
Thats some hypocrisy😂

Raggy-_-Oct 20, 6:57 PM

Oct 20, 7:02 PM

#3

dymable

Offline

Nov 2021

17

Reply to Raggy-_-

Does a random rating really bothers you so much?
Just leave it bro, so what if its not in the number 1 spot. Stop seeking validation like this. You liked that episode right? Thats all that matters!
And didn’t you rate aot 1?😂😂
Like no way anyone can possibly think its 1/10 if not review bombing themselves😂😂
Thats some hypocrisy😂

There's a difference between review bombing purely for fandom wars and genuinely hating something. People can genuinely hate this episode, yet what I explicitly wrote about are clearly from accounts made for score inflation. I genuinely think AoT Season 4 is one of the worst pieces of fiction ever written, that has absolutely nothing to do with pathetic fandom wars. Hope this helps

Oct 20, 7:17 PM

#4

rohan121

Offline

Sep 2018

11591

Review bombing for spam of 1s and 10s yeah. This is normal on mal though.

Oct 20, 7:27 PM

#5

YusukeU

Offline

Apr 2017

23

Reply to Raggy-_-

Does a random rating really bothers you so much?
Just leave it bro, so what if its not in the number 1 spot. Stop seeking validation like this. You liked that episode right? Thats all that matters!
And didn’t you rate aot 1?😂😂
Like no way anyone can possibly think its 1/10 if not review bombing themselves😂😂
Thats some hypocrisy😂

@Raggy-_- Shingeki is horrible at writing, only a layman who has never studied thinks otherwise.

Oct 20, 7:27 PM

#6

Hazzardous2

Offline

May 2023

92

There's a system in place that ignores fake reviews

Oct 20, 7:27 PM

#7

YusukeU

Offline

Apr 2017

23

Reply to Raggy-_-

Does a random rating really bothers you so much?
Just leave it bro, so what if its not in the number 1 spot. Stop seeking validation like this. You liked that episode right? Thats all that matters!
And didn’t you rate aot 1?😂😂
Like no way anyone can possibly think its 1/10 if not review bombing themselves😂😂
Thats some hypocrisy😂

@Raggy-_- Shingeki is horrible at writing, only a layman who has never studied thinks otherwise.

Oct 20, 7:28 PM

#8

Zyperexa

Offline

Jul 2021

12

but the rating is still increasing right now

Oct 20, 7:29 PM

#9

YusukeU

Offline

Apr 2017

23

It seems a bit crazy to say this, I spent years asking for the end of the Fullmetal fandom that was flooding with ratings 1, but today I discovered that they were a necessary evil, the top of evil turned into shit And any work gets an average of 9.00+ now, anything generic from a season gets almost 9. Unbelievable

Oct 20, 7:40 PM

#10

WestOnAndrewAve

Offline

Jul 2022

307

YusukeU said:
It seems a bit crazy to say this, I spent years asking for the end of the Fullmetal fandom that was flooding with ratings 1, but today I discovered that they were a necessary evil, the top of evil turned into shit And any work gets an average of 9.00+ now, anything generic from a season gets almost 9. Unbelievable

I mean only 14 titles are rated at least a 9, and only 142 have reached 8.5 so I don't really think out of the tens of thousands of entries on here that its being flooded with generic shows rated almost a 9 or above. And if you look at franchises only, that number drops a ton because some shows (ex. Gintama) occupy a lot of spots.

Oct 20, 7:43 PM

#11

xZabuzax

Offline

Nov 2016

3539

Let's be honest here, this does deserve some 1-rating bombing to get that rating down, how is this even top 2?

You One Piss fans sure are something else.

Oct 20, 7:54 PM

#12

YusukeU

Offline

Apr 2017

23

Reply to WestOnAndrewAve

YusukeU said:
It seems a bit crazy to say this, I spent years asking for the end of the Fullmetal fandom that was flooding with ratings 1, but today I discovered that they were a necessary evil, the top of evil turned into shit And any work gets an average of 9.00+ now, anything generic from a season gets almost 9. Unbelievable

I mean only 14 titles are rated at least a 9, and only 142 have reached 8.5 so I don't really think out of the tens of thousands of entries on here that its being flooded with generic shows rated almost a 9 or above. And if you look at franchises only, that number drops a ton because some shows (ex. Gintama) occupy a lot of spots.

@WestOnAndrewAve All gintamas are flod 10 of the fans. Frieren was flod 10 of the fans, One Piece anime, manga and this special has been considered flood. Bleach the three new seasons are a fan favorite, this when they are not seasonal works that those who do not like stop watching and only the fans continue selling and successively the grade increases a lot. Re:Zero S2 part 2 has a higher grade than Re Zero Season 1 It borders on insanity.

