This anime is very GOOD! Why no one watching this?

Offline

Dec 2022

937

it's good definitely, but nothing to write home about.

May 1, 6:03 AM

#4

Offline

Dec 2022

937

And speaking from experience, it can go down after he collects all set of characters. every episode is about collecting character, not only that it's addictive it also gives a since of achievement so ofc it feels good. no different to an isekai protagonist leveling up or collecting skill. iam more interested in what comes after that.

May 1, 6:08 AM

#5

Offline

Jul 2021

630

Reply to iiDavion

personally I am watching this and it's so damn good too

@iiDavion It was so GOOD that I cant wait for the next episode and I went straight to read the manga. Thankfully the manga is 120 chapters. (episode 4 is chapter 16 in the manga to those who interested to read.)

May 1, 6:09 AM

#6

iiDavion

Offline

Jun 2022

166

RjtheGreat14 said:
@iiDavion It was so GOOD that I cant wait for the next episode and I went straight to read the manga. Thankfully the manga is 120 chapters. (episode 4 is chapter 16 in the manga to those who interested to read.)

same here I also can't wait for the next episode

May 1, 6:21 AM

#7

Offline

Jul 2021

630

Reply to Yeshaiah2015yesh

And speaking from experience, it can go down after he collects all set of characters. every episode is about collecting character, not only that it's addictive it also gives a since of achievement so ofc it feels good. no different to an isekai protagonist leveling up or collecting skill. iam more interested in what comes after that.

@Yeshaiah2015yesh I think this anime is much more interesting than your average isekai. Other isekai mc just got OP skill buy eating something or leveling up. Here each skill is a character that have personality. In a story point of view skill with personality is much more interesting than a OP skill with zero personality.

May 1, 6:22 AM

#8

snekkoboi

Offline

Jan 2023

27

Yeshaiah2015yesh said:
And speaking from experience, it can go down after he collects all set of characters. every episode is about collecting character, not only that it's addictive it also gives a since of achievement so ofc it feels good. no different to an isekai protagonist leveling up or collecting skill. iam more interested in what comes after that.

Same. I'm actually a little concerned by the amount of time they are spending collecting these characters, because while they have personalities they aren't necessarily game-changing or original.

I think the show doesn't know what it's doing yet. If it's plot focused (which I thought it would be from the first episode and intro) then they need to pick up the pace, and stop wasting so much time on these secondary characters.

If it's character focused, they need to create more depth and emotions in each episode to get us attached to each character. I've felt sympathy so far, but nothing that has truly pulled at my heart strings.

I think "good" is an appropriate word for this anime. it's good, it's okay, it's not much more. We'll have to see where it goes. I am looking forwards to plot progression.

May 1, 6:27 AM

#9

Offline

Dec 2022

937

snekkoboi said:

Yeshaiah2015yesh said:
And speaking from experience, it can go down after he collects all set of characters. every episode is about collecting character, not only that it's addictive it also gives a since of achievement so ofc it feels good. no different to an isekai protagonist leveling up or collecting skill. iam more interested in what comes after that.

Same. I'm actually a little concerned by the amount of time they are spending collecting these characters, because while they have personalities they aren't necessarily game-changing or original.

I think the show doesn't know what it's doing yet. If it's plot focused (which I thought it would be from the first episode and intro) then they need to pick up the pace, and stop wasting so much time on these secondary characters.

If it's character focused, they need to create more depth and emotions in each episode to get us attached to each character. I've felt sympathy so far, but nothing that has truly pulled at my heart strings.

I think "good" is an appropriate word for this anime. it's good, it's okay, it's not much more. We'll have to see where it goes. I am looking forwards to plot progression.

you get what iam saying, i just hope the other guy does that, we possible can't write a hole essay for a simple comment.

