Urusei Yatsura is better than Ranma (personal opinion)

Aug 11, 3:48 AM

Offline

Apr 2018

281

Major reason is that it's a similar story but in Ranma 1/2, the author swapped Lum into an inferior role (Shampoo), being a much more charismatic character but is not the lead heroine. While Shinobu became Tendou Akane, who's as boring as Shinobu but is the focus of the story (beside Ranma).

To make it even worse, they have to cut Akane's hair short, destroying her attractiveness even further.

Also, the plot in general is just a watered down version of Urusei Yatsura. Now no more alien stuff but it's just some martial art nerds.

Aug 11, 4:38 AM

StarWars2000

Offline

Apr 2022

I prefer this show over the other one

Aug 11, 4:44 AM

Mr_Sai

Online

Sep 2022

416

shinobu is just a angry she hulk while akane can be short temper shes also caring and sweet

Aug 11, 5:02 AM

Zarutaku

Offline

Sep 2016

10226

Ecchi and Magical Sex Shift makes Ranma inherently superior.

No, this isn't my signature~desu.

Aug 11, 5:27 AM

tchitchouan

Offline

May 2019

7743

I agree, i much prefer urusei yatsura over ranma, not only the ecchi was better and more plentiful on lum on her friends than akane and her friends.

Bikini ⚔️ Armor
Queen's Blade
Bikini Warriors

Aug 11, 5:31 AM

zero_uchiha

Offline

Mar 2022

344

Maison ikkoku is better than Ranma and urusei yatsura( objectively )

Aug 11, 6:09 AM

IAmVento

Offline

Nov 2015

150

You’re debating a personal opinion lmao

Aug 11, 6:52 AM

Legdrasil

Offline

Apr 2021

Theoretically Ranma is just the Evolution of Urusei Yatsura, as Rinne is the Evolution of Ranma and so on. Rumiko Takahashi hast a Pool of recurring character sheets, that reappear in esch of her series. They are just adjusted or evolved to the series shes just writing. From that point of view, her best work is always the actual one (in this point it would be Mao). In reality, everyone has a unique taste, a unique opinion. I'm a huge Fan of her series and writings and there is no series I don't like. It's just that in terms of comedy, my Favourite is Urusei Yatsura, since it's so raw, full of great jokes but at the Same time rich of unique parts of japanese history and Folklore.
Ranma has also a special place in my heart, since it's the Anime/Manga that dragged me together with DragonBall into Martial Arts. At the same time it's not only jokes and Martial Arts, but even more full of Folklore and history, but didn't Blog me away as Urusei Yatsura did. Rinne is for me from enjoyability on a similar Spot than Ranma, but has not the Nostalgia thar I have from Ranma as a kid.
With her more serious works, it's very difficult for me to say. I really, really like Inuyasha and Mao nearly the Same, but with Ranma, it's obvious, there's Nostalgia kicking in again. So what Makes a series for someone better or worse, is far depending on what yout tastings are exactly. It's Personal preference and opinion.

Aug 11, 7:02 AM

Romangelo

Offline

Apr 2018

281

And Mendou => Kunou is a huge downgrade. This kendou senpai isn't funny at all. Or the pig guy who's just annoying. The supportive casts beside Shampoo and Happousai are mostly boring.

Aug 11, 7:04 AM

#10

Lucifrost

Offline

Feb 2016

11956

I agree. The martial arts was clearly added to compete with Dragon Ball.

その目だれの目？

Aug 11, 7:25 AM

#11

JumbledStars

Offline

May 2021

I like Ranma a lot better - feel like martial arts is a more compelling plot point that “whatever Takahashi feels like drawing that week”

Aug 11, 9:07 AM

#12

Eldencheese

Offline

Mar 2023

517

As in the remakes or the series as a whole

Aug 11, 10:13 AM

#13

StarWars2000

Offline

Apr 2022

how many episodes do you think it's going to have is it going to have the same amount the original had I hope there's no filler in it that's what I hated about the original they had so much filler and cut out a lot of content

Aug 11, 10:53 AM

#14

Sheol01

Offline

Jul 2024

1329

Reply to Romangelo

And Mendou => Kunou is a huge downgrade. This kendou senpai isn't funny at all. Or the pig guy who's just annoying. The supportive casts beside Shampoo and Happousai are mostly boring.

@Romangelo You seriously like the most annoying pervert in ALL of Anime'? No taste sir, no taste. Happosai is the one character I hated in Ranma.

Aug 11, 11:01 AM

#15

rohan121

Offline

Sep 2018

11599

Og Ranma anime was far better imo.