Fruit Basket's third season was inflated because of this, Kaguya Sama, Re Zero's 3rd season (and it's not even a problem because they're good shows) but there's an obvious influence there as to why the ratings are inflated

Seasonal animes: Kurusiya with almost 9, Boku no kokoro which is very bad and generic, it's almost 9 because of the animation.

Unfortunately, the top of evil has become this, and it has to do with why now the old users who gave 1 star to these works have stopped giving such a rating, in 10 years the top 100 will only have seasonal animes. You can print it.

Oct 20, 8:06 PM

#13

TheDefCrypt

Offline

Mar 2023

7

Reply to YusukeU

@WestOnAndrewAve All gintamas are flod 10 of the fans. Frieren was flod 10 of the fans, One Piece anime, manga and this special has been considered flood. Bleach the three new seasons are a fan favorite, this when they are not seasonal works that those who do not like stop watching and only the fans continue selling and successively the grade increases a lot. Re:Zero S2 part 2 has a higher grade than Re Zero Season 1 It borders on insanity.

Fruit Basket's third season was inflated because of this, Kaguya Sama, Re Zero's 3rd season (and it's not even a problem because they're good shows) but there's an obvious influence there as to why the ratings are inflated

Seasonal animes: Kurusiya with almost 9, Boku no kokoro which is very bad and generic, it's almost 9 because of the animation.

Unfortunately, the top of evil has become this, and it has to do with why now the old users who gave 1 star to these works have stopped giving such a rating, in 10 years the top 100 will only have seasonal animes. You can print it.

@YusukeU

You have over 600+ anime with a lower average score than 5. Seriously whats the point of even watching anime if you hate it so much? That's such a crazy way to spend your free time in life. "Hate watching" anime is a crazy hobby to have. There's just 0 chance in hell any sane person would take advice from someone with a delusional mind like the one you're in possession of.

Your passion about how much you hate anime is truly a sight to behold

Oct 20, 8:51 PM

#14

saravanavsk

Offline

Jun 2016

9

Reply to xZabuzax

Let's be honest here, this does deserve some 1-rating bombing to get that rating down, how is this even top 2?

You One Piss fans sure are something else.

@xZabuzax womp womp narutrash ain't getting the 4 episodes

Oct 20, 9:20 PM

#15

Todday

Offline

Apr 2019

222

It’s just nature balancing out. You really think this deserves to be rank 2 with only 15,000 ratings.

This is why there needs to be a minimum limit to get in the top 10. Does not make any conceivable sense an anime to be in top 10 with anything less than 150,000ish ratings.

It’ll help stop getting peoples hopes up lol and blaming other fandoms for when the show inevitably balances out to a more accurate rating

Edit:11,000 ratings at this point. 15,000 was the members*

ToddayOct 20, 9:39 PM

Oct 20, 10:16 PM

#16

Piniv

Offline

Sep 2021

58

Reply to Raggy-_-

Does a random rating really bothers you so much?
Just leave it bro, so what if its not in the number 1 spot. Stop seeking validation like this. You liked that episode right? Thats all that matters!
And didn’t you rate aot 1?😂😂
Like no way anyone can possibly think its 1/10 if not review bombing themselves😂😂
Thats some hypocrisy😂

@Raggy-_- gaslighting is crazy

Oct 20, 10:50 PM

#17

xZabuzax

Offline

Nov 2016

3539

Reply to saravanavsk

@xZabuzax womp womp narutrash ain't getting the 4 episodes

@saravanavsk Mate, Naruto is mid, I'm not even a Naruto fan so I don't care about the 4 episodes or whatever the fuck it was going to get, I didn't even know about those 4 episodes till you mentioned it, I'm actually a Steins;Gate fan.

Oct 20, 11:43 PM

#18

Ba-Cii10

Offline

Nov 2020

888

XD dude you cry when the rating of your favorite anime keeps going up. Then when it starts to naturally go down you'll make some conspiracy theories based on a single account that gave "1" "the carousel of shit is turning" haha

Oct 20, 11:55 PM

#19

AyaazMahim

Offline

Mar 2024

64

It deserves to even though the episode was amazing but it's not the second best anime in existence or I don't even know how Mal ratings work? I've seen many anime where much more people are giving episodes 5 stars with the episodes having ratings of 4.7, 4.8 but the anime is still ranked very low? How did this already get to top 2 with so many less votes? Mal rankings does not make sense to me.

Oct 21, 12:38 AM

#20

Brytan

Offline

Feb 2016

25

yup exactly, only One Piece gets hit because those terrible Frieren fans don't want to accept the superiority of this wonderful series.
Double standards

People die if they are killed ~Emiya Shirou

Oct 21, 12:41 AM

#21

Animedoctor3392

Offline

Oct 2024

9

I swear, anything can be hated these days,It was a nice ep,it made me feel something,what more do we want anyway.It's a 10 for me,I liked it,others may not like it that much but you seriously can't give this ep a 1 that's just pure joblessness,I have seen these Frieren watchers on Re zero reviews as well ,pathetic charade which will amount to nothing.