May 1, 6:30 AM

#10

removed-user

Offline

Jul 2018

564072

I have checked the synopsis on Anilist. Let's read it together aloud:

After being reincarnated, Ars Louvent is supposed to live in a different world as a weak aristocrat. Both his physical strength and intelligence were mediocre in both worlds, but here he naturally possessed a skill called "Appraisal" that allowed him to see the potential of any person. By gathering talented people by his side, Ars uses this "Appraisal" skill to transform his weak territory into the strongest one! But the road ahead of him won't be so simple

So, this is another generic story about an absolutely generic person who is absolutely nothing special, but he has a god damn fucking cheat skill which suddenly makes him almighty gigachad. Now explain what is actually so great about it that I would want to prefer it over finally watching Rebuilds of Evangelion or rewatching Madoka Magica, besides sharing some details of setting with your favorite JRPG.

Its basically a JRPG

You have also made an incorrect comparison. Suikoden is a role-play game, not cheat skill power fantasy game.

May 1, 6:40 AM

#11

kalebsmoker

Offline

Apr 2021

138

I'm liking it so far too. it's great

May 1, 7:14 AM

#12

Offline

Jul 2021

630

Reply to removed-user

I have checked the synopsis on Anilist. Let's read it together aloud:

After being reincarnated, Ars Louvent is supposed to live in a different world as a weak aristocrat. Both his physical strength and intelligence were mediocre in both worlds, but here he naturally possessed a skill called "Appraisal" that allowed him to see the potential of any person. By gathering talented people by his side, Ars uses this "Appraisal" skill to transform his weak territory into the strongest one! But the road ahead of him won't be so simple

So, this is another generic story about an absolutely generic person who is absolutely nothing special, but he has a god damn fucking cheat skill which suddenly makes him almighty gigachad. Now explain what is actually so great about it that I would want to prefer it over finally watching Rebuilds of Evangelion or rewatching Madoka Magica, besides sharing some details of setting with your favorite JRPG.

Its basically a JRPG

You have also made an incorrect comparison. Suikoden is a role-play game, not cheat skill power fantasy game.

@PostMahouShoujo The MC in this Anime is not really OP. his "Cheat skill" is useless in actual combat.

May 1, 7:35 AM

#13

Mainnus

Offline

Jul 2023

872

Liking it so far, there interesting elements to it, but lack amazing aspects in it.

^
^
User seem to have bias toward Isekai series.
its about nation building, not power fantasy.

May 1, 7:54 AM

#14

Offline

Dec 2022

937

RjtheGreat14 said:
@PostMahouShoujo The MC in this Anime is not really OP. his "Cheat skill" is useless in actual combat.

nha bro, MC's all ways carries plot Armor. let me bring this up, th MC never checked his own skills or used his appraisal skills on his self.
and it's op in these settings, ofc if he had born to NPC's as for a average family that would make it just a cheat skills.
but in the right sitting's it's op as fuck. look at him he already collected three s class character, one is already swiping the Flores in a war single handedly.
and the only reason he was able to achieve what he did, because 1• cheat skills.

2• the wealth, power and thrust of his father and family he has . this all ware possible only because because of the cheat skills.

And let me add another overwhelming advantage he has 3• he has his previous life memories and that's right their is. what makes him overpowered as fuck.

i total forget he was reincarnated, before.
and as he said it's about national building, not power fantasy. so his skills is in all rights overpowered.

Yeshaiah2015yeshMay 1, 9:22 AM

May 1, 8:17 AM

#15

Saleem_ilamdeen

Offline

Jul 2023

1

I have not watched it because English dub is not available yet

May 1, 4:35 PM

#16

Luxeraph

Offline

Feb 2017

322

Checked this after someone said it is a kingdom building isekai, watch two episodes and realize it's pretty generic and heck even a more boring version of world best assassin reborn as an aristocrat(black dude is blonde pigtails, mage slave is orphan girl from big city).

Also each time I see that japan map I get pulled out of the story by those perfectly straight borders, plus I got the feeling the story is just going to go down a warring states period rehash.

May 1, 7:12 PM

#17

Offline

Jul 2021

630

Reply to Yeshaiah2015yesh

RjtheGreat14 said:
@PostMahouShoujo The MC in this Anime is not really OP. his "Cheat skill" is useless in actual combat.

nha bro, MC's all ways carries plot Armor. let me bring this up, th MC never checked his own skills or used his appraisal skills on his self.
and it's op in these settings, ofc if he had born to NPC's as for a average family that would make it just a cheat skills.
but in the right sitting's it's op as fuck. look at him he already collected three s class character, one is already swiping the Flores in a war single handedly.
and the only reason he was able to achieve what he did, because 1• cheat skills.