Aug 11, 11:39 AM

#16

DaWizardO

Offline

Apr 2022

@Romangelo I am not sure if you are referring to the Manga or the original series, but Urusei Yatsura and Ranma are different with some parallels between them and your character swap comparison just doesn't make it justice. And I don't really see how you can say that it is a similar story, when each event/villain and setting is very different from Urusei Yatsura and with a bunch of new characters and different dynamics between each character.
Both stories are unique and just from your comment it seems like you didn't really pay attention to Ranma.

I can't really speak for the (original) anime, since I don't know if it covers everything or is true to the source material to make the distinction.

Aug 12, 6:22 PM

#17

Yozarou

Offline

Nov 2020

198

@Romangelo I’m sorry did you just call Akane boring? I can think of a number of words to describe Akane, but boring would not be one of them. I could honestly care less about Akane‘s hair, but I would say she looks more unique with short hair. Her long hair just made her look average.

If you prefer Urusei Yatsura, then good for you. But personally, I think Ranma 1/2 one of the funniest anime/manga I have ever watched/read. All of the characters have such big personalities and it is always fun seeing them be put into different scenarios or interact with different characters.

I can’t speak on Urusei Yatsura as I have only seen a few episodes of the remake. But Ranma 1/2 help me through some dark times and is also one of the first anime I’ve ever watched

YozarouAug 12, 6:25 PM

Aug 13, 5:17 AM

#18

Romangelo

Offline

Apr 2018

281

Reply to Yozarou

@Yozarou Don't get me wrong. I didn't say Ranma was a bad manga/anime. Just that it wasn't as good as Urusei Yatsura that predated it.

And the core reason is Akane. She wasn't a good lead heroine, even if you don't compare her to Lum, she's probably worse than most of the other girls on her own show. Hell, even female Ranma is a better girl than Akane.

Aug 14, 1:31 AM

#19

SoldierDream

Offline

Dec 2016

6111

Disagree. I tried UY, but I could not keep on with it. Never felt in it the same funny/lovely charm that hooks you in from the very beginning that Ranma did have.

Aug 14, 10:29 AM

#20

alexrawk

Offline

Sep 2020

I think I love both equally, but Takahashi is my favorite mangaka so I may be biased

Aug 15, 2:58 PM

#21

Kenshiro_CJ

Offline

Feb 2017

SoldierDream said:
Disagree. I tried UY, but I could not keep on with it. Never felt in it the same funny/lovely charm that hooks you in from the very beginning that Ranma did have.

the remake is infinitely fun. it's freaking hilarious tbh

Aug 16, 2:10 AM

#22

Romangelo

Offline

Apr 2018

281

Best way to enjoy Urusei Yatsura is to read the manga. It has all the jokes and edgy stuff. But both versions of anime were good as well, just not as great as the manga.

Aug 20, 12:34 AM

#23

DaWizardO

Offline

Apr 2022

@Romangelo Nobody is complaining about your personal opinion, but your reasons why are just showing that you did not pay attention.

Aug 20, 10:30 AM

#24

Kunii

Community Mod

ウェルカムチーム™

Offline

Feb 2014

649471

Thread locked for being a random X vs Y thread.

Anime Discussion Rules 2: Please refrain from creating threads that do not encourage discussion; e.g. random "xx vs. yy", picture collecting, etc.

GUIDELINES/FAQ ◀
AD RULES ◀
MD RULES ◀
CD RULES ◀
REPORT ◀
STAFF ◀
NEWJEANS - SUPER SHY ♫
SET BY SENPAIX

See All Discussions

Poll: » Reboot onlys, who do you consider best girl so far? VanVeleca - Nov 27	15	by JumbledStars »» 2 hours ago
Poll: » Ranma ½ (2024) Episode 9 Discussion Stark700 - Yesterday	30	by N_Erwann »» 3 hours ago
» List of manga chapter adapted so far shaftmajo - Nov 23	9	by Uruichi »» 10 hours ago
» All this pig crap is annoying MegamiRem - Nov 23	46	by ShidoItsuka74739 »» Yesterday, 2:41 PM
Poll: » Ranma ½ (2024) Episode 2 Discussion ( 1 2 3 4 ) Stark700 - Oct 12	150	by BetaMaleUltra »» Nov 29, 9:25 PM

Urusei Yatsura is better than Ranma (personal opinion)

More topics from this board

Poll: » Reboot onlys, who do you consider best girl so far?

Poll: » Ranma ½ (2024) Episode 9 Discussion

» List of manga chapter adapted so far

» All this pig crap is annoying

Poll: » Ranma ½ (2024) Episode 2 Discussion ( 1 2 3 4 )

MoreTop Anime

MoreTop Airing Anime

MoreMost Popular Characters