Oct 21, 1:23 AM

#22

Xypheron

Offline

Sep 2024

55

........................................................................................................

Oct 21, 1:27 AM

#23

Levi1108

Offline

Jul 2022

708

Not this again. Why do ppl still don't get how mal works? This is pretty natural. Like u fr saying this deserves to be that high with that many number of ppl rating it? We all know it's mostly the fans who watch and rate this higher. Those 1s helps balance things a little. I mean still giving 1 is a shitty thing. But no way a 26 min ep deserves to be that high compared to whole series. And this will keep happening in the future too. Op has a huge fanbase and if smtg like this keeps coming out in the future, I'm pretty sure it'll be high up again. It's just a matter of time until it gets balanced and goes down. Same with most other series which make their way to the top. It's not just Op that's getting review bombed with 10s and 1s. So it's not really a big deal. I get it that it just feels good seeing the series u love being up there. So just feel good as long as it's there.

Oct 21, 1:36 AM

#24

Brunilde

Offline

Dec 2020

442

Even if the review bombing started the episode has a better rating than yesterday so it might actually stay top 2 or at least i hope so

Oct 21, 1:37 AM

#25

Theo1899

Offline

Jun 2016

13383

Well shonen anime is an activity aimed at 13 year olds so we are witnessing typical playground 13 year old activities.

MEA·MENTVLA·INGENS·EST

Oct 21, 2:05 AM

#26

Granddor101

Offline

Aug 2024

3

Reply to Animedoctor3392

I swear, anything can be hated these days,It was a nice ep,it made me feel something,what more do we want anyway.It's a 10 for me,I liked it,others may not like it that much but you seriously can't give this ep a 1 that's just pure joblessness,I have seen these Frieren watchers on Re zero reviews as well ,pathetic charade which will amount to nothing.

@Animedoctor3392 frieren fans aren't review bombing anything why are you all like this when an anime is rated no2 closer to another anime with no1 and the rating starts falling you all be like it's being review bombed like that's the same thing you all said with fmab and rezero didn't even reach top3 how was it review bombed🤨🤨🤨

Oct 21, 2:10 AM

#27

Xypheron

Offline

Sep 2024

55

Reply to Granddor101

@Animedoctor3392 frieren fans aren't review bombing anything why are you all like this when an anime is rated no2 closer to another anime with no1 and the rating starts falling you all be like it's being review bombed like that's the same thing you all said with fmab and rezero didn't even reach top3 how was it review bombed🤨🤨🤨

@Granddor101 Ok.................................................................

Oct 21, 2:38 AM

#28

anlyan

Offline

Oct 2020

7

Btw, you guys forget kitsu and anime planet

Oct 21, 2:38 AM

#29

TransferUser

Offline

Apr 2024

497

If you want to look at a proper Top List that is actually believable: https://www.anikore.jp/pop_ranking/

Oct 21, 2:55 AM

#30

Lucapezzolo

Offline

Jan 2022

1

where do you see the single reviews

Oct 21, 3:02 AM

#31

xZabuzax

Offline

Nov 2016

3539

Reply to TransferUser

If you want to look at a proper Top List that is actually believable: https://www.anikore.jp/pop_ranking/

@TransferUser Mate, no offense but that list is even worse.

Oct 21, 3:12 AM

#32

Ba-Cii10

Offline

Nov 2020

888

Reply to TransferUser

If you want to look at a proper Top List that is actually believable: https://www.anikore.jp/pop_ranking/

@TransferUser Ratings based on mox 2-5k votes<<<Reliable list

Oct 21, 3:17 AM

#33

GosuDRM

Offline

Dec 2012

2953

Fucking dumbasses review bombing this masterpiece

Oct 21, 3:24 AM

#34

TaifSux

Offline

Jan 2021

99

Spamming 10's to take off completed shows with millions of votes to put this 23 minutes special at the no.2 spot is broken in the first place...

This shouldn't allowed to be in the list to begin with but MaL allows this types of clownery so its excepted that spammers take it as a competition of who can spam scores more.....Mal's top list broken to the core, so stop caring for it, you liked the episode, that's it.

I still remember when Oshi No Ko's music video was about to take over the top place, thankfully musics were purged the from list to participate. Same thing should be applied here too..

TaifSuxOct 21, 3:32 AM

Oct 21, 3:36 AM

#35

ryzxgum

Offline

Apr 2022

6358

we got salty people who don't watch one piece and even frieren (the new fmab) fans working overtime to spam with 1s lol thankfully the bots will be ignored but no-life activity like this over ratings is still hilariously pathetic.