2• the wealth, power and thrust of his father and family he has . this all ware possible only because because of the cheat skills.

And let me add another overwhelming advantage he has 3• he has his previous life memories and that's right their is. what makes him overpowered as fuck.

i total forget he was reincarnated, before.
and as he said it's about national building, not power fantasy. so his skills is in all rights overpowered.

@Yeshaiah2015yesh About MC not using his own skill to his self, I believe it was explained in episode 1, that he cannot use his appraisal skill to himself for some reason.

His cheat skill compare to other Isekai protagonist like Rimuru or Rudues (Mushoko tensei) is really not impressive.

Well MC is not DR stone level of IQ, So even with his past life knowledge I dont think he will be inventing guns in the near future.

MC cheat skill is NOT that OP, BUT it certainly give him an advantage but not in way that all his battles is a SURE WIN,

May 1, 7:20 PM

#18

Offline

Jul 2021

630

Reply to Luxeraph

Checked this after someone said it is a kingdom building isekai, watch two episodes and realize it's pretty generic and heck even a more boring version of world best assassin reborn as an aristocrat(black dude is blonde pigtails, mage slave is orphan girl from big city).

Also each time I see that japan map I get pulled out of the story by those perfectly straight borders, plus I got the feeling the story is just going to go down a warring states period rehash.

@Luxeraph I have already reading the manga after watching episode 4. It was Really GOOD. If you like the Kingdom Anime/Manga it has the same vibe.

May 1, 8:07 PM

#19

Ltstyle

Offline

Sep 2018

5

Huge fan of the manga, glad the anime is being well received

May 1, 10:25 PM

#20

LostSpectre

Offline

Jan 2013

6350

@PostMahouShoujo This is a good show if you're already comfortable being mindlessly entertained by fantasy/isekai to begin with.

Otherwise, watch a real show.

If you reply back to me and I never respond, I lost interest and don't care. Sorry about that.

May 1, 11:07 PM

#21

ElzardLN

Offline

Mar 2023

26

I'm watching it and I have read the manga and it's very good so I'm just leaving it for now till season 1 finishes then I will watch it again.

May 2, 10:45 AM

#22

Umi_no_Majo

Offline

Mar 2019

16

My guess? The low budget production is putting people off. I can tell the source material is quite good and the seiyuu are doing their best but this is a show based on character growth. As an anime with low action content, it should have had stellar character designs, beautiful backgrounds and superb animation. It does not. The character designer regularly produces simplistic (Kaguya-sama) to hideous (Oroka na Tenshi) level art. If this show had the team behind ButaReba, for example, people would have been flocking in to watch it.

Personally it doesn't bother me as I like watching old timey stuff and I have very low tolerance towards any type of action (I get bored to tears while people keep throwing stuff at each other and the plot goes nowhere). Late Gen Z and onwards who never got around to watching 80's, 90's anime (which happens to be most of the fandom these days) will struggle to keep up with the lack of visual stimulation.

May 2, 7:22 PM

#23

epyon4light

Offline

Mar 2017

238

damn I couldn't believe how big the mages assets were.

May 3, 5:42 AM

#24

Crisis_genocide

Offline

May 2023

199

I saw the manga a bit. I was quite hyped when I saw this

May 3, 6:38 AM

#25

LostSpectre

Offline

Jan 2013

6350

Reply to epyon4light

damn I couldn't believe how big the mages assets were.

@epyon4light Puberty hit her like a god damn truck murdering some poor soul in an isekai.

If you reply back to me and I never respond, I lost interest and don't care. Sorry about that.

May 3, 9:15 AM

#26

SakuraCosmos

Offline

Oct 2022

85

I'm loving this anime so much, it's so much interesting. my favorite Isekai so far.

