Tantei Gakuen Q Episode 38 Discussion

What did you think of this episode?

DO NOT discuss the source material beyond this episode. If you want to discuss future events or theories, please use separate threads.
DO NOT ask where to watch/download this episode or give links to copyrighted, non-fair use material.
DO NOT troll/bait/harass/abuse other users for liking or disliking the series/characters.
DO read the Anime Discussion Rules and Site & Forum Guidelines.

Apr 1, 2014 9:56 PM

YusakuGodai

Offline

Jun 2012

623

THIS IS AN ANIME ONLY DISCUSSION POST. DO NOT DISCUSS THE MANGA BEYOND THIS EPISODE.
----------------------------------------
I knew who the fake person was the very moment I saw an accessory of theirs :D Too obvious, lol. Anyway, sad end for Mitsuru. The world can be very cruel at times.

"No matter how far you travel, you can never get away from yourself."
-- Murakami Haruki

Aug 29, 2017 4:40 PM

gfsdfgsdgsdfgs

Offline

Jun 2016

3391

So the anime is asking us to believe:

1. The calls to the one dude was a fool proof way to get him to leave the room during the demons banquet. That's ridiculous to assume he'd just get up and leave losing his alibi, what if he didn't? There would no longer be a scapegoat, in practice ruining the entire plan.

2. That no one else would shake literally anything, even accidentally shaking something too much, since everything had cyanide in it. What if someone dropped something and still drank it? What if someone felt like having a shower, they would die from that snake, or what if the OCD guy actually saw the snake and ran? This is plausible but it's just as ridiculous as the first point.

3. How in the world did Gotouda set up the victim to have a knife over her throat set up with candles, and have the radio play at the perfect time. If he had it playing literally all the time it would of knocked off the pot early, not to mention someone would of turned it off. I take it we should assume she turned on the radio herself? If that's the case then there's also the possibility of her just not listening to that, or skipping the song. And how would that mechanism had been set up on her like that if nobody was even around to do that? Magic?

4. How did all the students plan to kill Mitsuru the way they did, if her lover wasn't working with them and abruptly gave her a spot at the concert hall. This part only makes sense if all four of them are involved, they didn't all accidentally set her up, it was proven they did it on purpose, but how did they have the time to do that if he sprung that on her on the fly?

5. We are meant to assume at best, that Mitsuru told the maid/her sister that everyone planned to kill her, but if she did that she would of told her that her lover wasn't involved, so this part makes no sense either. She should either not know that her accident was planned, or she should know and not try to kill her lover.

So we see again, the setup and case are interesting, the tricks are awesome, the cast and their interactions are fun, but the conclusion is absolute trash. If I'm making any false accusations here, or if I'm just misunderstanding something let me know, but jesus this anime's laziness can be really frustrating sometimes. For such a great case to end like this is a travesty.

Sep 21, 2017 3:37 PM

iamKetranLang

GetsugaTENSHO

Offline

Jul 2012

3959

This organization plot will be resolved before Conan xD

張大です for 張大勇督察

Jan 5, 2018 8:48 AM

Lucumo

Offline

Nov 2009

720

gfsdfgsdgsdfgs said:
5. We are meant to assume at best, that Mitsuru told the maid/her sister that everyone planned to kill her, but if she did that she would of told her that her lover wasn't involved, so this part makes no sense either. She should either not know that her accident was planned, or she should know and not try to kill her lover.

It was probably not hard to figure out those "coincidences". Anyone would ask why there was not enough gas in the car or why she had no winter clothing. So the sister did that and as such assumed that all other four students were involved.

I agree with the other points...and I really don't get how Gouda killed the woman. He wasn't there, so when did he put her to sleep?

And also the other flaw I mentioned in the previous post. Normally, bodyguards would be in front and behind the target. They weren't for whatever reason and only because of that was he able to slip away for some time. Pretty unlikely.

Sep 15, 2023 1:32 PM

Etherius_ZS

Offline

Oct 2018

2725

I still don't get how the first death is automated. If the broken pieces of the pot were brought from outside, then how can he who is nowhere near the mansion can commit the murder?

Etherius_ZSSep 15, 2023 1:51 PM

Aug 26, 1:26 PM

Ele1603

Offline

Jan 2022

Reply to Etherius_ZS

I still don't get how the first death is automated. If the broken pieces of the pot were brought from outside, then how can he who is nowhere near the mansion can commit the murder?

@Etherius_ZS Not sure, but maybe with the help of Pluto

See All Discussions

Poll: » Tantei Gakuen Q Episode 39 Discussion Mayuka - Jul 9, 2016	7	by Ele1603 »» Aug 26, 1:54 PM
Poll: » Tantei Gakuen Q Episode 30 Discussion gfsdfgsdgsdfgs - Aug 27, 2017	5	by Destroyer31 »» May 4, 7:26 PM
Poll: » Tantei Gakuen Q Episode 19 Discussion rayeine - Aug 20, 2016	5	by Destroyer31 »» May 3, 10:39 PM
» Help: Detective School Q filler episodes? JoNuttanon1994 - Feb 13	1	by Joker_Sama »» Feb 14, 8:54 AM
Poll: » Tantei Gakuen Q Episode 43 Discussion sifma - Mar 6, 2010	7	by _vesper_ »» Dec 5, 2023 3:36 PM

Tantei Gakuen Q Episode 38 Discussion

More topics from this board

Poll: » Tantei Gakuen Q Episode 39 Discussion

Poll: » Tantei Gakuen Q Episode 30 Discussion

Poll: » Tantei Gakuen Q Episode 19 Discussion

» Help: Detective School Q filler episodes?

Poll: » Tantei Gakuen Q Episode 43 Discussion

MoreTop Anime

MoreTop Airing Anime

MoreMost Popular Characters