Oct 21, 3:45 AM

#36

kaitonic

Offline

Dec 2011

1865

Let them bark as much they want. But we all know that this is a masterpiece that will be in our hearts as it was a love letter to all One Piece fans/

Oct 21, 4:01 AM

#37

Gear707

Offline

Sep 2013

275

Bloodbath incoming.

Oct 21, 4:03 AM

#38

Granddor101

Offline

Aug 2024

3

Reply to Xypheron

@Granddor101 Ok.................................................................

@Xypheron how many people have done this so far are they many?? and I'm pretty sure mal can handle this since this is obviously a bot account frieren is one of my fav animes but this is so unacceptable when did we start becoming fmab fans🤦🤦🤦

Oct 21, 4:04 AM

#39

CheliosX

Offline

Dec 2022

1832

It's normal. Nothing to be surprised about. They did it to Frieren, Apothecary Diaries, FMAB, Steins Gate and so on.
It's normal. Fandom wars y'know.
But for this to become #2 on MAL is quite baffling.

Oct 21, 4:09 AM

#40

Piniv

Offline

Sep 2021

58

Reply to TransferUser

If you want to look at a proper Top List that is actually believable: https://www.anikore.jp/pop_ranking/

@TransferUser kobayashi San anywhere near top 10 this list so ass

Oct 21, 4:29 AM

#41

TransferUser

Offline

Apr 2024

497

Ba-Cii10 said:
@TransferUser Ratings based on mox 2-5k votes<<<Reliable list

The numbers you see in the screenshot are not votes, they represent reviews. Frieren doesn't even have a thousand reviews on MAL.
The site is mostly used by Japanese users as it is only available in Japanese, so what it does is represent the opinion of the Japanese.

I think anikore's list is a lot better than the one MAL has.

TransferUserOct 21, 4:35 AM

Oct 21, 4:35 AM

#42

Ba-Cii10

Offline

Nov 2020

888

Reply to TransferUser

Ba-Cii10 said:
@TransferUser Ratings based on mox 2-5k votes<<<Reliable list

The numbers you see in the screenshot are not votes, they represent reviews. Frieren doesn't even have a thousand reviews on MAL.
The site is mostly used by Japanese users as it is only available in Japanese, so what it does is represent the opinion of the Japanese.

I think anikore's list is a lot better than the one MAL has.

@TransferUser So where is the vote count?

Oct 21, 4:54 AM

#43

KayKimii

Community Mod

Entranced

Offline

Mar 2022

2801

Thread locked for not encouraging discussion.

Anime Discussion Rules: 2.e Please refrain from creating threads that do not encourage meaningful and/or civil discussion. Examples include:

e.　MAL community data
e.g.　Questioning the score/ranking/character favorite counts
e.g.　Saying that series X should have a higher/lower score/count
e.g.　Specific reviews, moderation of data/community content/reviews, etc.
Concerns about the website should be reported using the appropriate buttons or designated MyAnimeList boards.

You may also use this thread if you want to talk about overrated/underrated anime. MAL has implemented a new system to take care of boosting/downvoting accounts automatically. You can read more about it here. You do not have to worry about the score being influenced by them. If it is influenced, it will be fixed after a few days.

✧Anime List

✧Manga List

✧Site & Forum Guidelines

✧Report

» let´s be honest. hype > quality....why? ( 1 2 ) AkaiSanji - Nov 3	68	by therealnagora »» Today, 2:21 AM
Poll: » One Piece Fan Letter Episode 1 Discussion ( 1 2 3 4 5 ... Last Page ) IzanaSolos - Oct 19	281	by Shadow_the_shade »» Nov 23, 8:26 AM
» I watched this and I liked it(I've never watched One Piece) utopia- - Nov 3	18	by AquaBlue-sama »» Nov 5, 2:02 PM
» No, you shouldn't watch this around the Sabaody, or Marineford arc. Polatrix - Oct 26	10	by Zarutaku »» Nov 3, 6:49 AM
» How caught up do I need to be to watch it? RizzardKing - Oct 24	28	by LilyVarbik »» Nov 3, 6:47 AM

Review Bombing Has Started

More topics from this board

» let´s be honest. hype > quality....why? ( 1 2 )

Poll: » One Piece Fan Letter Episode 1 Discussion ( 1 2 3 4 5 ... Last Page )

» I watched this and I liked it(I've never watched One Piece)

» No, you shouldn't watch this around the Sabaody, or Marineford arc.

» How caught up do I need to be to watch it?

MoreTop Anime

MoreTop Airing Anime

MoreMost Popular Characters