May 5, 3:43 PM

#27

Vandesdelca

Offline

Apr 2010

333

I am watching this anime and it is good. People just need to give it a try I think.

May 5, 5:30 PM

#28

Ayakaxiao

Offline

Jul 2021

91

fak yu, many people watching it

May 6, 6:39 AM

#29

CrazyFrogz

Offline

Aug 2011

637

It not that good. Bochi the Rock anime is more better than this.

May 6, 4:47 PM

#30

yro-san

Offline

Feb 2012

93

Because people on this site put every Isekai in the same trash bag, which I believe is dumb as rocks.
This one is pretty decent, with interesting characters and decent enough world building compared to 90% of others.
I'm still waiting for it to continue a bit before saying it's good though, as those stories often go bad once the character introductions stop.

May 7, 3:43 AM

#31

Offline

Jul 2021

630

Reply to CrazyFrogz

It not that good. Bochi the Rock anime is more better than this.

@CrazyFrogz Eh Bocchi The Rock??? One of the Most Generic cute girls doing cute things I have ever seen! I really dont understand why so many people like that anime?

May 7, 12:04 PM

#32

amlg

Offline

Nov 2009

3399

TBH, I sorta forgot about this series after ep 1, just watched ep 2 to 5

.

Forgot about it, cause I was thinking this is going to be filled with politics... what with MC visualizing the tan dude to Nobu.. which is filled with politics.

.

Nothing Written Here But Us Anime Bunnies *boing boing boing*

May 9, 5:26 AM

#33

Ryoda-

Offline

Jun 2008

123

This show is boring...

May 9, 4:22 PM

#34

sekaii-of-starz

Offline

Dec 2023

22

Probably because of minimal action/romance. It’s also just not a very known or hyped up show/manga.

May 9, 4:29 PM

#35

EdgyLord666

Offline

Oct 2021

2040

Well tensura also has this "suikoden element" and yet I still don't really like it.

May 9, 8:25 PM

#36

vininadal

Offline

Oct 2015

4

I dunno with its me getting old or those caracters are very childsy. To tell the thuth I have read almost 45 chapters of the manga before dropped and I can resume everything in a sunflower kid, finding powerfull people to protect him, and these people just blindly follow him becouse the power of friendship.

Masterpiece story if you're 12 years old, just sewage waste if you're older

May 10, 3:47 PM

#37

FarisRezky

Offline

Jul 2023

1

this anime is not bad tho

May 10, 6:47 PM

#38

Offline

Jul 2021

630

Reply to EdgyLord666

Well tensura also has this "suikoden element" and yet I still don't really like it.

@EdgyLord666 Interesting that you think Slime isekai is kinda "suikoden" because for me Rimuru is just to OP and in fact he does not have to gain followers to conquer the world.

May 13, 5:42 AM

#39

Scootboi

Offline

Feb 2011

1518

too many people see -isekai- and immediately get butt hurt.

this show is pretty good. I like the premise, MC isn't over powered or anything, just can see who is overpowered and recruits them.

May 14, 3:04 PM

#40

Jixxor

Offline

Nov 2010

37

Reply to Scootboi

too many people see -isekai- and immediately get butt hurt.

this show is pretty good. I like the premise, MC isn't over powered or anything, just can see who is overpowered and recruits them.

@Scootboi Rightfully so. This show is one of the worse offenders, really. Being Isekai literally adds nothing, not a single benefit, to the plot. Now personally I can ignore the pointless aspect of it being Isekai, with the very rare reminders (that, again, add nothing to the story) that it being an Isekai like when Ars mentions he's never even had a girlfriend in his past life.
All it being an Isekai does is make it a tad creepy with an adult man, reborn and currently being a kid, calling a 10 year old girl beautiful.

May 16, 9:29 AM

#41

WhaleCostume

Offline

Dec 2007

1475

The problem with this anime is MC. He is supposedly a middle-aged man, yet he is in almost all cases the lease mature and confident person in the entire show. How the F is an 11-year-old girl more mature than he is when he is 30(?)+11 years old?

The isekai genre hurts the show badly. It would have been fine if he wasn't a reincarnated person.

Jun 19, 6:38 PM

#42

Aggnog

Offline

Feb 2010

61

Reply to WhaleCostume

The problem with this anime is MC. He is supposedly a middle-aged man, yet he is in almost all cases the lease mature and confident person in the entire show. How the F is an 11-year-old girl more mature than he is when he is 30(?)+11 years old?

The isekai genre hurts the show badly. It would have been fine if he wasn't a reincarnated person.

WhaleCostume said:
The problem with this anime is MC. He is supposedly a middle-aged man, yet he is in almost all cases the lease mature and confident person in the entire show. How the F is an 11-year-old girl more mature than he is when he is 30(?)+11 years old?

The isekai genre hurts the show badly. It would have been fine if he wasn't a reincarnated person.

Exactly, not only that but he was literally more mature at 3 years old than when they aged him up to 11. This is unfortunately a common trope that a lot of average isekai use.

Jun 23, 9:45 PM

#43

Offline

Jun 2022

144

Most people don't watch this show because IMO they either find it boring (which the pacing is slow ngl) or to busy watching any other generic isekai where the MC has a harem and is overpowered

Jun 23, 9:47 PM

#44

Offline

Jun 2022

144

Reply to WhaleCostume

The problem with this anime is MC. He is supposedly a middle-aged man, yet he is in almost all cases the lease mature and confident person in the entire show. How the F is an 11-year-old girl more mature than he is when he is 30(?)+11 years old?

The isekai genre hurts the show badly. It would have been fine if he wasn't a reincarnated person.

WhaleCostume said:
The isekai genre hurts the show badly. It would have been fine if he wasn't a reincarnated person.

Now that I think about this, I agree that the show would have been better if it wasn't an isekai. props up for it being diffrent though

Jun 26, 6:15 AM

#45

Comander-07

Offline

Sep 2014

4841

What about this is supposed to be good??!

Im 3 eps in and its absolutely terrible at everything! Chatbots can generate you a more creative and compelling story then this.

This show would be way better if he wasnt a damn brat for no reason, having a 3 year old lecture an 11 year old about the responsibility of adults is just cringe.

Also the underlying theme of nobles and naturally talented people having to save filthy commoners, like wtf.

If you want an actual good, original isekai without an OP MC watch Handyman. This just shifts the OPness of MC onto his side characters, who have in term no motivations of their own other than serving the MC because the kid was nice to them.

Comander-07Jun 26, 6:21 AM

"This emotion is mine alone.
It is for Madoka alone." - Homura
or how I would descripe Mahou Shoujo Madoka Magica.

Jun 30, 2:49 PM

#46

Offline

Jun 2022

144

Reply to Comander-07

What about this is supposed to be good??!

Im 3 eps in and its absolutely terrible at everything! Chatbots can generate you a more creative and compelling story then this.

This show would be way better if he wasnt a damn brat for no reason, having a 3 year old lecture an 11 year old about the responsibility of adults is just cringe.

Also the underlying theme of nobles and naturally talented people having to save filthy commoners, like wtf.

If you want an actual good, original isekai without an OP MC watch Handyman. This just shifts the OPness of MC onto his side characters, who have in term no motivations of their own other than serving the MC because the kid was nice to them.

@Comander-07 They should have come for a better anime title than "Handyman".

Edit: I just checked the synposis, is Benriya Saitou-san a harem?

cvbnm07Jun 30, 2:59 PM

Jul 2, 5:36 AM

#47

Urayamashii

Offline

Mar 2022

84

It's good. Plus point on it's characterization. But doesn't it strangely felt like all of the world was around him no?

Jul 2, 1:54 PM

#48

KaeUBW

Offline

May 2012

747

Reply to cvbnm07

@Comander-07 They should have come for a better anime title than "Handyman".

Edit: I just checked the synposis, is Benriya Saitou-san a harem?

cvbnm07 said:
Edit: I just checked the synposis, is Benriya Saitou-san a harem?

No, it isn't. Watch in peace.

I despise woke people.

Jul 3, 8:37 PM

#49